Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That people object to council plans for selfish and uninformed reasons

216 replies

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:04

I live in a village which has doubled in size over the last 5 years (still pretty small tbh).

It is well located, 5 miles from a major town and has potentially good public transport links but with really low service levels (hourly trains, no buses on a Sunday sort of thing). There are few amenities here - no petrol garage, supermarket, pub, cafe but does have a few corner shops and a primary school. Loads and loads of countryside and good walking.

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons - e.g. don't support compulsory purchase of farmland, the village is "already too big".

Perhaps they are just going through the change curve but I don't see how they can't see the benefits in improving the amenities and services, providing more affordable housing in an area that desperately needs it, whilst still retaining almost all the countryside.

So AIBU to think they are being blinkered / selfish and actually this is a scheme for the greater good whilst also benefitting us residents.

OP posts:
Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 17:46

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:36

How disappointing to hear from all PPs where improvements to amenities, services and infrastructure were promised but not followed through on. I can see how this would make some very wary.

However, this actually supports my point that objecting to the development that will probably go ahead anyway is the wrong thing to do. The focus should be on ensuring the right improvements to amenities are made.

So do you no if extra schools/doctors surgeries etc are included in these plans?

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 17:41

TimeForMeToF1y · 14/01/2023 17:40

So nothing to do with the average leveli of intelligence, that was what I couldnt work out

I have no idea on the statistics on the proportion of objections with valid grounds. Do you work in planning?

good grief, you’re an idiot and hard work at that

ethelredonagoodday · 14/01/2023 17:40

I work for a council in a related field to planning.

I'm no expert in this, but from the peripheral involvement I've had I'll say this: People, in the main, detest development in their area, and fight it tooth and nail. Where this is fundamentally changing a place, I can I understand that!

Councils have government targets to achieve to provide new housing, so have to make provision for this in their local plans. All the easy to develop places have generally already been developed, so what's now left are the less popular sites, the technically more difficult sites, the sites which require investment to make them feasible.

Developers try to screw councils down to provide as little mitigation funding as they possible can, maximise the amount of units they can deliver, and employ consultants to downplay the impact of their development on existing infrastructure. Ultimately the majority of house builders are private businesses aiming to make a profit.

Councils try to condition developers to deliver amenities, but often the developers will argue this should only be done once they've built a certain number of units. Sometimes once they've got to that number of units, they stop building. Most developers I've had any involvement will do everything they can to reduce the extent of the mitigation funding they give to councils. If this gets to legal proceeding, the developers can generally afford better legal representation than the councils. It's not a fun game to be in to be honest...

TimeForMeToF1y · 14/01/2023 17:40

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 17:36

Nope, usually the idiots with no awareness or understanding tend to object over the silliest of reasons.

So nothing to do with the average leveli of intelligence, that was what I couldnt work out

I have no idea on the statistics on the proportion of objections with valid grounds. Do you work in planning?

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 14/01/2023 17:40

Small village here ruled by NIMBYs. Because there has been no development, the family houses are still occupied by singles or couples in their 70s who refuse any development. Meanwhile the school roll number is dropping and the bus route has just been massively reduced due to no longer being viable. Still they insist the village wouldn’t cope with more development.

Another village near us is losing its primary school due to falling roll numbers. 30-40 family houses in these villages would be transformative. Local demographics are important and mob rule shouldn’t be allowed to drive planning.

LlynTegid · 14/01/2023 17:36

It very much depends on the plans.

What we do not need in most cases is more commercial and retail space given the level of empty shops, or locations where there is no established public transport so all you do is just add car traffic. Until government is prepared to tackle things such as parents driving half a mile to and from school and then back home, you have to expect more cars, usually larger than is needed or desirable.

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 17:36

TimeForMeToF1y · 14/01/2023 17:36

As that's pretty much how averages work how does it impact on planning objections ?

Are you saying that only those with above average intelligence get to object?

Nope, usually the idiots with no awareness or understanding tend to object over the silliest of reasons.

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:36

How disappointing to hear from all PPs where improvements to amenities, services and infrastructure were promised but not followed through on. I can see how this would make some very wary.

However, this actually supports my point that objecting to the development that will probably go ahead anyway is the wrong thing to do. The focus should be on ensuring the right improvements to amenities are made.

OP posts:
TimeForMeToF1y · 14/01/2023 17:36

SandyLanez · 14/01/2023 17:08

YANBU, unfortunately half the population are impacted by below average intelligence

As that's pretty much how averages work how does it impact on planning objections ?

Are you saying that only those with above average intelligence get to object?

Liz1tummypain · 14/01/2023 17:35

I couldn't say if YABU or YANBU here. I know where we live there are similar plans. I always think objecting is useless because the plans have already been agreed but maybe that's just cynicism. For very small villages I think it's a shame because they don't widen the roads and it means more children have to walk along busy roads with narrow pavements and it's just a matter of time before they're going to see a nasty road accident.

But in the main I agree with you. People need housing and we need to accept they have to be built somewhere.

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/01/2023 17:35

I used to live in a lovely village where the council gave permission for a large number of new, large houses. They consulted locally and the response to questions about capacity of the separate infant and junior schools - neither of which had any room for expansion- was that there were spaces in other schools several miles away. What I need to add is that the land for these new houses was closer to the schools than the old houses in the village - meaning that this was existing residents (many of whom had lived in the village as children) who might well be denied places for their children by incomers buying the new houses.

The council's response was that those parents affected would "have to get their children to the schools where there were places". End of story.

OP, THAT (qnd issues such as the fact that the one GP surgery was already overstretched) is why people object. The fact that there was available brownfield land a couple of miles away meant nothing - because (of course) the developers wouldn't be able to demand such high prices if they built there.

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:34

EmmaEmerald · 14/01/2023 17:30

No, we have a crisis of overpopulation and unaffordable housing, neither of which are solved by schemes like this.

Wrong. We have an ageing population not over population. Are you suggesting the birth rate should reduce further then? Who will care for you in old age?

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 14/01/2023 17:34

Dogs4Ever · 14/01/2023 17:23

I live in a very small village. I love living in a very small village. I know everyone, my dogs know everyone, I can walk around chatting if I want to or just wave and walk. This is why I chose this village. I do not want it to double in size because I chose to live in a very small village. Why is it selfish not to want this village to grow?

Could it be because you literally made it all about you?

PumpkinDart · 14/01/2023 17:32

In our village they added basically another village to the outskirts of it, promises of a new school, doctors surgery, shop, park. All empty. Half built estate, half built links to the estate and the original village. It's a shit show. Don't bank on the amenities being carried out. Completely understand why people are objecting.

Grantanow · 14/01/2023 17:30

Housing developments in villages are unlikely to include social housing which is one of the key needs at present. So-called affordable homes are out of reach of many. Having opposed a large development I have no doubt that infrastructure will not keep pace - you won't easily get more GP surgeries, local shops, schools and community facilities. Developers are supposed to contribute to infrastructure but they often plead lack of profit and try to wriggle out in my opinion. And most developments are on greenfield sites (cheaper to do than brownfield) on the outskirts so leading to more car journeys to school, work and shopping with attendant pollution and traffic. Local councils should be helped by government to build social housing but I don't think the Tories care about that, given Mrs T sold off so many council houses.

EmmaEmerald · 14/01/2023 17:30

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:24

Because we have a housing crisis affecting 100,000s of people ?

No, we have a crisis of overpopulation and unaffordable housing, neither of which are solved by schemes like this.

Pixiedust1234 · 14/01/2023 17:29

Why would anyone object to a new hospital

You didn't read it properly. It was the fact they didn't think car parking was needed as much and factor it into the planning. Apparently ill people should be travelling on a minimum of two buses each way or cycle. Which is stupid and impractical. They didn't think it through properly, rode roughshod over people putting their views and decades later admit its not fit for purpose as even the doctors and nurses struggle to park..but apparently they should cycle more 🙄

ClubhouseGift · 14/01/2023 17:28

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:24

Because we have a housing crisis affecting 100,000s of people ?

So? You can’t just build houses and think that fixes everything. It doesn’t. It causes more problems when the infrastructure and amenities aren’t there too.

And quite honestly, the housing crisis isn’t Emily from Quiet Village’s problem or responsibility.

OrigamiOwls · 14/01/2023 17:27

My town is going through massive development, of houses only. No extra local infrastructure is planned. The doctors surgeries are full already, there are no dentists taking on patients (either NHS or private patients), the schools are at capacity. The town can't cater for all these extra people.

FrippEnos · 14/01/2023 17:26

Bamboozle123

Currently where I am the council allowed the builders to build as the builders promised a shopping area, with a dentist and doctors surgery and a new school.

What has appeared is a large build with a shopping area.

I don't know how the construction company got out of building the amenities.
But it has left locals (and the new locals) with a very bad taste in our mouths and a severe lack of trust in the council.

So why should the locals trust the council and construction company when they have already broken there word?

SameToo · 14/01/2023 17:26

You should be able to see the proposed plans on the Planning Portal which will show if there are any additional amenities proposed and proposed upgrades to existing amenities.

In my experience, the main worries are that the infrastructure won’t support the new build, drs offices/schools etc will be oversubscribed and the character of the area will be lost. If it’s another Barrett Homes or similar cut and paste development I wouldn’t be happy.

MintJulia · 14/01/2023 17:25

YABU. Is there work there? Senior school places? Sewage capacity? Sufficient water? Fragile eco-systems being damaged? There's a lot more to planning than just a few extra amenities.

The other issue is food security. We're in the middle of an energy crisis caused by the Russian invasion. If we build on any more good quality farmland, we could easily face a food security issue. Do you fancy going hungry.

The countryside isn't a pretty place for walking in. It's one huge factory that feeds us all, and if we build on any more land, we become more vulnerable (already at risk) of going hungry.

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:24

Dogs4Ever · 14/01/2023 17:23

I live in a very small village. I love living in a very small village. I know everyone, my dogs know everyone, I can walk around chatting if I want to or just wave and walk. This is why I chose this village. I do not want it to double in size because I chose to live in a very small village. Why is it selfish not to want this village to grow?

Because we have a housing crisis affecting 100,000s of people ?

OP posts:
Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:23

Pixiedust1234 · 14/01/2023 17:21

You should never support compulsory purchases of viable farmland. Thats just foolish as we can never get it back. Covid and brexit should have taught us that we are too reliant on other countries for basic food.

As for your title, many people where I live didn't want a new hospital with limited parking despite the council saying that it was in an area with good bus links and cycle paths. Councils are notorious for being wrong and generally being twats to their constituents.

See I think this is a great example.

Why would anyone object to a new hospital and miss the point that it's very much needed, rather than focusing on working with the council to ensure there are sufficient transport links or parking?

It just feels like we are missing the opportunity to improve our services by focusing on the wrong thing.

OP posts:
Dogs4Ever · 14/01/2023 17:23

I live in a very small village. I love living in a very small village. I know everyone, my dogs know everyone, I can walk around chatting if I want to or just wave and walk. This is why I chose this village. I do not want it to double in size because I chose to live in a very small village. Why is it selfish not to want this village to grow?