Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think all dogs should be muzzled in public?

220 replies

ToughTalker · 13/01/2023 20:10

By law.

Many things have been banned as dangerous where less people have been injured and killed.

Obviously we can’t ban dogs but it should be law to have them muzzled outside of your own property to reduce the injuries and deaths they cause.

OP posts:
rebecca100 · 13/01/2023 20:45

@anonymousMuse I love this post, an exact example of why specific breeds shouldn't be punished.
Your girl sounds lovely ☺️.
I bet these people would be horrified to know that Guide Dogs and Canine Partners use German Shepherds and police have been using rescue staffy's.

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 13/01/2023 20:45

It probably won't happen in my lifetime but I hope society moves away from its obsession with owning animals. Very few of them are necessary.

I wouldn't support all dogs being muzzled but I would support a total ban on off lead dogs except in designated fields etc, purchased and maintained by a large sum when someone buys a dog. All dogs to be registered, chipped and DNA entered on a database. Huge fines for breaches and dogs removed from offenders.

That won't stop attacks in the home but it would make life better for the many people who dislike being jumped at, sniffed or mauled while going about their daily business.

Before anyone starts the "Oh but the poor little doggies" line, please think if you have ever supported the killing of an animal so you could eat it. Be aware of double standards.

asblindasabat · 13/01/2023 20:44

DonnaDonna0 · 13/01/2023 20:17

I’d much prefer to muzzle some people than most dogs!

I’m with you on that!

Iamclearlyamug · 13/01/2023 20:44

anonymousMuse · 13/01/2023 20:40

FFS. Where to begin.

  1. In the vast majority of cases, dogs find muzzles are best distracting and at worst distressing. Therefore less tolerant and more likely to snap.
  2. what about service dogs who use their mouths to signal? And who don't want distracting by a bloody muzzle?
  3. What an overreaction to the small number of aggressive compared to the majority who are absolutely no trouble?
  4. Why are we punishing the dog for the owner and breeders piss poor care?
  5. How do gundogs and other working dogs do their job? I have a dog who could be considered "dangerous" according to her breed. Her jaw is more powerful than a lion's. She weighs approximately eight stone. She has NEVER put a foot wrong or uttered so much as a bark in aggression. She is utterly lethal with her rope toy when she swings it around, and she will kill all the feeling in your leg when she lays on you. I often wake up to find her laid on top of me in the night. She recently had an overnight in the vets for a routine operation and even they commended her behaviour as being the best they'd had all week. It's not rocket science; she knows I am Alpha, no exceptions. She knows DH and DD are to be respected, no exceptions. She is walked 2x a day, plus garden playtime. Fed four times a day. Given toys and puzzles to keep her mind occupied and is spent time with so she knows she's loved. Train the bloody owners and leave the dogs alone.

Couldn't agree more. I also have a dog who many people would class as 'dangerous'. Softest dog I've ever met bar none, immaculately trained and follows orders given by my 10 year old even though he weighs the same as she does 🤷‍♀️

gobbyshafto · 13/01/2023 20:43

LetsDoThis2023 · 13/01/2023 20:39

Men cause far more deaths
Cars cause far more deaths
House fires due to overloaded electrics

This.

Why should we care about any of these things when cancer kills more people?

WetBandits · 13/01/2023 20:42

anonymousMuse · 13/01/2023 20:40

FFS. Where to begin.

