Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To try and get my awful colleague sacked

235 replies

WhenHarryMetSandro · 14/01/2023 08:21

Some background is that I returned from maternity leave in October and my reduced days (went to 4 days) meant that my maternity cover has remained in the business in a slightly senior role to accommodate my reduced hours and so she has retained some of the admin parts of my role. She was part of the team and was given the ML cover in what I believe was an error of judgement from management. She got it after the person given it went on long term sick leave a week after I left. She was hated at the time by the team. She now has no line management responsibilities and I think misses the control.

She is still hated by the team. She is a micromanager, rude, disrespectful and generally, a jobs worth that tells on people like the teachers pet at school. She isn’t well liked around the rest of the business and people often comment on their displeasure of interacting with her. She will do things to make things harder for my team who are all great, hard working and lovely people. I cannot understand why! They really tolerate her BS most of the time. She will get involved in things that don’t fall under her job just to be a cow and ruin something for someone else. She usually gets nothing but support but she is pushing people to the point of leaving and getting sick of it.

Two of my team left during my ML time because they couldn’t stand her as their manager.

Things she has done recently that makes me think she is an arsehole are as follows :

sent round the company policy about not using the company printers for colour when a team member (worked at the company 10 years, always lovely person) printed out 5 sheets of A4 paper in colour for a charity function as her own printer had shut down whilst printing those last 5 pages. I had given the ok to do this. She knew this and still complained about it.

tells tales to me if my team are 2 minutes late getting to work. I don’t want this level of observation. it’s weird and unneeded.

insists on working in freezing cold temperatures and often sets this to her preference despite it being uncomfortable for the rest of the team who sit in hats and gloves to accommodate

has thrown away birthday cakes brought in by the team members if they’ve haven’t accommodated for her specific tastes (not allergies, just cake preferences)

I have made some adjustments to work shifts to create better work life balance for the team which has been well received by the team and she has painstakingly reviewed our company policy and flagged why I can’t or shouldn’t have done this despite knowing the team really would benefit. it’s a grey area and at managers discretion as long as it benefits the team with no detriment to the business. which it doesn’t.

Checks up on my own work and that of others. We are all very capable, intelligent people and she takes great pleasure in pointing out of anything looks out of the ordinary which normally back fires as there is a reason for it. It’s just embarrassing that my team or I feel we then need to explain or justify to her (we don’t)

AIBU to think that getting this person out of business is the only reasonable thing to do. Any advice? I’m half joking really. I appreciate times are hard at the moment so don’t like the idea of someone losing their job but she is just awful. How do you deal with people like this? She has been at the company 5 years now and has been awful the entire time. Makes most of us dread working and each interaction leaves a sour taste for days. Always the busiest person, always the person who doesn’t need to muck in. Always a tell tale. Always got an eye over her shoulder despite us being a really nice and supportive team. I mean, aside from this post but it’s past the point of thinking she will see the light.

OP posts:
freyamay74 · 14/01/2023 10:53

OP what are you expecting this person's current manager to do that you couldn't do yourself?

keepcalm11 · 14/01/2023 10:51

She sounds awful. Can you go to your line manager and ask for advice what to do, or HR?
There was a sitauion like this at my workplace and myself and other colleagues collected evidence that ended with the person being dismissed. I thoiught I would feel bad about it (and part of me still does a bit) but the MH of the team was suffereing and the customers were as well. It was unpleasant but had to be done.

VyeBrator · 14/01/2023 10:48

This is very unprofessional, putting such specific details on a public forum, could give her the ammunition to take a grievance out against you if she stumbles across this thread, or someone points it out to her.

There's just no need for it. You know if this woman is such a problem you need to take the correct course of action.

WhenHarryMetSandro · 14/01/2023 10:42

Bookkeys · 14/01/2023 10:34

It was probably a few days later and the cake was stale

It was 45 minutes. It was home made that someone had made especially as it was the birthday persons favourite (they are friends outside of work). The PITA person doesn’t like the friendship and so I believe was being vindictive. Initially she denied it and called it an accident, then she had she thought it was old cake, then she said it was clogging up the shared kitchen and the smell was upsetting her as she doesn’t like chocolate and it was closest to her desk. She was talked to by her manager about it.

OP posts:
IMustDoMoreExercise · 14/01/2023 10:39

WhenHarryMetSandro · 14/01/2023 08:31

Open to feedback on this, what makes me not sound great exactly? For wanting a respectful and relaxed workplace for my team?

You don't sound bad at all. Ignore the haters on here, they can't help themselves.

Yes, I would try and get rid of her. She is ruining the whole company and people will leave because of her.

It will be difficult to do though. Can you speak to HR about your concerns?

WeAreTheHeroes · 14/01/2023 10:39

Sakura7 · 14/01/2023 10:30

You think it's easy to manage this kind of behaviour out of someone?

People like this rarely change. OP was well within her rights to make the request she did, and clearly the company didn't consider it unreasonable.

