Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 17:46

This is interesting on Jediism:

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/578931/Temple_of_the_Jedi_Order_FINAL_DECISION.pdf

The Temple of the Jedi Order applied for charitable status for the purposes of the advancement of religion and/or the promotion of moral and ethical
improvement for the benefit of the public. The Charity Commission refused their application.

It's not the same as a discrimination case because the Jediists had to prove it was a religion, which is a narrower definition than 'religion or belief' in the EA.

In their decision the Charity Commission said,

... the Commission is not satisfied that the observance of the Force within Jediism is characterised by a belief in one or more gods or spiritual or non-secular principles or things which is an essential requirement for a religion in charity law.

That would not preclude Jediism from being protected as a belief under the EA, however the Charity Commission did also look at the Grainger test and concluded that it failed the fourth requirement:

(iv) It must attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance.

As far as I know there was no attempt to appeal this decision.

There is interesting discussion of this case here, including whether the Charity Commission set too high a bar for cogency/coherence:

www.farrer.co.uk/news-and-insights/charity-commission-decision-the-temple-of-the-jedi-order/

If a Jediist was discriminated against in the workplace, provision of goods and services, education etc. it would be up to them to bring a case under the EA. The defendant would probably cite the Charity Commission decision but there are good arguments for a court or tribunal to not follow the Charity Commission on this point. As far as I know, Charity Commission decisions do not create legal precedent.

tappinginto2023 · 13/01/2023 17:45

You can be an atheist and not a dick.

I'm happy with people having rights and respect even if I don't think the same way they do. I don't find it threatening at all.

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 17:40

Yes, I'm not saying discrimination doesn't happen, obviously it does, just as discrimination happens against other religions/beliefs, and other protected characteristics.

But it is protected under religion or belief and it is possible for people to bring discrimination cases on those grounds.

GordonShakespearedoesChristmas · 13/01/2023 17:35

It's a shame that things have be legislated for in order to be given the respect they deserve.
The right to follow your chosen beliefs is at the core of humanity IMO, be that a religion, atheism or agnosticism.
These should all be respected. The Govt's British Values state that peoples religions, or no religion, should be respected and tolerated.
Your view that it is absurd etc is your right, but no one has the right to use that belief to discriminate in the workplace. Hence the law.
It works for you as well.

ancientgran · 13/01/2023 17:35

Greensleeves · 13/01/2023 14:17

I agree with you. Nobody has the right to have their belief in the supernatural respected/protected from scrutiny. Having the right to hold preposterous beliefs isn't the same as having the right to gag other people from interrogating them, or even ridiculing them.

I don't think you have a right to interrogate or ridicule people at work for any reason. You are supposed to be working.

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 17:32

TedMullins · 13/01/2023 16:53

Of course people should be protected from discrimination and bigotry because of their religion. They should be free to practice their beliefs without imposing them on others. But I do see your point. The stumbling block I have is protecting misogyny in the name of religion - e.g. accepting that men and women of some religions must be separated to go swimming, or that Catholics can spout anti-abortion rhetoric under the guise of faith. I'm not sure as a secular country we should be enabling the discriminatory practices of religion.

You're so uncertain about the basis for your pro-abortion views that you want it to be illegal to have those views challenged?

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 17:26

I have left the Catholic faith (100%) but if someone in a position of power came along and said that for the purposes of their laws anyone baptised Catholic is still Catholic, I couldn't change that.

In the U.K., now, the protection of your belief guards against this scenario.

I may be wrong but I've heard German ex-Catholics can find it hard to get out of the church tax, maybe that's the sort of thing you're thinking of?

PartySock · 13/01/2023 17:19

TedMullins · 13/01/2023 16:53

Of course people should be protected from discrimination and bigotry because of their religion. They should be free to practice their beliefs without imposing them on others. But I do see your point. The stumbling block I have is protecting misogyny in the name of religion - e.g. accepting that men and women of some religions must be separated to go swimming, or that Catholics can spout anti-abortion rhetoric under the guise of faith. I'm not sure as a secular country we should be enabling the discriminatory practices of religion.

I completely agree with you, but I would say we're not a secular country really, we are a secular population. The head of state is supreme head of the Church of England and so must be a member of that faith. All schools have to have broadly Christian assemblies daily (unless that ridiculous law has been repelled). If we were truly secular, then there would be a clear division between Church and State.

Elmo22 · 13/01/2023 17:19

I think religious tolerance (and tolerance in general!) is incredibly important. I am religious and have experienced discrimination. I suppose if you haven’t experienced it, it might seem as though it doesn’t happen. I absolutely don’t mind people having a different viewpoint to me about faith/belief but I do mind being verbally and/ or physically attacked because of it.

That’s why I think posts like this can stray in to dangerous territory.

shewolfsout · 13/01/2023 17:14

I think it's really important, otherwise you'll have schools feeding Muslims pork and Hindus beef, employers refusing to employ Jews, Muslims or Sikhs, or refusing for them to wear their religious head coverings or refusing them positions unless they don't wear them. Just because you don't believe in something, doesn't mean other people shouldn't and their rights to do so shouldn't be protected and them protected from discrimination. Also the idea that religion is chosen is erroneous in that for any people their religion is their default and what they have known all their lives, the choice would be to leave their religion and often community as well. People have short memories of why it is so important to protect religious freedoms and for religion and belief to be protected characteristics.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 13/01/2023 17:13

No belief system should be protected from scrutiny or criticism.

And nothing in the Equality Act prevents either. You can scrutinise and criticise to your heart's content. You just can't use it as a reason to victimise, harass, or discriminate against an individual or group of people.

SocialLite · 13/01/2023 17:06

The thing is, you're just as protected in stating your belief as religious people are to state theirs!

What you can't do however, is persecute them for what they believe rather than just simply stating what you believe.

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/01/2023 17:05

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/01/2023 16:54

I looked into this a while back, and from what I can understand, that unless the church has officially excommunicated you, in their eyes, once you have been baptised you will always be a Catholic until you die and for an eternity beyond. So according to them you stop being a Catholic.

I meant to say, that according to them you never stop being a Catholic.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/01/2023 17:03

It's protected because for most people it's so ingrained in them from birth, upbringing etc that it is a fundamental part of their identity

l know no one including myself who has ingrained religion into their children. My oldest is 29. Religion has no impact on his life whatsoever.

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 17:01

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 16:38

Thata interesting. So you can change your race if referring to nationality, but cannot change your race is referring to ethnicity. Hmm. I've learnt so much from this thread!

I would think you could possibly change ethnicity.
While most people would probably define their ethnicity based on what they were classed at birth, you can change common attributes to different group within your life. So imho possible

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/01/2023 16:54

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 13/01/2023 15:52

Right, but again that's about who is making the decisions.

I have left the Catholic faith (100%) but if someone in a position of power came along and said that for the purposes of their laws anyone baptised Catholic is still Catholic, I couldn't change that. IIRC, Jews weren't allowed to convert in the later stages of Nazism. See also the 'one drop rule' in the USA.

I looked into this a while back, and from what I can understand, that unless the church has officially excommunicated you, in their eyes, once you have been baptised you will always be a Catholic until you die and for an eternity beyond. So according to them you stop being a Catholic.

TedMullins · 13/01/2023 16:53

Of course people should be protected from discrimination and bigotry because of their religion. They should be free to practice their beliefs without imposing them on others. But I do see your point. The stumbling block I have is protecting misogyny in the name of religion - e.g. accepting that men and women of some religions must be separated to go swimming, or that Catholics can spout anti-abortion rhetoric under the guise of faith. I'm not sure as a secular country we should be enabling the discriminatory practices of religion.

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 16:39

Giggorata · 13/01/2023 15:44

Since Christianity overlaid the indigenous pagan religions in the British Isles, it consistently persecuted pagans and witches and/or people they deemed witches, in some cases hanging and burning them; and there was widespread demonisation and reframing of the old gods.
Vestiges of this are still hanging on today in some quarters, with active prejudice and persecution against pagans, heathens and witches.
This, despite religion being a protected characteristic.
Not all religions.

Pagans and witches are protected:

www.lawson-west.co.uk/for-people/services/employment-law-solicitors-leicester-market-harborough-and-uk/articles/pagan-witch-wins-discrimination-case

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 16:38

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 16:27

Race includes ethnicity and nationality. So yes, it can be changed.
Eg, I am from x country, upon aquiring citizenship in Y country, I may either become dual citizen or relinquish my original one and become only Y citizen.
Hence I changed a characteristic included under race in EA2010.

Thata interesting. So you can change your race if referring to nationality, but cannot change your race is referring to ethnicity. Hmm. I've learnt so much from this thread!

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 16:34

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/01/2023 14:56

I think you're being a bit disingenuous OP.

I'm an atheist, perfectly happy being vocal about that if I'm asked, and I can see that there is clearly a gulf between religious people expecting the right not to be offended, which is nonsense and doesn't exist, and the right not to be discriminated against because of their chosen belief.

Where I do agree that there is a bizarre element to protecting religious belief, is that there is a blatant degree of hypocrisy and duplicitousness over what exactly constitutes a genuinely held religious belief. Nobody questions that Christianity is a recognised religion, and as such Christians are afforded the protection of the act, yet if you, in all sincerity, follow the Jedi code, you will not be taken seriously if you contend that you were discriminated against because of your Jedi adherence. It begs the question why not? It can not be the simple fact that the UK does not formally recognise Jediism as a legitimate religion, because there are plenty of minority religions that are also not formally recognised, but their adherents would be taken perfectly seriously should they claim that they had been the victim of discrimination because of of their faith.

In essence, I don't understand how the law can regard one 'faith' based in nothing evidential as credible, but disregard others on the back of them being less than credulous.

I don't know if there have been any discrimination cases brought by Jediists but theoretically they would be protected as long as their beliefs passed the Grainger test:

(i) The belief must be genuinely held.

(ii) It must be a belief and not an opinion or viewpoint based on the present state of information available.

(iii) It must be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour.

(iv) It must attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance.

(v) It must be worthy of respect in a democratic society, be not incompatible with human dignity and not conflict with the fundamental rights of others.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grainger_plc_v_Nicholson

These are the same criteria used to decide that belief in climate change, veganism and gender critical beliefs are all protected.

stargirl1701 · 13/01/2023 16:30

No, I think given the history of the 20th century, it is necessary.

Giggorata · 13/01/2023 16:28

Crabo · 13/01/2023 15:57

It’s amazing how many people still believe this in spite of the fact that history proves against it.

I'm not quite clear which bit you're referring to, Crabo, but just for clarity, I'm not talking about the so called Burning Times, which didn't happen.
I'm talking more about prejudice and discrimination by public services and members of the public in modern times.

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 16:27

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 16:03

Surely you can't change your race/genetics?

Race includes ethnicity and nationality. So yes, it can be changed.
Eg, I am from x country, upon aquiring citizenship in Y country, I may either become dual citizen or relinquish my original one and become only Y citizen.
Hence I changed a characteristic included under race in EA2010.

PartySock · 13/01/2023 16:26

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 16:03

Surely you can't change your race/genetics?

The state can.
In apartheid South Africa, the classifications were all over the place. People could be moved from one category to another at random.
Obviously an extreme example!