Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People that Say they don't watch TV

464 replies

Aquarius1234 · 14/01/2023 22:04

OMG so annoying. Esp those that lie.
You do watch TV so stop making out you spend all evening not looking at a screen!
Or those that say they never watch movies or go cinema. You then find out they go twice a year.
Watching sport or netflix counts as watching tv regardless if you watch it on your laptop or not.

OP posts:
JoonT · 15/01/2023 18:47

I hardly ever watch TV. The vast majority is mindless, woke garbage. That said, I have a soft spot for Bake Off. Actually, I quite like shows like that – where you have a bunch of random people competing at something (masterchef, etc). But I can't bear the soaps, and I never watch any dramas, which are badly-written, badly-acted, PC drivel. I also find 99% of films unwatchable.

TV has dumbed down for sure. I have recently been watching old episdodes of 'Great Philosophers' on youtube. In the 1970s, Bryan Magee, a British philosophy lecturer, made a series of programmes on which he discussed the great philosophers with a guest, usually a British or American professor. They would spend 40 minutes talking about, say, Plato, or Nietzsche, in an intelligent, civilized way – no gimmicks, no music, nothing. Just two highly-educated human beings having a fascinating discussion. God, it's amazing. Such a show would be unimaginable now. If anybody dared, they'd be accused of elitism. Somebody also bought me I Claudius on DVD for Christmas. Again, hard to imagine it being made today – the actors speak in too refined an accent. They also speak too eloquently and quickly.

FTStheFirstTimeSeller · 15/01/2023 18:43

Tv can be "intellectual".
Great way to learn languages. I learned most of my English with TV and I am currently learning fourth with the help of Netflix.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 18:37

@Pillowjoy

I don’t think it’s just that, though. I think there’s a real strand of anti-intellectualism in UK culture, and part of the reason discussions about not watching tv get such kneejerk responses is that people think that someone who says they don’t watch tv is claiming some form of superior intellectual status. When someone says ‘I don’t watch tv’, what people hear is ‘I’m clever. I’m cleverer than you.’ Which is akin to saying you torture kittens in the public approval stakes.

I agree that there's a culture of anti-intellectualism in the UK (although I actually think that applies in a lot of cultures). I think if you went to most European countries and walked into a home and said "I don't watch TV" you would get similar reactions from many people.

But the fact that you think saying: "I don't watch TV" is a way of saying "I'm cleverer than you" is an admission that this is basically what it sets out to achieve. I do think at some level (whether conscious or otherwise) this is what this statement is designed to communicate. Given that that is the cultural shorthand, perhaps it's not surprising it makes people feel so defensive. It's a bit like other cultural cues which are associated with self-conscious "cleverness" or sophistication. Saying you only eat organic food, or that you could never work for a multinational corporation, for example. It's usually a way of stealthily signalling a) that you "get it" and are in the know b) that your financial or cultural "richness" is such that you don't need to do things which ordinary people need to do.

Also let's unpick the concept of being an "intellectual" a bit. Why should watching TV be intrinsically less "clever" than other pursuits? All human life is on TV. You can watch things that are impenetrably highbrow or absolute trash on the same channel in the same 24 hours. There's nothing inherent to the medium which is less "clever". I've argued upthread that this dates back to the birth of television in the UK and the way people saw it as a mass medium and I can't get away from the idea that this is what it comes down to.

And why should "intellectualism" be the preserve only of those people who seek to distance themselves from the masses? If you set yourself up as someone who chooses pursuits to underline their own status as an intellectual, and in doing so in rejecting things that bring pleasure and information to ordinary people, you can see why this gets people's backs up.

FTStheFirstTimeSeller · 15/01/2023 18:29

If you want to see example of somewhat ridiculous "class issue" we foreigners are baffled by, there is a thread where someone said they wouldn't buy house with mirror furniture because it indicates what type of neighbours are around...
I wonder what they would say about tv watching!

FTStheFirstTimeSeller · 15/01/2023 18:26

I don’t think it’s just that, though. I think there’s a real strand of anti-intellectualism in UK culture, and part of the reason discussions about not watching tv get such kneejerk responses is that people think that someone who says they don’t watch tv is claiming some form of superior intellectual status. When someone says ‘I don’t watch tv’, what people hear is ‘I’m clever. I’m cleverer than you.’ Which is akin to saying you torture kittens in the public approval stakes.

I disagree. Unless there is something added to "I don't watch TV" there is nothing superior.
However, we had bunch of wxamples here of the percieved aelf superiority

Pillowjoy · 15/01/2023 18:17

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 18:07

@Gwenhwyfar

Also in the 70s and 80s some people had their TVs hidden by a cupboard and when satellites and wide screens first came out they were also seen as common.

Yep. Entertainment is the real front line of snobbery and the Byzantine weirdness of class attitudes today. It’s always been a subtle but unmistakable class cue but it’s far more complicated and even harder to understand with streaming, multichannel TV and the internet.

Much of this neurosis we have (writ large on this thread) about Netflix and all the stuff about “not watching TV” is people acting out weird shit their parents passed on to them back in the 1980s about what your TV habits signal to the neighbourhood about you.

I posted this upthread earlier but non British people find this sort of thing utterly bonkers and they are right. It’s crackers.

Lord Reith has a lot to answer for.

I don’t disagree with you about it being a class shibboleth (though I’m not British I lived in the UK for nearly 30 years), and the hair-trigger responses on this thread demonstrate that it’s clearly way more for some people than just ‘not sharing a widespread hobby’.

I don’t think it’s just that, though. I think there’s a real strand of anti-intellectualism in UK culture, and part of the reason discussions about not watching tv get such kneejerk responses is that people think that someone who says they don’t watch tv is claiming some form of superior intellectual status. When someone says ‘I don’t watch tv’, what people hear is ‘I’m clever. I’m cleverer than you.’ Which is akin to saying you torture kittens in the public approval stakes.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 18:07

@Gwenhwyfar

Also in the 70s and 80s some people had their TVs hidden by a cupboard and when satellites and wide screens first came out they were also seen as common.

Yep. Entertainment is the real front line of snobbery and the Byzantine weirdness of class attitudes today. It’s always been a subtle but unmistakable class cue but it’s far more complicated and even harder to understand with streaming, multichannel TV and the internet.

Much of this neurosis we have (writ large on this thread) about Netflix and all the stuff about “not watching TV” is people acting out weird shit their parents passed on to them back in the 1980s about what your TV habits signal to the neighbourhood about you.

I posted this upthread earlier but non British people find this sort of thing utterly bonkers and they are right. It’s crackers.

Lord Reith has a lot to answer for.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/01/2023 17:31

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 17:01

@Gwenhwyfar

I've seen the 'BBC only' thing quoted here on MN many times by women talking about their own childhoods. Snobby mothers I think!

Totally. There was no other rational explanation for it whatsoever.

My parents didn't go quite as far as banning non BBC but they had similarly Reithian attitudes. TV was basically something which working class people did because they were too lazy to do anything else and an a far inferior pursuit to reading (or basically anything else). My mum (who was a raging snob) used to walk into the room when we were watching TV and get visibly twitchy and anxious about it as if we were being brainwashed by it. If it was BBC (childrens programmes or news/current affairs) she would tolerate it. If it was anything American or ITV or with the whiff of mass entertainment about it she would mutter on about how "ghastly" it was and eventually turn it off in disgust. Adverts used to make her froth at the mouth.

I have to really fight some of these instincts with my own DD as YouTube/Tiktok trigger some of these responses in me. I'm (just about) self-aware enough to understand that my response is not rational and to understand that this is the medium which children use to communicate. But it's sometimes hard for me to unpick what is legitimate concern about inappropriate or unwholesome content and what is just the ghost of my mother and her judgement about mass entertainment.

