Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think all dogs should be muzzled in public?

220 replies

ToughTalker · 13/01/2023 20:10

By law.

Many things have been banned as dangerous where less people have been injured and killed.

Obviously we can’t ban dogs but it should be law to have them muzzled outside of your own property to reduce the injuries and deaths they cause.

OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 14/01/2023 13:49

Straight to the nuclear option! No, all dogs should not be muzzled in public. Also, show me a muzzle for the many designer brachycephalic dogs out there?

maeveiscurious · 14/01/2023 13:47

Passpass · 13/01/2023 20:28

Yep. It’s not just fatal attacks. Dogs and their irresponsible owners now overwhelm public places and spaces. People and especially children can’t run/play/congregate/eat without being jumped at, chased, scratched, lunged at, bitten, harassed. Enough.

Don't be ridiculous, our children played for years without any interaction with dogs.

Animal haters Biscuit

maeveiscurious · 14/01/2023 13:45

No, digs learn to socialise with play with mouthing with other dogs.

I think the incident had a set of circumstances which were nothing to do with the individual dogs.

Ariela · 14/01/2023 12:44

I disagree with@ToughTalker

A better thing to enforce would be all dogs on leads in public places. Simply because these days it seems very few people have control over their dog, and very few dogs appear to know the recall command.

MavisMcMinty · 14/01/2023 11:38

That’s like penalising everyone due to some people’s wrong doings - you just wouldn’t do that.

BREXIT.

Hiddenvoice · 13/01/2023 23:46

Nope I think this is unfair. My dog is anxious, we have taken on a dog who was previously mistreated, starved and beaten yet she is the most loveable little thing. She scares easily and due to this will bark when she feels intimidated. I have never walked her off leash unless she is in a secure environment with dogs and people she knows well. I will walk her in quiet places and if I’m heading towards something that I think might scare her then I take a wide birth. She wears a harness that says anxious on it. I keep her on a short lead when passing anyone. People regularly come up and just start patting her, they tell their kids to pat my dog. I say in advance to not pat her becuase she gets scared, she has never bitten anyone and I wouldn’t imagine she would but I’m a responsible owner and would not like to take that chance either.
Not all dogs should not be muzzled because some dogs are viscous. That’s like penalising everyone due to some people’s wrong doings - you just wouldn’t do that.
Those people who mistreat dogs and don’t know how to handle dogs should either have them taken away and given to people who know how to look after dogs or should be forced to go through proper pet training.
I also firmly disagree with muzzling certain breeds. Every breed is capable of attacking.

Phrenologistsfinger · 13/01/2023 23:28

I need my dog more than I need men, that’s for sure!

lifeinthehills · 13/01/2023 23:23

If I have to muzzle my dogs, I'll let them off lead. Then you'll see havoc from them.

As it is, they are on (extension) lead and perfectly under my control without a muzzle. Better situation.

I'm not prepared to have them muzzled and on a lead. That would take all the fun out of it for them.

staciea31 · 13/01/2023 23:20

I think this is the most ridiculous statement ever my baby girl does not have a vicious bone in her body and I would not muzzle her when there is no need to I think every dog is different and a responsible owner knows when and where their dog needs a muzzle if they do I think more people than dogs need to have a muzzle on

lifeinthehills · 13/01/2023 23:20

magicthree · 13/01/2023 23:18

You're not meant to feed bread to ducks.

As long as it's not their sole food source it's fine.

The problem is that they eat it dry and then drink and it swells up painfully in their stomach. If they must be fed bread, it needs to be thrown in the water and wet first.

magicthree · 13/01/2023 23:18

You're not meant to feed bread to ducks.

As long as it's not their sole food source it's fine.

LexMitior · 13/01/2023 23:10

Well, if you want stupid dog owner just go the pets section where a woman is asking if it is problem that her dog repeatedly growls at her one year old child.

What hope do you have for public control if this is the house. At least she is thinking about separating them

Duchess379 · 13/01/2023 23:09

I think a lot of people should be muzzled in public tbf

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 13/01/2023 23:03

Ridiculous

Velvian · 13/01/2023 23:03

YABU, but I do think all dogs should be on leads in public, other than specific fenced in areas

brews · 13/01/2023 23:01

Maybe not muzzled but a mandatory lead unless on private land? I would be keen.

We live in a rural area where many locals/ visitors walk their dogs off lead (not to mention people are oblivious to fields with pregnant ewes in.) My DH and DD are both runners, husband has been bitten several times and DD has been chased/snapped at a few times, not bitten, but shaken up 😓. It's tough one as most dog owners are responsible and can manage their dogs well, but the few spoil it for everybody

lifeinthehills · 13/01/2023 23:00

Mine are always on lead (extension). If they had to be muzzled, I might start letting them off lead.

iiojdasdewe · 13/01/2023 22:58

It's a pretty simple risk vs. reward analysis isn't it? The cost of policing such a rule far outweighs the risk (because the risk of being bitten by the dog of a law-abiding citizen in a public place is absolutely minuscule).

LexMitior · 13/01/2023 22:56

Interesting article. The scale of dog biting attracting a lawyer do specialize in suing the owners is telling. If there is money in it for lawyers, it's a growing problem.

ToughTalker · 13/01/2023 22:49

amp.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/apr/15/dog-bite-britain-the-problem-with-the-pandemic-puppy-explosion

The numbers quoted are only hospital admissions not people going to their GP to get tetanus shots or antibiotics for infected bites. Nor patching a wound up at home. The true number is likely to be double those quoted at a conservative estimate.

@XelaM would that poor lady have died though if the owners had no choice but to provide muzzles for their dogs or risk them being confiscated or a heavy fine? I doubt they would agree if there wasn’t a legal consequence.

I know I and my DC would feel a lot safer walking in the park or walking to and home from school if all the dogs running around were muzzled!

Dogs are trainable aren’t they? I’m sure there’d be a market for a type of muzzle to be developed that they can get used to? Even old dogs can bite.

As for dog attacks happening in people’s homes, that’s their property and they are responsible for what their animal does inside it. They keep them at their own risk and should face heavy criminal penalties if they injure or kill anyone while in their home.

Not interested in whataboutery. We need men and cars (and even tumble dryers in a UK winter), we don’t NEED dogs (apart from service dogs), dog ownership is not a right and should come with rules to protect the public as they are inflicted on them.

OP posts:
StoppinBy · 13/01/2023 22:48

LexMitior · 13/01/2023 21:37

@StoppinBy - what you have said is basically against the idea of any regulatory effort on public safety. There will always be people who flout the law - the point is that you can do something to address an issue.

Muzzling is extreme. A lead law in any public park with a childrens playground? Maybe a very good idea

I disagree with your take on my post.

Muzzling legislation like suggested would be disproportionate to both the issue of dog attacks and the benefit that would be achieved by implementing and trying to enforce it.

My point was, you will end up with a whole lot of dogs who are muzzled unnecessarily and the dogs who are owned by irresponsible owners still wont be muzzled while roaming or running off lead in places they shouldn't be.

lifeinthehills · 13/01/2023 22:42

LuvSmallDogs · 13/01/2023 22:33

I think the thing with very small cutesie breeds is that people respect them less as a dog.

I've seen videos online of people annoying their clearly wound up little dog, then laughing as it tries to snap at them. If it were a staffy they a) wouldn't do that and b) would get a nasty scar.

I admit I didn't take mine to training classes, but she's toilet trained, has good recall, knows "wait" to mean "stay" and "house" to go inside.

Yes to the first paragraph. It's rude for people to just pick up your dog anyway. If your dog bit someone who just picked them up, it would be blamed on 'the awful dog'.

Mine are on the larger side of small so get more respect, but people just don't get that they are still dogs with teeth and instincts if they feel threatened. It's never been a problem and I don't think it would be, but stay off my dog! They are not cuddly toys, even if they are cute.

LexMitior · 13/01/2023 22:40

@Frequency - the reports are grim, it appears that some of these dogs were chasing people and horses before the attack and another woman is in hospital.

Probably professional dog walkers need limits, and muzzles for their charges. This woman would have lived then.

eastegg · 13/01/2023 22:37

Stellaris22 · 13/01/2023 20:25

You're not meant to feed bread to ducks.

Good grief how to miss the point….

Frequency · 13/01/2023 22:36

There are no regulations around dog training or dog walking. Any old tom, dick or harry can declare themselves a "professional" dog trainer with zero education or experience. You only have to look at some of the "trainers" recommended on here to see that. Almost everything they teach flies in the face of the actual science surrounding canine behaviour.

You can love dogs and still be clueless about their behaviour. The fact that pack theory is still touted as law by well-meaning, otherwise-loving dog owners (as seen on this very thread) proves that.

Also, I've seen many, many walkers walking large groups of dogs off lead, some of whom had very little control over their charges. I tend to avoid popular spots with "professional" dog walkers for this very reason.

There needs much more regulation around dogs in general, breeding, training, walking, and rescuing all need to be tightly regulated.