Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to move from relatives house

563 replies

OrangeBlankets · 14/01/2023 09:32

I've been living in a relatives house for more than 2 years. When I moved in the relative was in a care home but the person who had POA for them agreed for me to move in and said it was ok for a short time and that I didn't have to pay rent.

Now the house owner died and so did the POA. The executors want me to move out.

I don't have anywhere to go, can they evict me?

OP posts:
SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 22:24

“OP I realise you probably just took the kind offer of the POA. My annoyance is more directed at the people who are defending what the POA has done. I hope you get things sorted.”

Ummm, not many people have talked about the POA himself. Do you mean me? I have outlined why a (probably elderly, since he has predeceased the GM) POA might not want to rent out the house and might very well have a case that keeping the house occupied and maintained so that the asset does not depreciate is sufficiently in the interest of the GM vs bringing it up to rental standards and dealing with tenants.

SpaceshiptoMars · 15/01/2023 22:24

@OrangeBlankets If the POA was a relative of yours and an executor, they may have been a beneficiary of GMs will. Perhaps you should ask to look at the clause in GM's will about what would happen to the POA's share if they predeceased her.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 22:24

You need knowledgeable advice. I know you said you are going to the cab but ime Shelter are much better.

I'm inclined to agree, this is a complex situation and not all CABs will have a dedicated housing specialist. They had to cut a lot of housing advice jobs a few years ago when Legal Services Commission funding for housing was cut to zero.

You not only need advice regarding your rights (if any) with regard to the house you're in, but also if the council will have a duty to help you because of your MH issues.

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 15/01/2023 22:20

So it's ok for the OP to live there rent free for much longer than a short time, but the GM (who we assume does not have mental capacity to consent, hence the activation of the POA) doesn't matter?! Or because GM was in a care home we stop giving a shit?

It is not up to the POA to allow OP to move in to make their life easier. They have to act in GM's best interests. Who knows what the GM could have used that income for.

Thank god for the OPG. It is no wonder so many people end up in court for financial abuse, thinking they can just do what they want with a POA. OP I realise you probably just took the kind offer of the POA. My annoyance is more directed at the people who are defending what the POA has done. I hope you get things sorted.

FloraSpoke · 15/01/2023 22:17

WinterFoxes · 14/01/2023 10:45

OP, You've had enough people telling you how lucky you have been. Right now you have a problem and need to solve it. I'm guessing you haven't saved money - maybe because you haven;t earned much. i can quite see how a very low paid or PT job's income can go just on bills and living expenses.

What you could do is reframe what you have been doing as professional housesitting - keeping the property cared for and inhabited in exchange for rent-free accommodation, which is, in effect, what you have been doing. Ask the executors to give you a good reference for having done this. Make sure the house is immaculately clean and tidy and the garden in good nick and take some photos. Then apply to an agency and say you are looking for a long term professional housesitting contract as your current one is about to come to an end.

Good advice- you need to focus on the best way forward now OP and take positive steps to find new accommodation.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/01/2023 22:16

@StalkedByASpider Agree on the disagreement. I just can’t imagine the OP not painting herself in the best light possible here so the silence on many of the knowns and unknowns is very telling to me.

At the end of the day though I believe in the universe balancing out so if she took advantage of Granny, then she’s got to live with that. If she didn’t then she has a clear conscience and none of the posts calling her out will make a bit of difference as she will know she’s done nothing wrong.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 15/01/2023 22:11

Lost123454 · 14/01/2023 09:39

You've been freeloading for two years

Time to move out and into the real world

She hasn’t been freeloading! She was offered to live in her grandmas house rent free but taking care of bills.

StalkedByASpider · 15/01/2023 22:09

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 21:59

I read OP’s posts very differently to most of you. I think she is looking to understand her position, not to screw her relatives over but to understand the legals. She’s now going to Shelter for advice, which is the best plan.

Whether she “should” have saved or not, she hasn’t, or hasn’t been in a position to do so. She needs to live somewhere and should also be careful to go through whatever steps needed to get any benefits needed. If this needs to formally be eviction, she needs to understand the best way to do this.

I agree with you entirely.

StalkedByASpider · 15/01/2023 22:07

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/01/2023 21:53

We know:

  1. the OP lived rent free for 2 years
  2. the Op claims to have MH problems
  3. the POA agreed to the OP staying for a short time
  4. the OP was not named as a beneficiary
  5. the OP has not saved any money for 2 years
  6. The OP thinks Granny is mean
  7. The OP got a dog
  8. What was the relationship between the OP and POA
  9. The beneficiaries want to sell the house.

You’re right there is a lot we don’t know:

  1. What did the tenancy agreement say
  2. Was Granny aware that the OP was living there and not paying rent
  3. Did the OP take good care of the house
  4. What the OP expected to do long term

As for the OP now claiming she’s a dependent that’s going to be a legal stretch. If the agreement was made by the POA it’s probably not going to pass the sniff test with the courts. In other words if Granny was in the care home with Dementia it’s unlikely she knew what was going on. I don’t think a court would look kindly on a POA establishing a dependent situation while granny was incapacitated.

Yes, I’ve not hidden the fact that I’m judging the hell out of the OP. And I stand by those judgements. The whole situation was dodgy as hell and the OP is still looking to see what she can get out of granny’s estate.

Fair enough. But we fundamentally disagree.

  1. Presumably the POA was someone that the grandmother knew and trusted
  2. The POA didn't ask the OP to leave before even though they originally agreed to a "short term" only so presume they were happy for her to remain
  3. The OP says she's been paying all the bills
  4. The OP hasn't said there are any complaints about the upkeep of the house so presumably she's been maintaining it
  5. Dogs and animals are recommended because of the help they can provide to a person's mental health
  6. The OP says she has poor mental health and has been unable to work - this could have been something really severe, we have no idea
  7. The OP seems to be trying to get back on her feet - she describes now having a job and being able to work - that's not the actions of a grifter
  8. OP says they won't let her stay even if she pays rent - which suggests this is about not wanting to lose her a familiar place that she sees as home rather than getting more freebies

The grandmother may have been aware that she was living there. Having someone act on your behalf doesn't mean that there's no understanding at all. Again, we just don't know.

The facts and questions that we don't know would fill this page.

If feels like everyone is pissed off because OP didn't have to pay rent for two years and they're outraged for some bizarre reason. OP says care home fees were taken care of, it doesn't sounds like the grandmother needed any more cash so she's not lost out in that way. And as @SheilaFentiman points out, renting the house commercially is a giant ball-ache. Maybe the grandmother/POA just wanted to have a caretaker in the property to keep it ticking over and the bills covered without all the hassle of a commercial let.

I don't understand people sometimes. An individual has said she has mental health problems that have stopped her from working and is now worried about losing her home. Fair enough to encourage her to move on, seek out alternatives, but this personal pile-on is absolutely awful. Especially when none of us have any clue about what's transpired.

redressgirl · 15/01/2023 22:06

yes you’ll have to leave really you should have saved enough money by now

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 21:59

I read OP’s posts very differently to most of you. I think she is looking to understand her position, not to screw her relatives over but to understand the legals. She’s now going to Shelter for advice, which is the best plan.

Whether she “should” have saved or not, she hasn’t, or hasn’t been in a position to do so. She needs to live somewhere and should also be careful to go through whatever steps needed to get any benefits needed. If this needs to formally be eviction, she needs to understand the best way to do this.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/01/2023 21:53

StalkedByASpider · 15/01/2023 21:27

You have no idea of the circumstances and neither do I.

All we know is that the POA granted them permission to live in the property and that the OP has stated she has struggled with her mental health (and has implied that she was unable to work due to her mental health so presumably has been pretty ill).

If a person was financially dependent upon a deceased but they're not included in the Will, it's possible to contest it legally. Whether it's successful depends on the exact circumstances.

I'm not making any judgement on whether the OP deserves to make a claim or not, because we don't know the full facts. I'm simply passing on information about the law. If it's not warranted, her claim won't succeed.

Your tone is extremely judgemental considering the OP has provided very few details and we know precisely fuck all about the circumstances around which she was permitted to live there, her previous relationship with her grandmother or anything else.

We know:

  1. the OP lived rent free for 2 years
  2. the Op claims to have MH problems
  3. the POA agreed to the OP staying for a short time
  4. the OP was not named as a beneficiary
  5. the OP has not saved any money for 2 years
  6. The OP thinks Granny is mean
  7. The OP got a dog
  8. What was the relationship between the OP and POA
  9. The beneficiaries want to sell the house.

You’re right there is a lot we don’t know:

  1. What did the tenancy agreement say
  2. Was Granny aware that the OP was living there and not paying rent
  3. Did the OP take good care of the house
  4. What the OP expected to do long term

As for the OP now claiming she’s a dependent that’s going to be a legal stretch. If the agreement was made by the POA it’s probably not going to pass the sniff test with the courts. In other words if Granny was in the care home with Dementia it’s unlikely she knew what was going on. I don’t think a court would look kindly on a POA establishing a dependent situation while granny was incapacitated.

Yes, I’ve not hidden the fact that I’m judging the hell out of the OP. And I stand by those judgements. The whole situation was dodgy as hell and the OP is still looking to see what she can get out of granny’s estate.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 21:48

StalkedByASpider · 15/01/2023 21:27

You have no idea of the circumstances and neither do I.

All we know is that the POA granted them permission to live in the property and that the OP has stated she has struggled with her mental health (and has implied that she was unable to work due to her mental health so presumably has been pretty ill).

If a person was financially dependent upon a deceased but they're not included in the Will, it's possible to contest it legally. Whether it's successful depends on the exact circumstances.

I'm not making any judgement on whether the OP deserves to make a claim or not, because we don't know the full facts. I'm simply passing on information about the law. If it's not warranted, her claim won't succeed.

