Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To increase the rent?

147 replies

Dickensian · 15/01/2023 08:48

Just that really. I'm an accidental landlord. Have lovely tenants - an elderly couple in their late seventies who have lived in the small house for 4 years. They are my first ever (and last) tenants. I will sell the house once they are no longer there. They love the place and expect to be there 'forever'. Before moving in, they had fallen on hard times for various reasons and would never have passed official rental agent tests, and a previously undeclared dog appeared (it's fine), but have always paid their rent on time. I have never increased the rent, they pay what they did when they moved in (£850). I don't have an agent but looking at market rents in my area I would say that £1000+ is the going rate for a similar type of property..

I actually have no idea about their financial circumstances but presume they wouldn't be able to/ want to buy the house.

The problem is that my BTL mortgage deal is coming to an end. From making a small profit, I will start to make a loss.

The UK inflation calculator shows that prices in general have increased more than 25% since they moved in.

My gut feeling is to look at an increase of 8-10% and absorb some of the cost myself. Or not increase it at all, but (being brutal) they might live in the house for another 20 years so that would be 20 years of loss which isn't very sensible.

So which option would you take:

  1. No increase at all (and make a loss) YABU
  2. Increase by 8-10% and review again in a couple of years
  3. Increase by 8-10% and start reviewing every year to keep pace with inflation
  4. Increase by more than 10% (up to 25% even) to bring rent up to market rent and nearer the price it was in real terms 4 years ago. Review annually in line with market rent.
OP posts:
RaiseTheStakesAndMakeTheLastWordDuckhead · 15/01/2023 22:07

I'm an 'accidental' landlord too but I have a residential mortgage (with permission to let from lender) and am operating at an annual loss. My tenants are also my first (and, like you, will likely be my last as I will sell when they decide to leave).

I offset the loss with the increase in property price. Even in the current market the area where my property is is still increasing (albeit more slowly nowadays), so overall I am still doing okay. I think given CoL increases, if you have good tenants, you should hold on to them.

When you look at the annual picture, rather than the monthly, does it add up? 8-10% is a big rental increase. In my situation, if my house goes up by just 1% a year that's equivalent to a 23% monthly rental increase.

roarfeckingroarr · 15/01/2023 21:59

It's not a popular view but everyone who wanted higher taxes for landlords, no mortgage interest relief, fees and costs to all fall on the landlord not the tenant etc were complicit in getting to this point where the margins are so low for BTL landlords. With the mortgage rises, it's unaffordable and landlords are editing the market or forced to hike rents.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 15/01/2023 21:23

RunningDownADream · 15/01/2023 20:49

What capital gains have you accrued in that time?

Is this not payable when they sell?
In which case it's irrelevant because no one knows what the price will be then?

babsanderson · 15/01/2023 21:20

peeweechigs · 15/01/2023 20:42

Because circumstances happen and it's the most sensible option at the time. Rather than she made a business plan that was buying houses and letting them out. Surely you aren't that stupid as to not realise that this is what an accidental landlord is?!

The term accidental landlord is a stupid phrase which demonstrates adults not taking responsibility and owning their own decisions. The OP and others may make what they think is the most sensible decision. It is not an accident, they make a decision.

LikeTearsInRain · 15/01/2023 21:19

You should rent at £850 per month as that was what agreed and sell up when they’re gone.

babsanderson · 15/01/2023 21:18

Annabananna1 · 15/01/2023 20:48

They will understand. We all know that everything is going up, including rent.
They will be expecting it.
Explain your mortgage interest payments have increased so you have to increase the rent to match it, otherwise you'd have to sell.
They may well be entitled to housing benefit?

They can approach the council for assistance if they can't make the increase. The council may help them out under homeless prevention scheme. It's worth looking in to. But essentially it isn't your problem. You need your costs covered one way or another.

The homeless prevention scheme will have major calls on it at the moment and will not be prioritising a couple who can just move to a cheaper house.

tenbob · 15/01/2023 21:15

RunningDownADream · 15/01/2023 20:49

What capital gains have you accrued in that time?

Why is that relevant?

RunningDownADream · 15/01/2023 20:49

What capital gains have you accrued in that time?

Annabananna1 · 15/01/2023 20:48

They will understand. We all know that everything is going up, including rent.
They will be expecting it.
Explain your mortgage interest payments have increased so you have to increase the rent to match it, otherwise you'd have to sell.
They may well be entitled to housing benefit?

They can approach the council for assistance if they can't make the increase. The council may help them out under homeless prevention scheme. It's worth looking in to. But essentially it isn't your problem. You need your costs covered one way or another.

mumof3now2 · 15/01/2023 20:44

Im in a housing association property and yesterday we had a letter saying they are increasing the rent 7%. Apparently they can go to 11% but due to the cost of living crisis, the government have capped it at 7%

peeweechigs · 15/01/2023 20:42

babsanderson · 15/01/2023 20:41

How do you accidentally rent out a house? You chose to this OP. Accept responsibility for your actions.

Because circumstances happen and it's the most sensible option at the time. Rather than she made a business plan that was buying houses and letting them out. Surely you aren't that stupid as to not realise that this is what an accidental landlord is?!

babsanderson · 15/01/2023 20:41

How do you accidentally rent out a house? You chose to this OP. Accept responsibility for your actions.

tenbob · 15/01/2023 20:41

pattihews · 15/01/2023 20:31

Not my experience at all, as a genuine accidental landlord who rented my home when work took me a distance away. I told the mortgage company and they said 'Fine.'

