Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that by and large, most successful women are generally academic but successful men are a mixture of academic, lucky or average?

60 replies

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 10:12

I don't quite know how to talk about this. When I had my daughter I hoped she would be academic more than anything. She really struggles with school and I don't think deep down that she will go to university. She wants to work with children, and has been obsessed with babies since she was a toddler. I am aware that things change, and she is only eight but school are concerned about her being so behind and she has a learning support plan.
I so wish that it was my son who struggled because well patriarchy. Out of my friends, all of my successful female friends have degrees, some have degrees and aren't successful (like me) but I know very few who aren't 'clever' be that emotional, academic or know a skill or trade. Even then, as a woman, we are paid so much less for our skills (compare a plumbers salary to a hairdressers or vet assistant). Yet I know plenty of men who are of average intelligence or below, no charisma or connections who just have ended up on 40k a year.
I just worry she's going to struggle financially, even doing something she loves, or be dependent on someone else.

OP posts:
GameofLifer111 · 14/01/2023 13:13

When I was 8 I was given extra homework to catch up in maths. I was behind and HATED learning.

When I was 20, I graduated with a BSC in coding. When I was 26 I had a MSC in coding.

You're panicking too early. Give your head a rest x

User359472111111 · 14/01/2023 13:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Realfastfoodie · 14/01/2023 13:07

Your broader point is so well made. I agree.

Speaking as someone who most people would describe as academic, I would gently encourage you to rethink your priorities for your daughter. I would rather my DC was happy than bright, 100 times over.

daretodenim · 14/01/2023 13:02

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:21

I definitely don't define successful as just relating to money. But being broke is hard, and it takes away your choices. If you're a nursery worker, you have to have a great knowledge of children's development, psychology, safeguarding, SEN, people skills, diplomacy etc. Yet society deems this role only deserves minimum wage. I used to make lattes all day for more. My sons preschool key worker spoke three languages, was an ex tefl teacher and she knew so much about Latin American politics. But something goes wrong for women and we end up in these lower paid roles.
I want my daughter to be able to afford to leave a relationship if she's unhappy, to be able to one day own her own home with a garden for the dog she wants, I want her to enjoy her maternity and not have her card declined when she's trying to buy a pint of milk. I have experienced all of these elements, and I worry that she will too.
So no, money doesn't define success. But it damn well makes your life easier at times.

I agree with all of this and your overarching point.

It really pisses me off.

PrincessConstance · 14/01/2023 12:51

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:43

@PrincessConstance I would argue the responsibility of a plumber is no more than a nursery worker. Spotting abuse, watching for autism, giving the child to the approved parent rather than the granny who's under the influence (personal experience) that's some serious shit.

The only way to find out is to give plumbing or my job for instance a try.🙂
Cleaning was quite arduous. My current job however means I have to make sure the production lines are stocked and keep running so we can fulfill orders. All in budget.
Dp looks at my 3 screens and says, 'Fuck that' and walks off.
We're currently renovating our house, I think that job is both arduous and technical in equal measure. I cannot imagine working in that environment day after day.
I personally think people overplay their hands when comparing roles. A big job is a big job, with responsibilities and the pay packet to match. If people want it they should do what it takes!

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:43

@PrincessConstance I would argue the responsibility of a plumber is no more than a nursery worker. Spotting abuse, watching for autism, giving the child to the approved parent rather than the granny who's under the influence (personal experience) that's some serious shit.

OP posts:
PrincessConstance · 14/01/2023 11:40

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:21

I definitely don't define successful as just relating to money. But being broke is hard, and it takes away your choices. If you're a nursery worker, you have to have a great knowledge of children's development, psychology, safeguarding, SEN, people skills, diplomacy etc. Yet society deems this role only deserves minimum wage. I used to make lattes all day for more. My sons preschool key worker spoke three languages, was an ex tefl teacher and she knew so much about Latin American politics. But something goes wrong for women and we end up in these lower paid roles.
I want my daughter to be able to afford to leave a relationship if she's unhappy, to be able to one day own her own home with a garden for the dog she wants, I want her to enjoy her maternity and not have her card declined when she's trying to buy a pint of milk. I have experienced all of these elements, and I worry that she will too.
So no, money doesn't define success. But it damn well makes your life easier at times.

I have one of those big jobs.
I'm not even from the UK. I've done everything from bar work to cleaning toilets.
At my present company, I started in production and worked my way up. If you're conscientious and driven you can achieve whatever you want.
Now I oversee the entire procurement process.
However, it's long hrs and a large amount of responsibility, especially now post covid.

Dp on the other hand has a Plumbing maintenance business, he has two degrees but runs his business around school hrs to suit his kids. He's been part of the mechanical management of major infrastructure projects like Meadowhall and other large projects. That is not comparable to hairdressing.

