Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that by and large, most successful women are generally academic but successful men are a mixture of academic, lucky or average?

60 replies

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 10:12

I don't quite know how to talk about this. When I had my daughter I hoped she would be academic more than anything. She really struggles with school and I don't think deep down that she will go to university. She wants to work with children, and has been obsessed with babies since she was a toddler. I am aware that things change, and she is only eight but school are concerned about her being so behind and she has a learning support plan.
I so wish that it was my son who struggled because well patriarchy. Out of my friends, all of my successful female friends have degrees, some have degrees and aren't successful (like me) but I know very few who aren't 'clever' be that emotional, academic or know a skill or trade. Even then, as a woman, we are paid so much less for our skills (compare a plumbers salary to a hairdressers or vet assistant). Yet I know plenty of men who are of average intelligence or below, no charisma or connections who just have ended up on 40k a year.
I just worry she's going to struggle financially, even doing something she loves, or be dependent on someone else.

OP posts:
OfCourseChangs · 14/01/2023 10:30

I’m in my fifties and the most successful woman in life overall I know does not have a degree. She has made a decent amount of money but she has a sunny disposition, everything seems quite effortless and people adore her. She worked as a PA to the mega rich, no idea who as she had to always sign non disclosures.

I do understand what you are saying though. I was academically inclined and knew it was my way out of poverty as a child. The other thing about Universities is it’s a time where quite a few people pair off so you end up with two people on professional wages. Okay I know not everyone makes a good wage who has a degree but in theory you are overall unless an outlier supposed to earn about 300k more over a lifetime.

Its the patriarchy. Give your DD experiences to gain confidence and get her to try as much stuff as possible.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/01/2023 10:28

My ds was way behind at 7 and 8. He’s got 2 MA’s now and is a successful journalist.

Chindren develop at different rates academically.

Arushofbloodtothehead · 14/01/2023 10:27

I agree with your title to an extent because I have a professional qualification that I studied and worked hard for, yet DH has a better paid job than me out of luck and knowing somebody in that company. I dont think a female would have been employed in this role.

For females though it isnt all about qualifications. For example I can think of one person who took the same degree as me (accounting and finance) but didnt use that degree and still works in the shop they worked at when we were in uni. Whereas there are others I know who have done lower level childcare courses and now own their own creche/pre school etc.

TulipCat · 14/01/2023 10:25

A lot of successful women who aren't academic are pretty, because, well, patriarchy. So sad that this is still the case but there you go. The best thing you can do for your DD is encourage her to use her strengths, whatever they may be, and to pursue avenues that interest her.

donttellmehesalive · 14/01/2023 10:25

I agree that traditionally manual labour for men has been viewed as more valuable and been paid better.

I suppose we all support this by being willing to pay a plumber more ph to fix a leak than we pay our hairdresser ph to cut our hair.

However, there is nothing stopping your daughter from training in any of those trades. And I think luck, networking and charisma play an important role in success regardless of gender.

MetaDaughter · 14/01/2023 10:25

Yes, your wider point is well observed and expressed, @HammergoHammer

(Sorry you’ve had some pointlessly snotty replies. I guess not everyone on MN strives for the same level of debate on universal issues! Grin)

Logicpuzzle · 14/01/2023 10:23

Yes it's not fair. But many successful women I know are not a a academic. They are hard working, determined and savvy. Some academic women I know are a ball of nerves in crappy relationships and you wouldn't call them successful. Also people get to define their own success. Parents don't define it for them however hard they try. I get it to some degree we would probably agree what successful is not. But try to see the positives and skills your daughter has and help her build on them.

nc8975 · 14/01/2023 10:20

I'm sorry you're worried OP, I understand what you're saying and agree to an extent although I would keep supporting your daughter and help her find her strengths. She's still very young.

But I know what you mean and I agree, when I look at my work place most (not all) of the men in senior roles are pretty average, whereas the women have had to have bigger achievements, qualifications, experiences etc to get to the same level. They are demonised more for behaviours I see in men. But I suppose we've always known that, women have to work harder to get to the same level. Girls outperform boys in all areas of school I think (correct me if I'm wrong) they do better at uni and I believe they start off better in the workplace, but at some point, despite all this, men disproportionately end up in senior roles and getting paid more.

WhiteCatmas · 14/01/2023 10:20

She’s 8.
Feed her passions, broaden her world and stop worrying she’s not academic. You don’t have to be academic to be successful & everyone’s definition of success differs.

icelolly12 · 14/01/2023 10:16

Seems a bit premature to be worrying about this at eight. Encourage her to do what she enjoys at this stage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread