Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to move from relatives house

563 replies

OrangeBlankets · 14/01/2023 09:32

I've been living in a relatives house for more than 2 years. When I moved in the relative was in a care home but the person who had POA for them agreed for me to move in and said it was ok for a short time and that I didn't have to pay rent.

Now the house owner died and so did the POA. The executors want me to move out.

I don't have anywhere to go, can they evict me?

OP posts:
Sausagenbacon · 16/01/2023 07:52

Why do you feel it's ok fo take this judgement upon yourself?
Who made you Head Girl of mumsnet, Harolde? Do you have any special qualifications to allow you to tell us all how mn should be done?

WandaWonder · 16/01/2023 07:14

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 22:41

As you haven't bothered even to read the OP's posts, you won't be aware that she has MH issues and says that she has got a job "now", implying that she didn't have one before. It's not a giant leap to think these 2 things may be connected.

If the OP wasn't working, she would only have been getting a little over £300 a month, barely enough to pay the bills on the house and keep herself.

I suspect that she may not have been in a position to "accumulate" any money, and even if she was, her MH issues may well have meant that she was not in a position to make such rational decisions and plan ahead.

There seem to be an awful lot MNers who have little conception of how MH issues can make it very difficult to make the sort of wise choices that those of us who are blessed with good MH make without really thinking. There's a sizeable empathy vacuum on this thread.

MH issues can explain how someone feels or feels towards a situation but using MH does not give the op more right to live there

And complaining about the people involved

There is only so long people can jusy go 'I have MH so situations should be changed to suit me' people have given good advice if the op doesn't take it then I am not sure what the answer is for the op

HaroldeVwilliam · 16/01/2023 06:49

@saltinesandcoffeecups

I suppose the bottom line is that the ethos of the site, MN is supposed to be helpful.
Are your posts helpful in anyway? How is the op being helped because it feels more like a court of judgement?
Why do you feel it's ok fo take this judgement upon yourself?

HaroldeVwilliam · 16/01/2023 06:39

@LakieLady

Yes I know. That was in response to the poster who said she had deprived the granny of rent as if an elderly lady would have a random lodger

Talia99 · 16/01/2023 04:14

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:18

@BookishKitten ..I know.

Mn shouldn't allow it.

I've only seen rhe few on the page I posted on.

People don't understand old age! Being alone, having a fall, getting into trouble. The peace of mind ops presence was or if she had dementia she would have still been a huge support.

The relative was in a care home. The OP had the house to herself. She wasn’t providing support.

SheilaFentiman · 16/01/2023 00:57

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2023 00:20

In this case the correct fiduciary responsible step would be

A: to sell the house. The money from the sale could then be invested in a safe low risk capital preserving
or
B: Do as you say and incur normal costs of home ownership.

The correct answer isn’t allow someone to live in the house incurring wear and tear. You also can’t assume that two years with the OP living in the house with a dog hasn’t caused more than average wear and tear. To be fair I’m not saying she (or the dog) has caused excess damage.

The expenses you mention would be considered reasonable even if Granny was still living in the home.

Hmmm. IMO, an occupied property with bills paid would outweigh an unoccupied one without, even allowing for “wear and tear”. And holding on to property, given average house price appreciation, is a low risk “investment”.

Anyway, we are off topic and it’s bedtime.

good luck, OP, I hope Shelter can help.

HamBone · 16/01/2023 00:55

Given that the Grandmother is now deceased, her Attorney’s decision to let the OP live in the house is irrelevant now, as the POA dies with the individual. There’s simply no point debating the rights or wrongs of the situation now, especially as the care home fees were covered by the Grandma’s savings.

The estate’s beneficiaries can now decide what to do, as they should. As @kateandme suggested, the OP would be wise to discuss her move amicably with them and request a few months grace to find herself a new home. In return, she’ll keep the house and garden clean and tidy and continue to pay her bills.

Why fall out with your family if you don’t need to? It’ll be much easier if you cooperate with each other.

stevec711 · 16/01/2023 00:46

Depending on where you live, they may have to serve you with a formal eviction notice.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2023 00:20

SheilaFentiman · 16/01/2023 00:04

Suppose that the property had been left empty (on grounds that no one knew when GM would die and so didn’t want to get a fixed term tenant, get EPC certs etc). And the POA has paid baseline utilities and council tax and gardeners and occasional “housekeeper” visits to check on the place from the estate.

There would then be less money in the estate after 2 years than there is now.

Would you consider the POA had been improper in this scenario too?