Managing the behaviour out of someone?? If it's such a problem and the person doesn't modify their behaviour, you manage the person out of the business. Any business that has the money and good legal advice can legally remove someone they don't want to keep. The fact this woman has been there 5 years suggests her actual work is fine she just has a different personality and take on things.

Nogbreaks · 14/01/2023 10:39

I would start managing her out.

WhenHarryMetSandro · 14/01/2023 10:35

WeAreTheHeroes · 14/01/2023 10:20

I've read all.your posts OP. She thinks very highly of you too. If she's been there for 5 years and is as bad as you say then it's management failure that she hasn't been managed out. It comes across that you think you are a superior manager and you are mates with your team, which isn't always a good thing.

I’m not mates with my team. I am a courteous and thoughtful manager of people, adults who can and do a brilliant job. They don’t need me to hit the roof if they were running late due to daycare drop off or traffic. I treat people how I’d like to be treated, with a bit of respect and dignity. It’s a workplace, not a prison camp. I am not there to make their days worse. I don’t socialise outside of work, I don’t talk badly about this colleague (or any colleague) and keep it friendly but professional as I think you should as a LM. I’ve posted on MN in a way I obviously wouldn’t discuss with my team.

Reasons she hasn’t been sacked are that I tried to pull it back, thought we could try something new and see if it helped. I made cases for her and worked with her. It helped for a few weeks or months but it would all start again once her fear of the sack would wear off.

OP posts:
LIZS · 14/01/2023 10:34

While you perceive her as mean she may perceive you as overly lax. You may not have the authority to agree terms such as shifts and personal printing and such may have come to light during your ml. You want to be your team's friend not their manager. Did they resent that she was not such a walkover, hence why some left even though they knew it was short term.

Bookkeys · 14/01/2023 10:34

SallyCinnamon12 · 14/01/2023 09:42

I really want to know if anyone pulled her up on Cakegate, and if so, what did she say?

Surely to god she didn’t just tip a whole birthday cake into the bin with no one asking her what she was doing..?

It was probably a few days later and the cake was stale

Chiconbelge · 14/01/2023 10:34

So you are a manager yourself but she doesn’t report to you because this was stipulated on your return? Who stipulated this and what was their reasoning? She has been allocated work that was previously part of your role - can someone within your team do it instead? Sounds like a crazy idea to take some of the work out of the team when it still affects them - it’s only thought to be 1 day a week of your role as it was previously. You need to start thinking and talking like a manager not like someone without any management responsibility or power yourself.

DirectionToPerfection · 14/01/2023 10:33

cocktailclub · 14/01/2023 10:31

It's not either fair or likely to happen to sack someone who adheres to company policy.
You managed her previously and have not addressed her behaviour.
It sounds personal and not as if she is breaking any rules (although you are)
If you can't work with her then you need to leave

Bullying would be very much against company policy, so no, she's not adhering to it.

Bookkeys · 14/01/2023 10:33

IVFbeenverylucky · 14/01/2023 09:16

All the stuff on ND: It can't be used as a defence every time someone criticises someone at work or in their personal life for being difficult or unreasonable.
It's also a silly term - totally meaningless. If you mean Aspergers' syndrome, then say so. If you mean something else, say that too.

FWIW I'm dyslexic, but I'm not ND. I think it's daft and offensive. My brother has severe disabilities, including autism, but he's not ND. He's not on the ASD. He's severely disabled.

@Soontobe60 If your DH "has" to comment on people breaking rules (like being 2 minutes like ffs), then just tell him it's a rule to not comment. Which it sort of is anyway. A social rule.

I agree

So many people these days declaring themselves as ND because they've read a few traits on Google that relate to them

TheOinkySplit · 14/01/2023 10:32

Is there no way you could try and solve this without her being sacked?

cocktailclub · 14/01/2023 10:31

It's not either fair or likely to happen to sack someone who adheres to company policy.
You managed her previously and have not addressed her behaviour.
It sounds personal and not as if she is breaking any rules (although you are)
If you can't work with her then you need to leave

Sakura7 · 14/01/2023 10:30

freyamay74 · 14/01/2023 10:25

@WeAreTheHeroes the OP used to manage this woman, but made it a condition of her return from ML that this woman wouldn't report to her any more!

She bottled out of managing her effectively but is now sniping from the sidelines.

Seeing as this woman has supposedly almost been sacked multiple times before, why wasn't she sacked while on the OP's watch?

This is sounding more and more like the OP is a weak manager and is more comfortable bitching from the sidelines than actually having the balls to deal with the situation head on

You think it's easy to manage this kind of behaviour out of someone?

People like this rarely change. OP was well within her rights to make the request she did, and clearly the company didn't consider it unreasonable.

OngoingCrisis · 14/01/2023 10:30

OP: someone is creating an uneasy working environment

Replies: BIRTHDAY CAKE???!!!¿¿¿

DanceCapital · 14/01/2023 10:29

They sound awful but nothing you have mentioned warrants dismissal. Except throwing away cake, I don’t care who you are, if I bring in cake no one is throwing it away apart from me.

freyamay74 · 14/01/2023 10:25

@WeAreTheHeroes the OP used to manage this woman, but made it a condition of her return from ML that this woman wouldn't report to her any more!

