Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
Fladdermus · 13/01/2023 16:11

YABU. History tells us that in the discrimination mine religion is the canary. Mess with that protection at your peril.

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 16:03

SueVineer · 13/01/2023 16:02

Race can be changed as the law sees it. Eg someone can become Scottish or Jewish, etc. in addition sectarianism such as prejudice towards Catholics (or Protestants) in Northern Ireland or Scotland isn’t based on the belief of the victim - it’s based on how they were born.

Surely you can't change your race/genetics?

OP posts:
SueVineer · 13/01/2023 16:02

NewFoxOldTricks · 13/01/2023 14:15

I know where you are coming from (atheist here)

Sex, ethnicity etc cannot be changed, but you can change religion ,so why protect

Race can be changed as the law sees it. Eg someone can become Scottish or Jewish, etc. in addition sectarianism such as prejudice towards Catholics (or Protestants) in Northern Ireland or Scotland isn’t based on the belief of the victim - it’s based on how they were born.

JarByTheDoor · 13/01/2023 16:01

RunnerBum · 13/01/2023 15:40

Yes, the same applies to being colourblind. It’s not a disability and so it’s perfectly legal to refuse to hire someone because they’re colourblind or to fire someone (within two years of them starting) because they’re colourblind. It’s legal to refuse to let a property to colourblind people and legal to refuse service in a restaurant or shop to someone because they’re colourblind. However, interestingly enough, if you have a blanket ban on colourblind people then that’s technically indirect discrimination on the grounds of sex because the vast majority of colourblind people are men. It’s a very strange area of the law and there’s a lot of it that I don’t agree with.

Yep, a really complex area of the law. There's also the occasional tribunal result where coeliac disease is treated as a disability under the EA, but that tends to be where the person is symptomatic IIRC, so it seems you could get rid of someone because their weird spongy bread annoys you, as long as they aren't sick 😅

There's also a lot of complexities around definitions and potentially conflicting rights and exemptions and exceptions and, as you say, indirect discrimination, so combined with the fact it gets interpreted in so many different ways in different courts and tribunals, some of which set precedent and some of which don't, and the whole thing is hidden under layers and layers of "advice" from various interested parties that may or may not accord with what was intended or what actually happens when there are cases… ugh.

Goldshelfie · 13/01/2023 15:58

Sorry, that was for babyjellyfish at 14.18

Crabo · 13/01/2023 15:57

Giggorata · 13/01/2023 15:44

Since Christianity overlaid the indigenous pagan religions in the British Isles, it consistently persecuted pagans and witches and/or people they deemed witches, in some cases hanging and burning them; and there was widespread demonisation and reframing of the old gods.
Vestiges of this are still hanging on today in some quarters, with active prejudice and persecution against pagans, heathens and witches.
This, despite religion being a protected characteristic.
Not all religions.

It’s amazing how many people still believe this in spite of the fact that history proves against it.

SueVineer · 13/01/2023 15:57

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

You can’t be sacked for criticism of religion. You could be sack for being bullying or abusive to someone on the basis of their religion or race.

religion is generally closely tied to ethnicity eg Jews and sikhs were both recognized as a race prior to religion becoming a protected characteristic.

you can absolutely “voice your opinion” about religion. But if you are harassing or discriminating against people because you don’t like one religion or another then it’s fair enough that they protected from you.

why don’t you try to be more tolerant op - you don’t have to believe in any particular religion but why abuse people who do. Try to live and let live.

Teddeh · 13/01/2023 15:57

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/10:

Religion or belief:

(1)Religion means any religion and a reference to religion includes a reference to a lack of religion.

(2)Belief means any religious or philosophical belief and a reference to belief includes a reference to a lack of belief.

(3)In relation to the protected characteristic of religion or belief—

(a)a reference to a person who has a particular protected characteristic is a reference to a person of a particular religion or belief;

(b)a reference to persons who share a protected characteristic is a reference to persons who are of the same religion or belief.

Lack or absence of belief is also protected, just as much as any (established and recognised) belief system. Sometimes it's also quite complicated: for example, the discrimination against people who are believed and/or perceived to be Jewish, even though they do not practise Judaism: is that discrimination on the basis of race (which includes ethnic and national origins? or religion? Sometimes it is a combination. Similarly for the discrimination against Roman Catholics, or people perceived to be of Roman Catholic origin or affiliation, in Scotland: where is the dicrimination based - religion/belief? Race? It's really hard to say.

What, specifically, would you change about the law (if you were able to mandate changes) as it protects religion?

Goldshelfie · 13/01/2023 15:56

After the Forstater judgement it has been confirmed that a lack of belief in gender identity is protected. As long as you don’t go around harassing people you are protected if you don’t believe. That doesn’t mean you will not suffer any detriment in reality, but legally you shouldn’t.

Thefrogwife · 13/01/2023 15:54

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 15:10

I'm not white Northern European. I'm black, African and Caribbean background, my grandmother is Catholic and my mother is 'spiritual'. My dad is an atheist. I went to church as a child but stopped when I was about 14.

Apologies for the assumption!

I'm Jewish and most Jewish people I know would definitely see their religion as part of a broader cultural background- and it's that which needs protecting against discrimination, rather than the actual belief system.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 13/01/2023 15:52

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 14:54

There are also some faiths you can’t leave - Islam and now Catholicism so you are of that faith often due to where you or your parents were born in the world.

Well... of course people can leave the faith even if the organization says they can't. Our protected belief characteristic should help protect apostates.

Right, but again that's about who is making the decisions.

I have left the Catholic faith (100%) but if someone in a position of power came along and said that for the purposes of their laws anyone baptised Catholic is still Catholic, I couldn't change that. IIRC, Jews weren't allowed to convert in the later stages of Nazism. See also the 'one drop rule' in the USA.

purpledalmation · 13/01/2023 15:48

NewFoxOldTricks · 13/01/2023 14:15

I know where you are coming from (atheist here)

Sex, ethnicity etc cannot be changed, but you can change religion ,so why protect

Protected status is not about immutable characteristics. It's about having those differences protected. Clue is in the name.

NCGrandParent · 13/01/2023 15:45

I think you don't understand what protection is afforded under the Equality Act 2010.

Giggorata · 13/01/2023 15:44

Since Christianity overlaid the indigenous pagan religions in the British Isles, it consistently persecuted pagans and witches and/or people they deemed witches, in some cases hanging and burning them; and there was widespread demonisation and reframing of the old gods.
Vestiges of this are still hanging on today in some quarters, with active prejudice and persecution against pagans, heathens and witches.
This, despite religion being a protected characteristic.
Not all religions.

Headabovetheparakeet · 13/01/2023 15:40

I'm sure there will be people out there who would make the same argument about every protected characteristic.

Plenty of people would still be more than happy to make negative comments about homosexuality if they could get away with it.

Viviennemary · 13/01/2023 15:40

I assumed that protected characteristic means its something you should be free to practise not that people are prevented from saying they are an atheist. But Idon't think it's very tactful or kind to rubbish somebodys religion to their face.

RunnerBum · 13/01/2023 15:40

JarByTheDoor · 13/01/2023 15:24

The funny thing about this is that a few years ago, when government and local health boards wanted to reduce or get rid of gluten-free prescription food for coeliacs, lots of official documents were created which made it clear that coeliac disease is not considered a disability under the Equality Act. So, presumably, someone could refuse to hire me solely because I have coeliac disease and must follow a strict gluten-free diet. But since ethical vegetarianism is protected under the religion/belief characteristic, the vegetarian has a protection against discrimination that I don't have. And while vegetarianism is a choice, coeliac disease is most definitely not.

Going back to one of the OP's points, the whole choice thing is a bit of a red herring anyway. I can't choose to change my age or my race but I could choose to become disabled (if I weren't already), if I were willing to give myself an impairment that would qualify me under the Equality Act. Undergoing gender reassignment is a choice, although whatever led an individual to that decision may not have been chosen. People choose to get married or not to get married, and a lot of the time pregnancy and maternity have been chosen by the person protected by that category.

But I don't really think that people's beliefs — the things they think inside their head, rather than the things they do as a result of those thoughts — are truly chosen anyway. I can choose to act as though something is true even though I'm not sure or I think it's probably false, and I can choose to expose (or not expose) myself to things that I think may convince me that something is true (or false), I can train myself to avoid thinking in ways that may challenge things which I want to be true, but I can't directly choose to change what I believe to be true. No matter how much I wanted to, I couldn't make myself genuinely believe that I am a millionaire, or that cheese is made from coal, or that when I wake up tomorrow the sun will rise in the west.

Yes, the same applies to being colourblind. It’s not a disability and so it’s perfectly legal to refuse to hire someone because they’re colourblind or to fire someone (within two years of them starting) because they’re colourblind. It’s legal to refuse to let a property to colourblind people and legal to refuse service in a restaurant or shop to someone because they’re colourblind. However, interestingly enough, if you have a blanket ban on colourblind people then that’s technically indirect discrimination on the grounds of sex because the vast majority of colourblind people are men. It’s a very strange area of the law and there’s a lot of it that I don’t agree with.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/01/2023 15:40

Greensleeves · 13/01/2023 15:00

PMSL at "Is it Jews?" - are you quite well?

Personally, I tend to direct my ridicule at the brand of extremist Christian fundamentalism that, to my mind, is doing the most active damage to the society I live in - homophobic, transphobic, misogynistic, right-wing, repressive and cruel. The kind of literal Bible-believing fundamentalists who genuinely believe that a woman wearing trousers is "defrauding" men, and publish helpful manuals on how best to beat your infant without leaving a mark.

I'm not going to stop ridiculing, criticising and openly despising those churches and the damage they do, and I won't support a law that protects their right to go on destroying people's lives.

So, no. It isn't "Jews". FFS.

So it’s ok to skate Christian’s and laughable that you’d be accused of doing the same to another group? OK.

Extreme Christian’s aren’t the only religion who see women and gay people as second class citizens. Do you openly ridicule Muslims then? The extreme side of their faith also has discriminatory principles.

oohokay · 13/01/2023 15:35

Agreed for mainstream religion held by the majority of people, but 2 missing factors: (1) religion is often linked to ethnicity, so discriminating "legally" against minority religions could be a way to disguise ethnic discrimination (2) in many countries, conflict between different religions has had deadly mass consequences (eg civil war, riots).. We might say "this doesn't happen nowadays so we don't need anti religious discrimination legislation" but actually it might well be the other way round, that the legislation has nipped this in the bud well in advance

BunchHarman · 13/01/2023 15:31

I agree. But then I have really strong opinions on the fact that it is all clear bullshit anyway, and I struggle to reconcile intelligence with faith, even though plenty of religious people are intelligent.

thedancingbear · 13/01/2023 15:26

‘Sorry love, we’re sacking you because you’re Jewish. Nothing personal, you understand’

JarByTheDoor · 13/01/2023 15:24

RunnerBum · 13/01/2023 14:40

It covers a huge range of beliefs, including atheism. If memory serves, it also vegetarianism.

The funny thing about this is that a few years ago, when government and local health boards wanted to reduce or get rid of gluten-free prescription food for coeliacs, lots of official documents were created which made it clear that coeliac disease is not considered a disability under the Equality Act. So, presumably, someone could refuse to hire me solely because I have coeliac disease and must follow a strict gluten-free diet. But since ethical vegetarianism is protected under the religion/belief characteristic, the vegetarian has a protection against discrimination that I don't have. And while vegetarianism is a choice, coeliac disease is most definitely not.

Going back to one of the OP's points, the whole choice thing is a bit of a red herring anyway. I can't choose to change my age or my race but I could choose to become disabled (if I weren't already), if I were willing to give myself an impairment that would qualify me under the Equality Act. Undergoing gender reassignment is a choice, although whatever led an individual to that decision may not have been chosen. People choose to get married or not to get married, and a lot of the time pregnancy and maternity have been chosen by the person protected by that category.

But I don't really think that people's beliefs — the things they think inside their head, rather than the things they do as a result of those thoughts — are truly chosen anyway. I can choose to act as though something is true even though I'm not sure or I think it's probably false, and I can choose to expose (or not expose) myself to things that I think may convince me that something is true (or false), I can train myself to avoid thinking in ways that may challenge things which I want to be true, but I can't directly choose to change what I believe to be true. No matter how much I wanted to, I couldn't make myself genuinely believe that I am a millionaire, or that cheese is made from coal, or that when I wake up tomorrow the sun will rise in the west.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/01/2023 15:24

I always think it’s bizarre that people think that the universe came from nothing

The only people who think this are Creationists.

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 15:21

Crabo · 13/01/2023 15:14

Frankly most atheists I have met do not understand the true nature of faith anyway. I always think it’s bizarre that people think that the universe came from nothing. You might just as well say there is more probability that the information in Beethoven’s ninth Symphony evolved from nothing as that in the universe evolved from nothing without an agency. It just depends on your world view. What are the probabilities?The problem is we have been spoon fed this idea that because we know the mechanism we can dispense with the agency. That is something I do not accept

Spoon fed science...

OP posts:
Crabo · 13/01/2023 15:14

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 15:05

Ah yes, or maybe we are all just brains in vats! You know what I mean. I accept that God can never be disproven. Technically nothing can. Maybe I should have referred to probability as opposed to proof.

Frankly most atheists I have met do not understand the true nature of faith anyway. I always think it’s bizarre that people think that the universe came from nothing. You might just as well say there is more probability that the information in Beethoven’s ninth Symphony evolved from nothing as that in the universe evolved from nothing without an agency. It just depends on your world view. What are the probabilities?The problem is we have been spoon fed this idea that because we know the mechanism we can dispense with the agency. That is something I do not accept