If you want something, go achieve it. However, where there is a benefit there will be a burden. Don't blame the patriarchy for that.

nc8975 · 14/01/2023 11:34

@HammergoHammer in my previous sector it was overwhelming female, I can't remember the stats exactly, I remember it was shocking though, something like 80% female overall but 90% of the senior management were male.

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:29

I see it in nursing all the time.My hospital
Band 5 nurses- majority women
Band 6 nurses- half women/ half men
Band 7 nurses- about a third women
Band 8 modern matrons- 3 men. There hasn't been a female modern matron during my time in this hospital, despite many going for the role and having experience acting up in the role.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 14/01/2023 11:26

I think there's a great degree in truth in what you're saying. In another way this is pretty much why I put my niece and nephews through Saturday maths tutoring and extra science on week day afternoons - I was particularly militant about it with my niece especially as she's black and we've had many conversations which I've told her that she'll need to work to a herculean effort to make it half as far. Many people's version of success varies but there are some basic truths regardless.

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:25

@NuffSaidSam obviously wanting a career in childcare isn't damning yourself to a life of minimum wage, but that's what my post is about, you have to have a skill and then something else (drive, connections, emotional intelligence) to really make it as a woman. Statistically if you go into childcare you will end up in a nursery, the same as if you train as a nurse, you will likely end up as a band 5 working on a ward or in the community. It's not like, say, accountancy where you are very much in demand, not just for your accountancy skills, but for what that degree says about your abilities.

OP posts:
HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:21

I definitely don't define successful as just relating to money. But being broke is hard, and it takes away your choices. If you're a nursery worker, you have to have a great knowledge of children's development, psychology, safeguarding, SEN, people skills, diplomacy etc. Yet society deems this role only deserves minimum wage. I used to make lattes all day for more. My sons preschool key worker spoke three languages, was an ex tefl teacher and she knew so much about Latin American politics. But something goes wrong for women and we end up in these lower paid roles.
I want my daughter to be able to afford to leave a relationship if she's unhappy, to be able to one day own her own home with a garden for the dog she wants, I want her to enjoy her maternity and not have her card declined when she's trying to buy a pint of milk. I have experienced all of these elements, and I worry that she will too.
So no, money doesn't define success. But it damn well makes your life easier at times.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 14/01/2023 11:21

I agree with you general point about the workplace being biased towards men. I think that's a generally accepted fact.

In terms of your daughter, you need to change your mindset though. Although, probably easier to be successful if you're very academic it's not the only way to be successful. Concentrate on her strengths, put your energy into giving her every opportunity to expand and develop those. Encourage her to work hard and be positive about what she can achieve.

FWIW I'm a nanny and earn more than £40k a year (quite a bit more!) so wanting a career in childcare doesn't necessarily limit her to a minimum wage job. It's your attitude that will do that.

EatYouNextTuesday · 14/01/2023 11:13

Depends on your definition of successful.

I am intelligent but not academic. I work full time at a job I enjoy and am interested in. I brought my son up without his father being involved and he is a clever, funny and warm little boy. We have a comfortable home, small luxuries and a limited disposable income for treats, presents and things we want. I am not in a relationship and am likely to remain single indefinitely.

I don't equate success with being married, having a high-powered job and lots of money. We have a nice life and we are happy.

If your daughter loves children and that continues into later life - would it not be a success for her to be happy and fulfilled with a job in childcare?

Beamur · 14/01/2023 11:12

Depends how you measure success too.
Most of the women I know who are happy and well off seem to have a combination of good interpersonal skills, enough intelligence to navigate the world and the willingness to work hard/be curious, they're more entrepreneurs in spirit than academic per se.

lljkk · 14/01/2023 11:10

It's fairly offensive to imply that a 'low' prestige/earner person is "unsuccessful" in life.

Trying to be constructive, I can't make sense of this thread because "successful" is never defined.
Candidate definitions

  • earns at least 40k/year
  • has a career
  • simply feels successful
  • some other definition, could literally be anything
  • some combination of above.

Tell me what you're talking about & maybe I can figure out if I have an opinion about the answer.

Bigweekend · 14/01/2023 11:07

Isn't it because of attitudes like yours? Why wouldn't she be a plumber?

Hattie72 · 14/01/2023 11:03

I am successful and have a “big” job, but I was academically average mainly because I was lazy and more into partying than going to lectures at uni. I would say I have been successful in my career because I have great peoples skills, build networks/ relationships easily and also happened to be in the right place, at the right time. I think peoples skills and being well like and well connected is far more important than a good degree at least in my industry.

MyTurkey · 14/01/2023 10:54

I could have been your daughter at 8. I loved children, babies and animals. I used to spend hours playing with my neighbours' toddlers. Neighbour was a teacher and said to my mum that I wasn't very bright but had the gift of 'children' so would probably not be able to do O levels but might get some CSEs and work as a nursery nurse. Admittedly I wasn't doing very well at school at that point and wasn't interested in learning. They moved away but my mum bumped into her not so long ago and seem to take great pleasure in telling her about my 2 degrees and Msc and professional career.