She bottled out of managing her effectively but is now sniping from the sidelines.

Seeing as this woman has supposedly almost been sacked multiple times before, why wasn't she sacked while on the OP's watch?

This is sounding more and more like the OP is a weak manager and is more comfortable bitching from the sidelines than actually having the balls to deal with the situation head on

Vinvertebrate · 14/01/2023 10:25

You sound unprofessional. I’d like to hear her side of it tbh.

Allergictoironing · 14/01/2023 10:25

Totally with you @WhenHarryMetSandro , and have worked with this type of person in the past. Hard to get them out, because they stop JUST short of it being a sack-able offence after 2 years in the job. And it isn't the seriousness of the (usually petty) individual things they do, it's the cumulative effect of it all going on relentlessly.

To the pp who seemed to think ND just means ASD - it means anyone who's brain works differently from the typical hence NeuroDIVERSE e.g. ASD (which is the current term for autism), ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia etc. Still no excuse for interfering with a team that the person doesn't manage, or being a PITA.

The suggestion that the team get together and "discuss" this with the person would be a bullying charge just waiting to happen, same with some of the other suggestions about talking it over with the person bearing in mind the OP is no longer her line manager.

There are many comments on this thread that seem to pick up on single incidents and to justify those situations, but a) if you don't work in the exact same environment as the OP then you can't possibly know what is/isn't acceptable there, b) it is not this person's place to enforce rules (e.g. the cake thing, if there really is a rule), c) the OP has made it clear that these are just examples, and the most minor ones at that to reduce the chances of identification and d) unless you've worked with someone like this, you can't imagine just how awful it can make your working day.

I can also see why the OP made it a condition of her return to not have to manage this person. Even the very best manager in the world can't turn round somebody who doesn't care, or is determined that they are right despite being the only one who thinks so. If the OP wasn't a valued manager, then HR/senior management wouldn't have accepted this demand in the first place.

It's just so very tiring to have to deal with this day in day out - been there, got the t-shirt, was a factor in me quitting one job. The only thing you can really do in this kind of situation is to have a long chat with your own line manager or even the next level up, ensuring that you bring evidence of all the cases of over-stepping and inappropriate behaviour and not just a sample like above - maybe keep a diary? You could possibly push for them to be moved into a different area, where not only will they not impact on your team but if they continue behaving like this in the new role then there will be justification for your complaints.

I wish you luck OP, it's a horrible situation to be in. Keep pushing back on her comments (I manage my team MY way), and keep that diary!

DirectionToPerfection · 14/01/2023 10:24

There's a lot of gaslighting towards OP on this thread.

Apparently it's ok for this person to be horrible to her and her colleagues, but the minute OP expresses any (completely understandable) negative reaction to this, she's accused of being a bully.

Honestly, can you hear yourselves?

LosCinco · 14/01/2023 10:23

MaverickGooseGoose · 14/01/2023 08:45

You come across as a child. Your examples are all petty. Time to look for something else.

The problem with petty is that it is much harder to deal with and just as soul destroying trying to work with than someone who is openly doing major things.

If you complain you look like you're being petty and for each individual thing they can come back with "oh, sorry an accident" or "it came across wrong" or "I only thought that..."

But it's the amount of stuff that gets you on edge waiting for the next petty behaviour even if you ignore it on the face of it.

I've worked with that situation. Things like finding your mouse unplugged after you've been to the toilet. They're the only other one in the room. You spend 5 minutes trying to find out what's wrong before you plug it back in. Small issue really. You can't really complain because it makes you look petty, and you know they'll either deny it or say something like "oh something was making a funny noise, so I pulled it out to see if it was that, and I thought I'd put it back."
But you know it's personal because it's all things round you that's happening, and you're on edge waiting for the next thing.
Or drawing pins on your chair, chewing gum under the desk, the project you've just printed out to hand to the manager having 2 pages removed from the middle etc. It's all really petty and silly, and each individual issue could have an innocent explanation if it was just a one off.

You also know that if someone does call them out then they'll play the misunderstood and trying to be terribly helpful victim.

Meowandthen · 14/01/2023 10:23

Some of you are miserable killjoys. Never heard of a birthday cake and a few minutes of fun in an office? I call BS.

Hadtochangeforthisone · 14/01/2023 10:22

You do know OP, that posters hang around AIBU just to disparage the OP no matter how reasonable their post.
I guess there are a lot of unhappy people on these boards who get a little ego kick to put someone else down. ? Sad I know. Especially as I thought MN was meant to be a supportive forum.

Anyway OP, I will take your post at face value. Without imagining ulterior motive or projecting another narrative.

You colleague sounds a complete PITA.. If nothing else the fact that two staff members left whilst she was managing told me a lot. However, the fault lies with senior management and that is who you need to speak to.
You also need to make sure you don't let things go as 'minor' . (She obviously doesn't) and therefore need to look at the grievance procedures and follow them to the letter..

Swipe left for the next trending thread