Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That people object to council plans for selfish and uninformed reasons

216 replies

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:04

I live in a village which has doubled in size over the last 5 years (still pretty small tbh).

It is well located, 5 miles from a major town and has potentially good public transport links but with really low service levels (hourly trains, no buses on a Sunday sort of thing). There are few amenities here - no petrol garage, supermarket, pub, cafe but does have a few corner shops and a primary school. Loads and loads of countryside and good walking.

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons - e.g. don't support compulsory purchase of farmland, the village is "already too big".

Perhaps they are just going through the change curve but I don't see how they can't see the benefits in improving the amenities and services, providing more affordable housing in an area that desperately needs it, whilst still retaining almost all the countryside.

So AIBU to think they are being blinkered / selfish and actually this is a scheme for the greater good whilst also benefitting us residents.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 16/01/2023 12:25

It’s the fact that planning woefully underestimates school places.
In our area they build 3 and 4 bed detached the draw is the outstanding primary and outstanding secondary schools (the house builders put it in their brochures)
99% of houses sold will have at least 1 school aged child that’s why they want to live here.
When I checked regs it was something like the criteria assumed 30 children (primary and secondary) per 100 houses.
Across all building that might be true eg city centre flats marketed at young professionals probably have few children.
But it’s not rocket science that 100 detached houses here is probably another 100/150 children wanting school places and the criteria says 30 enough. And that’s not 30 locally - I recall it was place within several miles. Rurally that could be hour or more round trip to some remote village school as closest schools are full.
You can see what is going to happen.
Then they realise and add more capacity but takes yrs, meanwhile traffic etc as parents have to drive kids to remote schools, 45 in junior classes etc. My DDs old school went up 30 capacity 5 yrs ago and is up 30 again from next year.

Namechange828492 · 16/01/2023 12:04

It's not just the countryside, i live in london where a green space is going to be used for a large amount of homes. As it's london schools/etc are already at breaking point. My own estate is "new" (ish) so i cant really complain, people need places to live but equally building on flood plains is a recipe for disaster

With an ageing population we could build some bigger houses to allow multi generational living.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 11:55

TrainspottingWelsh · 14/01/2023 20:55

You’d have to kill me and animate my corpse before I’d agree to compulsory purchase of farmland.
Yes, we need more affordable housing. But there are plenty of brownfield sites to build social housing on, which is what we really need, and I don’t see any justification, either personally or on a societal level, to destroy the countryside with shitty overpriced executive shoeboxes and the people that often come with them.

People always say this, and it conjurs up an image of lush forests and natural beauty instead of what England mostly is: plain, unused fields. In that regard the natural degredation has been done already - nature was a lot happier when that field was a forest.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 11:53

EmmaEmerald · 14/01/2023 17:30

No, we have a crisis of overpopulation and unaffordable housing, neither of which are solved by schemes like this.

Totally wrong. As the OP said, it's an ageing population. You either solve that with better economic conditions for young people to have families, or more immigration. Can't have neither.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 11:51

And it doesn't just affect villages and new houses - I live in a very built up area that is aiming to revamp its riverside to be much more pedestrianised and pleasant. It would mean about 40 short-term car park spaces are removed, which is apparently unthinkable to a few very loud residents for reasons I doubt even they know.

Some people will moan about any change whatsover.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 11:49

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons

If you're surprised you live in a nation of NIMBYs you haven't been paying attention.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/01/2023 11:47

Yuja · 16/01/2023 05:53

YANBU we have the same thing in our village. People not wanting younger generations to have what they have got.

True.

I don't want anyone to have a 1.5 hour commute to work for a 20 minute journey, with the prospect of another 4000 homes being built and absolutely no geographical possibility of the roads being able to absorb additional traffic.

I don't want anyone to have to live in a small, isolated development of houses on the side of a major trunk road with nowhere for their kids to play safely, no nearby amenities and that overly busy road being their only way in or out to any shop, school etc.

Nor do I want anyone to find themselves living surrounded by flood water, because the new estate they live on was built on land called the water meadows, until the developers called it The Green.

Sometimes building on green space is ludicrous because of the geography of an area. Ignoring that led to all of the above today where I live.

And we are told we are being mean when we carry on objecting.

Raise your bar...

PatrickBasedman · 16/01/2023 09:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

exLtEveDallas · 16/01/2023 06:41

Our village has grown rapidly in the 10 years we’ve been here. But as ever NOT with affordable homes or amenities. We live at the ‘top’ of the village (1 mile to the ‘bottom’) and the last estate (all very large executive homes) was built at the bottom. The top is a mixture of private and LA homes - from 2 bed Maisonettes to older 3&4 bed houses, the bottom is all 4&5 bed private homes.

The village primary is way oversubscribed. Guess which children don’t get to go there now?

There is a consultation shortly for another estate being built, again without any amenities. You can bet your arse I’m objecting.

Yuja · 16/01/2023 05:53

YANBU we have the same thing in our village. People not wanting younger generations to have what they have got.