I can, however, recognise this with laser-like accuracy in other adults of my generation who had a similar upbringing. When another adult says "oh we never watch TV (but we do watch documentaries on Netflix", a part of me goes: "I see you and I know exactly what your game is."

People who say they don't watch TV (but actually do watch documentaries or highbrow series on Netflix) are basically snobs.

My DM was and is the biggest TV addict you could ever meet, but when we were little we weren't allowed to tell people she watched all the soaps :)

Also in the 70s and 80s some people had their TVs hidden by a cupboard and when satellites and wide screens first came out they were also seen as common.

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 15/01/2023 17:15

Maybe some people use the term "TV" the same way that a lot of people "hoover" their carpets.

Technonan · 15/01/2023 17:07

Maybe they don't. Does it matter?

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 17:01

@Gwenhwyfar

I've seen the 'BBC only' thing quoted here on MN many times by women talking about their own childhoods. Snobby mothers I think!

Totally. There was no other rational explanation for it whatsoever.

My parents didn't go quite as far as banning non BBC but they had similarly Reithian attitudes. TV was basically something which working class people did because they were too lazy to do anything else and an a far inferior pursuit to reading (or basically anything else). My mum (who was a raging snob) used to walk into the room when we were watching TV and get visibly twitchy and anxious about it as if we were being brainwashed by it. If it was BBC (childrens programmes or news/current affairs) she would tolerate it. If it was anything American or ITV or with the whiff of mass entertainment about it she would mutter on about how "ghastly" it was and eventually turn it off in disgust. Adverts used to make her froth at the mouth.

I have to really fight some of these instincts with my own DD as YouTube/Tiktok trigger some of these responses in me. I'm (just about) self-aware enough to understand that my response is not rational and to understand that this is the medium which children use to communicate. But it's sometimes hard for me to unpick what is legitimate concern about inappropriate or unwholesome content and what is just the ghost of my mother and her judgement about mass entertainment.

I can, however, recognise this with laser-like accuracy in other adults of my generation who had a similar upbringing. When another adult says "oh we never watch TV (but we do watch documentaries on Netflix", a part of me goes: "I see you and I know exactly what your game is."

People who say they don't watch TV (but actually do watch documentaries or highbrow series on Netflix) are basically snobs.

Pillowjoy · 15/01/2023 16:56

Beees · 15/01/2023 16:50

but I don’t think that many children watch tv now at all.

I'd say that your child and his friends were anomalies if they truly all never watch TV. Bonding over TV shows or what they are watching on netflix etc is still very much the done thing in every school I've taught at in the past few years and as a supply teacher that sample size is pretty extensive.

He’s been at three schools in two countries and I just haven’t seen much evidence of extensive tv watching across the board. I’m not saying none at all, just that ‘screen time’ is very much gaming, and tv, when it happens, seems to be a ‘family activity’ often initiated by parents.

Beees · 15/01/2023 16:50

but I don’t think that many children watch tv now at all.

I'd say that your child and his friends were anomalies if they truly all never watch TV. Bonding over TV shows or what they are watching on netflix etc is still very much the done thing in every school I've taught at in the past few years and as a supply teacher that sample size is pretty extensive.

TwoMonthsOff · 15/01/2023 16:48

@Gwenhwyfar
presumably when the BBC wasn’t broadcasting ‘til death Do us part’ anymore
😭

Heatherjayne1972 · 15/01/2023 16:45

I unplugged my tv at the beginning of the pandemic. No way was I watching boris everyday and having all that fear poured into my kids
I moved it and unplugged it from the arial thing so we can’t watch it even if we wanted to
I don’t have Netflix. I hate sport
they can watch dvds as I still have a DVD player and they play Xbox or whatever
but no. No telly here- genuinely

Gwenhwyfar · 15/01/2023 16:41

"In our childhoods, absolutely that would have been a big deal, but I don’t think that many children watch tv now at all."

They watch videos on YouTube and TikTok don't they?
Imagine not knowing about anything outside your own friends' and family...