Yes, usually for the remainder of the term of the existing mortgage

But I’ve never heard of a mortgage company that will let you renew at the end of a fix and remain on a residential product. They’ll move you to a BTL one

peeweechigs · 15/01/2023 20:38

Babyroobs · 15/01/2023 11:50

I can't stand BTL, but I expect this couple are claiming housing benefit to help with their rent. However you putting up the rent may not equate to an increase in their housing benefit.

You can find out from the council up to how much housing benefit they'll pay for that property for those people in that area. Then you'll know how much they may be able to afford.

Honper · 15/01/2023 20:33

Never really understood how you'd find yourself accidentally letting a house and accidentally taking out a BTL mortgage. Sounds careless.

Anyway you can do what you want, so just do that.

pattihews · 15/01/2023 20:31

tenbob · 15/01/2023 20:27

Because when you become an accidental landlord, a lot of mortgage companies will transfer you over to a BTL product rather than let you stay on a residential mortgage when you are actually renting the house out

Not my experience at all, as a genuine accidental landlord who rented my home when work took me a distance away. I told the mortgage company and they said 'Fine.'

mondaytosunday · 15/01/2023 20:28

I just increased rent by 15%. The tenants gave notice (I hadn't raised it in over three years but rents have been exploding), and got new tenants within a day at the higher rent. Then the tenants new flat fell through and wanted to stay - I agreed as long as they paid the extra, which they readily agreed.
Another house, I've had same tenant for 8 years and I've never increased the rent as I know the tenant who has become disabled. But his housemate moved out and so I've lost his rent, and now the buy to let mortgage fixed rate is coming to an end. If I can't find a new mortgage at a similar rate I will have no choice but to sell - I can't afford tripling my repayments. But I do fear he will not move out!
I live off the rent - it's not just covering the mortgage.
You need to increase the rent, but check your lease as there might be a limit to how much you can increase it by. I would have increased the rent but have held off due to his circumstances, but there will be a time I need to do what's right for me, not him.

tenbob · 15/01/2023 20:27

pattihews · 15/01/2023 20:21

How can you be an Accidental Landlord if you have a BTL mortgage? You took a punt, you've clocked up three years of a major property price rise and now you want out.

Because when you become an accidental landlord, a lot of mortgage companies will transfer you over to a BTL product rather than let you stay on a residential mortgage when you are actually renting the house out

Lovemydoggiesomuch · 15/01/2023 20:26

I don’t understand the accidental landlord and be on BTL mortgage.
The majority of people renting are also financially on a knife edge …

KillingLoneliness · 15/01/2023 20:25

What % would you need to increase it to in order to prevent you from making a loss?

pattihews · 15/01/2023 20:21

How can you be an Accidental Landlord if you have a BTL mortgage? You took a punt, you've clocked up three years of a major property price rise and now you want out.

AlbertaAnnie · 15/01/2023 20:17

I would have a honest conversation with them I’m sure they are aware mortgage rates are increasing - advise them that you are likely going to be increasing rent to cover this but don’t intend to profit off them and put the offer on the table for them to buy it at that point? If not ask if they are claiming everything they should ie/ housing benefit to help with the increased rent. I think that’s all you can do. Good luck

ivykaty44 · 15/01/2023 20:13

I’d talk to them frankly about a rent review, suggest they look at sheltered accommodation or other social housing with council. Often it’s easier to get social housing for over 65s but the dog maybe a sticking point. If they were on a rolling monthly contract this would help them move into social housing if they can get offered something suitable.

what us the percentage rise in the tenancy agreement?

LumpyandBumps · 15/01/2023 20:04

Nobody rents out a property with the intention of making a loss unless it is a deliberate subsidy to a family member or close friend.

Most BTL mortgages are interest only, so the initial sum doesn’t decrease, and currently there is not even the eventual ‘carrot’ of increased equity, as property prices have started to drop.

I know that many landlords (including me) tend to keep to the initial rent. It can make sense if good tenants remain and there are no void periods.

You then get to the situation where the rent has been the same for 5 or more years and all the increased costs you are absorbing start to add up.

If the income from the rental isn’t covering your costs you need to increase the rent. It’s hard to do. Increasing the rent to the current market value, or even by the rate of inflation over the last 4 years will be a big jump. No tenant wants to be faced with that. Understandably people don’t have the mindset to think how lucky they are to have been paying a lower rent for many years, they worry about having a large increase.

Do whatever you can to make the increase as comfortable as possible this time, but manage expectations and advise the tenants that from now on the rent will be reviewed annually, and will always need to cover your outgoings, and an amount for contingency expenses.

There is absolutely no provision for a landlord ‘not being able to afford’ essential repairs, so you need a buffer to be able to pay for a new boiler, roof repair, etc. You won’t be able to raise it on your mortgage.

It might be that the couple are already considering applying for a council property ( assuming there are decent bungalows, etc nearby, not just high rise flats) as they will feel more secure in a lifetime tenancy.

There is a place for the private rented sector for people who need the flexibility to move for work, etc, but social housing is normally preferable for those needing a long term home.

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 15/01/2023 19:53

I make a loss of about £100 a month on my property when you take into account the tax bill etc. also an accidental landlord. I’ve just increased the rent by £25 a month which will help me somewhat and will still be affordable to the tenants. Better a loss of £75 a month than an empty house. I just see it as a pension investment and try not to think about it!