Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have DH's location visible at all times?

582 replies

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 07:44

This should really be AWBU because it's the same for both of us. We've had location sharing on between us 24/7 for a couple of years now. I can always see where DH is and vice versa. It's hugely helpful and we turned it on for very practical reasons. No more messaging each other where are you, having to explain that we're stuck in traffic, worrying about each other if we're running late etc. It's certainly not to 'check up on each other', there has never been a hint of suspicion of infidelity in the relationship and we both trust each other fully. Days go by without me checking his location, but it's very handy to have there when we need it.

We're both happy with the arrangement, but I said to a friend the other day that I'd just quickly check whether DH was home yet and looked at my phone, and she reacted like what I was doing was really awful. She was gobsmacked and sort of acted like it was a controlling/abusive thing (despite it being both ways). I've mentioned it to several friends since and I've had very mixed reactions. Some couples do the same, some thought it was very odd.

AWBU? Is this a weird invasion of each other's privacy?

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 14/01/2023 08:33

I don't see why it's useful for meal planning. I just get the meal ready and everybody who is there eats it and anyone who is not repeats it when they get in. I'm not going to faff around with checking locations and changing meal times as a result.

In terms of why I don't like it, it's not that I'm not trustworthy(!), I just am in my mind a free and independent person and I would feel horrible tethered by someone like this. I'm not joined at the hip to anyone and never will be.
If I wanted to see where my DC are (they're older now so we only do this when arranging pickups from random places) they just share their location on Google maps.

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 08:33

JonSnowsCupbearer · 14/01/2023 08:21

What was his plan re the kids? Stuck in a work meeting wouldn't cut it at nurseries/schools I know!

Sorry, to the point of the thread. I think the fact this is becoming the norm is very dangerous to society. My children's generation have so much more to deal with than I did due to technology such as this, and social media., I would think about what you are demonstrating is acceptable to your children, as imo being able to know where someone else is at any time is not.

When my kids were at nursery and I was collecting them I would be occasionally late due to being caught up before leaving work or traffic etc.
We could then both keep an eye on the situation and then my wife might go and get them. Happened the other way too.

as for the nursery, ours was private and for the very rare occasions we were a few minutes they had to just fucking lump it. We paid nurseries about £100k in total across both kids.

SunsetBlue · 14/01/2023 08:33

CraneBoysMysteries · 14/01/2023 08:08

We do this too and it works for us both. We never text 'why are you at...?' Etc But purely practical.

Yesterday DH was due to pick the kids up from nursery. I checked to see if he left work at 5, he hadn't. I'm a little closer so decided to get them and let him know. He'd got stuck it a work meeting and wouldn't have been able to text me but I could see he wouldn't make it on time so got them myself. No hassle, no arguments, just simple

We also have alerts for one another when we're within 0.5 miles of home it pings the other person. They'll stick the kettle on and be at the door to help unload kids and bags etc.

Works for us!

But it doesn't work for you all... it works for your DH!

I cannot imagine a life where my DH was due to collect the kids but I was the one checking HIS whereabouts to make sure he was on time. And then realising I'd have to do it because he wasn't where he should be.

In your scenario what's happening is you have ALL the responsibility and he literally has none. He doesn't even have to try and make alternative arrangements. What if you had plans, work or a commitment you couldn't get out of? It's 100% your DH's responsibility to say 'I have school pick up' or 'I just need to make a quick call to rearrange my childcare'.

This has made my head spin!

SallyWD · 14/01/2023 08:32

If you're both happy then I think it's fine. I personally wouldn't like it and wouldn't do it. Not sure why. I have nothing to hide and live a boring life! I go to the shops, to work, to see friends etc. DH always knows where I am. However, I'd just hate to have my every movement tracked. There's something scarily big brother about it. I also wouldn't want to track my DH.

namechange1487 · 14/01/2023 08:32

CraneBoysMysteries · 14/01/2023 08:08

We do this too and it works for us both. We never text 'why are you at...?' Etc But purely practical.

Yesterday DH was due to pick the kids up from nursery. I checked to see if he left work at 5, he hadn't. I'm a little closer so decided to get them and let him know. He'd got stuck it a work meeting and wouldn't have been able to text me but I could see he wouldn't make it on time so got them myself. No hassle, no arguments, just simple

We also have alerts for one another when we're within 0.5 miles of home it pings the other person. They'll stick the kettle on and be at the door to help unload kids and bags etc.

Works for us!

