Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That people object to council plans for selfish and uninformed reasons

216 replies

Bamboozle123 · 14/01/2023 17:04

I live in a village which has doubled in size over the last 5 years (still pretty small tbh).

It is well located, 5 miles from a major town and has potentially good public transport links but with really low service levels (hourly trains, no buses on a Sunday sort of thing). There are few amenities here - no petrol garage, supermarket, pub, cafe but does have a few corner shops and a primary school. Loads and loads of countryside and good walking.

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

I'm really surprised that so many locals are objecting for what seem to be really weak reasons - e.g. don't support compulsory purchase of farmland, the village is "already too big".

Perhaps they are just going through the change curve but I don't see how they can't see the benefits in improving the amenities and services, providing more affordable housing in an area that desperately needs it, whilst still retaining almost all the countryside.

So AIBU to think they are being blinkered / selfish and actually this is a scheme for the greater good whilst also benefitting us residents.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 16/01/2023 19:18

MereDintofPandiculation · 16/01/2023 18:40

Of course the infrastructure needs building, I'm not disputing that. I'm just saying that it's not a good reason to object to new developments.Of course it is a good reason. It’s difficult to absorb 400 new people an area if there are no plans for improving infrastructure. Yes, they’ve all come from somewhere else - but they haven’t all come from the same somewhere else.

I can’t think of a better reason to object that infrastructure though? Small village on its 7th new estate in 10 years. Issues already apparent after estate 1 and 2 (no gp, no dentist, no train station - there is a train line, no shops, one primary school intake 15, issues with sewers/flooding) It’s not speculation it’s inevitable issues will follow due to lack of infrastructure. But yet estates 4,5,6,7 added.
Latest proposal is a massive retirement housing development but no Gp. The Gp
in next village already overwhelmed.

SeenAndNot · 16/01/2023 19:03

YABU. There are so many issues with building onto farmland. It’s devastating for wildlife, bad for food supply, and contributes massively to pollution with so many more cars driving to towns to get supplies.

The vast majority of councils approve new housing but pay no attention to additional amenities, leaving doctors, schools oversubscribed.

MereDintofPandiculation · 16/01/2023 18:40

Of course the infrastructure needs building, I'm not disputing that. I'm just saying that it's not a good reason to object to new developments.Of course it is a good reason. It’s difficult to absorb 400 new people an area if there are no plans for improving infrastructure. Yes, they’ve all come from somewhere else - but they haven’t all come from the same somewhere else.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/01/2023 18:15

Additional 1500 houses built around me. House price has risen the same as the rest of the area.

Individual tales aren't the point.

Local solutions that are actually viable, sustainable are the point.

Mamaneedsadrink · 16/01/2023 18:05

whattodo1975 · 16/01/2023 16:28

People think that more house close to them will bring down the value of there house. Supply and demand and all that. Isn't necessarily the case though.

Big apartment block next to me, our house price has dropped considerably

GlassBunion · 16/01/2023 17:37

We've had thousands of houses built on farmland, greenfield sites and even some woodland.
All built as desirable 'luxury' housing ( my arse!)
What is actually needed is affordable housing for those in lower paid jobs or even ordinary paid jobs.
Huge volumes of these houses were purchased by landlords with vast portfolios in order to provide expensive rental properties or were bought in bulk by London Boroughs in order to move out their tenants as they could make so much more , by doing their existing housing up in order to rent/sell to highest bidders.

Locals can barely get a look in.

The latest development near me is flogging the fact that there's a GP in our village. It closed down years ago.
That there's a dentists five minutes away... it doesn't take NHS patients nor do any of the dentists for quite some distance away.
That there's a local primary ... it's already oversubscribed.
What has enraged us is that all of these houses haven't even been built yet but have all been sold to these london boroughs and property portfolio holders.

We desperately need homes for young people, ordinary people , local workers.
Two 'blocks' of what look like post war utilitarian blocks of flats/maisonettes have been built , in really poor fabric ... think plastic grey mouldings and plain dark brick with no features, for key workers.
It's so wrong.

Yet our town is full of delapidated areas and is in desperate need of renovation.

We need proper housing solutions for real people. And local too.

Spanielsarepainless · 16/01/2023 17:02

Our local town has hundreds of new houses. All sorts of infra-structure promised in the plans, surgery, schools, shops etc. What did they get? Nothing. So next time locals will oppose new developments. People only get fooled once.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/01/2023 16:34

Kabalagala · 16/01/2023 15:20

Infrastructure can be a bit of a red herring imo. The reality is, these new houses don't create any more need for schools, gps, buses, parking etc. It just shifts the problem to a new area. Even traffic issues to some extent are just being moved around.
I'm sure if you live in a nice place you don't want it to change, but that's not possible with a growing population.

Except of course in areas where they are the crux of the matter.

As I said, ignoring any and all objections, dismissing them this lightly, leads to the kinds of misery I have described, here and many other such threads. I am describing the area I live in, not some potential, imagined scenario

whattodo1975 · 16/01/2023 16:28

People think that more house close to them will bring down the value of there house. Supply and demand and all that. Isn't necessarily the case though.

Kabalagala · 16/01/2023 16:21

OhmygodDont · 16/01/2023 15:58

That doesn’t work either though really if I moved to Sheffield in a brand new build Sheffield now has an extra five people.

No good Dorset maybe having five spaces as I’m not there. We would need a gp, a school etc in Sheffield.

Most of those houses on this executive estates are not people finally managing to move out of their parents or out of hostels or from smaller overcrowded properties it’s people moving to “cheaper” or greener areas. The local population still often stuck just where they were but now with more demand on infrastructure.

Same argument people have with where will be place Ukrainian people who where let to stay in spare rooms, where will we house the asylum seekers ect building more houses without everything else doesn’t work properly. Everyone bleats on well it’s not their fault the government need to build the infrastructure yet now people try and claim it doesn’t really need to be built.

I live in a large city now with a school on my doorstep but it’s clearly for anyone this stuff needs building when your adding 200- 500 plus homes.

Yes but the lack of infrastructure was an preexisting problem. I don't know of anywhere that has too many school places. It's the same people and the same problems moving around. 5 people move to sheffield there's not suddenly an empty school in Dorset, because chances are that school in Dorset already had a waiting list. Of course the infrastructure needs building, I'm not disputing that. I'm just saying that it's not a good reason to object to new developments. We need more schools and gps irrespective of new houses being built.

theemmadilemma · 16/01/2023 16:08

Where I used to live was quiet and lovely when I moved there some 18 years ago. By the time I left 2 years ago they were continuing to build on every available slither of land even though the local ammenaties could no longer cope, and no more were being created. Traffic was ridiculous.

I since moved to just outside a lovely village and I would hate, hate to see huge development happening locally.

OhmygodDont · 16/01/2023 15:58

Kabalagala · 16/01/2023 15:20

Infrastructure can be a bit of a red herring imo. The reality is, these new houses don't create any more need for schools, gps, buses, parking etc. It just shifts the problem to a new area. Even traffic issues to some extent are just being moved around.
I'm sure if you live in a nice place you don't want it to change, but that's not possible with a growing population.

That doesn’t work either though really if I moved to Sheffield in a brand new build Sheffield now has an extra five people.

No good Dorset maybe having five spaces as I’m not there. We would need a gp, a school etc in Sheffield.

Most of those houses on this executive estates are not people finally managing to move out of their parents or out of hostels or from smaller overcrowded properties it’s people moving to “cheaper” or greener areas. The local population still often stuck just where they were but now with more demand on infrastructure.

Same argument people have with where will be place Ukrainian people who where let to stay in spare rooms, where will we house the asylum seekers ect building more houses without everything else doesn’t work properly. Everyone bleats on well it’s not their fault the government need to build the infrastructure yet now people try and claim it doesn’t really need to be built.

I live in a large city now with a school on my doorstep but it’s clearly for anyone this stuff needs building when your adding 200- 500 plus homes.

Butchyrestingface · 16/01/2023 15:22

The council plans to create loads more houses along the main road here, probably doubling the village in size again.

Amazed that you are so dismissive of residents of a small village perfectly reasonable concerns and objections to having their area DOUBLE in size. Confused.

Kabalagala · 16/01/2023 15:20

Infrastructure can be a bit of a red herring imo. The reality is, these new houses don't create any more need for schools, gps, buses, parking etc. It just shifts the problem to a new area. Even traffic issues to some extent are just being moved around.
I'm sure if you live in a nice place you don't want it to change, but that's not possible with a growing population.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/01/2023 15:09

Same thing here. The dishonesty is part of the process.

Couldyounot · 16/01/2023 15:01

Developers try to screw councils down to provide as little mitigation funding as they possible can, maximise the amount of units they can deliver, and employ consultants to downplay the impact of their development on existing infrastructure. Ultimately the majority of house builders are private businesses aiming to make a profit.

Councils try to condition developers to deliver amenities, but often the developers will argue this should only be done once they've built a certain number of units. Sometimes once they've got to that number of units, they stop building. Most developers I've had any involvement will do everything they can to reduce the extent of the mitigation funding they give to councils. If this gets to legal proceeding, the developers can generally afford better legal representation than the councils. It's not a fun game to be in to be honest...

This is pretty much exactly what happens where I live. Plus on the rare occasions that mitigation payments for (e.g.) road improvements are made, they get swallowed up by the county council and no improvements are actually made. Sure, there are plenty of objections along the lines of "we don't want that there 'ere" but most concern lack of infrastructure.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 16/01/2023 14:46

OhmygodDont · 16/01/2023 14:32

Problem is infrastructure. No matter how much we beg the council never do it.

where we just moved from had two big rather huge actually housing estates added and another one being built with another proposed adding well over 1,000 houses total. Guess what not a single school or doctors or dentist or even a bus stop. The road can’t actually cope by 8:30am is backed up and again around 3pm as it all leads off a parkway too, so getting into those smaller estates and what used to be almost a village esk school is now terrible.

But alas we apparently desperately need 4/5 bed tiny executive houses at over 400k each with 1 parking space and a postage stamp garden for people who then can’t have a local school or doctor or even corner shop.

I'm not sure your post or my previous ones have actually come through. Or maybe we posted in invisible ink.

Just as with planning, local and central government, some posters here are just pretending they haven't read our objections. Because then they'd need to acknowledge that the NIMBY bollocks doesn't always apply and the "where will our kids live?" is currently being answered with "often in places that are unsuitable for development"

LIZS · 16/01/2023 14:45

Agree they are not "affordable" in the general sense of the word. A 10% discount on a high price is still high. Dc will struggle to ever afford housing in our area, to buy or rent.

whoruntheworldgirls · 16/01/2023 14:38

@Sorefootouch I said i would support a smaller development, as would most others in the village, the initial proposal was fine but it keeps growing. If the school, doctors etc can't accommodate all the new people what's supposed to happen then?? These aren't affordable houses that are being built either.
And you know nothing or my situation so can't comment on what my child's life will be like when she's an adult.
Where i live what the council need to stop doing is handing every single development over to student housing and then maybe there would be a lot more affordable family homes. Maybe stop expanding the universities that then swallow up the local houses as student lets.

OhmygodDont · 16/01/2023 14:32

Problem is infrastructure. No matter how much we beg the council never do it.

where we just moved from had two big rather huge actually housing estates added and another one being built with another proposed adding well over 1,000 houses total. Guess what not a single school or doctors or dentist or even a bus stop. The road can’t actually cope by 8:30am is backed up and again around 3pm as it all leads off a parkway too, so getting into those smaller estates and what used to be almost a village esk school is now terrible.

But alas we apparently desperately need 4/5 bed tiny executive houses at over 400k each with 1 parking space and a postage stamp garden for people who then can’t have a local school or doctor or even corner shop.

Sorefootouch · 16/01/2023 14:30

whoruntheworldgirls · 15/01/2023 21:23

They are not unreasonable to be unhappy at the village doubling in size! That's a lot more strain on the amenities.
I'm objecting to the large number of planned new houses for our village, the village is big enough already (much bigger and I'm not sure how much longer it could be called a village!) the school is at capacity, as it stands the pre school and local child minders are full, the doctors is over capacity, the dentist not a chance in hell of getting in there, they are planning on ripping out established trees and hedgerows to build on, not proposing any changes to the current road to help with increased traffic/builder's traffic.
I'd support a smaller development but our planned one is too big, maybe people in your village feel the same

i grew up in a village like this. Don’t you see that your kids will never be able to settle down, have kids themselves, feel secure and happy etc because there are no houses that they can afford?

You are so unbelievably selfish. Just listen to yourself. You are just like the hopeless nimby whingers in the village I grew up in. Cannot abide sacrificing anything for the good of the young people of today.

I have a big house I am happy with in a nice location, but if the local council wanted to knock down the house oppose and whack up a high rise I’d be fine with that, because people have a right to have a stable home life.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/01/2023 14:23

Of course people will object to a huge change to their community!

Of course people will object to compulsory land purchases.

FriedEggChocolate · 16/01/2023 14:20

In our village they've had 3 local devlopments. Two of them managed to be buit on the edge of the village with no social housing, because the social housing need could be pooled together and placed on a brownfield site in the middle of the village. Means that the owners of the 4 bed executive homes don't have poor people living next door. The social / shared ownership housing is now being built, after the other developments have been finished, immediately next to the railway line. Which will be nice. There are no ammenities - primary schools are at capacity, no secondary school, bus service has just been classed as unviable and cancelled, we can't get a dentist to run the practice and the GPs have no spaces.

Interestingly, the social housing's location puts these homes right next to the better one of the primary schools, so they're bang in catchment. The two big executive developments are on the edge of the village, so will be lucky to get any place in village schools because of the number of children from the social housing. What goes around and all that....

Dixiechickonhols · 16/01/2023 12:56

Op mentions lots of infrastructure issues though. Only hourly trains, no buses on Sunday, one school, no petrol garage, no supermarket, no pub, no cafe.

Straightaway you can see more building there will mean lots more traffic on road. People can only live there with a car.
Then they will approve houses with 1 parking space when nearly everyone has 2 to live there and it’s no wonder why parking and traffic is a nightmare in village.

Current system seems to be everyone locally can see it will be a mess infrastructure wise, still goes ahead. It is indeed a mess, then scramble to put something sticking plaster like in place eg portacabin at local school.

Jimboscott0115 · 16/01/2023 12:30

Ah, it's the old 'we desperately need more housing in this country, but not where I live' argument that has raged for years and years.

Noone has a right that the house/area they bought in has to remain the same, but unfortunately there's so many people with that kind of attitude that I makes significant development difficult in some areas. I've seen it in replies here already around 'what if they moved to live in a quiet area' which as above, is a typical insular response as nothing is stopping them moving again. Areas change, needs change - people need to get over it.

*There are areas where genuine concerns re infrastructure and school capacity etc exist but the OP clearly wasn't referring to these.