Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Someone who has an unplanned pregnancy has just as much of a right to express feelings feelings of shock and emotion as someone who deals with infertility that wants to share their struggles/sadness

113 replies

lemesser6 · 14/01/2023 02:31

We both have our feelings to work through. one is not greater than the other. i for tile people can share their sadness and people who have a suppress pregnancy can share their shock. If their unexpected upsets you then i've got news for you.

It seems like women who gave unplanned pregnancies are shamed to oblivion fir even mentioning "it was just so unexpected!" "we're not even trying" "i was just so surprised when i found out" why? why am i not allowed to express these feelings to others, just as infertile people express their struggles to others.

Although i obviously understand both sides can be traumatic, you don't have to hold space for everyone/every situation. If you are going through infertility it's totally ok to scroll past the post, block that person, or if it's said in real life flat out tell them " that sounds really hard and i care about you but i am NOT the person the person to come to about this". Although i don't think it's right to make a nasty comment or scold your real life friend. I think people should obviously talk to SOMEONE ELSE about how that made you feel like your partner, mum, neutral friend or a therapist.

As you can see i that was a bit of a rant but i just needed to get it off my chest because my friend has really upset me but i don't want to go into details.

OP posts:
Muddays · 14/01/2023 09:46

@lemesser6 well, if you've been weirdly strong enough to read the responses and get this far well done.
I'm actually going to defend you here and hopefully help both sides get a little perspective back.
Firstly let's state the obvious.
It's not acceptable, e.g, as a first time metal detectorist to flaunt discovering the treasure of the sierra madre when next to a more experienced, exhausted one who has found their thousandth ring pull or bottle top. It's mean, because life really can be a cruel lottery, luck, chance etc.
However, those who want to have children are prepared for and embrace the vast responsibility, awesome challenges and changes, life and health changing future that a child will bring.
It's absolutely terrifying for someone who isn't prepared for this and I respect anyone who recognises how much their life will change because it means they're taking it seriously and will hopefully be good parents as a result.
It's not something anyone has any right to assume should be greeted with unabashed joy.
Pregnancy, birth and what follows is glamorised. It's flaming tough, and can destroy the best of people's idealism. Not everyone has a successful birth and an unexpected pregnancy involves many unknown outcomes.
So back off ladies. The OP is allowed to be afraid of the future just as her friend is.

EggsActly · 14/01/2023 09:32

Of course you should be able to express your feelings, OP. Just NOT to someone you know is struggling with infertility.

I can’t stand the judgement I see on some threads when women find themselves unexpectedly pregnant. And it does exist, you’re right.

I’ve had two ‘accidental’ pregnancies in the 30 years I’ve been sexually active, 16 years apart. They were both really difficult to deal with emotionally, and in both cases they were genuine contraceptive failures - not me being careless and irresponsible, which some snotty posters on MN seem to level at any woman who finds herself in this situation.

In both cases, I terminated. That was my choice and my right, and I was allowed to feel a lot of mixed emotions about it.

However, I wouldn’t have talked about my situation with someone I knew was struggling to conceive. In fact, I didn’t. I had a good friend going through her third round of IVF when I had the second unexpected pregnancy and subsequent abortion, and I didn’t tell her about it until a very, very long time afterwards. It would have been totally inappropriate to share my ‘whoops, aren’t I so fertile?!’ experience with someone who didn’t know if she would ever be able to have a child. I got pregnant the first time I tried when I did want children - every time - and I also wouldn’t have shared that with friends who had fertility issues.

Come on, it’s just common sense and not being an arsehole!

HelterSkelter224 · 14/01/2023 09:17

Lovethatforyou · 14/01/2023 08:52

You’re right - no one person’s feelings trump another’s. Our feelings are valid and important. But we can all make an effort to be considerate and kind.

Also imo, there is not much worse than wanting a baby that never comes. There are somethings, of course. But not much.

It’s an all consuming grief that doesn’t ease in time - devastating, painful and completely soul-destroying. Everything hurts. When it happened to me I wanted to live in a forest with no contact with people so I could just be alone with my pain rather than having to feel jealousy and bitterness and sadness towards other people who could do what I couldn’t. I didn’t think I’d survive it.
If you know you know.

Having been through it and come out of the other side over ten years later I’d always give someone going through infertility a break, leeway, extra understanding and forgiveness.

❤️

GreyGoose1980 · 14/01/2023 09:13

PinkSyCo · 14/01/2023 04:25

It’s fine to express shock at an accidental pregnancy but if you’re moaning on and on to an infertile friend then that’s downright cruel! And I say that as someone who has had two ‘surprise’ babies.

This.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 14/01/2023 09:11

@tenbob No they're no. It's not my thread, I'm just showing my support for the OP who is getting a hard time (not that she's come back).

I hope you can show more empathy for others in future instead of just insulting them.

Best of luck with everything Flowers

tenbob · 14/01/2023 09:01

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 14/01/2023 08:41

@tenbob You really don't read much on here do you. I've seen several posts pulled due to the OP getting upset at being told they're awful for wanting a termination. It's not at all a supportive place to post.

At least you clarified you're an uncaring person and cheers for doubling down on the insults. As I said, some people can have an opinion and others aren't allowed. I'm clearly in the second group.

Of course it's only me in the wrong. You throwing insults at a stranger behind a keyboard is totally normal behaviour 🙄. Probably normal behaviour in your totally normal friendship group too. You sound delightful to be around.

If any of your posts here are supposed to be dispelling the myth that you’re cold and have a very weird take on normal human behaviour, I’m afraid they aren’t succeeding.

Best of luck with everything 💐

Lovethatforyou · 14/01/2023 08:52

You’re right - no one person’s feelings trump another’s. Our feelings are valid and important. But we can all make an effort to be considerate and kind.

Also imo, there is not much worse than wanting a baby that never comes. There are somethings, of course. But not much.

It’s an all consuming grief that doesn’t ease in time - devastating, painful and completely soul-destroying. Everything hurts. When it happened to me I wanted to live in a forest with no contact with people so I could just be alone with my pain rather than having to feel jealousy and bitterness and sadness towards other people who could do what I couldn’t. I didn’t think I’d survive it.
If you know you know.

Having been through it and come out of the other side over ten years later I’d always give someone going through infertility a break, leeway, extra understanding and forgiveness.

gogohmm · 14/01/2023 08:43

Knowing about biology and being a fully fledged adult eg in your 40's doesn't mean you are perfect, you can have a whoops, and yes it can be devastating. Both situations are not ideal and both have the right to complain but it's not sensitive to complain to someone struggling with infertility that you accidentally got pregnant!

MrsF111 · 14/01/2023 08:42

Changechangychange · 14/01/2023 02:54

It’s fine to express all of that, but not to somebody who is going through infertility. Just as it is fine for a millionaire to stress about the best investment vehicle for their savings, but if they are complaining about this to somebody using a foodbank, they can’t really expect a positive response. And fine to complain about your mum ringing you too much, but not to somebody whose own mother has just died the week before.

OP, you have clearly being discussing your surprise pregnancy with your infertile friend, and she’s gone off at you. Entirely predictable, take your own advice and choose your audience more wisely next time.

100% this!

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 14/01/2023 08:41

@tenbob You really don't read much on here do you. I've seen several posts pulled due to the OP getting upset at being told they're awful for wanting a termination. It's not at all a supportive place to post.

At least you clarified you're an uncaring person and cheers for doubling down on the insults. As I said, some people can have an opinion and others aren't allowed. I'm clearly in the second group.

Of course it's only me in the wrong. You throwing insults at a stranger behind a keyboard is totally normal behaviour 🙄. Probably normal behaviour in your totally normal friendship group too. You sound delightful to be around.

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 08:38

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 14/01/2023 08:18

There are two sets of women I don't engage with in chit chat, those who are infertile and those with twins.
It's just a minefield to skirt around their feelings.

So you would ditch a friend that had twins? Nice.

Don't be ridiculous.

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 14/01/2023 08:18

There are two sets of women I don't engage with in chit chat, those who are infertile and those with twins.
It's just a minefield to skirt around their feelings.

So you would ditch a friend that had twins? Nice.

Superstorefan123 · 14/01/2023 08:17

It’s all about knowing your audience (both ways…)

I wouldn’t moan to a pregnant friend about how terrifying and soul destroying seeing my dead baby on a scan was (as I wouldn’t want to scare them)

I wouldn’t expect them to moan to me about how crap morning sickness is (when I’m desperately wishing to experience any pregnancy symptoms)

All about being considerate.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/01/2023 08:15

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 08:07

But you don't always know that someone is infertile and you can't ask. As you've rightly pointed out.
So saying oh little baby t did this yesterday would be so easy to say and accidentally upset another person.
If someone is suffering with infertility then I'm afraid they will get upset on a daily basis because dc are the most important thing to parents. And discussing family life is the norm.
Very harsh but true.

Well no, of course you can't ask if they're infertile! But it's not hard not to ask people if they're planning to have children. It's an extremely personal question.

If someone asks what you did over the weekend and you say you took your kids to the swimming pool, I suppose that could cause some private upset but they asked and you didn't labour the point. You're unlikely to be able to get away with never mentioning your family at all but I don't think that's what upsets most people who are struggling. Stuff like outright asking a difficult and personal question is something else entirely.

It's not a minefield. I think you're just overly affected by the sharp response you got to a question you now know you shouldn't have asked.

Pipsquiggle · 14/01/2023 08:14

@lemesser6
This is all about context
Did you know she had infertility issues?
Were you saying 'It just happened! We weren't even trying!'...........

If so - YABU

Infertility is so much harder than an unexpected pregnancy.

You do understand that with an unexpected pregnancy at least you get to decide whether you want to become a mother or not.

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 14/01/2023 08:11

BigChesterDraws · 14/01/2023 04:37

Unplanned pregnancy? Do you need a diagram to help understand how it happened? If you’re having sex, a baby is always a possible outcome. No contraception is perfect.

You’re absolutely right. Those of us who don’t want kids/any more kids should just resign ourselves to a sexless marriage, just to be on the safe side.

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 08:07

ReneBumsWombats · 14/01/2023 07:55

I wouldn't ever talk about children to someone I knew was struggling with infertility and I'd never ask anyone about their plans to have children. It's not a minefield, it's pretty obvious!

But you don't always know that someone is infertile and you can't ask. As you've rightly pointed out.
So saying oh little baby t did this yesterday would be so easy to say and accidentally upset another person.
If someone is suffering with infertility then I'm afraid they will get upset on a daily basis because dc are the most important thing to parents. And discussing family life is the norm.
Very harsh but true.

Phrenologistsfinger · 14/01/2023 07:56

YABU

ReneBumsWombats · 14/01/2023 07:55

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 07:46

@ReneBumsWombats
So now you never talk to infertile people? How do you even know who they are? Do you really not know what you shouldn't say to someone whom you know to be struggling to conceive?

No, not about dc and family life I don't. In most workplaces that is often the topic of conversation. As this whole thread has demonstrated some infertile people don't want to mention it at all others may want to, how would I know without potentially upsetting that person?

I wouldn't ever talk about children to someone I knew was struggling with infertility and I'd never ask anyone about their plans to have children. It's not a minefield, it's pretty obvious!

Theunamedcat · 14/01/2023 07:53

Amazing how infertile people need spaces to discuss but anyone with an unplanned pregnancy is seen to be "ranting" and "has choices"

choices?

Keep an unplanned baby and alter the course of your life bring them into a potential not the greatest situation or kill it.....can you live with the abortion? Can you live with yourself? Everyone talks about it not being a baby just a bunch of cells it's a few pills and a heavy period but that's just the physical part whereas the emotional part? it doesn't matter that logically its a bunch of cells no bigger than a grain of rice part of you still might wonder what it would look like boy or girl did you make the right choice it goes on and on

Why can't women all women support each other why does one need for a safe speaking place top the other?

Riverlee · 14/01/2023 07:49

If you were telling an infertile person, then maybe a tad insensitive.

However, if it were two different situations, then that’s fine. No one has top trumps over emotions.

Has someone said to you that someone unexpectedly finding themselves pregnant shouldn’t feel shocked and emotional, and that an infertile person has ‘more rights’ to feel emotional? The two situations are perfectly valid.

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 07:46

@ReneBumsWombats
So now you never talk to infertile people? How do you even know who they are? Do you really not know what you shouldn't say to someone whom you know to be struggling to conceive?

No, not about dc and family life I don't. In most workplaces that is often the topic of conversation. As this whole thread has demonstrated some infertile people don't want to mention it at all others may want to, how would I know without potentially upsetting that person?

heartbroken22 · 14/01/2023 07:41

I totally get you and I'm so glad you posted this. YANBU. You can only understand if you've been through it.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/01/2023 07:39

Tricolette · 14/01/2023 07:30

Ime often and understandably people with infertility don't share this very private issue.
If OP has expressed her concerns about being unexpectedly pregnant and it has upset another person who is infertile then unless OP knew it's a regrettable situation.
Many years ago an ex work colleague returned to see a manager. I didn't like this particular person but as she was chatting in reception I felt I had to say hello. She was discussing a pregnant friend. Stupidly, I accept, I asked if she was thinking of starting a family and she curtly told me I should keep my nose out of other people's business.
I learned my lesson never to ask but I never forgot how nasty she was and whilst I realise it was coming from a place of pain there was no need for the rudeness.

There are two sets of women I don't engage with in chit chat, those who are infertile and those with twins.
It's just a minefield to skirt around their feelings.

It isn't a minefield not to ask people about their family plans. It's common sense and you admit you were foolish in asking the question. You were rude and hurtful too, albeit unintentionally.

So now you never talk to infertile people? How do you even know who they are? Do you really not know what you shouldn't say to someone whom you know to be struggling to conceive?

Tandora · 14/01/2023 07:36

@PissedOffNeighbour22 i also found your post cold and odd. You expressed a callous lack of empathy towards people struggling with fertility, which is one of the most painful/ soul destroying/ isolating / life changes challenges a person could have. You say you were once told that you might be infertile, but you also said you didn’t want children, so clearly you don’t have personal experience of the type of struggle I’m describing.
I’m sorry to hear of your termination and traumatic birth, and of your experience on mumsnet, but that has very little relevance to OP’s post. I’m also surprised that people would tell you you had to keep the pregnancy as (as pp said) mumsnet is very pro choice, but maybe things were different in the past? Maybe you posted your question as oddly and obtusely as your comments on this thread and that’s what people were reacting to?