Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have DH's location visible at all times?

582 replies

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 07:44

This should really be AWBU because it's the same for both of us. We've had location sharing on between us 24/7 for a couple of years now. I can always see where DH is and vice versa. It's hugely helpful and we turned it on for very practical reasons. No more messaging each other where are you, having to explain that we're stuck in traffic, worrying about each other if we're running late etc. It's certainly not to 'check up on each other', there has never been a hint of suspicion of infidelity in the relationship and we both trust each other fully. Days go by without me checking his location, but it's very handy to have there when we need it.

We're both happy with the arrangement, but I said to a friend the other day that I'd just quickly check whether DH was home yet and looked at my phone, and she reacted like what I was doing was really awful. She was gobsmacked and sort of acted like it was a controlling/abusive thing (despite it being both ways). I've mentioned it to several friends since and I've had very mixed reactions. Some couples do the same, some thought it was very odd.

AWBU? Is this a weird invasion of each other's privacy?

OP posts:
Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:57

springerspanielpuppy · 14/01/2023 09:53

Seems some people who use the tracking will go to great lengths to explain or justify why.

Nobody has to justify it. Nobody is answerable to you. You have asked repeatedly why people use it and they are giving you the courtesy of answering you. 😆

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:56

thats some reading of the situation. He may well have gone on to phone or message his wife or the nursery at 5.03pm but upon checking his phone he will have seen that the issue was sorted and the pressure was off.

he could even have been in the lift or at the front door of the building and leaving at 5pm as planned.

utterly bizarre.

minionsrule · 14/01/2023 09:55

saleorbouy · 14/01/2023 09:35

Think back a few years before this technology was available. Did we have the incessant need to know where each other location and what they were doing. Just because the technology is available doesn't mean you need to use it. This over supply of information surely is one of the catalysts to modern day 'anxiety' issues.
Mobile phones, social media, and apps certainly have their advantages but I can't help thinking that their contribution to not being able to switch off and concentrate and have undisturbed quality time with the people you are with contributes to many of societies social issues, and behaviours.
Did my Grannie need to know where her husband was 24/7,no. And she was much more relaxed without technology intrusion.
Just ask yourself how many minutes today did you manage in-between looking at or getting disturbed by your devices.

I get your point but we could say the same about everything.
Why do kids going to high school HAVE to have phones (and most parents think they do for safety at least). Kids have been going to school for decades before without having one 😉

merlotlover · 14/01/2023 09:55

We've got a family one and I'll use it when I'm making tea to see if anyone stuck in traffic to slow tea down etc, or check on my DS coming home from school if he's running later than usual
I think it can be a great tool, as long as it's not over used

Dagray21 · 14/01/2023 09:54

We have it on aswell. Also for our teenage son. We initially started using it as my husband cycles in the woods near our house. This woods is huge!! He fell off his bike in a nasty fall and knocked himself out for a bit. When he came back I got an awful fright. He could have been lying there for ages and I wouldn't know where to look for him. This was when we started sharing our location. Another time he got a puncture in the back end of somewhere and I was able to get to him with whatever he had asked me to bring.

We now use it really for what time to put food in oven really and for boring things like that. My friends all think its weird but when I explained like above they all agreed its great although I think they still think its weird!! We are together a long long time and we know eachother inside out. No trust issues and controlling behaviour. X

Wolfout · 14/01/2023 09:54

Same as you OP, we have this for the family. It’s consensual and neither of us are doing anything we wouldn’t tell the other about anyway. We have quite boring lives!

I am definitely not checking DHs location ‘constantly’ - some posters seem to think we are glued to it! Why would I do that? I only use it occasionally mainly to check what time he’s going to be home for dinner, back for childcare etc.
He cycles so doesn’t hear his phone if I message him, and he was always forgetting to text when he left work.

I guess we have an honest trusting relationship so it’s fine for us, but if I felt pressured into it or felt ‘checked up on’ I would not have agreed. However I often get similar horrified reactions when I tell people.

Also for me it’s an element of security especially if I am walking home late, same for teen DD.

Anyway it’s a useful tool for us - we also have a shared family calendar app on our phones. We are both quite organised people and like things being planned, don’t like surprises, but I guess that’s our personal preference, I know it’s not how everyone likes to live.

However it has reminded me that I’ll talk to the DCs about only ever sharing their phone location with someone they fully trust.

springerspanielpuppy · 14/01/2023 09:53

Seems some people who use the tracking will go to great lengths to explain or justify why.

Quincythequince · 14/01/2023 09:52

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:47

@whataboutsecondbreakfast and @Quincythequince
I am not being disingenuous nor am I normalising abusive behaviour to my children. If anything, I hope that if in future they have a partner who tracks them excessively then they’ll be slightly better able to spot that and call it out, precisely because they’ve seen DH and me use it in a sensible non-abusive way.

After all, the next generation does not avoid using something just because their parents didn’t use it. Quite the opposite in fact.

Tracking anyone at all, when it’s not needed, is excessive.

If both parties agree, that still doesn’t make it ok.

And your example of a delivery needing to be dealt with, makes no sense. If you wanted him to manage it, why not ask? And if you ordered it, why not just deal with it.

How did you know he would even stay in to take it if he didn’t know about it (which you’re saying he didn’t).

How is a text more intrusive on your time, than you having to check location all the time?

Yarrawonga · 14/01/2023 09:50

Are there a lot of women on here who have dinner on the table when their presumably male DP walks in?

My male husband has the dinner on the table when I walk in.

ShandaLear · 14/01/2023 09:50

Our family of 4 have it. I don’t use it much - maybe to check if my DD is on the train back from college so I can surprise her with a lift from the station - that sort of thing. When she turned 16 I said she could turn it off but she didn’t want to.

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 09:49

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:42

So he'd never pop out to post a letter or take DC for a walk? Go to by you a surprise?

No, he wouldn't take DC out for a walk in the dark in winter not long before bedtime, or to the postbox. They're very little. Ditto with going out to buy me a surprise gift (I wish) 😂😂 If he had had to leave the house he would have let me know as it would have been out of the ordinary.

I'm not sure why we're exploring the minutiae of a specific, mundane situation that happened in my life, but I think you're going to have to accept my life plays out differently to yours.

OP posts:
Echobelly · 14/01/2023 09:48

YANBU if it's mutual and agreed to by both parties.

I admit, I do find it kind of weird; on the rare occasions one of us is stuck somewhere we'll just let the other know, but it's not like that's common enough for us to need to track one another.

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:48

CraneBoysMysteries · 14/01/2023 09:43

Lots of posters are getting totally hung up on specific examples others have given where they've found it helpful. Lots of 'what abouts' and 'why didn't you...'

The fact is in (most) of those examples, the user found it helpful and both parties had agreed it worked for them. There is no further arguments or picking it apart.

Some use it and find it useful, some don't and wouldn't use it ever

As long as both parties use it respectfully and are on board with it then it works.

It's not for everyone and I'd personally never encourage others to use it as we do as they probably have their own ways of working. In the same way I wouldn't expect others to question why we do it this way. It works for us, end of.

Hear hear!!

AllotmentTime · 14/01/2023 09:47

@whataboutsecondbreakfast and @Quincythequince
I am not being disingenuous nor am I normalising abusive behaviour to my children. If anything, I hope that if in future they have a partner who tracks them excessively then they’ll be slightly better able to spot that and call it out, precisely because they’ve seen DH and me use it in a sensible non-abusive way.

After all, the next generation does not avoid using something just because their parents didn’t use it. Quite the opposite in fact.

MimiSunshine · 14/01/2023 09:45

We don’t have it. Sometimes I do think it would be handy to be able to check if DH was nearly home.
But overall I’m of them belief that it’s just a bit too big brother.

my friend has it on with her DH and when we’ve occasionally met up and gone out for lunch in different areas of the country to where either of us live, he’ll message her to check in and say something like ‘ooh lunch at x, very nice.’
it makes my skin crawl and just seems so snoopy and weird, like he was cheap king up on her as there was no need to check if she was on her way at that point.

Thighlengthboots · 14/01/2023 09:44

I would absolutely hate that and it feels controlling and creepy to me. But thats me, not you, so if you are both fine with it then carry on. But I think if you tell people about it you will get alternative opinions because many of us would hate it and will express that. If you both like it then just ignore those opinions.

yaflouloci · 14/01/2023 09:44

@Westernesse

'It just does. I’m not going to text while I’m driving or sent repeated texts giving constant updates or constant phone calls. We can simply see where we each other is if we are delayed or whatever'

I meant YOU are using the app whilst driving.

springerspanielpuppy · 14/01/2023 09:43

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:34

That's nonsense though. Just because he was there then doesn't mean he'd be there when the delivery came if he's not expecting it. He could have gone out again for any number of reasons.

Absolutely ^^

Your drip feed makes no sense @Algor1thm and if that was his reply to you having to possibly change your plans then he’s a knob.

CraneBoysMysteries · 14/01/2023 09:43

Lots of posters are getting totally hung up on specific examples others have given where they've found it helpful. Lots of 'what abouts' and 'why didn't you...'

The fact is in (most) of those examples, the user found it helpful and both parties had agreed it worked for them. There is no further arguments or picking it apart.

Some use it and find it useful, some don't and wouldn't use it ever

As long as both parties use it respectfully and are on board with it then it works.

It's not for everyone and I'd personally never encourage others to use it as we do as they probably have their own ways of working. In the same way I wouldn't expect others to question why we do it this way. It works for us, end of.

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:42

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 09:41

Well I knew he was home for the evening with DC, doing dinner and evening routine etc. Bar an emergency like the house was on fire I knew he wouldn't have left. And if there was an emergency he'd call me. It's all very specific to the circumstances to your own life and relationship - in the case of ours it makes sense. We have small children and we're boring.

So he'd never pop out to post a letter or take DC for a walk? Go to by you a surprise?

Helpmesortit · 14/01/2023 09:42

Westernesse · 14/01/2023 09:36

How do we know anything? We don’t. Anything could happen at any time but we just have to make judgement calls and live our lives.

You know by calling the person and saying?
hey, where are you?
what’s your plan?
will you be home in the next 10mins?
ok great I’ll leave the dog in the garden is that ok with you?
🙄

Shoxfordian · 14/01/2023 09:41

I wouldn’t like it; but as it works for you both then it’s up to you

Algor1thm · 14/01/2023 09:41

Redblanky · 14/01/2023 09:34

That's nonsense though. Just because he was there then doesn't mean he'd be there when the delivery came if he's not expecting it. He could have gone out again for any number of reasons.

Well I knew he was home for the evening with DC, doing dinner and evening routine etc. Bar an emergency like the house was on fire I knew he wouldn't have left. And if there was an emergency he'd call me. It's all very specific to the circumstances to your own life and relationship - in the case of ours it makes sense. We have small children and we're boring.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 14/01/2023 09:40

It’s completely fine OP I get how you’re both using it. I have my location services turned off because I don’t want my devices tracking my every movement over years. But if I wanted to use it I can see how it could be handy.

notseventeenforever · 14/01/2023 09:40

I don't know anyone in real life that has an app to stalk their partners.

Only on mumsnet does someone find it 'just so helpful that they know when to pop the tea on' 🤢