Very much like us. Just such a practical tool to organise stuff and keep day to day tasks managed better.

theDudesmummy · 14/01/2023 08:32

We have this, no problem. Its mainly for me, as he is building a house (ours) and therefore often not able to actually answer the phone if he is up a ladder, carrying wood etc etc. And I like to know if he is there so if I have a break or am driving past I can pop over to see how he is doing, take him coffee etc. I don't know if he ever looks at my location...

NewUserName2023 · 14/01/2023 08:31

It comes down to consent. If you both agree to be tracked then no problem. However for anyone over 18 if someone is tracking you via your phone without your consent then no!

I have friend who tracks their DC at Uni and the DC would be furious if they discovered!

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 08:31

Do I want my kids new boyfriend or girlfriend controlling their movements? No. How are they supposed to stand up for themselves if their parents have normalised tracking them.

Same with lots of modern things, by parents modelling using it in a healthy way. My DC have never heard DH and me have a conversation of the “why weren’t you where you said you’d be” type, because there’s no need. They’ve seen it used like “okay Daddy’s/Mummy’s going to be a while yet, you two get on and eat your tea” or when they are bouncing up and down in front of me going “Is Grandma nearly here yet?? Look on your phone and see!”

GalwayShawl · 14/01/2023 08:31

I find it really reassuring. We live rurally and also rely on the M6 which is always suffering from something.

The only time o came unstuck was when I was busted at McDonald’s on the M6 when he’d actually made a lovely dinner - oopsy

JonSnowsCupbearer · 14/01/2023 08:31

Choconut · 14/01/2023 08:16

I think it's because you have such a good relationship that this works for you.

I find that people on MN (and from your experience in RL too it seems) often seem to have a problem with openness and transparency, they don't want their OH asking anything about their past, not even something as innocent as their first kiss, they don't want locations turned on because it must mean they're being checked up on, they don't want their OH using their phone or knowing their password and they definitely don't want their DH opening their mail (and they would not dream of opening their DH's as it would be a gross invasion of privacy even if he was absolutely fine with it).

Tracking is not part of an open and transparent relationship, and I don't not have a close relationship because I fundamentally disagree with it.

This is such a dangerous view. Just think about how vulnerable people can be controlled because of your narrative.

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 08:30

liveforsummer · 14/01/2023 08:26

I don't really see how that works out. You see them stationary on a road somewhere - how do you know if they are stuck in traffic or in a ditch for example. You'd still need the message surely?

I assume he's in traffic not stuck in a ditch. If I happened to see he was in the same spot 15 mins later I'd probably call him... that's never happened.

OP posts:
Seaweasel · 14/01/2023 08:30

I wonder if it's generational. I'm late 40s and DH late 50s, DCs in their early 20s. I remember the tracking apps being introduced and asking DS, (who would have been in his teens, I guess) if he would feel safer if we had it and he laughed and said something along the lines of 'mind your own business'. Both had been travelling to school alone by train since 11 with no issues. It's not my business what DH does before or after work, nor if the kids wanted to go for a walk somewhere after school. If they're late home and there's a problem, I'll find out soon enough. However, I was young and so were my kids during a time when there were bus and train conductors, people always around to help. It would seem that these services are being eroded so perhaps it is inevitable that there is less trust in society and more responsibility on the individual.

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 08:27

My wife and I turned our’s on on our iPhones years ago when we were away somewhere and have never turned it off.

it’s never been used for evil by either of us.

Sometimes if she is out with the kids I will have a look and see if they are on their way home or not to see how much peace I have left and when she is on her way home from the airport for a work trip I will see how close she is so I can have a cup of tea ready for her coming in the door.

PanettoneMoly · 14/01/2023 08:27

I have DH, my dad and 4 friends on Find My Friends 🤷🏻‍♀️ I like to use it occasionally to tell DH gleefully that he’s got the wrong train home again. If that makes me weird, controlling and dysfunction, I’m totally down with that. Sorry not sorry.

liveforsummer · 14/01/2023 08:26

I don't really see how that works out. You see them stationary on a road somewhere - how do you know if they are stuck in traffic or in a ditch for example. You'd still need the message surely?

ArcticSkewer · 14/01/2023 08:25

It's not a message I want my children to have. I want them to feel entitled to their privacy and not to be monitored 24/7.

Individual actions have effects beyond the individual. As 24/7 tracking becomes normalised, its use will spread.

Do I want my kids new boyfriend or girlfriend controlling their movements? No. How are they supposed to stand up for themselves if their parents have normalised tracking them.

Some people need to deal with their anxieties which are causing controlling behaviours. Others need to revisit what boundaries look like. There are a lot of people using these features in unhealthy ways

WandaWonder · 14/01/2023 08:25

WednesdaysPlaits · 14/01/2023 08:21

Our whole family has it on. It’s extremely helpful when you’re trying to plan meals, make sure nobody has forgotten school/club pick ups, want to see if it would be a pain to ask someone to pop by the shop for bread etc.

Nobody has anything to hide so why would it be an issue?

It doesn't need to be an issue I just don't need to track people

I don't understand why it is so hard to understand without some big saga back story to why people don't track

I don't use tiktok either same I don't track there is lots of things I don't do there is no issues I just don't do them

Maray1967 · 14/01/2023 08:25

WhatsErFace2020 · 14/01/2023 07:58

I have both kids (teens) and DH and they each can track me. It’s checked to see when people are coming home/still at work/events etc. For the teens it’s so so handy, they take forever to respond sometimes and I just want to know they’re safe.

having said this I’m glad this wasn’t available when I was a teen - my parents would have found out I was in a field rather than having a sleepover 🤣😂

This took me back to being 16. I would have been in exactly the same situation!! With my now DH…

We all have this on, but we don’t use it - we text. We just have it in case we lose the phone … or I suppose in an emergency if we can’t contact someone.
I can see how it could be seen as controlling. Everything depends on the nature of the relationship. If my DH ever used to comment on where I’d been, I’d switch it off.

Pl242 · 14/01/2023 08:24

DH and I share location. Completely practical. Started I think when we had our first child. Useful to check how someone’s commute is going. It works when signal would be out for texting. If one of us was out with baby easy to see without other having to text back the answer whilst wrangling a child. Don’t in anyway use it constantly. Can see why people wouldn’t want to. That’s fine. It isn’t and shouldn’t be compulsory! But we find it useful.

chali7 · 14/01/2023 08:23

I work in various locations all through the week and do alot of driving. While I'm out and about, I always send my OH my location. For me, it means he can check how close to home I am, whether I made it there safely, and whether I'm on my way home etc without needing to ask. It also means that if something was to happen (as I work alone) someone would have a rough idea of where I am which makes me feel a bit of relief.

On the flip side i dont have OH's location but he works much more locally and I don't really need to know where he is. If I did though, it would be an easy way of knowing. If you're both happy with it and it works for you, it's great.

rainbowandglitter · 14/01/2023 08:23

I see that the Life360 app has been down for a while, all the comments on Twitter from angry people amazes me .

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 08:23

the excuse that you know when to put the tea on is bizarre.. are people expecting to be served a plate of food or a hot cup the minute they walk through the door?

Well this is probably quite specific to me, but it’s handy to know if DH will be home in time for the DCs’ dinner or if he and I will eat separately later.

It’s not essential, it’s just one of those mildly helpful things that can make life a bit smoother/easier.

Also to a PP saying they would address the anxiety, I have spent 20+ years with my mother worrying about whether I’ve arrived safely from every car journey I’ve ever been on. We lost a family member to a car accident when he was a teenager. I’d rather just give her the easy reassurance tbh.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/01/2023 08:23

We do this too with Life 360. Its really useful and doesn't bother me in the slightest.

WednesdaysPlaits · 14/01/2023 08:21

Our whole family has it on. It’s extremely helpful when you’re trying to plan meals, make sure nobody has forgotten school/club pick ups, want to see if it would be a pain to ask someone to pop by the shop for bread etc.

Nobody has anything to hide so why would it be an issue?

JonSnowsCupbearer · 14/01/2023 08:21

CraneBoysMysteries · 14/01/2023 08:08

We do this too and it works for us both. We never text 'why are you at...?' Etc But purely practical.

Yesterday DH was due to pick the kids up from nursery. I checked to see if he left work at 5, he hadn't. I'm a little closer so decided to get them and let him know. He'd got stuck it a work meeting and wouldn't have been able to text me but I could see he wouldn't make it on time so got them myself. No hassle, no arguments, just simple

We also have alerts for one another when we're within 0.5 miles of home it pings the other person. They'll stick the kettle on and be at the door to help unload kids and bags etc.

Works for us!

What was his plan re the kids? Stuck in a work meeting wouldn't cut it at nurseries/schools I know!

Sorry, to the point of the thread. I think the fact this is becoming the norm is very dangerous to society. My children's generation have so much more to deal with than I did due to technology such as this, and social media., I would think about what you are demonstrating is acceptable to your children, as imo being able to know where someone else is at any time is not.