Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think work no longer ‘pays’

529 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 13/01/2023 19:38

This is a controversial topic so I’m expecting a few biscuits to be thrown at me so I’ve got my hard hat on. Inspired by the ‘benefits overhaul’ thread.

I often see on here that working and owning your own home is always better than claiming benefits and living in social housing. But it seems like the perks are long gone if I’m honest.

It feels like every day I’m dragging myself up at 6am to take my daughter to nursery (when I would much rather have her at home with me), just to pay our enormous mortgage and bills, before breaking even at the end. We haven’t had a holiday in 5 years. A few months ago I went into my overdraft for the first time in about 6-7 years despite the fact my spending is no different. What are the upsides again? Is it just that we get to choose the care home we die in (perhaps)? Because right now I’m feeling pretty pissed off with the whole thing and wondering if anyone else feels the same.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Burgoo · 15/01/2023 19:29

I know I am privileged. I get to go away when I like, I have a mortgage which will be paid in 25 years, I have a pension pot and I can go out for dinner whenever I fancy it. Does work pay for me? Yes.

AND it is a total rip-off which, had I a lesser paying job, I would be furious about. Because of my situation I have to pay:

  1. Ridiculous interest rates that aren't in my control much of the time for the mortgage
  2. VAT
  3. National Insurance
  4. Income Tax
  5. Fuel Duty
  6. Vehicle Tax
  7. Council Tax
  8. TV licence
  9. Stamp duty (when I bought the place)
  10. Inheritance Tax when I die (my daughter will have to pay)
  11. Prescriptions

Those are just the ones I can think of. It's ludicrous. I feel like the middle earners take an absolute kicking at every turn. We aren't entitled to much at all, we haven't got enough to be "rich" and comfortable and at the same time we keep the country going. We subsidise big companies paying lower earners shit wages (universal credit etc).

What incentive does anyone in my position have to work? If I were not with my partner who is also in the same pay bracket as me, I'd be screwed. I often feel that the rich can off-shore and have expensive lawyers who can get tax breaks and the poor get hand-outs. When do people who are in my spot get any kind of leg up?

Grumpybutfunny · 15/01/2023 19:20

@Maverickess yes enforced child payment taken off at source and a public flogging to boot for not paying up. I would love to see it be a crime to not pay punishable by prison or chain gangs. I would love to see town billboards with picture of the parents who don't pay child support.

On a practical level I would mandate schools and nurseries have to provide wrap around care including holiday camps etc and make it free. Shared houses for families can work, especially things like supported living for people in your sort of situation. You could even do them like halls of residence with shared childcare facilities. I would happily pay more in tax to fund situations like that so parents can work, rather than fund out of work benefits.

Critically illness policies for businesses include cover for those more vulnerable and as they are group policies they are significantly cheaper as the risk is spread. Businesses can also insure having to provide sick pay (think it's up to 6 months at full pay).

I'm not inhumane I do think we need a safety net I just think it goes to far as it is. It allows barriers to work to be over come by being funded not to work instead of removing those barriers.

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/01/2023 17:38

AnElegantChaos · 15/01/2023 14:04

So you're advocating forced labour? There's another word for that.

Your post is repellent.

Agreed. Its disgusting and makes me despair that people can be so lacking in basic human empathy and compassion.

It is they who are failures in life. Not benefit claimants.

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/01/2023 17:33

SilverGlitterBaubles · 15/01/2023 14:41

@Grumpybutfunny Critical illness cover is cost can be extremely high if you have any existing health problems, a family history of heart disease, cancer etc or if you have smoked or are overweight. In some cases insurers will refuse to provide cover at all. This is not the answer.

They never let facts get in the way.....

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/01/2023 17:32

WHY shouldn’t we aim for more than managing, though? And how do you define managing, even? Why is the optimum seen as whatever country is offering the lowest?

We’ve designed this world, and it’s so depressing to hear people say that managing is sufficient for anyone who isn’t basically a capitalist machine.

I’ve been really poor and it was dreadful. It angers me that single people are treated so badly compared to families. But mostly it angers me that the only people who many want to see have any enjoyment in life are those who are well-paid.

I have a decentish job, higher rate taxpayer, I manage being single because I’m frugal. But if I had a kid, I’d want better than this for them. Not just the kids whose parents can afford private school and Bupa and who don’t think they’ll ever become vulnerable in any way.

Maverickess · 15/01/2023 17:18

Benefits aren't pittance either! Benefits are meant to be the minimum standard so a room in a shared house, basic food and enough free time to look for paid employment. They are not an opportunity to make sure you are home for the school run etc. When DS was really little we worked opposite shifts with one weekend off together every 8 weeks so we didn't have a massive childcare bill and could establish ourselves in our careers. DS doesn't remember a minute of it and it's put us in a good position.

@Grumpybutfunny how would you address a situation like mine, where I needed to be available for school runs some days because my DD's father decided, after the event, that being a responsible adult and co- supporting the child he co-created wasn't for him a few years in, and the childcare options swung from very good to non existent and back again over the course of the years I needed them? There was no one to work opposite shifts with, they walked away.
What exactly are the options, small child in shared accomodation with not enough basic food for two because it's designed to support one, and do what with said child outside of school hours while I 'volunteer', work or seek work?
Mandatory adoption because my partner decided he just didn't want to any more?
Shove her back?
Enforce payment of child support?
Or, let me guess, perhaps tell me I'm getting what I deserve because I should have chosen better, while ignoring the fact that he's the one not taking responsibility and thus encouraging such behaviour? I think I know which option you'd be going for.

ZHC jobs are not those aimed at working families, we have some ZHC at work they are all taken by young adults looking for work around college/university or woman wanting to earn pocket money. My MIL works a zero hour contract now she semi retired to pay for holidays etc.

Then the government need to step in and at least ensure that essential jobs like supermarkets and care homes, that will always have minimum hours that need to be covered, offer proper contracts at full time hours, I agree that they were never aimed at working families, but the reality is they are used so employers keep their costs down in jobs where they don't need to be used, because they always have hours to cover. They should exist, but only for as and when jobs, seasonal stuff where demand rises and falls, not to keep costs low for employers, and then have people like you blaming the people getting those jobs for taking them because they're all that's on offer - and don't start with the people have choices, because as a society if we want care homes and supermarkets then we need people to work in them.

So many people with attitudes like yours have no issue at all with using the services provided by those working in the type of jobs where zero hour contracts keep costs to business and therefore customers lower, only with said workers needing support when they can't live on the results of those artificially low prices. Funny that.

CecilyP · 15/01/2023 17:07

We definitely do not need to create more jobs for nursery workers. Nurseries are understaffed already and crying out for people who want to work in them!

That suggests there is already a surplus of jobs and a shortage of workers to fill them.

Bettyboop3 · 15/01/2023 16:49

CecilyP · 15/01/2023 16:21

I don't think the government should be paying for 39 weeks off. I would rather they put that money into nurseries creating jobs in the process.

Do we need more jobs for nursery workers. Is it easy to recruit at the moment? There must be a finite number of people wanting to work looking after other people’s sprogs. Not to mention the added costs of buildings to house all these nurseries. It’s probably more cost effective to fund maternity leave.

We definitely do not need to create more jobs for nursery workers. Nurseries are understaffed already and crying out for people who want to work in them!

CecilyP · 15/01/2023 16:23

And as for critical illness cover, then DH was unable to get it after suffering a heart attack in his 40s. However you’ll be relieved to know he’s actually a high earner who has not claimed any benefits since.

CecilyP · 15/01/2023 16:21

I don't think the government should be paying for 39 weeks off. I would rather they put that money into nurseries creating jobs in the process.

Do we need more jobs for nursery workers. Is it easy to recruit at the moment? There must be a finite number of people wanting to work looking after other people’s sprogs. Not to mention the added costs of buildings to house all these nurseries. It’s probably more cost effective to fund maternity leave.

Zombiemum1946 · 15/01/2023 15:50

Critical illness cover !!! I haven't been able to get that since my cancer at 35. Life insurance companies won't even look at me. Some people have no idea just how quickly it can all fall apart at no fault of your own. Given the current cost crisis this thread is sickening in it's blaming of those struggling. I've been there as a child and an adult, it's shit not luxury or fun.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 15:39

DuringDuranDuran3 · 15/01/2023 15:19

I was made redundant

I received £74 a week contributions based job seekers payment for a few weeks

Try living off that !

I got a job quickly

It is better to be in work

JSA isn't the lap of luxury some people might think it is - and it's taxable.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 15:38

I took 4 months off which we funded

Good for you. Now try and get your head around the fact that not everyone can afford to do that.

Jengnr · 15/01/2023 15:28

Kpo58 · 13/01/2023 19:42

Which could then be taken away again if you end up in a care home.

It isn’t ‘taken off you’ you sell one home to pay for another.

pointythings · 15/01/2023 15:25

@Grumpybutfunny it's easy to cover opposite shifts if you aren't a single parent...

The American system of not offering more than 10 weeks mat leave is really not something to aspire to - I have relatives in the US and believe me, they aren't happy with it. At 10 weeks you aren't even close to physically recovering from the birth even if you've had a normal vaginal birth.

You're advocating for going backwards in terms of rights for workers. Why not look at countries where things are better for workers, not worse? Right now you're coming across as an extreme capitalism red in tooth and claw libertarian. It's not a good look.

DuringDuranDuran3 · 15/01/2023 15:19

I was made redundant

I received £74 a week contributions based job seekers payment for a few weeks

Try living off that !

I got a job quickly

It is better to be in work

Grumpybutfunny · 15/01/2023 15:16

FortSalem86 · 15/01/2023 14:34

My work place only offers a contract of guaranteed hours if you are fully flexible. If you are a parent, carer or disabled you are discriminated against basically.

We both work 24/7 shifts and because we are loyal they help us out so they are basically opposite shifts. We in turn help them out covering shifts etc when we can.
If we were awkward and didn't cover shift I don't imagine the same flexibility would be offered.

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain I took 4 months off which we funded. American maternity leave is only 10 weeks unpaid and they manage. In truth a lot of companies offer employees more as a benefit of employment. I don't think the government should be paying for 39 weeks off. I would rather they put that money into nurseries creating jobs in the process.

Group critical illness policies are surprisingly cheap for companies to offer. Considering we are currently in a labour shortage it would be a good selling point for most employers.

HRTQueen · 15/01/2023 14:45

YANBU

I was better off as a student (mature student)

rent paid, no council tax, could earn a little, ds
nursery fees paid

I know a few newly qualified nurses who are in the same position

Im a mh unit manager I looking for another job as I simply can’t make ends meet it’s ridiculous and I feel cheated after I have put so much work in and worked so hard

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 14:42

and my having paid NI for nearly 50 years to accrue entitlement to a state pension should* actually entitle me to it,

I meant shouldn't, of course

SilverGlitterBaubles · 15/01/2023 14:41

@Grumpybutfunny Critical illness cover is cost can be extremely high if you have any existing health problems, a family history of heart disease, cancer etc or if you have smoked or are overweight. In some cases insurers will refuse to provide cover at all. This is not the answer.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 14:40

I would say anything but disability to be honest

So this applies when a woman has just given birth, she should be straight back to work? and my having paid NI for nearly 50 years to accrue entitlement to a state pension should actually entitle me to it, I have to keep working to maintain that entitlement?

No I don't think you should have the nice things in life unless you are working or can fund that lifestyle through other means such as savings or investments

As someone living on a SP I can't have anything nice, is that right? bang goes the smoked salmon sarnies then, and back to the sandwich spread with no butter - that's be too much of a luxury. Your argument pretty much is a good life (however defined) is for the rich.

Wind-up, and I fell for it. Well done.

JenniferBooth · 15/01/2023 14:36

@FortSalem86 And people like the OP wonder why there isnt an army of family carers to look after elderly relatives so they can be discharged from hospital

JenniferBooth · 15/01/2023 14:35

I also think critical illness cover should be mandatory

And how are care workers supposed to afford that ......oh i get it. What you are saying is you are happy to pay double what you pay now for elderly relatives in care homes so care workers can be paid more so they can afford critical illness cover. Ditto supermarket workers. You will be happy for food to go up so supermarket workers get paid more to afford this cover.

FortSalem86 · 15/01/2023 14:34

My work place only offers a contract of guaranteed hours if you are fully flexible. If you are a parent, carer or disabled you are discriminated against basically.

Grumpybutfunny · 15/01/2023 14:25

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/01/2023 13:47

Benefits are meant to be the minimum standard so a room in a shared house, basic food and enough free time to look for paid employment

I swear some people would love it if workhouses were re-opened. Any chance of an answer to my question about what benefits this would apply to?

I would say anything but disability to be honest. I also think critical illness cover should be mandatory. If you look at Asian families it's not unusual to hold down a day job and help in the family business on a weekend or even shock horror after doing a 8hour shift at work. Our local indian take away is run by a family, the youngest son is a FY2 doctor he still takes his turn to help his parents out and he would never say no to them. The other kids also have their own careers and businesses but you still see them helping.

No I don't think you should have the nice things in life unless you are working or can fund that lifestyle through other means such as savings or investments.

To me the state should fund education, health, security, investment and infrastructure investment in that order. We should set a tax limit at X% whatever is left can fund benefits.

State pensions should also be looked at, the money we pay in NI should be invested in the country's future. The return on that investment funds any increases, so the economy isn't growing pensioners don't get a rise just like the current situation with the emergency service, teachers etc.

Yes I do think if you can't fund yourself to stay home you should have to do something for the state to get hand outs. No one has the right to have kids they can't afford, we worked our finance out when DS was small and realised having a brother or sister for him wasn't viable so we didn't have one.