Your tone is extremely judgemental considering the OP has provided very few details and we know precisely fuck all about the circumstances around which she was permitted to live there, her previous relationship with her grandmother or anything else.

Well said, @StalkedByASpider

Those who are saying the POA acted improperly in depriving the grandmother of rent… well, possibly. But if a house is being rented out commercially, then it needs to be of minimum standards such as EPCs, fire safety etc. It seems like the POA was elderly too - appointing a rental agency etc may well have been beyond them.

As the POA has died, the OPG would not be able to raise any issues anyway, but I think that, given there was no certainty how long the GM would live when she went into the home, any spending required to bring it up to rental standard, appoint an agency etc could also be considered not in the best financial interest of the GM.

In any event, the actions of the POA are not OP’s responsibility and talk of collusion is really overblown.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 21:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Wetblanket78 · 15/01/2023 21:30

Yes they can you have been living there two years rent free. So had plenty of time to save up for somewhere else. You weren't expecting to live there forever were you if it's they're inheritance?

StalkedByASpider · 15/01/2023 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You have no idea of the circumstances and neither do I.

All we know is that the POA granted them permission to live in the property and that the OP has stated she has struggled with her mental health (and has implied that she was unable to work due to her mental health so presumably has been pretty ill).

If a person was financially dependent upon a deceased but they're not included in the Will, it's possible to contest it legally. Whether it's successful depends on the exact circumstances.

I'm not making any judgement on whether the OP deserves to make a claim or not, because we don't know the full facts. I'm simply passing on information about the law. If it's not warranted, her claim won't succeed.

Your tone is extremely judgemental considering the OP has provided very few details and we know precisely fuck all about the circumstances around which she was permitted to live there, her previous relationship with her grandmother or anything else.

freyamay74 · 15/01/2023 21:24

If the OP has mental health problems the last thing she needs is people advising her to contest the will. All she'd do is stack up enormous bills for herself and it's clearly not going to go in her favour. The house is not hers, it never has been and it now belongs to the beneficiaries.

The best thing the OP can do is accept that for her own mental health she needs to move forward, hopefully the executors will be reasonable in allowing her a few weeks to move out. I can't see it being any good for her health to be given 'advice' that will just land her with a load of costs and a CCJ if she doesn't pay them on time

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:18

@BookishKitten ..I know.

Mn shouldn't allow it.

I've only seen rhe few on the page I posted on.

People don't understand old age! Being alone, having a fall, getting into trouble. The peace of mind ops presence was or if she had dementia she would have still been a huge support.

MILLYmo0se · 15/01/2023 21:17

Leaving aside everything else what does the will actually say about the house and other assets, because the executors have no right or ability to change anything in the will. If it says 'my assets are to be divided between X Y and Z' then everything will be sold, debts and taxes paid off and remainder divided between the inheritors. If assets are left to one person any and all debts with Revenue, Council, funeral, solicitors need to be paid off before settling probate which may necessitate the sale of the home too.
Would you even be able to pay the market value in rent for the property by yourself ifit were the case the estate had been left in its entiety to one person and they didnt need to sell it.
I understand it being difficult to deal with reality having been in a bit of a bubble for the last 2 years, particularly if your mental health is fragile but at this point you have to forget about your current home and focus on where/how you will move onto somewhere new.

Redbone · 15/01/2023 21:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BookishKitten · 15/01/2023 21:15

i cannot believe the amount of hatred in some of these comments. The OP has explained they’ve had mental health problems - which in case some of you don’t know - can be as debilitating as physical health problems. They haven’t been swindling anyone, they have a contract, and paid their utilities, and on top of that they are related to the owner so we don’t know the extent of family ties to comment.
for the love of everything, in online interactions, BE KIND, especially when the other person shares their vulnerabilities as the OP has done here.
OP, you have my sympathy for what you’ve been going through. I do hope you find adequate advice and that you’re able to live with your companion pet in a safe place.

BookishKitten · 15/01/2023 21:10

next time, read all the posts written by the author (check the bottom of the original post and just select see all posts).
this poster has experienced mental health problems, they’ve paid bills and they also have a contract. In online interactions, please be kind, you never know what the other person is going through and it can tip them over the edge. It’s not a question of lacking intelligence or being lazy or entitled, this person clearly has had problems. It can happen to all of us.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/01/2023 21:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:04

I honestly don't know anyone in their right minds would have some random lodger living with a vulnerable elderly person.

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 15/01/2023 21:03

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:00

Op this thread has moved on but I wanted to say how awful some people can be on here. Something awful goes on with money here, it's like a money obsessed pit!
Nothing else matters except money! Eg maybe you were amazing Company for your grandma and boosted her happiness beyond measure for the last year's of her life!
Etc etc

She said upthread her GM was not a nice person.

Moreover, living in a vulnerable person's house rent free for two years when they do not have the mental capacity to consent is financial abuse, plain and simple. The OPG take POAs to court day in day out for this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread