Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have DH's location visible at all times?

582 replies

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 07:44

This should really be AWBU because it's the same for both of us. We've had location sharing on between us 24/7 for a couple of years now. I can always see where DH is and vice versa. It's hugely helpful and we turned it on for very practical reasons. No more messaging each other where are you, having to explain that we're stuck in traffic, worrying about each other if we're running late etc. It's certainly not to 'check up on each other', there has never been a hint of suspicion of infidelity in the relationship and we both trust each other fully. Days go by without me checking his location, but it's very handy to have there when we need it.

We're both happy with the arrangement, but I said to a friend the other day that I'd just quickly check whether DH was home yet and looked at my phone, and she reacted like what I was doing was really awful. She was gobsmacked and sort of acted like it was a controlling/abusive thing (despite it being both ways). I've mentioned it to several friends since and I've had very mixed reactions. Some couples do the same, some thought it was very odd.

AWBU? Is this a weird invasion of each other's privacy?

OP posts:
CaptainMerica · 14/01/2023 09:21

We do this. I get why other people might find it odd, but personally, I would hate getting calls and texts asking where I am every day.

My drive home takes an hour, and I wouldn't call from the car if I was driving. DH might not even answer, if he was working. This way, if he wants to know where I am he can just check, and vice versa.

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:20

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:15

It just does. I’m not going to text while I’m driving or sent repeated texts giving constant updates or constant phone calls. We can simply see where we each other is if we are delayed or whatever.

We use it occasionally by the consent of both parties.

it’s a consensual exchange of information. Why does it matter to you whether it’s a text or the FindMyIphone app?

Agree. Most of the time I don’t need to know where DH is, so texts every time he’s running a bit late or whatever would be redundant. On the occasion that I do want to know, I can then find out instantly, rather than waiting for a text.

Some couples probably text a lot more than we do and that’s fine too. This is just an alternative which some people find useful.

Cuddlywuddlies · 14/01/2023 09:20

I would find this very suffocating to be honest. If you weren’t home then why did you feel the need to check if he was?

Deathbyfluffy · 14/01/2023 09:20

I genuinely don’t understand why some people have a problem with it unless they’re doing something they shouldn’t be or have a controlling partner.

My wife and I have it, and while we barely use it it’s so handy when we do need it (if I’m giving her a lift, meeting her in public etc)

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:20

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:15

It just does. I’m not going to text while I’m driving or sent repeated texts giving constant updates or constant phone calls. We can simply see where we each other is if we are delayed or whatever.

We use it occasionally by the consent of both parties.

it’s a consensual exchange of information. Why does it matter to you whether it’s a text or the FindMyIphone app?

Constant? How many updates do you need in the course of one journey? But I see now, it's another mechanism that makes things easier for you, but adds another task to DW's list.

Quincythequince · 14/01/2023 09:19

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:16

How do they say no… The same way they say no to anything else which isn’t appropriate unless you really trust the person. Sharing finances, or moving in together, all the things we do that require trust.

Behaviour that has been normalised to children their whole life at home, is not easy to say not to.

Stop being so disingenuous.

And if like so many on here so, think it’s perfectly fine and there should be nonissue with it, how would that be received?! Probably not very well I imagine.

To all those who track and are tracked, what would your or your DP do if you suddenly decided it wasn’t for you anymore?

pattihews · 14/01/2023 09:19

It is not normal to expect that somebody should be able to know where you are at all times.
It is dysfunctional behaviour to expect to have this level of intrusion into somebody else’s life by way of knowing where they are at all times.
It also normalises this in our younger generations. How do they say no to a bf or GF wanting to track them?

This with bells on. And we wonder why so many of the younger generation are so anxious and dependent. 30 years ago young people disappeared for months at a time on their travels and learned to cope with life on their own, with only an occasional call or letter home. And parents lived with it and learned to let go and the children returned with life skills and ready to live independently.

Now my young relatives arrive to stay with me from New Zealand and have a daily WA FaceTime hour with their parents. They never really leave home, mum and dad are always there to advise.

GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 14/01/2023 09:19

I wouldn’t agree to it personally, but if your husband and you are happy with it then I don’t see why it would be an issue? Your both adults and have chosen to do this.

denishhol · 14/01/2023 09:19

Personally I'd hate it. It's why I don't plan on getting married. I just don't like being that close to someone. I change bfs like the wind amd that's how I like it. I get bored of people. Being married just sounds too stiffy and formal for my liking.