BloaterW1 · 16/01/2023 05:43

I wouldn't buy for the views it if the land could be built on , someone elses view was probably blocked when said house was built. I bet they complained as well.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 16/01/2023 05:27

Genuine question OP, if you purchased a house that you worked and saved years for, and it was your perfect house for whatever reason ... quiet village, sea view, backed onto a reserve, next to woodland etc whatever does it for you, .... and a couple of years later a huge housing development went up next to you blocking said view or whatever it was that you moved for? You wouldn't care at all?? 🤔

BloaterW1 · 16/01/2023 05:19

Think of the house prices!

Brieandcamembert · 16/01/2023 01:11

People often pay a real premium to live in a nice house in a small rural village. When a huge sprawling new build estate blocks your views, stops you being so rural and the farm shop goes because the farm became ab estate, the houses there are devalued and lots of lifestyles are spoilt. We need to have a real overhaul of how we think about housing.

We need farmland, we need countryside
We can't just build and build. We are a relatively small Island.

PatrickBasedman · 16/01/2023 00:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

whoruntheworldgirls · 15/01/2023 21:23

They are not unreasonable to be unhappy at the village doubling in size! That's a lot more strain on the amenities.
I'm objecting to the large number of planned new houses for our village, the village is big enough already (much bigger and I'm not sure how much longer it could be called a village!) the school is at capacity, as it stands the pre school and local child minders are full, the doctors is over capacity, the dentist not a chance in hell of getting in there, they are planning on ripping out established trees and hedgerows to build on, not proposing any changes to the current road to help with increased traffic/builder's traffic.
I'd support a smaller development but our planned one is too big, maybe people in your village feel the same

TrainspottingWelsh · 15/01/2023 21:21

The affordable housing is never actually affordable. A few years ago a new estate was built on the outskirts of the nearest town. The affordable housing was advertised at 25% more than the far larger, better built 1930’s semi’s immediately opposite that the average first time buyer couldn’t afford either.

lieselotte · 15/01/2023 21:07

I think there's a degree of nimbyishm but I have seen a total difference in attitude towards green field sites and brown field sites in my area. The brown field sites have attracted some opposition, but minimal. The green field sites have been very hard fought. I totally agree with that viewpoint. I have limited concerns about an old industrial/military/office development being changed to housing, although there are still concerns about infrastructure.

But concreting over the countryside isn't justified.

Kinnorafron · 15/01/2023 20:55

Inkyblue123 · 15/01/2023 19:42

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, even if it disagrees with your own and many other posters have given examples of why your neighbours may object. What boils my piss us when the council do as they like ; regardless of how many people object. If the amenities are that poor and you would prefer to live somewhere more densely populated, you are free to sell up and move. But I really don’t see why a village that does not want development should have it forced on them. What you see as progress, other people will view as lowering their quality of life.

Correct. This is because we have a government that has scrapped planning law and replaced it with a framework to allow large developers to build as many 4/5 bed houses as they like, and pretend it's to address housing needs.
There is a small army of jargon spewing planning people ready to tell you (in some arcane language) why you have to have what Persimmon wants to build on your local farmland, and why you can't have any road improvements (in fact they will often make the roads worse as part of a pretence that 90% of people won't use cars.

BloaterW1 · 15/01/2023 20:26

Inkyblue123 · 15/01/2023 19:42

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, even if it disagrees with your own and many other posters have given examples of why your neighbours may object. What boils my piss us when the council do as they like ; regardless of how many people object. If the amenities are that poor and you would prefer to live somewhere more densely populated, you are free to sell up and move. But I really don’t see why a village that does not want development should have it forced on them. What you see as progress, other people will view as lowering their quality of life.

The objections need to be relevant though. Council don't do what they like , they need a reason within planning law , that central government sets , to stop an application. If they don't they could face very heavy legal costs. Most big developers can outspend councils in terms of legal costs.

woodhill · 15/01/2023 20:22

That's good to hear. I think this wasn't always the case though

mumwon · 15/01/2023 20:09

from our experience with the large development on our door step: they were going to do a detour on the other side so they wouldn't block our estates only access . they than suggested it would be one way - it wasn't. They increased density of houses the height of flats the number of parking spaces and decreased the infrastructure, we are talking of 3000 houses will we get extra gp's in an area where there are not enough will there be enough I could go on

Oigetoffmylawn · 15/01/2023 20:00

woodhill · 15/01/2023 19:33

We're the btl landlords allowed to,buy the affordable housing?

Depends on the scheme but usually not, they're usually reserved for local occupancy and often first time buyers. No second home owners etc.

Inkyblue123 · 15/01/2023 19:42

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, even if it disagrees with your own and many other posters have given examples of why your neighbours may object. What boils my piss us when the council do as they like ; regardless of how many people object. If the amenities are that poor and you would prefer to live somewhere more densely populated, you are free to sell up and move. But I really don’t see why a village that does not want development should have it forced on them. What you see as progress, other people will view as lowering their quality of life.

woodhill · 15/01/2023 19:33

We're the btl landlords allowed to,buy the affordable housing?