Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to move from relatives house

563 replies

OrangeBlankets · 14/01/2023 09:32

I've been living in a relatives house for more than 2 years. When I moved in the relative was in a care home but the person who had POA for them agreed for me to move in and said it was ok for a short time and that I didn't have to pay rent.

Now the house owner died and so did the POA. The executors want me to move out.

I don't have anywhere to go, can they evict me?

OP posts:
LookingforMaryPoppins · 15/01/2023 17:43

Of course they can ask you to move out! The personal representatives will be tasked with distributing the estate in accordance with your grandmothers wishes as set out in her will. It was lovely that you have had this benefit for so long but why on earth would you expect it to continue and why would you reward the kindness by being difficult. It's not your house and never has been.

You should be given proper notice but I am perplexed why you feel hard done by.

GinUnicorn · 15/01/2023 17:37

OP I mean this kindly but you need to face facts a bit here.

You will have to leave and you have the choice of doing so on good terms with relatives who have helped you, with good references and maybe negotiating a few months grace or

Being evicted and burning your bridges plus having no references and potential legal fees. It’s in no one’s interest least of all yours with mental health illness.

You need to start to be proactive and help yourself. It is scary but you can do it.

kateandme · 15/01/2023 17:34

Can you sit down and have a conversation with the current owner.listen to eachtoher and teynand come up with something. You've got to go.but how and how long and in what mood this tales needs a adult conversation.dont make it even harder for yourself by digging heels into ground that already seems to have turned to sand.

Wheresthebeach · 15/01/2023 17:31

So you were suppose to move in for a short time, but stayed two years? When the owner has died instead of getting yourself sorted, you're trying to stay? And questioning if they can evict you?

That's terrible, you are taking advantage of their kindness.

ShoshanaBlue101 · 15/01/2023 17:31

How long have you been on the housing list for? The best thing would be to contact your housing officer...though they may not be able to do anything until you are evicted.

Pelsall116 · 15/01/2023 17:27

You were only meant to be there a short time. I get the housing situation is difficult, seek advice and look at what rentals are available
Unless the house was left to you - and I guess it was not - then you don't have a right to remain there without a tenancy agreement. You presumably managed to save some money on what you saved on rent

Nannygoat151 · 15/01/2023 17:23

2 years isn’t a short time and if youve been living there free all this time you should have saved enough money to move

angela99999 · 15/01/2023 17:17

I don't think you have any right to stay, especially as you knew it was short term and paid no rent.

GeneticallyModifiedGrump · 15/01/2023 17:12

'If I get evicted do I have to pay costs for that? I thought the owners would have to pay.'
It's really difficult to feel sorry for anyone with this mentality.
Is two years free rent not enough OP?

TrashyPanda · 15/01/2023 15:55

The beneficiaries may well have discussed and decided to let OP stay there "for a short time"

it is the beneficiaries who want her out of the house.

The op has been clear that the nursing home fees were paid from other assets

that is totally irrelevant

MattHancocksWhiteBikini · 15/01/2023 15:34

OP - It's hard, but you need to accept that what was a good thing is coming to an end.

It really makes no sense to try and obstruct this, all you'll achieve is a burnt bridge from someone who did something kind for you.

Do not make them formally evict you via the courts. It achieves nothing and will definitely stop you from asking them for a reference.

Just ask for a signed letter stating you are evicted and present to the council as homeless. Have a conversation with your relative expressing gratitude for the last 2 years and explain the situation with housing and your dog, they may give you a grace period - they may not - but attempting to delay the inevitable through legal channels will get you exactly nowhere.

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 15/01/2023 15:11

Everybody I know who has a POA has nominated one of the beneficiaries of their will. The beneficiaries may well have discussed and decided to let OP stay there "for a short time". They may have thought the grandmother would not survive long, and it was better to not get a "proper" tenant if the grandmother was going to die in the next few months. Getting a proper tenant may hsve involved repairs, redecorating, certificates etc, then a delay to selling if the owner died quickly. They may not have expected her to survive two years.