In this case the correct fiduciary responsible step would be

A: to sell the house. The money from the sale could then be invested in a safe low risk capital preserving
or
B: Do as you say and incur normal costs of home ownership.

The correct answer isn’t allow someone to live in the house incurring wear and tear. You also can’t assume that two years with the OP living in the house with a dog hasn’t caused more than average wear and tear. To be fair I’m not saying she (or the dog) has caused excess damage.

The expenses you mention would be considered reasonable even if Granny was still living in the home.

SheilaFentiman · 16/01/2023 00:04

Suppose that the property had been left empty (on grounds that no one knew when GM would die and so didn’t want to get a fixed term tenant, get EPC certs etc). And the POA has paid baseline utilities and council tax and gardeners and occasional “housekeeper” visits to check on the place from the estate.

There would then be less money in the estate after 2 years than there is now.

Would you consider the POA had been improper in this scenario too?

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 15/01/2023 23:58

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 23:55

It indicates a scenario where a POA might sensibly decide that a relative staying rent free but covering bills and maintenance was more suitable than spending estate money clearing out a house and sorting out commercial tenants.

Yes, where the donor of the POA still lives at home with spells away.

The GM in this scenario lived in a care home. There is absolutely no justification for allowing someone to live rent free for two years in her house.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 23:55

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 15/01/2023 23:52

That's a completely different scenario.

It indicates a scenario where a POA might sensibly decide that a relative staying rent free but covering bills and maintenance was more suitable than spending estate money clearing out a house and sorting out commercial tenants.

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 15/01/2023 23:52

ChungusBoi · 15/01/2023 23:37

As someone who managed a relative’s property in this context, I see utility (and flexibility) in having a relative who isn’t formally a paying tenant living in the elderly person’s home whilst they are away, covering the bills, maintaining it, and making up the spare room for when I travel to see my elderly relative in her care home.

If someone needs their POA to act on their behalf, you should still try to accommodate the person’s wishes if reasonably practicable. Aunt was adamant she wanted to be in her own home when well enough to cope (with carers coming in). Aunt’s medical conditions meant short spells in hospital, longer spells of recovery in a care home, and then home until the next hospitalisation, so I had to keep her own home in good order whilst she was away for when she was ready to occupy it again. Letting her home on a standard tenancy would not have been flexible enough.

To let her house out would also have taken investment greater than aunt’s rapidly dwindling savings, so I would have had to raise the money somehow - equity release against her home? and it would have taken more time than I have available to bring it up to the standard of a professional let. She had 80 years worth of stuff to go into storage for a start! And old bathroom, kitchen, tatty furniture etc, that she refused to change in any way. So those of you saying that the POA should have just let it on a market rent - it’s not always practical or even cost effective.

Hopefully this paints a picture of what can be involved.

That's a completely different scenario.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 23:45

Good post, ChungusBoi

My sibling and I will probably sell my mum’s house when she follows my dad into care, but it isn’t needed for care fees (owing to other finances) and if there was a chance thst a relative could keep the place going and give us more time to sort it out (and the occasional use of a spare room to visit them in the nearby care home), I would definitely think about it!

ChungusBoi · 15/01/2023 23:37

As someone who managed a relative’s property in this context, I see utility (and flexibility) in having a relative who isn’t formally a paying tenant living in the elderly person’s home whilst they are away, covering the bills, maintaining it, and making up the spare room for when I travel to see my elderly relative in her care home.

If someone needs their POA to act on their behalf, you should still try to accommodate the person’s wishes if reasonably practicable. Aunt was adamant she wanted to be in her own home when well enough to cope (with carers coming in). Aunt’s medical conditions meant short spells in hospital, longer spells of recovery in a care home, and then home until the next hospitalisation, so I had to keep her own home in good order whilst she was away for when she was ready to occupy it again. Letting her home on a standard tenancy would not have been flexible enough.

To let her house out would also have taken investment greater than aunt’s rapidly dwindling savings, so I would have had to raise the money somehow - equity release against her home? and it would have taken more time than I have available to bring it up to the standard of a professional let. She had 80 years worth of stuff to go into storage for a start! And old bathroom, kitchen, tatty furniture etc, that she refused to change in any way. So those of you saying that the POA should have just let it on a market rent - it’s not always practical or even cost effective.

Hopefully this paints a picture of what can be involved.

ChellyT · 15/01/2023 23:27

OrangeBlankets · 14/01/2023 09:32

I've been living in a relatives house for more than 2 years. When I moved in the relative was in a care home but the person who had POA for them agreed for me to move in and said it was ok for a short time and that I didn't have to pay rent.

