Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think work no longer ‘pays’

529 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/01/2023 19:38

This is a controversial topic so I’m expecting a few biscuits to be thrown at me so I’ve got my hard hat on. Inspired by the ‘benefits overhaul’ thread.

I often see on here that working and owning your own home is always better than claiming benefits and living in social housing. But it seems like the perks are long gone if I’m honest.

It feels like every day I’m dragging myself up at 6am to take my daughter to nursery (when I would much rather have her at home with me), just to pay our enormous mortgage and bills, before breaking even at the end. We haven’t had a holiday in 5 years. A few months ago I went into my overdraft for the first time in about 6-7 years despite the fact my spending is no different. What are the upsides again? Is it just that we get to choose the care home we die in (perhaps)? Because right now I’m feeling pretty pissed off with the whole thing and wondering if anyone else feels the same.

OP posts:
Nogreens · 14/01/2023 13:41

You are right but shhh, you must not offend. Everybody deserve a good quality of life whether they work for it or not.

orbitalcrisis · 14/01/2023 13:40

Single parent with one child calculation. Where I live local housing allowance for a 2 bedroom property is £897.52/month, cheapest 2 bedroom place on rightmove within 10 miles currently £1000/month (£1300 within 3 miles). Pretty much no social housing unless you wait in temporary accommodation for years. Further away is mildly cheaper but the local housing allowance is lower in that area so nothing saved, add the moving costs, new school, new uniform, ect. if there's even a school place available there...

Universal credit amount: £1477.01

rent: 1000
council tax: 56

Leaves £421.01 for bills, food, etc.

For that you must spent 35 hours a week job searching and prove it or face sanction. Attend regular meetings at the job centre that cannot be rearranged without being sanctioned. Answer questions on your journal within a few hours or face sanction.

You can also be evicted from your rental property for no reason at all after the initial contract length, usually 1 year. Then out of all your riches you have to pay moving costs, agency fees, deposit and first months rent all up front. Last time I moved I had paid out almost £5500 before my housing element was updated, despite the only thing changing being the address. I also had to pay to have the carpets cleaned and the kitchen and bathroom deep cleaned as per my tenancy agreement, while also fighting to get my deposit and rent over payment back, and the over payment from the utility companies who always claim there's a cheque in the post. Life of Riley, right? Being poor is extremely expensive.

StarDolphins · 14/01/2023 13:36

Jojobees · 13/01/2023 19:44

1 child at home whilst on universal credit will get you £750-800 per month. If that leaves you better off than a job go for it.

I would. I can easily live on that (but I’m in the v lucky position of no mortgage) But I can’t because I’ve saved & done without for many years. So no help for me. Doesn’t pay to be fugal.

DogBowlsAreMyWeapon · 14/01/2023 13:35

@BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn your poor friend has really been through the mill and she has my deepest sympathies. However there is no “charge” on unused space.

I’m in a 3-bed council and my rent is £92/week. It is £92 whether all 3 of us are here or whether I’m alone. I will not be charged “extra” when they leave home.

Grumpybutfunny · 14/01/2023 13:27

The baby years are hard OP. Coming out the other side now and we have 1 child, I stayed in work and went back when he was 4 months. He's now 9 he loves the expensive holidays and nice house we have as I've climbed the ladder as I didn't take to much time out. He can't remember the baby years, the memories he has will be from now. Because I'm senior I get most weekends off vs trying to get my career back if I had wait until he was at school.

In the baby years I think it's about surviving and keep your career alive so once they are school you can give them the best life possible.

We are likely to be unable to retire before DS has kids (we had him at 22) so will look after any grand kids around our shifts and likely pay half of his childcare bill (assuming his wife's family pay the other half). I think the government fails woman by not offering free childcare from the end of maternity leave for the 1st child. Even allowing them to deduct the full cost of childcare from tax they pay would be a massive benefit

TimeToFlyNow · 14/01/2023 13:22

You could cut your hours to get state hand outs if you like, you must both be on really low incomes though

And you wouldn't be any better off financially

Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 13:22

What exactly IS the truth? All you’ve done is talk in circles.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 14/01/2023 13:21

Looking at another life stage - how easy is life for someone with children and on benefits?

A friend of mine is a single parent and was lucky enough to get social housing - a nice house, in a good area of town close to the childrens' school and withing walking distance of the shops. Jackpot, right?

But then her children passed the threshold for sharing a room and she was deemed to be overcrowded, so they moved her. To a less nice house that needed significant repairs (and decorating, including new flooring that she had to pay for herself - not all the costs are paid for you), in a village several miles away with no shop and little public transport. So she had extra costs for heating a larger house with poor insulation and bad windows, and needed to use the car a lot more. Then one of her children died and she was hit with the spare room charge. She couldn't find a swap to downsize that was within reasonable distance of the school. Then her older child went to university - 2 spare rooms, 2 x spare room charge.

There are very few social housing properties small enough to avoid that charge for a single adult so she's stuck in a house she doesn't like, in an area with no jobs, paying a penalty for extra rooms - one of which she didn't ask for in the first place.

Isn't she fortunate?

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:20

Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 13:18

No I’m not comparing the 2 I’m pointing out you are just full of rubbish. Thinking you are better than everyone else here and your finances are in control because you don’t get universal credit but they clearly aren’t, and you are no better than anyone else.

They are under control. All payments have been made but we are moving somewhere cheaper so we don’t just break even every month. That’s called taking responsibility. Not cutting my hours to get a state handout. You just don’t like the truth.

OP posts:
Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 13:18

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:15

Haha; another one trying to compare the general high cost of living to getting free handouts from.. oh yeah, me 🙄

No I’m not comparing the 2 I’m pointing out you are just full of rubbish. Thinking you are better than everyone else here and your finances are in control because you don’t get universal credit but they clearly aren’t, and you are no better than anyone else.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:15

Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 13:13

Well aren’t you just better than everyone! Yet you still can’t afford your home or a holiday and you are due to have another baby soon too. Your children are also affected by your money. Do you not get child benefit? Isn’t that money handed out that you don’t pay back?

Haha; another one trying to compare the general high cost of living to getting free handouts from.. oh yeah, me 🙄

OP posts:
Happin · 14/01/2023 13:15

Would you prefer handouts, having to constantly prove you're looking for a job and go for interviews, not affording the basics never mind meals out, holidays, and never having a way of increasing this potential. Or would you prefer having a job that you can work your way up in to earn better to make a better lifestyle for yourself?

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:15

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:12

You’re trying to be all cutting and ‘see! See! You have a MORTGAGE YOU CANT AFFORD!’ Like that is any comparison to free state handouts. It isn’t. And we all know it.

No, im saying you don’t have to worry about benefit claimants because they’re not affecting your already precarious financial situation. But what you can do is think about how you can make your own situation better.

Coffeellama · 14/01/2023 13:13

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:10

But my financial choices only affect me. I will suffer the direct consequences of not paying my mortgage, or going into an overdraft. It’s not the same as just getting handouts from other people which you don’t pay back and don’t earn. If you can’t work that out you’re literally not up to having this conversation.

Well aren’t you just better than everyone! Yet you still can’t afford your home or a holiday and you are due to have another baby soon too. Your children are also affected by your money. Do you not get child benefit? Isn’t that money handed out that you don’t pay back?

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:12

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:11

Well, you and your family. Particularly your kid, if your poor financial planning means you can’t afford to send them to nursery any more.

You’re trying to be all cutting and ‘see! See! You have a MORTGAGE YOU CANT AFFORD!’ Like that is any comparison to free state handouts. It isn’t. And we all know it.

OP posts:
TimeToFlyNow · 14/01/2023 13:12

Well private renting isn't great. We had to move 4 times in 6 years . You are welcome to try it if you like

And even if you get some or all of your hb paid they aren't going to pay your moving costs.

Obviously the council may then re house you , usually after you've spent some months/years in a homeless shelter

Then when your child is older you will need to try and get back into the work place and work your way back up again

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:11

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:10

But my financial choices only affect me. I will suffer the direct consequences of not paying my mortgage, or going into an overdraft. It’s not the same as just getting handouts from other people which you don’t pay back and don’t earn. If you can’t work that out you’re literally not up to having this conversation.

Well, you and your family. Particularly your kid, if your poor financial planning means you can’t afford to send them to nursery any more.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/01/2023 13:11

Also, my house has increased in value by nearly £100k in 5 years, despite me doing absolutely fuck all. One of the biggest perks of home ownership - you can trade up in very little time. Much harder in council housing and impossible when renting (if anything it works the other way in renting - of the 8 properties I rented over the years, the nicest was the cheapest, and the first one I rented).

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:10

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:07

You don’t have to start slinging insults, this is a friendly space. I’m just asking you to reflect on your own financial choices before getting stuck into someone else’s.

But my financial choices only affect me. I will suffer the direct consequences of not paying my mortgage, or going into an overdraft. It’s not the same as just getting handouts from other people which you don’t pay back and don’t earn. If you can’t work that out you’re literally not up to having this conversation.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:09

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:00

Plus I pay it back, in fact I have to. Should people have to pay their UC back then, pumper?

But again, thinking of your own choices - could you have pre-empted the £20 of overdraft and sold the furniture first? Do you have an interest-free overdraft? Would it be financially viable for you and your husband to cut to four days per week instead of full time, and save two days of nursery fees?

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 13:07

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 12:59

😆

Oh please that’s a shit ‘comparison’ and you know it! You just look a bit silly.

You don’t have to start slinging insults, this is a friendly space. I’m just asking you to reflect on your own financial choices before getting stuck into someone else’s.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:07

Onnabugeisha · 14/01/2023 13:06

They do, everyone pays in advance and after- it’s this innovative sort of payment called “taxes”

Being directly liable for your own debts is not the same as throwing a few quid into a pot that you then take £100 out of.

OP posts:
fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/01/2023 13:06

Of course it pays. I live in my own home, where no landlord can dictate what I do, run monthly inspections, put my housing costs up, evict me etc. I’m not at the mercy of a benefits system that can change as the wind changes. If I don’t like my working circumstances I can try to change them.

None of that would be possible if I didn’t do my job. Yes, my job is very tiring (I’m currently on reduced hours due to burnout) and I don’t have a lot left over, but the value of my personal freedom is incalculable.

Wages should absolutely be increased across the board though. Nobody in full time work should need their rent paid - public money shouldn’t be paying off a person’s second/third/thirtieth home’s mortgage for them. I’d also support universal basic income.

Onnabugeisha · 14/01/2023 13:06

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:00

Plus I pay it back, in fact I have to. Should people have to pay their UC back then, pumper?

They do, everyone pays in advance and after- it’s this innovative sort of payment called “taxes”

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/01/2023 13:00

Plus I pay it back, in fact I have to. Should people have to pay their UC back then, pumper?

OP posts: