Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That people object to council plans for selfish and uninformed reasons

216 replies

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:04

I live in a village which has doubled in size over the last 5 years (still pretty small tbh).

It is well located, 5 miles from a major town and has potentially good public transport links but with really low service levels (hourly trains, no buses on a Sunday sort of thing). There are few amenities here - no petrol garage, supermarket, pub, cafe but does have a few corner shops and a primary school. Loads and loads of countryside and good walking.

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons - e.g. don't support compulsory purchase of farmland, the village is "already too big".

Perhaps they are just going through the change curve but I don't see how they can't see the benefits in improving the amenities and services, providing more affordable housing in an area that desperately needs it, whilst still retaining almost all the countryside.

So AIBU to think they are being blinkered / selfish and actually this is a scheme for the greater good whilst also benefitting us residents.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 15/01/2023 19:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Where my friend is they had some "affordable" housing built.
It was not even remotely close to affordable for the locals.
And most of the properties were bought by either BTL landlords, or HAs.

In some areas it has very little to do with the "NIMBY"s

PatrickBasedman · 15/01/2023 17:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

woodhill · 15/01/2023 16:52

Government needs to do more to insist the infrastructure is put in place before PP is even allowed

AfraidToRun · 15/01/2023 16:38

We have had four housing developments in my small town. All promised a new GP surgery, play areas and a primary school. Never happened.

thereisonlyoneofme · 15/01/2023 16:21

We have been promised new GP surgery, playing field. None of these materialised houses were built, affordable homes reduced in number because they werent cost effective no promised facilities. They should be made to build facilities before housing is even started

fishonabicycle · 15/01/2023 16:04

Because what generally happens is that a load of houses are built, the narrow roads stay the same, the schools become oversubscribed as do GPs etc, and the traffic becomes bloody awful.

CovertImage · 15/01/2023 14:56

I've yet to see a new development that's increased the numbers of shops, schools, transport or GP places.

And yet all you need to do according to the OP is to campaign to the local council to have these things put into place - once the development has been built anyway of course.

It's almost like s/he's being deliberately stupid.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 15/01/2023 13:47

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:53

Yes there are plans to build new / enhance existing amenities - it is still a draft plan so opportunity to shape specifics still from the consultation.

Also even the parish council are supportive provided the improvements happen.

I doubt they will be built.

We have a ring of new developments around our market town. All had additional amenities included in the proposals. The only thing that has been included are a couple of fenced off play areas, that are not maintained by anyone.

No road improvement, no shops, no surgery, school, nothing. Just an additional thousand plus houses, and still growing.

Nearby is a development on a water meadow. Water issues meant planning was refused, by Rishi Sunak! Developers waited and reapplied with additional water tanks. Local houses that have never flooded in hundreds of years have now flooded. The holding tanks? Not built because, according to the official response, the development is not yet complete. Whe it is, in 5 or 6 more years, there will be 'adequate steps' taken. Until then... tough!

Developers do anything to avoid the additional stuff that they can't make as much profit from.

BloaterW1 · 15/01/2023 13:40

KatieB55 · 15/01/2023 13:20

The village we used to live in also had developments of executive homes. What was needed was starter homes and flat/bungalows so elderly could downsize to stay in the village.

Bungalows are expensive to build, land is expensive so the numbers don't add. Much what people think it's difficult to get permission to build anywhere. The public doesn't hear much about pre applications where developers are told no. If the planning laws were made more liberal then a wider range of houses could be built as it would push land prices down. I think the average arce of land with pp for houses is about 1million . There might be a bidding between developers and the farmer gets a nice retirement fund. I doubt any have said no I'll take half and build bungalows and starter housing.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 15/01/2023 13:38

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:24

Because we have a housing crisis affecting 100,000s of people ?

You are being obtuse here, and in reply to the hospital post.

We have similar issues and are being swamped with outlying developments that simply cannot be sustained. Yet even the insurmountable geographical issue is being ignored.

Because apparently "people need somewhere to live" actually means "who gives a fuck if people can actually live, bring up a family, get to work, in these houses?"

Sometimes those of us shouting No! have really good, common sense reasons for doing so.

KatieB55 · 15/01/2023 13:20

The village we used to live in also had developments of executive homes. What was needed was starter homes and flat/bungalows so elderly could downsize to stay in the village.

Cinnabomb · 15/01/2023 12:56

My lovely, small very desirable village is being ruined by new estates. As PP says - the infrastructure isn’t following. On our road the biggest issue is sewage. Somehow developers and the water company have agreed on their surveys that there isn’t an issue. There is. The field they are building on already floods in winter, which is going to get hugely worse when it all becomes hard standing. Already when there are heavy rains, some of the drains flood and people end up with raw sewage in their gardens. We have reported this again and again and again, and “officials” keep saying that adding more housing onto the existing sewers without improving them isn’t a problem.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/01/2023 12:54

Maybe more staff would be retained if buildings weren’t overcrowded and lists overwhelmed though.
Yes I know funding main issue.
Teaching 40 kids in a temp portacabin is a lot less attractive than 30 in a nice new purpose built school.

Alaimo · 15/01/2023 12:54

I live in a small apartment block on the edge of a neighbourhood that's mostly made up of detached homes. When the idea to build these apartments on a small empty field was original proposed the number of objections from the nearby home owners was ridiculous. Lots of "I walk my dog there" even though there's a gigantic nature reserve a 2 minute walk in the opposite direction. There are now 60-80 apartments in two 3-story blocks and another 20 terraced houses built on this spot. There's an underground car park for residents and a bus stop across the street. It's exactly these underused semi-urban spaces that we should be filling with high-density housing in my view.

dew141 · 15/01/2023 12:53

This is a loophole that has to close. Happens all the time and the thing we need most - affordable housing - never materialises

I've often wondered how private housing remains affordable. Are the new developments sold below market value? Or is it more about shared ownership schemes? And do they stop house prices rising to the 'natural level' for the local area?

In our town, nearly all the new developments are £800k plus (some in the several millions) and I can't imagine how they tick any affordable housing criteria.

UndertheCedartree · 15/01/2023 12:48

stealthninjamum · 14/01/2023 17:14

The problem in my area is that no money is spent on infrastructure with these developments. I’m not inherently against new developments but in an area with too few school places, problems getting a GP and heavy traffic so poor air quality, minimal public transport they’ll put in a new estate and make things worse for everyone. The developers have to pay a levy that is supposed to fund infrastructure work but other than the odd roundabout I don’t know where that money goes. Our developers also produce maths that show they’re not making much money so don’t need to produce social housing.

This is a loophole that has to close. Happens all the time and the thing we need most - affordable housing - never materialises.

lljkk · 15/01/2023 12:43

Isn't there a national shortage of GPs, teachers, dentists?

Even if sparkly new buildings were created there literally are no professionals to staff them.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/01/2023 12:41

Yes massive housing development over 20 yrs ago on former asylum site. More and more houses added and still being added but no primary school that was on plans?! Village primary too small and can’t expand as no room. Kids driven miles to school. I went to exhibit about asylum and it stuck me how self contained it was - school, gym, theatre, butchers, shop, railway station etc all there - now it’s just houses on site and people drive to access anything.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 12:34

StubbleAndSqueak · 14/01/2023 18:38

Near us developers 'run out of money" to build the extra school, surgery, dentist or leisure centre etc that was promised so yes I'm very cynical
They should be made to build those first as part of the pp.

When our (admittedly very old and small) station was re-developed we were told there would be a shopping piazza the size of a Wimbledon tennis court and a river walkway. What we got was a station forecourt the size of a tennis court, M&S Food, Sainsbury's Express and Puccino's. As for the walkway, the local joke was that the planners confused millimetres with feet and thought they were looking at another South Bank. Guess what, no walkway. Just lots of nice expensive flats over the station for the developer to sell, and increased traffic on an already gridlocked main road.

TiredandLate · 15/01/2023 12:29

I live in a similar sounding village, hundreds of houses have been built, hundreds more in planning and none of the amenities have appeared 🙄. No new doctors, dentists or schools, just a 2 hour gridlock on the roads twice a day.

We were promised a new secondary school opening in 2020, it's 2023 and the location hasn't even been agreed. It was intended for my dd's year group to be the first intake, at this rate she will have left school before the building starts.

Casilero · 15/01/2023 12:28

Compulsory purchase of farmland to build house on? I didn't know that was even happening. That's reason enough to object.

woodhill · 15/01/2023 12:20

dew141 · 15/01/2023 08:36

I'm aware that it's not just London and the SE that have taken their share of housing developments (my sister has many in Cornwall and I've seen the same in the Cotswolds).

But I'd say that the high density of existing population in parts of the SE makes it extremely difficult to absorb the planned large-scale additions. We have good public transport (we're on the Tube) but the roads still can't cope with the current volume of traffic.

Whereas my brother lives in a fairly deprived area of Yorkshire and he'd like to see redevelopment as some of the buildings are apparently dire. While there's a concentration of jobs near us, remote working presumably reduces the need to focus on the SE somewhat? Plus it costs over a million to buy a four bed semi here so i doubt it will help much with affordability long-term.

So no, I don't want to see green belt being built on and if that makes me a NIMBY, so be it. Our local area is turning into a concrete jungle and, as I mentioned earlier, air quality already fails the minimum standards. It's not selfish to want the odd pocket of green where people can walk and the trees improve the air quality.

Yes and the flooding factor

Plus the government keeps talking about climate change and not driving etc

Sugarplumfairy65 · 15/01/2023 12:05

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:53

Yes there are plans to build new / enhance existing amenities - it is still a draft plan so opportunity to shape specifics still from the consultation.

Also even the parish council are supportive provided the improvements happen.

I used to work in the industry.
I cannot count the number of times these developers have wriggled out of their obligations to provide amenities that were part of the original planning permission. We end up with village schools that can only take half the children in the village so the rest have to be driven miles to other schools, no other amenities nearby so again they have to be driven to because the public transport is inadequate.
This is not progress, its madness and only benefits the developer.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 15/01/2023 11:52

I live in a small village and grew up in a small village, I tried living in a city once and it had a horrible effect on my mental health I was never as glad to move back to a village. I don’t care how selfish it makes me I chose to live somewhere small and don’t expect it to be turned into a town.

it’s all fine and well saying build more surgeries etc good luck getting the GPs to staff them, the surgery I work in has been looking for gps to replace the ones who retired for nearly.a year now with no interest

there are enough empty properties, buildings, shops etc that should be looked at to tackle the housing crisis first before just firing up 1000s more houses on green sites

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/01/2023 11:35

Anyone buying in a village 5 miles from a major town and expecting it to be preserved in aspic is daft.

Hundreds of thousands of homes are needed and 5 miles from a major town is a good location.

Swipe left for the next trending thread