Now the house owner died and so did the POA. The executors want me to move out.

I don't have anywhere to go, can they evict me?

So much to unpack here...

I'm curious to how long is a short time in your books? 2 years is well past a short time in my books.

Yes you need to make other arrangements for lodgings.

Yes YABU to think after two deaths that your arrangements to stay will be ok.

I'm assuming the executors want to move on, sell the property or even get a decent income from it but can not with you being there.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 22:51

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:04

I honestly don't know anyone in their right minds would have some random lodger living with a vulnerable elderly person.

The OP is not "some random lodger", she's the late owner's granddaughter!

EL8888 · 15/01/2023 22:47

Whadda · 15/01/2023 22:44

I think this may be one of the most entitled threads I’ve ever seen on here.

OP, living somewhere rent-free for two years is a massive privilege. It’s a shame that you don’t see it for the gift it was, rather than take umbrage now that the house is no longer available for you.

@Whadda same. They’ve got my CF of this year so far. I would even go as far as to wonder if it’s a wind up or a reverse. Is anyone this entitled and thick skinned?!

CPL593H · 15/01/2023 22:45

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:00

Op this thread has moved on but I wanted to say how awful some people can be on here. Something awful goes on with money here, it's like a money obsessed pit!
Nothing else matters except money! Eg maybe you were amazing Company for your grandma and boosted her happiness beyond measure for the last year's of her life!
Etc etc

I don't think this had anything to do with the grandmother (who the OP appears not to have liked) and everything to do with a really dodgy action by the POA, who I think did deprive the grandmother of assetss.

That is done, but as I said earlier in the thread @OrangeBlankets needs to concentrate on finding a new home because she will not be able to stay there.

Whadda · 15/01/2023 22:44

I think this may be one of the most entitled threads I’ve ever seen on here.

OP, living somewhere rent-free for two years is a massive privilege. It’s a shame that you don’t see it for the gift it was, rather than take umbrage now that the house is no longer available for you.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 22:41

C1N1C · 15/01/2023 20:48

I'm not reading 400 posts but based on what I have... surely a smart person would have used this time to accumulate some money for when this situation happens???

As you haven't bothered even to read the OP's posts, you won't be aware that she has MH issues and says that she has got a job "now", implying that she didn't have one before. It's not a giant leap to think these 2 things may be connected.

If the OP wasn't working, she would only have been getting a little over £300 a month, barely enough to pay the bills on the house and keep herself.

I suspect that she may not have been in a position to "accumulate" any money, and even if she was, her MH issues may well have meant that she was not in a position to make such rational decisions and plan ahead.

There seem to be an awful lot MNers who have little conception of how MH issues can make it very difficult to make the sort of wise choices that those of us who are blessed with good MH make without really thinking. There's a sizeable empathy vacuum on this thread.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 22:39

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/01/2023 22:16

@StalkedByASpider Agree on the disagreement. I just can’t imagine the OP not painting herself in the best light possible here so the silence on many of the knowns and unknowns is very telling to me.

At the end of the day though I believe in the universe balancing out so if she took advantage of Granny, then she’s got to live with that. If she didn’t then she has a clear conscience and none of the posts calling her out will make a bit of difference as she will know she’s done nothing wrong.

There have been 500 posts on this thread in about 36 hours. OP has posted 10 times, only two of which were today. I don’t think her silence is “telling” - there’s a barrage of repetitive criticism on here so I hope she has popped on, skimmed off useful advice and logged off to protect herself. Unsurprising, given everything she is going through with house worries etc.

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 22:34

SpaceshiptoMars · 15/01/2023 22:24

@OrangeBlankets If the POA was a relative of yours and an executor, they may have been a beneficiary of GMs will. Perhaps you should ask to look at the clause in GM's will about what would happen to the POA's share if they predeceased her.

I suspect it would go to his children (who are probably the OP’s aunts and uncles)

SheilaFentiman · 15/01/2023 22:33

Actually, I don’t know what the situation would have been if OP had paid rent - the POA might have been obliged to have “landlord standards” for the property even though she was a relative. (I’m guessing the POA was the GM’s brother)

Siepie · 15/01/2023 22:30

HaroldeVwilliam · 15/01/2023 21:18

@BookishKitten ..I know.

Mn shouldn't allow it.

I've only seen rhe few on the page I posted on.

People don't understand old age! Being alone, having a fall, getting into trouble. The peace of mind ops presence was or if she had dementia she would have still been a huge support.

The grandmother was in a care home. The OP wasn't living with her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread