Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you find this acceptable for your relative in a care home?

35 replies

Greengables4 · 14/01/2023 06:52

Resident with full capacity has been told by a care assistant (in front of everyone) that he needs 'to talk more and be more sociable in the main dining area.'

Been called 'too sensitive' as he 'doesn't say much'.

Another carer accidentally gave the relative's phone to another resident believing it was theirs. Relative was worried and asked staff to look for phone (relative is immobile) before it was found, said male carer who's made these other comments said 'Let this be a lesson for you in making sure you look after your phone next time.' even though it wasn't relative's fault.

Always called 'big man' when carer assists him to stand, feels very patronising to him.

Are these things worth mentioning to manager?

It's the same male care assistant who's said all these.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tiani4 · 14/01/2023 10:56

Ask to speak to the manager to get this resolved- they will want to know and can easily resolve it as it's making the client feel uncomfortable

This carer is patronising this client
How he spoke to him was experienced by the client as being told off
He doesn't like being called Big Man, he prefers his name to be used
A carer accidentally gave away his mobile phone to another resident and then this carer (instead of apologising that it happened ) 'told off' this resident for 'not looking after his phone'

Whilst these aren't safeguarding issues, they are issues around respect and dignity for the client (regardless of capacity or not)

Some people may like a bit of ' bantz' but other people don't , it's a soft skill to know who does and who won't.

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 10:15

Never-the-less presumably allowed an opinion on what you said.

I mean sure, but I was talking directly about people assuming having capacity means you can advocate for yourself. So even if these things are not 'advocate necessary' as you think, it makes no odds. Millions of adults have capacity but can't/don't/won't advocate for themselves.

donttellmehesalive · 14/01/2023 10:09

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 09:46

I suppose I don't see any of the three examples in the op as an 'advocating' situation (or defending as I think op put it) as so minor.

They are only 'minor' from your POV. They may not be minor to the 80 year old man.

However as you say you don't consider these examples to to 'advocating' situations I think it's safe to say when I spoke about people's opinions on him advocating I probably wasn't talking to you.

Never-the-less presumably allowed an opinion on what you said.

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 09:46

I suppose I don't see any of the three examples in the op as an 'advocating' situation (or defending as I think op put it) as so minor.

They are only 'minor' from your POV. They may not be minor to the 80 year old man.

However as you say you don't consider these examples to to 'advocating' situations I think it's safe to say when I spoke about people's opinions on him advocating I probably wasn't talking to you.

donttellmehesalive · 14/01/2023 09:42

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 09:30

One thing that surprises me is the assumption that if someone has capacity that they can advocate for themselves.

I suppose I don't see any of the three examples in the op as an 'advocating' situation (or defending as I think op put it) as so minor. But my replies are only based on my own experiences of care homes. My relatives who are residents would easily deal with all three of those scenarios themselves. But I take the point that not everyone is the same. OP knows the resident better than we do and is a carer herself so I'm sure she'll make the right decision.

Justcallmebebes · 14/01/2023 09:34

I absolutely would bring this up. It's all about dignity and choice. It's not up to a carer to scold a resident for not being sociable enough or demeaning him in his tone and/or words.

Plus, if the resident doesn't like being called big man, for whatever reason and regardless of how it's meant, then he shouldn't be called it.

I can't believe some of these posts

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 09:30

One thing that surprises me is the assumption that if someone has capacity that they can advocate for themselves.

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 09:29

Notthetoothfairy · 14/01/2023 08:16

I’m not sure I would, tbh. It really doesn’t sound that bad and you wouldn’t want any of the carers to take a dislike to him when he is so reliant upon them.

Ignore this OP. Trying to scare people into silence with wet threats is not ok.

gogohmm · 14/01/2023 09:28

Flip it around, in the dining area is he sitting refusing to talk to other residents, this could be construed as rude? The phone seems like a misunderstanding and "big man" could be a compliment in some areas.

My suspicion is they are trying to get him to settle better, to get along with the people he lives with because they are worried about him. If he has full capacity then he should discuss these things himself

ChristmasFluff · 14/01/2023 09:23

It's really difficult for residents to speak up in these situations because of the power imbalance of being dependent on their carers.

Yes, I would complain about these incidents, and as someone who used to work in care homes, I'd have had a word with the carer myself had I seen either incident or if the resident expressed that he didn't like being called 'Big Man' - that's not complaint-worthy unless it continues when he's been asked to stop, but the other two incidents totally are.

Howmanysleepsnow · 14/01/2023 08:19

I would 100% want to know if one of our carers was speaking to someone like this, regardless of capacity. Definitely raise these concerns, for everyone’s sake.

Notthetoothfairy · 14/01/2023 08:16

I’m not sure I would, tbh. It really doesn’t sound that bad and you wouldn’t want any of the carers to take a dislike to him when he is so reliant upon them.

romdowa · 14/01/2023 08:13

You should 100% talk to the home on his behalf. He's an old man in a very vunerable position, he probably doesn't feel like he can speak out for himself. But the staff need to remember that this is this man's home and he should be able to spend his time as he pleases and not be spoken down to in such a disrespectful manner.

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 08:11

I’m not suggesting he starts a sing along. He could just go in the communal areas, he doesn’t have to do anything apart from being somewhere other than the four walls of his room. He could try it, he might find it interesting or he might not. If he doesn’t so be it.

Right, but he doesn't have to do this simply because he is 80. He has the right to make his own choices still, or at least he is supposed to.

WestBridgewater · 14/01/2023 08:09

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 07:52

@WestBridgewater

No he doesn’t have to socialise at 80 but he would probably benefit from it.

Would he? Why? Just because he is 80?

What if he isn't sociable and is happier spending his time alone?

I dread reaching this age and having forced socialisation - it's one of my bigger worries. I don't socialise now, I'm bloody sure o won't want to be doing it when I'm 80.

OP I would absolutely raise this with the home, the man himself is the single most important factor here. Someone unthread mentioned how the cater would feel finding out there was a complaint, well that's not your issue. Your sole issue here is to ensure the elderly man is given respect and dignity.

I’m not suggesting he starts a sing along. He could just go in the communal areas, he doesn’t have to do anything apart from being somewhere other than the four walls of his room. He could try it, he might find it interesting or he might not. If he doesn’t so be it.

keepareaclean · 14/01/2023 07:52

@WestBridgewater

No he doesn’t have to socialise at 80 but he would probably benefit from it.

Would he? Why? Just because he is 80?

What if he isn't sociable and is happier spending his time alone?

I dread reaching this age and having forced socialisation - it's one of my bigger worries. I don't socialise now, I'm bloody sure o won't want to be doing it when I'm 80.

OP I would absolutely raise this with the home, the man himself is the single most important factor here. Someone unthread mentioned how the cater would feel finding out there was a complaint, well that's not your issue. Your sole issue here is to ensure the elderly man is given respect and dignity.

stbrandonsboat · 14/01/2023 07:41

I'm an ex care home nurse and, yes, you do need to complain. The carer has been patronising and this needs addressing. Care home residents are not children and should be treated with respect at all times and their care should be directed towards their individual needs and preferences.

RambamThankyouMam · 14/01/2023 07:35

I've always come down pretty hard on patronising and disrespectful "banter" from caring/healthcare staff. I can't bear it. My mother-in-law is a dignified Holocaust survivor who doesn't need to be called condescending names by carehome staff.

Greengables4 · 14/01/2023 07:35

Thanks and yes I agree, I suppose I meant rather a quiet chat with the management or the carer, doesn't really warrant cqc or anything.

OP posts:
CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 14/01/2023 07:33

I wouldn’t make a formal complaint, just have a chat with his names carer or manager. If possible, make it into an informal chat between you, your relative & carer.

My Dad had 6 years in a care home, full capacity until a few days before he died. It took him a good few months until he was confident to advocate for himself (even though he was a bloody angry, opinionated gobshite).

Just saying, hey, “xxx likes to be known as xxx.” may be all that’s needed for the ‘big man’ issue.

As for the phone, labels are you friend. And possession, label, label and then label more! No staff can possibly remember every single resident item. We’d even label lighters that they held in the manager office.

Dad was an anti social bugger, taking months just to have one meal a day in the floor dining room. And even that was sporadic. Again, a chat with his named carer would help, likewise to discuss the phone misunderstanding.

And it’s vital to remind your relative that they have a voice & they will be listened to. Many feel infantilised in the whirlwind of moving into a care home, it’s a massive adjustment (with the feeling that it’s just a waiting room to die in Dad’s case). Give your relative the confidence to talk about how he’d like his day to be, what his preferences are.

You do not have to go in all guns blazing for all issues, as tempting as it is. Remember that this is your relative’s home, and a major confrontation could cause your relative to lose any feelings of security they have.

Greengables4 · 14/01/2023 07:25

It's kind of like saying anyone in any situation should be able to stand up for themselves, whether that's in school, work or in a relationship. It's not always so simple sadly.

OP posts:
WiseUpJanetWeiss · 14/01/2023 07:23

I think it depends. Either of the comments could be seen as innocuous and affectionate, or rude and patronising, depending on the circumstances.

Personally I don't like endearments unless they are genuine and reciprocated. My DM used to call a couple of her carers "Dear" and they might call her "My lovely" - but it was meant. They had a genuine friendly relationship. However, people differ and everyone's needs should be taken into account.

My DM had a couple of carers who absolutely might have said "let that be a lesson" to you, but in jest, and DM would have laughed. Others saying the same would have got short shrift.

I did on occasion step in where my DM was annoyed about something, but I had a good relationship with the managers.

I think PPs saying your relative should be able to stand up for himself as he has capacity are failing to realise the complexity of being in a care situation, and that there is a huge difference between having capacity, and having the confidence and communication skills to advocate for oneself.

If you're a carer yourself you can maybe have a friendly carer-to-carer chat rather than making a complaint?

harrassedmumto3 · 14/01/2023 07:16

I wouldn't make a formal complaint, no. A private word with the carer is all that's needed.
'Big man' would be fairly common in Glasgow, for example. I can't help but feel that you're nitpicking with that one.

donttellmehesalive · 14/01/2023 07:15

I suppose I am putting myself in the carer's shoes and imaging how he will feel when his manager tells him that they've received a complaint about him.

Not for doing anything wrong really, but just for trying to encourage a resident to socialise and a misunderstanding about a phone. In his shoes, given everything the carer does for the resident, I think I'd feel hurt. Couldn't you just have a friendly word with the carer directly?

Greengables4 · 14/01/2023 07:14

Ok, thanks for your Feedback and replies.

OP posts: