Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry my daughter will be taken away because of disagreement on parenting styles

132 replies

Anonymoussad · 14/01/2023 18:58

My daughter is four years old.

Maybe 3 or 4 times a month, she plays up a lot when it comes to bedtime. And by play up, I mean she starts to run around like crazy, she hits us, throws toys, has an awful attitude, kicks her bedroom, she's just really unpleasant because she doesn't want to go to sleep. She comes up with every excuse.

This can go on for 3 or 4 hours.

I usually close the door after 40ish minutes if nothing is calming her down. I explain to her why I'm closing the door, and then I stand outside her door for 60 seconds only with the door closed. She doesn't like this, but it's the only thing that seems to calm her down and make her realise she needs to sleep. She has lights on in her room, and she knows I'm outside. I never do this for more than 60 seconds. And usually, she will then climb into bed and sleep.

We live with my mother in law and last week as I was stood outside the door keeping it closed, she came upstairs and told me to stop. She started crying, saying it was abuse. She was saying I was traumatising her. And she said my little girl has spoke with her about how she doesn't like it.

I know my girl doesn't like it. But she gets even more hysterical if I don't close the door. She runs in and out of her room, she goes absolutely wild and thinks it is all a fun game, for hours and hours on end. She gets so upset because she is tired, and I am telling her to go to sleep.

Anyway, I agreed I would no longer close the door. I didn't want to, but I have no choice since it is her house.

However , now my daughter has started to act up every single night, and nothing I can do can calm her down. I can't close the door anymore, so we basically have 3 hours of my girl getting worked up and upset because she won't sleep even though she needs to.

I'm worried my mother in law has put into my daughters head that she is being abused, mummy is being horrible and her door is being locked. Whereas I see it as a timeout.

They have said I will be reported to social services when my girl tells her teacher I lock her in the room. And I'm devastated that she could be taken away over this.

I know it isn't the best approach and I am seeking help from a sleep specialist hopefully they can see me soon.

Am I really being that unreasonable by closing her door? Will she be taken away over this?

I am dealing with so much right now and I feel sick to my stomach that this has been blown so much out of proportion. I can't stop crying. I know closing the door on her for a minute isn't nice, but she's safe and it makes her realise it is time to calm down and sleep. And it's always a last resort after I see her working herself up and nothing is calming her down.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 14/01/2023 20:18

This is a non issue.
The child is a danger to herself if she's allowed to continue with the zooming around and wild behaviour, especially if she's upstairs and there's a danger of falling down stairs.

I'd rejig the bedtime routine for a little while - turn off the TV/ screens at least an hour before bedtime, and dim the lights everywhere, then take her to bed for a little reading of rhymes, listening to soothing music (Mozart, Johann Strauss are nice) and then dozing off to sleep, hopefully.

I'd be very tempted to let MIL take over the bedtime for a bit, to see what she comes up with. This would be after I had ruled out problems caused directly by MIL, however.

If you suspect this woman has set up a triangular communication dynamic, seeking to turn herself into your child's ally or confidant and setting your child up in opposition to you, I would prefer to sleep in a cardboard box under a motorway than remain in her house.

It is very possible that your child's behaviour is a response to being pulled in different directions - by her natural attachment to you and her grandmother horning in with a whispering campaign against you. Something is distressing your child. You need to get to the bottom of it.

Does MIL provide childcare?

gamerchick · 14/01/2023 20:17

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 20:14

Some of these replies are hilarious

Imagine someone posting on here ‘I’m housing my DS, his wife and child, they are unable to get her to sleep without hours of tears, they end up just shutting the child in her room and letting her cry for minutes at a time, DGD has told me she doesn’t like being left in the room by herself, I’ve voiced concerns about this and been told to do the bedtime myself if I don’t like how they’re doing it’

Posters would be ripping the DIL and DS a new bumhole in the comments

its absolutely not acceptable to ask MIL to do bedtime herself, it’s her bloody home.

I really don't think it would go down like that tbh.....

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 20:14

Some of these replies are hilarious

Imagine someone posting on here ‘I’m housing my DS, his wife and child, they are unable to get her to sleep without hours of tears, they end up just shutting the child in her room and letting her cry for minutes at a time, DGD has told me she doesn’t like being left in the room by herself, I’ve voiced concerns about this and been told to do the bedtime myself if I don’t like how they’re doing it’

Posters would be ripping the DIL and DS a new bumhole in the comments

its absolutely not acceptable to ask MIL to do bedtime herself, it’s her bloody home.

Tomblibooz · 14/01/2023 20:14

Sounds like she's overtired and overstimulated. My DD who's a similar age can get like this, and her running around can get frantic. It was as if once she cried, the energy was burned and she'd go to sleep, but obviously we didn't want her going to sleep crying every night (crying because we'd just silently keep putting her back to bed and stopped engaging with her).

We looked for other solutions and we've basically brought bedtime a lot earlier, 6.30pm usually but can be earlier if she's had a big day. We cuddle up in her bed and read books until she goes to sleep. We have a nightlite in her room but not anything that moves or spins as it's distracting. No bath before bed, gets her hyper. No screens before bed either. One teddy to cuddle along with a hot water bottle. Made sure she has a good balance of activities and downtime during the day if we can.

Bringonsummer19 · 14/01/2023 20:10

Can’t you just lay next to her till she falls asleep? It’s not ideal but must be better than the trauma your both experiencing

EricNorthmanYesPlease · 14/01/2023 20:09

You dont have to do anything just because its HER house. You are entitled to raise your child safely as you see fit, and calming her down in 1 minute with your technique is much kinder than 3+ hours of distress. Of course your daughter wont like it, its not meant to be a fun manoeuvre, but ultimately its dor her own good.
Your MIL as others have suggested needs to be asked to do bedtimes for a week to see what you are dealing with. Either she will leave you to it from then on, or have a way that works . She does however need to be told that if your daughter brings it up, she needs to tell your daughter you do it because you are trying to get her to sleep quicker rather than her messing about.

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 20:07

ShakespearesBlister · 14/01/2023 19:57

I suppose the real question is why do you live with your mother in law?

Bets are it’s cultural.

Hence why no mention of the father in this mess

BurtonsRevenge · 14/01/2023 20:07

Could you close the door on your MIL instead ?

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 20:06

TheShellBeach · 14/01/2023 19:51

60 seconds? FFS that's fine. I would have done it and paid no attention to MIL.

Or told MIL to do bedtimes herself.

The Ferber sleep training book recommends this anyway. It is not child abuse.

You’d have told the woman housing you to do bedtime for your child herself?

Good grief

Polik · 14/01/2023 20:06

I suspect you are minimising when you say 60 seconds.

I think you need help. Early Help would be ideal. If ypu told your HV (honestly) what's happening that could possibly trigger an EH referral. Parenting Trams often tun sleep clinics, you may get a referral.

Personal opinion - under 5 ish I wouldn't use any form of isolation time out.

gamerchick · 14/01/2023 20:06

The obvious answer is that your MIL does bedtime. Or am I missing something? Other than ,move the fuck out of there.

Nobody is going to o be interested in how you do bedtime, much less take your kids away.

Hoplesscynic · 14/01/2023 20:03

And you seriously believe that SS can/will take your daughter away over this? I'd be surprised if they even come out to see you, but if they did they'll pretty soon realise what a waste of time it was.
Stop buying into your MILs drama, do what works to get DD calm and in bed.
Your MIL sounds pretty awful, I'd say move out but if you can't then get your DP/DH to deal with her - firmly.

BreatheAndFocus · 14/01/2023 20:03

I meant to say that star charts worked well for my DC at that age. Give stars and have little rewards after gaining a small number. Then have a big reward for getting a bigger number.

Give stars for each stage of the bed process maybe, so your DD is frequently rewarded.

Floralnomad · 14/01/2023 20:01

Your OP makes no sense , you say she does it for 3/4 hours but after 40 minutes you close the door for 60 secs and she stops and goes to bed - so which is it 3/4 hours or 40 minutes ? If the first time you held the door shut it had the desired effect why do you continue to let her play up for 40 minutes the next time ? However the obvious answer is to move out

BreatheAndFocus · 14/01/2023 20:00

Why would your MIL say this? Is she stressed by the extended bedtime or is she trying to scare you? Are you quite young? Why are you living with your MIL? Is your DP/DH there too? If so, why isn’t he helping?

Speak to your HV for support if you need it, and really try to get out and in your own place.

RippleEffects · 14/01/2023 19:59

When your parenting is undermined and you start second guessing what you're doing it makes it all a bit tougher.

What concerns me about your words is your fear that you're doing something wrong. If it feels like potentially its wrong, then go with your gut - your own judgement.

What I've observed over the years is there are many right ways of doing things. A common factor in them working is consistency and boundaries.

I'm a fan of a carrot and stick approach.

When my eldest two were little it was just me and them. One of my succesful for me methods was they started the bedtime routine with their choice of three bedtime reads each (three shorts, three chapters, three made up stories/ rhymes) their choice. If they played up they would get a warning we'd be down to two, followed by removal of one. We're down to two. I wonder which two we'll have - enthusiastic still lots to play for and opportunity to have two great stories, which do you think you'd like etc.

We always had one story each - but sometimes it would be my choice as they'd used up their choices.

They don't come with a manual - I've three now, youngest 11 and each so very different with different challenges at different ages.

ShakespearesBlister · 14/01/2023 19:57

I suppose the real question is why do you live with your mother in law?

saltofcelery · 14/01/2023 19:53

This is what my daughter did for five years before she was diagnosed with autism and ADHD. Now she takes melatonin at 6.30 and is asleep by 7.15. She's a very, very happy child now and we have no more meltdowns or issues near bedtime.

I feel for you as I thought at times I was losing my mind.

chocaholic73 · 14/01/2023 19:53

This is not abuse. Nothing wrong with what you are doing.

chickchickpox · 14/01/2023 19:52

So sorry you are going through this, it sounds tough. As if parenting isn't hard enough your MIL doesn't sound very supportive at all. Maybe she could try bedtime and see what bright ideas she has? I work alongside SS (not a SW but attend meetings etc) there's no way they will take your LG away from you from what you have said in this post. How does you LG behave in general? Is it just bedtime that's the issue? I'm a Mum of a 4 yo and I would probably be taking the same approach tbh with you. I understand you are in your MIL house so don't want to upset her as she clearly feels very strongly about it but 3 hours of screaming is not good for you, your daughter or the whole house so you can't carry on the same way you are now and your MIL needs to realise that.

TheShellBeach · 14/01/2023 19:51

60 seconds? FFS that's fine. I would have done it and paid no attention to MIL.

Or told MIL to do bedtimes herself.

The Ferber sleep training book recommends this anyway. It is not child abuse.

Cherrysoup · 14/01/2023 19:51

Why do you allow her 40 minutes before closing the door which you say calms her and she then gets into bed? I would definitely ask your mil to shut the fuck up do bedtime for a week.

When can you move out?

samqueens · 14/01/2023 19:46

Babygate helped for us too!

samqueens · 14/01/2023 19:44

Onnabugeisha · 14/01/2023 19:27

To the child there isn’t really a difference because they cannot open the door either way.

To HV / Social services there is!!

I think the most worrying part of your post is that this is what your mil has said. But you actually write “they have said you’ll be reported…” is that your PIL or your partner and his mother?

of course if your DD says what they are suggesting she could say then someone would investigate. But there’s no reason she’d say that surely as it’s not true that this is every night etc. And, of course as @missmap says, it would not escalate to the level of social services intervention. There’s a book called Toddler Taming by Christopher Green that offers a very similar approach. As long as you’re explaining the process to your daughter calmly and carrying it out calmly and not yelling at her and throwing her in her room then what you’re doing seems to be implementing a strategy to help calm the situation rather than abuse.

id be worried if my PIL took this attitude rather than trying to be on my team about it and even more worried if my partner was on board with that.

(Also my little one sometimes got this way when she needed to do a poo before bed, in case that helps at all… sadly you can’t make them do one, so you sometimes just have to ride it out, but some trips to the loo might help!)

Manasprey · 14/01/2023 19:44

Do you have a routine? Or is it:"right, bed. "?

Mine used to go a bit mad at bedtime. Vivid memories of dc2 doing an ET and wearing the entire contents of the laundry basket, and parading around, singing, while I tried to read to dc1.

We used to watch cbeebies, go and do teeth, have a bit of a sing etc getting pjs on, then sit in my bed and read stories. That usually calmed them enough. Usually.