Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Someone who has an unplanned pregnancy has just as much of a right to express feelings feelings of shock and emotion as someone who deals with infertility that wants to share their struggles/sadness

113 replies

lemesser6 · 14/01/2023 02:31

We both have our feelings to work through. one is not greater than the other. i for tile people can share their sadness and people who have a suppress pregnancy can share their shock. If their unexpected upsets you then i've got news for you.

It seems like women who gave unplanned pregnancies are shamed to oblivion fir even mentioning "it was just so unexpected!" "we're not even trying" "i was just so surprised when i found out" why? why am i not allowed to express these feelings to others, just as infertile people express their struggles to others.

Although i obviously understand both sides can be traumatic, you don't have to hold space for everyone/every situation. If you are going through infertility it's totally ok to scroll past the post, block that person, or if it's said in real life flat out tell them " that sounds really hard and i care about you but i am NOT the person the person to come to about this". Although i don't think it's right to make a nasty comment or scold your real life friend. I think people should obviously talk to SOMEONE ELSE about how that made you feel like your partner, mum, neutral friend or a therapist.

As you can see i that was a bit of a rant but i just needed to get it off my chest because my friend has really upset me but i don't want to go into details.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Emmamoo89 · 20/01/2023 08:55

YABU

SoGladofYou · 20/01/2023 06:52

Of course you have a right to your feelings. But do consider how, where and to who you express them.

Rickandmortified100 · 20/01/2023 06:29

Oh have some sensitivity. You KNOW why it might be hurtful for a person with fertility issues to hear someone complaining about how easily they got pregnant. Don’t be so thoughtless.

Shoxfordian · 20/01/2023 05:30

Sounds like you picked the wrong audience op unless it’s just something you put on Facebook

daemonologie · 20/01/2023 05:17

lemesser6 · 14/01/2023 02:31

We both have our feelings to work through. one is not greater than the other. i for tile people can share their sadness and people who have a suppress pregnancy can share their shock. If their unexpected upsets you then i've got news for you.

It seems like women who gave unplanned pregnancies are shamed to oblivion fir even mentioning "it was just so unexpected!" "we're not even trying" "i was just so surprised when i found out" why? why am i not allowed to express these feelings to others, just as infertile people express their struggles to others.

Although i obviously understand both sides can be traumatic, you don't have to hold space for everyone/every situation. If you are going through infertility it's totally ok to scroll past the post, block that person, or if it's said in real life flat out tell them " that sounds really hard and i care about you but i am NOT the person the person to come to about this". Although i don't think it's right to make a nasty comment or scold your real life friend. I think people should obviously talk to SOMEONE ELSE about how that made you feel like your partner, mum, neutral friend or a therapist.

As you can see i that was a bit of a rant but i just needed to get it off my chest because my friend has really upset me but i don't want to go into details.

YANBU. Sounds like a fair statement to me.

Muddays · 20/01/2023 05:12

@Lovethatforyou I just read your extraordinary description of what infertility really means to a woman and it's profoundly moving. Now I understand why some very loved women (friends and family) in my life have been so distant for so many years. Thank you for your very personal and generous post. I think many people will benefit from your insight and be far more understanding and supportive as a result.

Nimbostratus100 · 14/01/2023 13:56

kingtamponthefurred · 14/01/2023 12:57

Nonsense. It is perfectly permissible to have mixed feelings about a pregnancy and to express them. And the foetus can't hear.

the feotus can't hear now, but will be able to hear in the future, when they come across anyone who has heard the negative statements made during the pregnancy.

I am not talking about a calm discussion about mixed feelings, and nor is the OP, the OP is talking about freely and publicly expressing negative feelings about the child that is coming into the world. How is hearing that, or hearing of that, going to affect a sibling, for example, and affect the way they feel about their own origin, and their baby sibling. Or a cousin, or an aunt, or a grandparent, or a predator, and yes they have been known to line up future victims before birth, or a medical professional, or an education professional, or a social care professional, or a family friend.

Negative feelings about unplanned pregancys should be kept private, and discussed quietly with a very few trusted parties, no, they should not be freely expressed into the world at large

KimberleyClark · 14/01/2023 13:03

Oh god just realised OP was talking about u planned not unwanted pregnancies. Ignore my posts above.

KimberleyClark · 14/01/2023 13:01

Unwanted, not I wanted.

KimberleyClark · 14/01/2023 13:01

I realise I wanted pregnancies must be traumatic but the thing is, there is something you can do about them. Someone suffering with infertility cannot just go off and get themselves pregnant.

kingtamponthefurred · 14/01/2023 12:57

Nimbostratus100 · 14/01/2023 04:49

YAB extremely unreasonable

Someone shocked and upset at being pregnant, who is going through with that pregnancy, is sending words and responses out into the world that they can never take back. How is that going to affect the child? You are publicly negative about the existence of your child, you are just not. No good can possibly come of it for the child.

You are speaking out against a defenceless baby, your infertile friend is doing the exact opposite, speaking out of wanting a nd love for a baby that may never come into existence, but if it does, has only been spoken about lovingly.

So YABU becasue neither of you are speaking about just yourself, and the effect on you, but on someone else too, who you should be the main carer and advocate for

Nonsense. It is perfectly permissible to have mixed feelings about a pregnancy and to express them. And the foetus can't hear.

Militarywife7 · 14/01/2023 12:31

I personally feel bad for you’re friend, I think you could of handled this differently given her fertility struggles. You have every right to be happy, shocked etc but also sensitive in discussing this with your friend. I’ve known people to discuss pregnancy news gently with infertile friends so as not to make them feel overwhelmed.

Ive struggled with infertility and have personally broke down on my own at pregnancy announcements. Not because I wasn’t happy for them, but because it’s an horrific thing to deal with mentally and emotionally. It truly was the worst experience of my life. This subject is also really difficult for people to share so please be understanding with her.

It sounds like you haven’t been purposely unkind, but rather haven’t thought about her emotions or struggles and how to approach the subject gently.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 14/01/2023 12:30

Yanbu op but you really do need to make sure you know your audience well.

I wanted my son, but had terrible HG that made me housebound, isolated, dehydrated, depressed and I needed to scream into the void.

I desperately thought many times about abortion.

It even upset my partner. He wasn't the right person to talk to about it, even though I needed a partner to help me.

It doesn't mean you or I or any one struggling with pregnancy have no right to feel the way we feel.

However we'd probably post it in the pregnancy board along with people who are already pregnant for peer to peer support. Or we'd tell our doctors. We wouldn't project it to a wider audience that might include people who are struggling.

We're all accountable for our own actions.

Dowhahdiddy · 14/01/2023 12:21

Why are you ranting to someone who is ttc that you’re up the duff and don’t want it? Keep quiet and go have an abortion? And improve your contraception methods.

burnoutbabe · 14/01/2023 12:20

LemonBounce · 14/01/2023 07:02

This is a really difficult one. I think if it's a very close friend who you share everything with AND the unplanned pregnancy is a bad shock and will cause you lots of problems (e.g. maybe there's a bad relationship with the dad, you're living somewhere not fit for a baby) - then you should be able to share. Friendship is two way and you also need support. But you need to be really mindful of how difficult and deep the pain of infertility is too.

Yes I was assuming it was that sort of situation-unexpected pregnancy in difficult situation (just been dumped) and no one to discuss with bar best mate -who is married and trying for a baby.

Not married couple with a happy accident.

Who else does the single pregnant person discuss it with if not best mate? (With caveats if she has just suffered from a miscarriage)

Calphurnia88 · 14/01/2023 12:15

fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/01/2023 11:57

For me it depends on whether it’s a case of “oh God I need to have an abortion and I’m scared shitless” - in which case I’ll absolutely listen and help - or “oh my God I managed to get pregnant without even trying, that’s so surprising, did you know women can get pregnant so easily, or am I some kind of fertile superhero, it’s all so SURPRISING in me land right now!” - in which case I won’t.

Appreciate everyone’s mileage is different though. And I’m in a weird category of childfree and infertile though the latter came with significant medical trauma so I’m sensitive to unusual things compared to most maybe.

I agree with you.

It's unclear if OP is talking about a pregnancy that is unplanned but she is going ahead with happily, or a pregnancy that is unplanned and she is now considering her options about (in which case a handhold from a friend is needed, although whether that should be a friend experiencing fertility issues is questionable).

DuplicateUserName · 14/01/2023 12:10

Spyral · 14/01/2023 06:19

I noticed this. I think it's a name change fail on the part of the OP...

@lemesser6 @michellet86 ??

And quite the controversial poster in both of those NNs...

Sparklybanana · 14/01/2023 12:07

Yabu. I've been on both sides but infertility is much worse.
Infertility means your entire future and dreams the way you've always assumed it'd happen may not happen. It goes against the 'norm' so if you never end up having children, your pain will be dragged up in future conversations until you die. Holidays and more money do not replace the ghostly sounds of children that never were, laughing when you sit and think what your life could have been.
Having an unexpected pregnancy will not bring you long term emotional pain as everything will normalise. No one bats an eye lid if you say you have 2 children when you were only planning 1.
Even if you have an abortion - it is still a choice you made. Infertility is not a choice.
I absolutely understand how painful it is to see pregnant women, prams and newborns when it's not happened for you. Add on complaining about being pregnant and the worst jealousy you've ever felt x 100 is hard to keep in check.
For all those who are in this right now - I hope it works out for you. X

Thesonglastslonger · 14/01/2023 12:02

Yabvu.

Inastatus · 14/01/2023 12:01

@lemesser6 I think you should follow your own advice -
“I think people should obviously talk to SOMEONE ELSE about how that made you feel like your partner, mum, neutral friend or a therapist”.

Totally unreasonable and insensitive to offload on to your friend who is struggling with infertility. I remember the pain that every pregnancy announcement caused me when I was dealing with miscarriages. Only a couple of close friends knew about my fertility issues and when one of them got pregnant she cried for me when she very gently told me that she was expecting. Of course I was happy for her but it still felt like I’d been punched in the stomach. I don’t think you are a true friend to this woman.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/01/2023 11:57

For me it depends on whether it’s a case of “oh God I need to have an abortion and I’m scared shitless” - in which case I’ll absolutely listen and help - or “oh my God I managed to get pregnant without even trying, that’s so surprising, did you know women can get pregnant so easily, or am I some kind of fertile superhero, it’s all so SURPRISING in me land right now!” - in which case I won’t.

Appreciate everyone’s mileage is different though. And I’m in a weird category of childfree and infertile though the latter came with significant medical trauma so I’m sensitive to unusual things compared to most maybe.

SBHon · 14/01/2023 11:55

It’s a bit like a millionaire complaining they don’t know what to do about tax or investments to someone on the breadline.

Both people have problems and they’re both valid. But obviously it would be nice to be considerate about who you vent your problems to.

Calphurnia88 · 14/01/2023 11:55

I'm not quite clear on what has triggered this post, but of course you have a right to express your shock at an unplanned pregnancy. How you express it matters though, or at least it does if you want to be considerate of other people's feelings.

There's a big difference announcing your surprise pregnancy on Facebook (you mention social media) and seeking out someone you know has fertility issues to talk about your surprise pregnancy.

Which one is it?

AramintaLee · 14/01/2023 11:44

It's a matter of empathy and sensitivity.

I don't want children and am using contraception to avoid it as much as possible, but if I fell pregnant I wouldn't be broadcasting my feelings of disappointment and my termination plans to someone who was having fertility struggles.

Tandora · 14/01/2023 11:31

Lovethatforyou · 14/01/2023 08:52

You’re right - no one person’s feelings trump another’s. Our feelings are valid and important. But we can all make an effort to be considerate and kind.

Also imo, there is not much worse than wanting a baby that never comes. There are somethings, of course. But not much.

It’s an all consuming grief that doesn’t ease in time - devastating, painful and completely soul-destroying. Everything hurts. When it happened to me I wanted to live in a forest with no contact with people so I could just be alone with my pain rather than having to feel jealousy and bitterness and sadness towards other people who could do what I couldn’t. I didn’t think I’d survive it.
If you know you know.

Having been through it and come out of the other side over ten years later I’d always give someone going through infertility a break, leeway, extra understanding and forgiveness.

❤️