Obviously there is nothing wrong with wanting to be a childcare worker but beware of labelling an 8 year old as this or that.

AnnieApple123 · 14/01/2023 10:54

I know a lot of academically-inclined women who did very well in the education system but haven’t gone on to do anything very exciting since. Lots with postgrad quals.

Bard6817 · 14/01/2023 10:51

Doing a four year apprentiships to aquire a trade, plumber electrician engineer, lol. Not academic? I’m afraid they are worth more than most degrees, you have no idea of the content of them, not to mention that they can be horrible messy and sometimes dangerous. ps. I know some fabulous females in these trades…. They do remarkably well btw.

Theres only about 4 degrees that actually improve your earning capability, all maths, science, engineering related (can’t remember the researched 4th) I consider it a huge misselling scandal, but go google the research and see which degrees actually make up the £100k headline benefit the salaries.

Alas, degrees were dumbed down from when i was a young chap…. I know because i went through both systems. People who could barely read and write english passed with a 2:1. Baffles me how. But good for them, because it’s not easy peasy, and i admired their work ethic.

I guess the question i would turn back to you - is how do you measure success???

It’s not just about salary…. For me it was having a period where i earnt enough to be financially secure for life, which then allowed me to drop to the near bottom rung and bring in a £30k salary for a part time role, where i turn up, fix issues, head home, no stress, and get professional kudos as a fixer. I particularly enjoy working with the younger members of the company, and when they ask for technical insight or even career advice, i provide it.

Was i lucky - yes. Found a career that was well regarded and well paid.
Was i academic - no - but i have 2 degrees, despite failing all my GcSE and have no a levels.
I do feel successfull - but i’m no (never have been) captain of industry and happy to do a part time 9-5 run of the mill - and have a great family life where i dont bring any stress/work home and although i’m not main breadwinner - happy to pass on most of my earnings to help run the home and support our kids.

I also feel rather average - except that financially - excluding property - i’m in top 5%.

So possibly - most people will interpret the above as luck…. But - id caveat that with not having a life for 30’odd years, 100% workaholic, no time for LTR, didn’t end up marrying, no kids of my own, step kids now…. Might have been luck - but at the expense of hard work and a limited life.

The successfull women i’ve worked with through the years…. They did professional qualifications more than the academic qualification route - but i suspect that’s an age thing - and now i would expect it to be academic followed by professional.

I guess i’d sum up to say…. I don’t see having a degree as anything special any more, i’d encourage individuals more into the professional routes first via apprenticeships, but if they did go down the degree route - don’t pick up the entitled attitude that so many graduates with limited work exnvironment arrive with - and look to move forward with adding more industry specific professional qualifications.

(i’d caveat the above by saying that i know it’s not the only route - and that for instance some degrees are very specialised and a must have for certain paths…. I’ve just found that to be the exception out of the thousands of degree courses out there… Comparing 100 variants of generic studies degrees with a Maths degree from bath, is comparing apples & oranges - and you can’t make OJ with apples.)

I think there is a route to success no matter which path you take. I think the academic route is more aligned to females these days (i will get blasted for that - but it’s based on some old research which i still believe to be accurate).. I just fear that people are sold the academic route as a definate route to success - but it’s not. Whichever route you do take - it’s hard - and i’m sure our own definitions of what success looks like throughout our life changes over time anyway - and industry has a way of breaking/dumbing things down over time so it doesn’t have to pay silly money for skills long term. So if you want big money - don’t join big organisations - because they are a meat grinder and only less than 5% in them reach that level. And you have to be picky about the not so small companies and what skills and experience you are bringing to the table.

OneCup · 14/01/2023 10:42

There are many incompetent men at my workplace and noone bats an eyelid. Expectations for women are much higher and you'll get 'talked to' when that happens. In this respect, I agree with you.
I however do think there are different ways of being successful and being academic is only one of them.
My DC is not academic and I do not worry about her future at all.

Ruffpuff · 14/01/2023 10:38

I was academically behind at 8. I started catching up at 12. Although by this point we had already been ‘set’ at school, and so it was harder to persuade teachers I should do the higher papers- which I eventually got As in. I went to university and I now have a good job.

She’s only 8. Things can change drastically in a few years.

EileenAdler · 14/01/2023 10:36

Internalised misandry and nobody is stopping women from becoming self-employed trades "people".

CovertImage · 14/01/2023 10:36

MetaDaughter · 14/01/2023 10:25

Yes, your wider point is well observed and expressed, @HammergoHammer

(Sorry you’ve had some pointlessly snotty replies. I guess not everyone on MN strives for the same level of debate on universal issues! Grin)

Yours was the 5th response and not a single response above yours was "snotty", I don't know why people do this on here.

By the way "I guess not everyone on MN strives for the same level of debate on universal issues!" is as snotty as fuck