  1. In the vast majority of cases, dogs find muzzles are best distracting and at worst distressing. Therefore less tolerant and more likely to snap.
  2. what about service dogs who use their mouths to signal? And who don't want distracting by a bloody muzzle?
  3. What an overreaction to the small number of aggressive compared to the majority who are absolutely no trouble?
  4. Why are we punishing the dog for the owner and breeders piss poor care?
  5. How do gundogs and other working dogs do their job? I have a dog who could be considered "dangerous" according to her breed. Her jaw is more powerful than a lion's. She weighs approximately eight stone. She has NEVER put a foot wrong or uttered so much as a bark in aggression. She is utterly lethal with her rope toy when she swings it around, and she will kill all the feeling in your leg when she lays on you. I often wake up to find her laid on top of me in the night. She recently had an overnight in the vets for a routine operation and even they commended her behaviour as being the best they'd had all week. It's not rocket science; she knows I am Alpha, no exceptions. She knows DH and DD are to be respected, no exceptions. She is walked 2x a day, plus garden playtime. Fed four times a day. Given toys and puzzles to keep her mind occupied and is spent time with so she knows she's loved. Train the bloody owners and leave the dogs alone.

Only problem with this is that you didn’t attach a photo of the good girl 😌

anonymousMuse · 13/01/2023 20:40

FFS. Where to begin.

  1. In the vast majority of cases, dogs find muzzles are best distracting and at worst distressing. Therefore less tolerant and more likely to snap.
  2. what about service dogs who use their mouths to signal? And who don't want distracting by a bloody muzzle?
  3. What an overreaction to the small number of aggressive compared to the majority who are absolutely no trouble?
  4. Why are we punishing the dog for the owner and breeders piss poor care?
  5. How do gundogs and other working dogs do their job? I have a dog who could be considered "dangerous" according to her breed. Her jaw is more powerful than a lion's. She weighs approximately eight stone. She has NEVER put a foot wrong or uttered so much as a bark in aggression. She is utterly lethal with her rope toy when she swings it around, and she will kill all the feeling in your leg when she lays on you. I often wake up to find her laid on top of me in the night. She recently had an overnight in the vets for a routine operation and even they commended her behaviour as being the best they'd had all week. It's not rocket science; she knows I am Alpha, no exceptions. She knows DH and DD are to be respected, no exceptions. She is walked 2x a day, plus garden playtime. Fed four times a day. Given toys and puzzles to keep her mind occupied and is spent time with so she knows she's loved. Train the bloody owners and leave the dogs alone.
LetsDoThis2023 · 13/01/2023 20:39

Men cause far more deaths
Cars cause far more deaths
House fires due to overloaded electrics

This.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/01/2023 20:38

YABU. The majority of dogs aren’t dangerous. They should all be on leads in public places though and parents need to teach their children not to approach dogs.

LetsDoThis2023 · 13/01/2023 20:38

Don't be silly.
Dangerous breeds should just be banned.

StillMedusa · 13/01/2023 20:38

As previous posters have pointed out: most dog attacks occur within a home ; unfortunately there are PEOPLE who should not own dogs because they are substandard dog owners who generally go for badly bred breeds which need a high level of training. The vast majority of dogs are not dangerous.

Men cause far more deaths
Cars cause far more deaths
House fires due to overloaded electrics.

Why is a death due to an untrained animal somehow more outrageous than the death of a woman at the hands of her partner.. who at least in theory has intelligence and free will?

ps Dogs are definitely not all on leads in Australia!!!

WetBandits · 13/01/2023 20:37

XenoBitch · 13/01/2023 20:33

Have you seen the muzzles you can get for pugs? They end up looking like Hannibal Lecter.

People see a muzzled dog and assume they are aggressive.

Yep! There’s a lady I see on walks whose dog is muzzled but off lead, I was confused at first when he came quite close to me and my dog as his body language was entirely friendly, which is when she called over to say he’s only muzzled because he eats everything he finds. He’s become a regular zoomies buddy for my dog now when they see each other! 🥰

Peoniesandcream · 13/01/2023 20:37

More harm would come from them not being muzzled so it's common sense really.