The op has been clear that the nursing home fees were paid from other assets.

LumpyandBumps · 15/01/2023 15:08

OrangeBlankets · 15/01/2023 11:22

If I get evicted do I have to pay costs for that? I thought the owners would have to pay.

I have only had to get as far as court eviction on one occasion ( the tenant wanted to be housed by the LA and stopped paying her rent so I would evict her). Even though I used Section 21 which is sometimes called ‘no fault’ or ‘no reason’ the tenant was ordered to pay the court costs, when she didn’t move out the bailiffs fees were automatically added to the order, and when she didn’t pay, the costs of getting an attachment of earnings order were also added. This was 6-7 years ago, but she finally ended up paying around £700, which was more than double the original court fee.
The fees will have increased over the years, but I don’t know how much.
The debt was registered as a County Court Judgement as it was not paid within one month of the order.
I have no idea if you will qualify for LA accommodation, but speaking as a landlord you will seriously jeopardise any chance of renting privately if you have a CCJ, and if the reason for it is disclosed as being for eviction costs your chances will be negligible. I don’t know the situation in your area but here the demand for accommodation currently far exceeds the supply.
You can make things difficult for the executors by forcing them to evict you but unless you will qualify for LA housing you will also make things much more difficult for yourself.

Daleksatemyshed · 15/01/2023 14:39

It's an unfortunate situation but really the person in the wrong originally was the POA. I've held POA for a relative and when you take it on there's quite strict guidelines which you agree to when you sign up, mainly to keep financial records and to act in the best interests of the relative. I expect they let the Op stay then couldn't find a way to tell them to leave

TrashyPanda · 15/01/2023 14:29

BadNomad · 15/01/2023 12:52

Oh I agree, it is morally fucked-up. But morals don't matter here. Whatever the POA did, that is not on the OP. She will not have to pay any legal fees relating to the actions of the POA. The OP is just a tenant. She will be treated as such. If there is a tenancy agreement, then the new landlord will officially ask her to leave under Section-something. If there is no tenancy agreement, then she'll be asked to leave under Section-something-else. If she refuses to leave after that, then it will go to court.

Ignorance of the law is no excuse and never had been
this isn’t about morals - it is about the law

OP knew her relative was acting as POA, ie that they were acting on behalf of a person who could not act on their behalf. The rent free agreement did not benefit anyone but OP and is contrary to the POA, as it goes against the financial safeguarding. Therefore the POA was acting contrary to their powers and any agreement they entered is capable of being overturned. And it is obvious to anyone (including OP) that the agreement did not protect the GM. Should the beneficiaries wish to challenge this, then it is possible that legal costs could be awarded against OP. And it is probable that she would be asked to recompense the estate with 2+ years rent.

the law is perfectly clear. It is in place to prevent financial abuse of vulnerable people.

freyamay74 · 15/01/2023 14:26

Bottom line is, the house does not belong to the OP, the grandmother's name was on the deeds and she has left her estate to the beneficiaries she chose.

So even if there's a tenancy agreement (and it seems very unclear) there are entirely lawful steps which will be taken to remove the OP. And it's highly likely she'll end up liable for the costs of removing her if she tries to drag things out.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 14:12

OrangeBlankets · 15/01/2023 11:22

If I get evicted do I have to pay costs for that? I thought the owners would have to pay.

They can ask the court to order you to pay the costs. Generally, such applications succeed.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 14:02

boilthekettle · 14/01/2023 15:22

How are people thinking that the OP would have been able to save much, realistically, if she was unwell and presumably on benefits?

I have never claimed universal credit but surely they wouldn't have just handed the OP the portion meant for housing (so she could save it) because she had no rent - and the UC she received would have been under a hundred quid a week or so?

Not enough to eat and pay bills and for absolutely everything else.

They certainly wouldn't have been given the money for rent without producing . an enforceable agreement that clearly showed that she is liable for rent.

And renting from relatives, even with an agreement that shows liability, also requires proof that it is a genuine commercial arrangement. I am currently appealing a case where a client has been refused help with rent because they are renting from their parents, who have moved to their second home in Spain.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 13:42

Mynewhome · 14/01/2023 12:44

Most of the people on this thread don't know how the housing /homeless system works. Op does not have a choice if you can't find anywhere to go, has no funding to do so then she has to go through the system.

Quite. People who haven't experienced it themselves or worked in a field where they deal with homelessness are often very quick to tell those less fortunate that should leave their homes when asked to.

Likewise those who expect the OP to have saved up enough money to put up RIA and deposit, when they have no idea if she's been well enough to work.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 13:24

Kennykenkencat · 14/01/2023 11:37

Mil had this type of thing.

Her father died and she was left the house (I don’t think he updated his will as they had been estranged for years when he died)
When she was told about the house she went to see it and found he had moved in his gf and her teenage children.

The children might or might not be relevant but they were allowed to stay and the gf was given use of the house until her death.

MIL has now died and I presume the gf is in residence.

My friend and her siblings are in a very similar position, except the "girlfriend" is now in her mid-80s. Friend's DF specified that his partner would have the right to remain in what had been the family home for the rest of her life or until she moves into a care home.

It's over 20 years since he died and one of friend's brothers reckons she's going to outlive him. Thankfully, they're all very fond of her, so are fairly philosophical about it.

Backthetruckup · 15/01/2023 13:07

I think this is a classic case of just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 12:59

BMW6 · 14/01/2023 09:47

Come on OP, you've been living rent free for 2 years, you must have saved thousands towards a deposit to buy or at least rent a property.!

You have NO right, morally or legally, to stay in your GM's home. It forms part of her estate and needs to be disposed of according to her will.

The gravy train has reached its final destination. Time to get off.

OP has disclosed that she has MH issues. If her MH problems means she was not well enough to work, she may only have been getting £77 a week, out of which she has been paying the bills for the house.

How much would you be able to save on £77 a week? My basic bills come to more than that.

Talia99 · 15/01/2023 12:59

Florissant · 15/01/2023 12:24

Correction: The OP did state that they signed a tenancy agreement with the POA, but that that agreement is now defunct. Ergo, there is no valid tenancy agreement.

That’s not correct. If the original agreement was valid (and not in breach of the duties of the POA), it is legally treated as being made by the deceased and remains valid on death. The ‘landlord’ becomes the executors and eventually the beneficiaries. They would have to comply with the terms of a valid lease to evict the OP.

Whether or not the tenancy agreement was valid since there was no rent and it may not have benefited the owner for the OP to live there is another matter. If it saved the owner paying bills and council tax, that may be seen as enough of a benefit.

BadNomad · 15/01/2023 12:52

TrashyPanda · 15/01/2023 12:41

Yes, it could be argued - but it probably wouldn’t stand up to any investigation, unless the property was in such a state nobody would rent it. Equally, were any other relatives offered the house at a rental fee? If not, why not?

its hard to argue that giving a house rent free to a relative of the Attorney was not a deliberate deprivation of assets of the very person they were supposed to be acting for.

there is a reason there are laws and governing body set up to protect vulnerable people - and this is a very good example of why these laws exist and need to be enforced.

Oh I agree, it is morally fucked-up. But morals don't matter here. Whatever the POA did, that is not on the OP. She will not have to pay any legal fees relating to the actions of the POA. The OP is just a tenant. She will be treated as such. If there is a tenancy agreement, then the new landlord will officially ask her to leave under Section-something. If there is no tenancy agreement, then she'll be asked to leave under Section-something-else. If she refuses to leave after that, then it will go to court.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 12:50

You definitely need to get advice from a specialist housing adviser, OP. If there's not a housing advice centre where you live, Shelter should be able to point you in the right direction. This might be a bit complex for CAB.

I'd also suggest that you make an appointment to see the homelessness officer at your local council. If you are vulnerable because of your MH issues, they may have a statutory duty to help you or even house you.

Good luck.