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 09:18

pattihews · 14/01/2023 08:59

It's like bringing a police state into your home. Adults have the right to do whatever they decide to do without being tracked 24/7, even if that involves disappearing for a few hours. They have the right to go on a detour without explanation, to do something unplanned, not to have to account for why they were here or there at any given time. I can see that there may be odd occasions when this might be useful but to have it on permanently seems to me extremely unhealthy. If my partner's going to be late I'd expect a call or a message or I'd call or message. Monitoring them is infringing on their independence. We are allowed to have secrets, even in devoted relationships. We are not accountable to our partners or families 24/7. The idea of my partner being able to see where I am at any time makes me shudder — not because I'm up to anything, but because this is totally unnatural. I have the right to privacy, I've earned the right to be trusted. Horrible.

I have to disagree that as a part of a young family my husband has the right to disappear off on a detour at any time without informing me of his whereabouts or roughly what time he thinks he'll be home. We have small children and childcare to juggle. He can't just piss off wherever he likes without checking with me first and just assume I'll do the childcare. If we had no children at home it would be different, although I'd still expect him to let me know where he was e.g. "I'm going to the pub after work, I'll be home late so don't save dinner for me".

OP posts:
Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:18

GoTeamRocket · 14/01/2023 09:13

No one is too busy not to send their partner a quick text. Running late, popping to shops after work etc etc.

It also seems like more 'women's work' and 'mental load', monitoring kids, checking app to see when to put on dinner etc etc.

Slightly off topic, my DS is starting to navigate the walk to primary school by himself. I will not give him a phone, because I feel that it creates more distractions and riskier behaviour (I.e. looking at phone rather than road . I just don't think it is true that children are safer with access to a phone. Clear instructions and the ability to problem solve will make them safe.

Same with tracking, your family members aren't safer because you know their exact location. It might be more convenient, but with a cost to privacy and independence.

FFS.

say I’m running late somewhere. I would maybe drop a text before I get in the car and then we can both monitor things from there using the app.

or my wife might think “I’ve had a meeting cancelled, I might pop to the shop and could get the kids, I’ll just check where Westernesse is”.

now she might see that I’m flying down the motorway and would probably get the kids more easily or she might see that I’m still further up the road. So then she can decide whether to call me and offer to collect the kids or not to bother and just go to the shop.

there’s nothing nefarious about this.

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:18

GoTeamRocket · 14/01/2023 09:13

No one is too busy not to send their partner a quick text. Running late, popping to shops after work etc etc.

It also seems like more 'women's work' and 'mental load', monitoring kids, checking app to see when to put on dinner etc etc.

Slightly off topic, my DS is starting to navigate the walk to primary school by himself. I will not give him a phone, because I feel that it creates more distractions and riskier behaviour (I.e. looking at phone rather than road . I just don't think it is true that children are safer with access to a phone. Clear instructions and the ability to problem solve will make them safe.

Same with tracking, your family members aren't safer because you know their exact location. It might be more convenient, but with a cost to privacy and independence.

I agree re women's work. It's "easier" that women's at home is checking whereabouts regualrly than husband let her know when he's late?

Also agree re DC and phones. My DS started secondary at a time whe many DC did have phones but not "all". He didn't and on his first day managed to get on the wrong bus home.

He didn't have a phone so he talked to the driver, who told him where to get off as close to home as possible and he walked the rest of the way. A good lesson, if he'd had a phone he'd have called me and I'd (probably) have left work to collect him. If I'd been tracking him, I'd have been a nervous wreck wondering why he wasn't where he was supposed to be.

Quincythequince · 14/01/2023 09:17

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:15

It just does. I’m not going to text while I’m driving or sent repeated texts giving constant updates or constant phone calls. We can simply see where we each other is if we are delayed or whatever.

We use it occasionally by the consent of both parties.

it’s a consensual exchange of information. Why does it matter to you whether it’s a text or the FindMyIphone app?

Fair enough to not text when driving.

Bit why would you need to do it repeatedly.

Why is one (I’m leaving now, see you soon xx) text, sent as you leave work, so burdensome?

Would you not call and say for example ‘do you need anything from the shops etc’ on occasion either?

Yarrawonga · 14/01/2023 09:16

We share locations. We find it helpful. There are no downsides. For us.

I couldn’t care less about what other people think about it.

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:16

Quincythequince · 14/01/2023 08:51

It is not normal to expect that somebody should be able to know where you are at all times.

It is dysfunctional behaviour to expect to have this level of intrusion into somebody else’s life by way of knowing where they are at all times.

It also normalises this in our younger generations. How do they say no to a bf or GF wanting to track them? And they do have that right tbh!

How do they say no… The same way they say no to anything else which isn’t appropriate unless you really trust the person. Sharing finances, or moving in together, all the things we do that require trust.

Raspberry290 · 14/01/2023 09:16

I think if this works for you both and you’re both happy with the arrangement then it’s totally fine!

Happin · 14/01/2023 09:16

As long as you've both consented there's nothing wrong with it.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 14/01/2023 09:16

The whole idea gives me the shivers.

I'm a grown adult - I don't need to be monitored or have my location visible 24/7. If DH ever suggested it, I'd think he was losing his marbles.

I find it very weird that knowing your family's location 24/7 is now becoming the norm. I also don't think it's a healthy thing to be teaching children or teenagers.

yaflouloci · 14/01/2023 09:15

@Westernesse too busy to call on hands free or send a text? Do not believe it. How many times do you check the app that you've not got time for one text or one phone all?

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:15

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:11

I don't understand how it makes things easier. Rather than you dropping a text now and again when you're running late, she's expected to check what time you'll be home regularly?

It just does. I’m not going to text while I’m driving or sent repeated texts giving constant updates or constant phone calls. We can simply see where we each other is if we are delayed or whatever.

We use it occasionally by the consent of both parties.

it’s a consensual exchange of information. Why does it matter to you whether it’s a text or the FindMyIphone app?

Quincythequince · 14/01/2023 09:14

Bayleaf25 · 14/01/2023 09:11

@Quincythequince i wouldn’t have a clue how to use voice operated texts and Bluetooth in our old car hasn’t worked for years. The ‘find my friend’ works well for us and we’ve been married for well over 20 years with no control issues on either side.

I think it’s just an example of why it works for some but not others.

You would if you spent 5 mins looking into it!
About as long as it took to set up find my phone.

Anyway, I have no beef with people who say it works for them, so what you need to.

The expectation that other have things to hide, or are t trustworthy because they don’t want to use it is bizarre.

I also think it’s just another way of removing the social norms of basic courtesy in many instances too.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 14/01/2023 09:14

I would hate it and think it's creepy to track someone.

I have a teen dd and would not feel comfortable putting a tracker on her phone.

I think it's weird and creepy.

GoTeamRocket · 14/01/2023 09:13

No one is too busy not to send their partner a quick text. Running late, popping to shops after work etc etc.

It also seems like more 'women's work' and 'mental load', monitoring kids, checking app to see when to put on dinner etc etc.

Slightly off topic, my DS is starting to navigate the walk to primary school by himself. I will not give him a phone, because I feel that it creates more distractions and riskier behaviour (I.e. looking at phone rather than road . I just don't think it is true that children are safer with access to a phone. Clear instructions and the ability to problem solve will make them safe.

Same with tracking, your family members aren't safer because you know their exact location. It might be more convenient, but with a cost to privacy and independence.

SunsetBlue · 14/01/2023 09:13

No we don't share our locations. I don't want to be visible all the time. Everyone has a right to privacy.

We love eachother. Nothing to hide. No distrust. Happy family. But no, I don't to be visible all the time.

tigger1001 · 14/01/2023 09:11

WednesdaysPlaits · 14/01/2023 08:21

Our whole family has it on. It’s extremely helpful when you’re trying to plan meals, make sure nobody has forgotten school/club pick ups, want to see if it would be a pain to ask someone to pop by the shop for bread etc.

Nobody has anything to hide so why would it be an issue?

It's not about having things to hide. It's about good communication.

If you are running late, it's just common decency to let your partner know. It shouldn't be on them to check.

Having been in an abusive relationship, thankfully long before smart phones, the "you have nothing to hide" is a dangerous message.