EffortlessDesmond · 13/01/2023 20:37

I have a well trained, now elderly, bitch. I hardly ever put her on a lead, unless on a road. She's not keen on kids, and detours them, she's not very sociable generally. And we walk in proper country. On 8K today we saw one person, with another gundog breed. They sniffed each other politely, had a 20 second chase and walked on with their humans. Where do you all live that you think that dogs are such a problem? The problem comes from people who want butch fighting dogs, and train them for aggression.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 13/01/2023 20:37

Here in NI we have had a spate of attacks on women by men resulting in things ranging from death to serious injury - can we have them muzzled as well then, or at least some sort of chastity belt type thing for them? Maybe a curfew?
In all seriousness, this won't work because trust me us well behaved, hard working dog owners are the ones who obey laws for our dogs, and the ones who own the dogs who do the attacking don't.

TrentCrimm · 13/01/2023 20:36

No. The vast majority of dogs will never present a problem to any member of the public.

I say this as someone who did muzzle a foster dog, because we just weren't 100% sure how he would react to certain situations. He never once resisted us putting the muzzle on him, but the way his whole demeanour changed to sadness when we fastened it on, was really upsetting.

I still think in those circumstances we were right to muzzle, but it's not something I would do for no concrete reason.

happygertie · 13/01/2023 20:36

Fucking stupid idea

curlymacv · 13/01/2023 20:35

bellswithwhistles · 13/01/2023 20:31

Why should my gorgeous Golden Retriever have to wear a muzzle just because some awful people can't control their dogs acquired purposely to be aggressive?!

let's be honest, when was the last time you saw a golden retriever being walked around in a rough area! Or a dangerous dog by a well to do lady?

Bit judgemental there...

But yes you're being unreasonable. Muzzles won't stop the behaviour other people seem annoyed by, like jumping up, or dogs running at them. Plus as other people said most of the attacks happen in the home...

echt · 13/01/2023 20:33

If you muzzle dogs in public, why not have a curfew on men?

Same reason, most of the shit happens at home.

XenoBitch · 13/01/2023 20:33

Have you seen the muzzles you can get for pugs? They end up looking like Hannibal Lecter.

People see a muzzled dog and assume they are aggressive.

rebecca100 · 13/01/2023 20:33

@ghjklo deed not breed!
Breed specific legislation is outrageous. Are you aware that any breed of dog is capable of biting, even the small ones? I used to work with seized dogs and believe me, they come in all shapes and sizes.
I agree that if necessary a dog should be muzzled, that should be on a case by case basis, not a blanket rule for certain breeds.

Suzi888 · 13/01/2023 20:32

Humans probably cause the most damage and deaths, yet here we are.

WetBandits · 13/01/2023 20:32

Nope. My dog has been trained to wear a muzzle in specific circumstances, such as when anyone comes into my home to work, as he is nervous of strangers in his home (nothing has ever happened but I don’t want to take any chances) and for vet trips as again, whilst nothing has ever happened, I don’t want to ever run the risk of him being startled when he is having jabs and snap at the vet. He doesn’t mind the muzzle and behaves normally when he’s got it on.

I wouldn’t want to muzzle him in public and have some other unmuzzled dog off lead come and attack him and him be left utterly defenceless. Also, rightly or wrongly and as unlikely as it is, if someone attacked me whilst I was walking him, he would absolutely defend me, and he couldn’t do that if he was muzzled.

I do think that any dog known to bite or who is likely to fight another dog if given the chance should be always be on lead and, if appropriate, muzzled.

XenoBitch · 13/01/2023 20:31

Stellaris22 · 13/01/2023 20:25

You're not meant to feed bread to ducks.

Not only that, you often get a kid come running at them and scare them all off. Maybe that kid should be on a leash of some kind.

BCxx · 13/01/2023 20:31

They’d be far better clamping down on all the dodgy breeding and dogs changing hands from people just getting rid of them all the time. Most dogs bite for a reason unfortunately. Far too many inexperienced people are buying these fashionable breeds and it’s ending in tears 😔 I’ve had dogs all my life and none have ever tried to bite so muzzling them outwith our house would just be a waste of time, like banning cars and making everyone cycle everywhere because of a relatively small number of drunk drivers

Swipe left for the next trending thread