Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People that Say they don't watch TV

464 replies

Aquarius1234 · 14/01/2023 22:04

OMG so annoying. Esp those that lie.
You do watch TV so stop making out you spend all evening not looking at a screen!
Or those that say they never watch movies or go cinema. You then find out they go twice a year.
Watching sport or netflix counts as watching tv regardless if you watch it on your laptop or not.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoNewsIsGoodNews · 17/01/2023 08:44

JessicaBrassica · 15/01/2023 18:52

I watch one show with my husband and one with my daughter. Sometimes we'll watch something as a family. Frequently we'll watch the first couple of episodes then forget to watch the rest. Never watch live TV (no aerial). Did has been to the cinema 3x in her life. I've not been without a child for 5 years.
I do say we don't watch TV because I actually can't discuss anything that is on TV.

’I watch one show with my husband and one with my daughter. Sometimes we'll watch something as a family. Frequently we'll watch the first couple of episodes then forget to watch the rest. …,

I do say we don't watch TV because I actually can't discuss anything that is on TV.’

In most people’s eyes, you do watch TV then, albeit not live. Like most people these days. Why make a statement about not watching TV? What are you trying to prove?! Why not say that you don’t watch much TV?! If you really need to share that info with people in your life…

MissingMoominMamma · 16/01/2023 23:43

I do actually listen to the wireless! 😁

Changechangychange · 16/01/2023 23:11

Honestly, for me it is a mixture of laziness and stinginess. We had a tv until terrestrial tv was switched off. We got a Freeview box but we don’t have a rooftop aerial in our flat, and the set top aerial didn’t work well enough, even with a booster. So we got rid of it, and went to the pub for sports/used YouTube for other stuff.

We did use the CBeebies app when DS was young, but that has also been switched off and full iplayer seems really invasive to set up. Plus we’d have to pay for another TV licence, which seems expensive when there’s nothing I’m desperate to see.

We don’t have Netflix because there isn’t anything on it that I want to watch that much, which isn’t available elsewhere. Somebody mentioned Games of Tbrones upthread - I followed it on Tumblr! Much quicker, probably funnier, and no gore. I had absolutely no desire to watch an actual episode. We do have Prime, but again there doesn’t seem to be much on it to interest me. DS watches it a lot.

I considered Disney, Paramount etc, but again they seem really expensive just so DS can watch Spidey and His Amazing Friends, especially when there’s a channel on YouTube playing it non-stop.

When I go to DM’s or to a hotel, I never find much on live TV. It all seems to be Police Camera Action, reality shows, or sitcom repeats. I like a lot of stuff on the Discovery Channel and History Channel, but nothing I’d pay £60 a month to Sky to be able to watch. I enjoyed Deutschland 83 on Prime, but that was 6 years ago and I keep meaning to watch 86 and 89 but never get round to it.

It isn’t snobbery, I spend my time on Mumsnet, YouTube, Duolingo and playing Solitaire, not reading Proust. DS likes watching kids’ programmes, and I am happy to sit with him. DH pirates a lot of stuff (mostly old Law and Order series as far as I can tell), but I can’t be bothered working out how to do that.

We don’t own a car for similar reasons - I live close to both my work and DS’s school, so I wouldn’t use it more than once a fortnight or so, and I’d rather have an occasional bit of inconvenience using a taxi or public transport over spending a fortune on running a car I rarely use.

WisteriaLodge · 16/01/2023 22:37

Do you play the piano or violin and listen to the wireless? This is what I mean! SIL says she never watches tv, but she actually watches catch up, cue MIL clasping her hands and gasping in pride thinking that her daughter was in the corner of the living room reading Jane Austen and not watching tv, I had to put her straight of course..

TheKeatingFive · 16/01/2023 18:59

Who cares? I just roll my eyes at these types.

Gwenhwyfar · 16/01/2023 18:57

"not Netflix/Prime/Disney as they streaming platforms they may or may not be using their TV to access."

That's silly. Someone watching Netflix on their computer is no less of a TV watcher than someone who watches it on a TV set.

PriamFarrl · 15/01/2023 23:11

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 23:07

@PriamFarrl

Not just Lord Reith but the whole puritanical idea that time is money and should be spent wisely. If you aren’t actively doing something then you are wasting time.

I have to say I'm hugely guilty of this. I have a raging Protestant worth ethic and have to be doing something productive all the time or I hate myself. Which is why binge-watching TV doesn't really suit my temperament. Even reading for long periods of time makes me feel idle and guilty.

But yes I do think TV gets unfairly tarred with the brush of idleness. People can waste a lot of time on it for sure and moderation is key but it's not intrinsically worse or less healthy than any other kind of down-time.

Exactly. You can be watching a documentary about Ancient Rome and that is seen as bad because it’s TV. But if you are reading some complete trash that’s seen as good because it’s a book.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 23:07

Work ethic! Not worth ethic

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 23:07

@PriamFarrl

Not just Lord Reith but the whole puritanical idea that time is money and should be spent wisely. If you aren’t actively doing something then you are wasting time.

I have to say I'm hugely guilty of this. I have a raging Protestant worth ethic and have to be doing something productive all the time or I hate myself. Which is why binge-watching TV doesn't really suit my temperament. Even reading for long periods of time makes me feel idle and guilty.

But yes I do think TV gets unfairly tarred with the brush of idleness. People can waste a lot of time on it for sure and moderation is key but it's not intrinsically worse or less healthy than any other kind of down-time.

PriamFarrl · 15/01/2023 22:49

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 18:07

@Gwenhwyfar

Also in the 70s and 80s some people had their TVs hidden by a cupboard and when satellites and wide screens first came out they were also seen as common.

Yep. Entertainment is the real front line of snobbery and the Byzantine weirdness of class attitudes today. It’s always been a subtle but unmistakable class cue but it’s far more complicated and even harder to understand with streaming, multichannel TV and the internet.

Much of this neurosis we have (writ large on this thread) about Netflix and all the stuff about “not watching TV” is people acting out weird shit their parents passed on to them back in the 1980s about what your TV habits signal to the neighbourhood about you.

I posted this upthread earlier but non British people find this sort of thing utterly bonkers and they are right. It’s crackers.

Lord Reith has a lot to answer for.

Not just Lord Reith but the whole puritanical idea that time is money and should be spent wisely. If you aren’t actively doing something then you are wasting time.

OopsAnotherOne · 15/01/2023 22:39

I almost never watch live TV, but I regularly watch Netflix on my TV. It depends what your definition of “watch TV” is really. When people tell me they don’t watch much TV I assume it means live TV (freeview, Sky etc) but not Netflix/Prime/Disney as they streaming platforms they may or may not be using their TV to access.

To be honest though OP, there are bigger issues out there, this really isn’t something to get worked up about.

Gwenhwyfar · 15/01/2023 22:28

GilChesterton · 15/01/2023 21:02

TV has dumbed down for sure

The era that produced I, Claudius was also the era that produced Love Thy Neighbour and Some Mothers Do 'Ave Em. You can find examples of high and low culture in any era.

TV is actually much more sophisticated these days. Some of the series on Netflix demand quite a lot of attention to understand the plot.
And I think Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em was quite good anyway!

tillytoodles1 · 15/01/2023 21:49

I watch TV occasionally, usually Game of Thrones maybe once or twice a week. If it stopped woking I would get rid of it and not get another one.

GilChesterton · 15/01/2023 21:02

TV has dumbed down for sure

The era that produced I, Claudius was also the era that produced Love Thy Neighbour and Some Mothers Do 'Ave Em. You can find examples of high and low culture in any era.

AnnieSnap · 15/01/2023 20:33

@JoonT what do you mean by ‘woke’ and ‘PC drivel’ exactly? 🤔

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 20:23

@Pillowjoy

They think it’s a claim of intellectual elitism, rather than an entirely neutral choice not to engage in a widespread leisure activity. (Maybe akin to not drinking being greeted with disbelief, attempts to persuade and a sense that the non-drinker must be boring or that there must be some explanation for why they don’t do something so widespread…) I don’t see it as an intellectual decision, it’s just a choice to do other stuff rather than watch tv.

I don't disagree with that. I think that the expectation that everyone "should" watch landmark shows as some sort of cultural moment can be incredibly suffocating. I remember feeling like this about Game of Thrones and, much earlier, Big Brother (and to a lesser extent when the Harry Potter books first came out). People seem insulted by your reluctance to participate and it gets very draining.

I also don't watch a great deal TV because I don't have time, and very little live TV except news, because the timing doesn't work for me. And I will almost never prioritise watching TV over another leisure activity.

But I stand by the fact that I think nine times out of ten when people say: "I don't watch TV" it's a) very rarely true and b) pointed and with an undertone of cultural one-upmanship.

scrivette · 15/01/2023 19:19

I very rarely watch tv, maybe a film a month, although I did watch and enjoy Wednesday recently, it's the first series I have watched for years.

JaneJeffer · 15/01/2023 19:19

JoonT · 15/01/2023 18:47

I hardly ever watch TV. The vast majority is mindless, woke garbage. That said, I have a soft spot for Bake Off. Actually, I quite like shows like that – where you have a bunch of random people competing at something (masterchef, etc). But I can't bear the soaps, and I never watch any dramas, which are badly-written, badly-acted, PC drivel. I also find 99% of films unwatchable.

TV has dumbed down for sure. I have recently been watching old episdodes of 'Great Philosophers' on youtube. In the 1970s, Bryan Magee, a British philosophy lecturer, made a series of programmes on which he discussed the great philosophers with a guest, usually a British or American professor. They would spend 40 minutes talking about, say, Plato, or Nietzsche, in an intelligent, civilized way – no gimmicks, no music, nothing. Just two highly-educated human beings having a fascinating discussion. God, it's amazing. Such a show would be unimaginable now. If anybody dared, they'd be accused of elitism. Somebody also bought me I Claudius on DVD for Christmas. Again, hard to imagine it being made today – the actors speak in too refined an accent. They also speak too eloquently and quickly.

Grin
Bubblebubblebah · 15/01/2023 19:15

Few, not couple

Bubblebubblebah · 15/01/2023 19:14

@Pillowjoy I think post couple of posts above your last one explains why people often hear that.😉

Pillowjoy · 15/01/2023 19:12

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 18:37

@Pillowjoy

I don’t think it’s just that, though. I think there’s a real strand of anti-intellectualism in UK culture, and part of the reason discussions about not watching tv get such kneejerk responses is that people think that someone who says they don’t watch tv is claiming some form of superior intellectual status. When someone says ‘I don’t watch tv’, what people hear is ‘I’m clever. I’m cleverer than you.’ Which is akin to saying you torture kittens in the public approval stakes.

I agree that there's a culture of anti-intellectualism in the UK (although I actually think that applies in a lot of cultures). I think if you went to most European countries and walked into a home and said "I don't watch TV" you would get similar reactions from many people.

But the fact that you think saying: "I don't watch TV" is a way of saying "I'm cleverer than you" is an admission that this is basically what it sets out to achieve. I do think at some level (whether conscious or otherwise) this is what this statement is designed to communicate. Given that that is the cultural shorthand, perhaps it's not surprising it makes people feel so defensive. It's a bit like other cultural cues which are associated with self-conscious "cleverness" or sophistication. Saying you only eat organic food, or that you could never work for a multinational corporation, for example. It's usually a way of stealthily signalling a) that you "get it" and are in the know b) that your financial or cultural "richness" is such that you don't need to do things which ordinary people need to do.

Also let's unpick the concept of being an "intellectual" a bit. Why should watching TV be intrinsically less "clever" than other pursuits? All human life is on TV. You can watch things that are impenetrably highbrow or absolute trash on the same channel in the same 24 hours. There's nothing inherent to the medium which is less "clever". I've argued upthread that this dates back to the birth of television in the UK and the way people saw it as a mass medium and I can't get away from the idea that this is what it comes down to.

And why should "intellectualism" be the preserve only of those people who seek to distance themselves from the masses? If you set yourself up as someone who chooses pursuits to underline their own status as an intellectual, and in doing so in rejecting things that bring pleasure and information to ordinary people, you can see why this gets people's backs up.

You’re misunderstanding me, @Thepeopleversuswork - and you’re a poster I have a lot of time for. I’m not saying that I think tv is inherently anti-intellectual (my —total prick— doctoral supervisor was generally absent doing his regular stint of heavy-duty public intellectual stuff back in the day, and I know quite a few academics who make tv documentaries on art and history), I’m saying I think this is what people hear. They think it’s a claim of intellectual elitism, rather than an entirely neutral choice not to engage in a widespread leisure activity. (Maybe akin to not drinking being greeted with disbelief, attempts to persuade and a sense that the non-drinker must be boring or that there must be some explanation for why they don’t do something so widespread…) I don’t see it as an intellectual decision, it’s just a choice to do other stuff rather than watch tv. From the other current thread about people coming home from work and getting straight into their night clothes, I think I go out more at night than many people on here. Another thing is that don’t have the commitment many people seem to for box sets. The last series I watched was The West Wing. People keep telling me that Mad Men and Breaking Bad are brilliant, but I just can’t commit to that many hours. No judgement on those who do, obviously, but the idea freaks me out.

SultanOfSwing · 15/01/2023 19:12

Why do you care whether or not other people watch TV? Or what they clam about their tele habits?

NamelessTemptress01 · 15/01/2023 19:03

Just say I don’t watch much TV or I rarely watch TV then

JessicaBrassica · 15/01/2023 18:52

I watch one show with my husband and one with my daughter. Sometimes we'll watch something as a family. Frequently we'll watch the first couple of episodes then forget to watch the rest. Never watch live TV (no aerial). Did has been to the cinema 3x in her life. I've not been without a child for 5 years.
I do say we don't watch TV because I actually can't discuss anything that is on TV.

TheCatterall · 15/01/2023 18:47

I don’t watch TV. We stopped watching and paying for it 12 years ago. This was a decision made with my sons that were 10 and 16 at the time as we’d been discussing family budget and when they saw the annual break down etc they didn't feel that the bbc licence and sky fees were worth the money for how much we watched. I read extensively, do many online courses and have several hobbies instead.

I know what is going on in soaps and tv world from social media and friends, news media etc.

I have no idea what the op is getting all worked up about.