Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That people object to council plans for selfish and uninformed reasons

216 replies

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:04

I live in a village which has doubled in size over the last 5 years (still pretty small tbh).

It is well located, 5 miles from a major town and has potentially good public transport links but with really low service levels (hourly trains, no buses on a Sunday sort of thing). There are few amenities here - no petrol garage, supermarket, pub, cafe but does have a few corner shops and a primary school. Loads and loads of countryside and good walking.

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons - e.g. don't support compulsory purchase of farmland, the village is "already too big".

Perhaps they are just going through the change curve but I don't see how they can't see the benefits in improving the amenities and services, providing more affordable housing in an area that desperately needs it, whilst still retaining almost all the countryside.

So AIBU to think they are being blinkered / selfish and actually this is a scheme for the greater good whilst also benefitting us residents.

OP posts:
Andypandy799 · 14/01/2023 20:11

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 19:35

NIMBY is such a ridiculous term. No-one is going to take an interest in my back yard like I do - it's just a stupid ill-considered insult.
In fact in my area we are bearing the brunt of local politicians dumping the new estates here so they aren't in their back yard.

But that’s the problem houses needed to be built and obviously people who it affects don’t want it but then there is never a solution to the problem

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 14/01/2023 20:10

NewYearNewName2023 · 14/01/2023 19:51

Where I live they keep building massive developments but nothing is ever done with infrastructure, so yes people start to get pissed off with worsening traffic, no parking (due to ridiculous planning rules that don't allow for enough parking on new developments even though public transport is shit around here and most people have to travel to other bigger towns get to work so 'encouraging walking and cycling' is never going to work), no school places, and increasing pressures on already hard to get GP appointments

Not to mention that people tend to move to areas like you describe because that is exactly the type of place they want to live, not a much bigger village or small town

This. It's stupid and simplistic to just say people are being NIMBYs

Mamaneedsadrink · 14/01/2023 20:09

7 years ago we brought a house, checked the planning zones etc and paid a premium for the views. That was actually the thing that swayed us. Now I have a 6 story apartment next door and might be surrounded by more in the future, and not only lose my views but any sunlight! Those are the breaks, but it's devastating as our house has dramatically dropped in value as well. If we had realised this would happen we never would have brought this house.
I can see the same if you buy in a village, you buy it because you want that 'lifestyle'.
I think in 100 years people will realise that planning should have been better thought out when all we are surrounded by is these box houses. But who knows, maybe also no one will care. Time will tell 🤷🏼‍♀️

ohfook · 14/01/2023 20:08

My previously tiny fairly rural estate has grown in size massively in recent years. Just like other posters have said the infrastructure and amenities haven't changed at all.

It's a ballache getting a doctors appointment you can't park anywhere near the little Tesco and school places have became very competitive. The worst thing imo is we have this tiny roundabout that now deals with a huge amount of traffic. It desperately needs changing - there have been two fatal accidents on it - but it doesn't look like it's happening.

AlmostSummer21 · 14/01/2023 20:02

YABU

Some people like living in a small village, 5 miles from a town. They don't mind not having (or even don't want) your list if 'amenities' if you do, you should move to somewhere that already has them.

it's hilarious that you think new build estates means additional amenities.

I liked our village, until they built two huge housing estates & not so much as a new corner shop, let alone Drs, post office, schools. It's technically still a village, just a bloody over crowded one now!

of course the existing houses are worth less as it's lost its charm, gained shoddily build new houses & now has 'issues' (too much traffic, not enough Drs, too many teenagers with nothing to do except cause trouble & take over the kids play park!

maybe I'm a nimby, but I chose to live here because it was a village with lots of green space & farming land. I wanted cows & sheep as neighbours!!! There are plenty of places in the U.K. that need regenerating & housing stock made nice or flattened & new houses built.

NewYearNewName2023 · 14/01/2023 19:59

FrippEnos · 14/01/2023 17:26

Bamboozle123

Currently where I am the council allowed the builders to build as the builders promised a shopping area, with a dentist and doctors surgery and a new school.

What has appeared is a large build with a shopping area.

I don't know how the construction company got out of building the amenities.
But it has left locals (and the new locals) with a very bad taste in our mouths and a severe lack of trust in the council.

So why should the locals trust the council and construction company when they have already broken there word?

Where we are they built a 400 house development on a road, which has a weak bridge (only one car at a time) on it.

