Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that by and large, most successful women are generally academic but successful men are a mixture of academic, lucky or average?

60 replies

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 10:12

I don't quite know how to talk about this. When I had my daughter I hoped she would be academic more than anything. She really struggles with school and I don't think deep down that she will go to university. She wants to work with children, and has been obsessed with babies since she was a toddler. I am aware that things change, and she is only eight but school are concerned about her being so behind and she has a learning support plan.
I so wish that it was my son who struggled because well patriarchy. Out of my friends, all of my successful female friends have degrees, some have degrees and aren't successful (like me) but I know very few who aren't 'clever' be that emotional, academic or know a skill or trade. Even then, as a woman, we are paid so much less for our skills (compare a plumbers salary to a hairdressers or vet assistant). Yet I know plenty of men who are of average intelligence or below, no charisma or connections who just have ended up on 40k a year.
I just worry she's going to struggle financially, even doing something she loves, or be dependent on someone else.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pocodaku · 24/08/2023 05:55

FlowersAndBooks · 23/08/2023 16:33

I know a lot of very dim people who work in sales and recruitment earning £100k +. I’m not being rude, I just know they have zero qualifications, and can’t spell very basic words.

The most academic person I know has just finished his phd at age 33 and has never worked. He will stay at uni, and work as a researcher/lecturer. Not exactly going to be raking it in!

Also, if your DD has a passion for childcare, then great that she’s found something she actually loves! She could be a nanny to the rich and famous, a childminder, or a nursery worker/nursery manager/ owner, maybe an early years teacher. There are decent careers in childcare, and frankly, I’d much prefer my DD was doing something she loved, making a difference and not sitting behind a desk her whole life. She may prefer to have her own babies and be a sahm. Good luck to her

While I take your larger point about financial ‘success’- finishing a PhD involves a great deal of work, stamina, problem solving and creative thinking.

beguilingeyes · 24/08/2023 05:32

I've always said that a penis and a posh voice will get you anywhere in this country, including no. 10.
I spent most of my working life in banking and the succession of well spoken idiots who ascended rapidly was still a thing up until I left in 2008.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/08/2023 19:44

Yeah, I know what you mean.

Women generally need to be exceptional in some way to be really successful. But lots of very average men end up in great positions. Then the exceptional women are held up as proof that the organisation is inclusive and sexism doesn’t exist.

You see it even in children’s TV and books. There’s one female character and she’s incredibly clever, while the male characters are all average. It’s supposed to be inclusive but it’s really not.

lljkk · 23/08/2023 19:24

absurd fucking thread

Theborder · 23/08/2023 19:21

If I had a female to converse with during the time my kitchen got done I would have loved it to be honest. She’s very personable and chatty too. I would have thought bloody good for you and I think a lot of people do, hence the gifts she receives. But it is a lot physically, she gets very tired. Her muscles are now massive but long term you do think, how sustainable is that career. I don’t know much about it.

Theborder · 23/08/2023 19:18

@Spendonsend

All sorts of factors really. I mean my niece is still a rarity working as a young builder but so far she has been treated absolutely wonderfully by her male colleagues who have taken her under their wing. The one difference is she receives gifts from customers like beer, flowers, chocolate etc to say thanks. The males don’t get the gifts.

Spendonsend · 23/08/2023 19:15

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2023 19:06

" women and men can do any job they like are there are no male/female jobs."

I don't 100% agree. There are still some jobs that require physical strength that the average woman doesn't have.

I dont agree with it myself! And i wrote it. But i always get told that women can do any job, its just the industry needs to change. Eg smaller pack sizes, or different tools ...

Theborder · 23/08/2023 19:11

@Gwenhwyfar

I do kind of agree. I mean my niece went into construction. She grafts. But she’s strong and sporty and also quite masculine overall. I can’t imagine my DD being able to do it. She would moan like fuck about the cold weather, but then so again so would my son 🤣.

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2023 19:06

" women and men can do any job they like are there are no male/female jobs."

I don't 100% agree. There are still some jobs that require physical strength that the average woman doesn't have.

Spendonsend · 23/08/2023 17:21

Its a difficult conversation to have because in the age of equality women and men can do any job they like are there are no male/female jobs.

However I think there are more opportunities in traditionally male jobs to earn more than minimum wage, with zero qualifications and a criminal record and rubbish personal skills (like getting drunk and fighting, being a bit flakey with timings) than there are traditional female roles where you can do that.

Theborder · 23/08/2023 17:01

@karmakameleon

A male primary school teacher, even a mediocre one can very easily land a deputy head position within a few years of qualifying. Just for having a penis.

Theborder · 23/08/2023 16:59

You’ve described my niece. Always needed help at school and in the end was diagnosed with dyslexia/dyscalculia and was just never going to be academic. Wonderful person. Anyway she’s 19 now and went straight into a “male trade”. She works in construction and is very happy with her life and progressing well. There’s nothing stopping her from entering into a trade. A work ethic will get you far.

beguilingeyes · 23/08/2023 16:56

I've been reading about how all of the early software engineers were women, because it wasn't thought of as important, the emphasis was on the hardware.
As soon as the focus shifted, the men started taking over (and the money went up) and nowadays most of the software people are men

thecatsthecats · 23/08/2023 16:55

EffortlessDesmond · 23/08/2023 16:26

Hustle is vital... it's worth more than a pile of degrees. Everyone I know who has been successful, male and female, has had a drive to win and been willing to take risks. Almost all of us went overseas to earn better in the 1970s, for example.

Yes - although my husband currently earns more than me, I'd say that he's more likely to plod steadily up the ranks, whereas I'm more likely to make a million chancing my arm a bit.

In fact, he's currently earning more because I chose to work part time to retrain and upskill in a lucrative freelancing field. Used some of the spare time to improve my investment portfolio. Whereas he's spending days meticulously going through job applications point by point, and if I'm applying, I just sling my CV out there.

It's a good balance to be fair. His steady upward progress is a safety net, and I filter out the ridiculously self-effacing nonsense he puts in job applications.

thecatsthecats · 23/08/2023 16:50

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2023 16:22

"The most successful female friend of mine is the least academic. She has what you'd call hustle - ambition, opportunism, single-mindedness and isn't risk averse."

Mine too, but she's quite butch and has many characteristics we'd normally associate with men.

Oh, mine definitely isn't! Very feminine.

I'm not butch, but I'm definitely the most "masculine" out of that friend group - though really I'd say I'm slap down the middle between stereotypically male or female.

But yeah, I do think there's a gendered split to it. And it's generally not about what society chooses to reward either (where gendered professions e.g. plumbing v nursing) - the "hustle" types I know succeed in environments where you have to prove your worth on the bottom line. Marketing, sales, entrepreneurs.

FlowersAndBooks · 23/08/2023 16:33

I know a lot of very dim people who work in sales and recruitment earning £100k +. I’m not being rude, I just know they have zero qualifications, and can’t spell very basic words.

The most academic person I know has just finished his phd at age 33 and has never worked. He will stay at uni, and work as a researcher/lecturer. Not exactly going to be raking it in!

Also, if your DD has a passion for childcare, then great that she’s found something she actually loves! She could be a nanny to the rich and famous, a childminder, or a nursery worker/nursery manager/ owner, maybe an early years teacher. There are decent careers in childcare, and frankly, I’d much prefer my DD was doing something she loved, making a difference and not sitting behind a desk her whole life. She may prefer to have her own babies and be a sahm. Good luck to her

EffortlessDesmond · 23/08/2023 16:26

Hustle is vital... it's worth more than a pile of degrees. Everyone I know who has been successful, male and female, has had a drive to win and been willing to take risks. Almost all of us went overseas to earn better in the 1970s, for example.

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2023 16:22

"The most successful female friend of mine is the least academic. She has what you'd call hustle - ambition, opportunism, single-mindedness and isn't risk averse."

Mine too, but she's quite butch and has many characteristics we'd normally associate with men.

Gwenhwyfar · 23/08/2023 16:21

"My last two female bosses both worked their way up from entry level customer facing roles, so I can see that degrees etc aren’t necessary if a person has drive, capability, and luck."

Must depend on the sector because I don't know anyone who's done this and I think it's becoming even rarer.

thecatsthecats · 23/08/2023 16:19

Sorry, missed a point there...

I think it's easy to dismiss "hustle" as luck, but there's something fairly fundamental to the opportunity-seeking mindset that some individuals have.

It's no more or less "lucky" to be born with that mindset as it is to be born academic.

The one thing I would say is to make sure that her academic achievements are never glossed over. Because people always say that academic success will be rewarded later in life, when in my experience the big winners are those who have the "hustle". So academic kids can lose out twice -once for being put down for their achievements and twice for being less successful than others!

thecatsthecats · 23/08/2023 16:13

The most successful female friend of mine is the least academic. She has what you'd call hustle - ambition, opportunism, single-mindedness and isn't risk averse.

My husband is a chronic over-thinker. He'll sit there dealing with the 100 might-happens, rather than cracking on and dealing with the one or two 'did happens'. I take more inspiration from my friend than my husband in work!

I see the same attitude with very successful men - they don't fart around worrying about ticking every box. They're not worried about uber-competence Vs uber-confidence.

Worldgonecrazy · 23/08/2023 15:44

My last two female bosses both worked their way up from entry level customer facing roles, so I can see that degrees etc aren’t necessary if a person has drive, capability, and luck. Having said that, there have been a large number of middling male colleagues with far less ability and nouse.

Soothsayer1 · 14/01/2023 13:34

I think broadly speaking it's because men hold more of the power and they make the rules to favour people like them i.e. men
I think this will shift as we seem more women in senior positions and as women have fewer children and so are less encumbered by domestic responsibilities, and as it becomes more than normal for men to have to step up and pull their weight on the domestic front

Liz1tummypain · 14/01/2023 13:33

To be successful,as in to get into a well paid job ( if that's what we're talking about) , I think men and women all need to be clever, driven, and/ or lucky. I don't see it through the prism of genders. My daughter is quite bright and ridiculously, mercilessly driven and that's what I put her fantabulous, ( as in well paid) career down to.

karmakameleon · 14/01/2023 13:28

HammergoHammer · 14/01/2023 11:29

I see it in nursing all the time.My hospital
Band 5 nurses- majority women
Band 6 nurses- half women/ half men
Band 7 nurses- about a third women
Band 8 modern matrons- 3 men. There hasn't been a female modern matron during my time in this hospital, despite many going for the role and having experience acting up in the role.

When we looked at primary schools for my eldest, the theme seemed to be that almost all the classroom teachers were women but the head was always a man.

Swipe left for the next trending thread