Gwenhwyfar · 15/01/2023 16:40

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 16:20

@Gwenhwyfar

Of course, adults can suit themselves. I don’t think a lack of regular tv viewing has a negative impact on quality of life unless you have nothing else to do.

But deliberately and systematically choosing to exclude a child from such a major cultural touchpoint, in the apparent belief that this is somehow enriching their lives, seems perverse and selfish.

I knew a girl when I was at school who was only allowed to watch the BBC channels (presumably commercial tv was insufficiently intellectually enriching). That struck me as an extraordinary piece of nanny state arrogance on the part of the parents.

I agree with you completely.
However, I've seen the 'BBC only' thing quoted here on MN many times by women talking about their own childhoods. Snobby mothers I think!

Pillowjoy · 15/01/2023 16:38

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 16:20

@Gwenhwyfar

Of course, adults can suit themselves. I don’t think a lack of regular tv viewing has a negative impact on quality of life unless you have nothing else to do.

But deliberately and systematically choosing to exclude a child from such a major cultural touchpoint, in the apparent belief that this is somehow enriching their lives, seems perverse and selfish.

I knew a girl when I was at school who was only allowed to watch the BBC channels (presumably commercial tv was insufficiently intellectually enriching). That struck me as an extraordinary piece of nanny state arrogance on the part of the parents.

In our childhoods, absolutely that would have been a big deal, but I don’t think that many children watch tv now at all. DS, who is almost 11, doesn’t, and none of his friends seem to — their screen touch point is playing Xbox games together. If I forbade him to watch tv, it would currently have zero negative impact on his life.

Pillowjoy · 15/01/2023 16:29

Westernesse · 15/01/2023 15:36

Almost everyone who trots out “I don’t watch TV” is a liar and they are saying it to try to project something about themselves.

The tiny minority of those who truly do not watch TV or any form of screen are very likely to have significant issues.

Either way, when someone comes out with this I mark it as a red flag and the person is one for the watching from there on.

What a silly comment. I would find someone who has such a batshit reaction to someone not sharing their hobby far odder than whether or not someone watched tv.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 16:20

@Gwenhwyfar

Of course, adults can suit themselves. I don’t think a lack of regular tv viewing has a negative impact on quality of life unless you have nothing else to do.

But deliberately and systematically choosing to exclude a child from such a major cultural touchpoint, in the apparent belief that this is somehow enriching their lives, seems perverse and selfish.

I knew a girl when I was at school who was only allowed to watch the BBC channels (presumably commercial tv was insufficiently intellectually enriching). That struck me as an extraordinary piece of nanny state arrogance on the part of the parents.

Bubblebubblebah · 15/01/2023 16:16

Even with freeview one can choose what they want to watch. Not having streaming service doesn't mean people just put random channel on and mindlessly watch whatever is on it even if they don't like it though.

DuchessofSandwich · 15/01/2023 16:14

I watch tv now but didn't watch it for 6 years in my twenties. As in: I physically didn't own a tv, and netflix/youtube/smart phones didn't exist yet.

I like streaming, I didn't/don't like mindless watching without being able to pick it out myself or being able to pause it. Maybe that's what people mean?

VickyEadieofThigh · 15/01/2023 16:14

We have good friends whom we love but the woman half of the couple says almost every time we speak - if we recommend a TV series, for example - "Oh, we never watch TV, I'd be happy not even to have a set in the house". The male half says nothing of the kind.

Invariably, later in the conversation she will bring up programmes they've watched in the last week...They have subscriptions to Netflix and Britbox, too.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/01/2023 16:10

"And risks making their children very alienated from most of their peers and leaving them struggling to learn technology at school."

I agree that it's not good for children to have an upbringing where they are not exposed to normal things, but it's fine for an adult to not watch TV at home. Presumably, even those who don't have their own TV will occasionally watch something if they visit someone else or at the cinema.

Bubblebubblebah · 15/01/2023 16:07

I don't think people not watching anything has issues. Horses for courses. Same like with people who watch a lot