This road is a nightmare at the best of times with huge queues at rush hour, so they were supposed to sort that out.

Of course they never did (suspect they did the surveys during lockdown and argued that there wasn't enough traffic to warrant it) , they put a roundabout at the other end but the end with the bridge is still the same as it ever was

Justanotherlurker · 14/01/2023 19:56

Intersting comparison thread

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4719386-how-are-we-paying-to-house-asylum-seekers

NewYearNewName2023 · 14/01/2023 19:51

Where I live they keep building massive developments but nothing is ever done with infrastructure, so yes people start to get pissed off with worsening traffic, no parking (due to ridiculous planning rules that don't allow for enough parking on new developments even though public transport is shit around here and most people have to travel to other bigger towns get to work so 'encouraging walking and cycling' is never going to work), no school places, and increasing pressures on already hard to get GP appointments

Not to mention that people tend to move to areas like you describe because that is exactly the type of place they want to live, not a much bigger village or small town

JaniceBattersby · 14/01/2023 19:50

Nobody wants 100 houses built in their backyard whether they live in a big city, a town, a village or a tiny hamlet.

So yes you might have moved to a village for peace and quiet but if you’re living in a city (maybe not through choice..) and you have a tiny patch of green space near you and they decide to build yet more houses on there, then that could have a huge impact on your quality of life.

Every place needs to take their quota of new homes. Why should villages be exempt? Your house was a field once too.

I live in a market town with not enough amenities to go around. I don’t want a load more people moving here but I accept that if my kids want to stay here when they grow up, fields are going to have to be built on.

The real issue is this government who refuse to give councils real power to fight developers who renege on S106 agreements and who use viability assessments to wriggle out of providing a proportion of ‘affordable’ homes in each development.

Justanotherlurker · 14/01/2023 19:49

A lot of the problems are already well documented across the world now, the no new infrastructure/schools argument is as tired as 'just build on brown belt'.

The opposition is still there if the infrastructure and schools where to be built first, it has been tried and tested, because nobody wants to live near a school or build a school where they take their dog for a walk, the road improvements would mean it causes problems etc etc, much needed ring roads that have been needed for multiple towns and cities over the past decades have been hamstrung

The issue is that people are all for the generic feel good policies until it hits them personally.

One thing on Social media for the likes, and winning of arguments against the bad guys, but when it becomes a reality then there is caveats.

lljkk · 14/01/2023 19:47

We are in weird position of also not objecting to a big local development plan. We will lose a nice view & our country lane will swap for big road, & we still can't object. When we bought at edge of this urban area we thought of course future development will happen here. We are campaigning hard for good cycle & pedestrian paths; I can focus energy on those. Even though we will move away before it all happens...

I'm a little confused about "no new housing without more infrastructure" objections. I hear this a lot locally, but.. the infrastructure growth will never precede new residents, and everything is going to max out before any capacity increases (no more class sizes 22-26).

If the capacity was fixed at 100k school places for existing 95k kids, & then 10k more kids suddenly need school places then the whole system will be over capacity regardless of where those new kids are; they are going to overcrowd somewhere. May as well be here.

FWIW, DH & are looking to strongly downsize. Meanwhile our neighbours are all 1-2 people living in 4 bed houses, their kids long ago moved away. Who else is doing their bit to free up housing stock?

LIZS · 14/01/2023 19:44

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

Are you sure it is the council proposing this? Developers often come up with speculative schemes for public consultation which later get modified or rejected. Is there a Local Plan designating the area for housing? Developers are charged CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy) as a contribution towards upgrading local amenities and may include some additional facilities as part of their plans, although these are often at a late stage of development. Payments are released in stages depending on progress . CIL is used by the Local Council, and Village Council if there is one, to spend on all kinds of purposes including community buildings, play areas, parking, health centres, road safety.

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 19:41

Planners have to write reams and reams of impenetrable arcane jargon designed to make it impossible to understand by anyone except planners so that there is an illusion they are doing something.

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 19:38

Just more backhanders for the planning dept.
I don't believe our local planners are corrupt - they are just working in a ridiculous framework created by the government in which their job is to allow large housing developers to do whatever the fuck they like whilst pretending there is some regulation when there really isn't.

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 19:35

Andypandy799 · 14/01/2023 19:17

This is the problem with current planning laws and all the NIMBY’s

NIMBY is such a ridiculous term. No-one is going to take an interest in my back yard like I do - it's just a stupid ill-considered insult.
In fact in my area we are bearing the brunt of local politicians dumping the new estates here so they aren't in their back yard.

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 19:32

EmmaEmerald · 14/01/2023 17:30

No, we have a crisis of overpopulation and unaffordable housing, neither of which are solved by schemes like this.

and there is affordable housing going begging in some places, but no jobs to support it - because everything in the UK is ridiculously over focused on the South East of England.

LynneBenfield · 14/01/2023 19:27

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 18:48

This is exactly my experience. I'd have no problem with well planned development with proper infrastructure provision - but we get gridlock, parking chaos, no public transport or cycling provisions, no school places and no GP provisions, just hundreds of 4 and 5 bedroom houses without enough space for the cars they need because there is no other way to get around.

Same here. Hundreds of larger family homes but no additional public services or infrastructure to support them. Just more backhanders for the planning dept.

Oigetoffmylawn · 14/01/2023 19:24

I've yet to see a new development that's increased the numbers of shops, schools, transport or GP places.

We've had enormous estates built near us (I'm in a city) and we have rules on how many houses can be built before a school or GP practice is needed, but all that does is make the house builders team up with 1 or 2 others so each company builds just under the limit! 1000s of homes, and no new school. Ours schools are heaving, our GP practices closed to new patients. The LA are aware, there's petitions and all-sorts to try and change it and yet still it happens. So the only option is to object to the houses themselves.

drpet49 · 14/01/2023 19:21

hattie43 · 14/01/2023 17:16

I have mixed views on this in that if you buy a house in a small village / hamlet you don't then expect to live in a town a few years and multiple builds later . I also realised housing is needed .

40 years old yes. Not nowadays

Andypandy799 · 14/01/2023 19:17

This is the problem with current planning laws and all the NIMBY’s

FOJN · 14/01/2023 19:14

I think it's easy to dismiss people as nimbys but too many of us have experience of new developments with promised infrastructure that doesn't materialise.

In the last small town (pop 12000) I lived in the council granted planning for 2000 new homes. The infrastructure was supposed to be added to the last phase of the development, 10 years later there are houses and thousands of extra people but no new school or GP surgery.

The department of transport assessed the average commute to the nearest large town,15 miles away, would be 2 hours at peak travel time because of the narrow country roads leading out of the town, there were no plans to improve the roads. Hardly surprising the locals objected.

What constitutes affordable housing is a joke when a supposedly "affordable" 3 bed semi starts at 450k.

I live in an even smaller town now with hardly any amenities or job opportunities, thank god the local landscape means they can't build anymore houses.

Justanotherlurker · 14/01/2023 19:00

Yes NIMBY's is alive and well IMO, I live in a naice safe labour seat commuter town with good ammenities and commuter links, with regular bus and rail.

Over the past few years both brown and greenfield sites have been rejected because of local opposition, as with most problems that need fixing as long as it doesn't impact them personally then they are all for it (especially online).

Everybody thinks the 'next town over' is more suitable to allievate the housing crisis, if you build them locally it will hit them in the pocket, but then again don't concrete over the UK just build away from 'me' personally.

It is widely recognised and is actually becoming apparent to a lot of my younger collegues at work how hypocritical a lot of older people are (I am their manager, luckily mortgage free now, but was the opposition to all our local objections because we need to build more houses)

SpaceRaiders · 14/01/2023 18:57

These people already exist in your community, they’re likely in unstable housing. Services are already overwhelmed. Not building homes just exacerbates social issues.

I agree with you Op. If you want affordable housing for future generations, then at some point you will have to concede that the acres on the outskirts of villages/towns will need to be built on.

This country is so precious about its open spaces, whilst having amongst the strictest planning policies in Europe. Ask yourself, who does that serve?

superdupernova · 14/01/2023 18:52

StubbleAndSqueak · 14/01/2023 18:38

Near us developers 'run out of money" to build the extra school, surgery, dentist or leisure centre etc that was promised so yes I'm very cynical
They should be made to build those first as part of the pp.

Could be worse. A huge development near me came with the promise of a train station with a connection to London. It's been over 10 years since the development was complete. It's finally happening in 2024, apparently. The nearest station is a congested drive away with expensive limited parking or a very very long bike ride. I felt sorry for all the commuters who bought houses there.

Kinnorafron · 14/01/2023 18:50

Also my small town is having most of the new housing for the borough dumped here for political reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread