Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 20:54

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 20:12

How many times have you died to inform your estimate of the probability of there being 'something' after your next death? Or are you just believing what you're comfortable with?

Obviously I'd be very much more comfortable believing in an eternal existence in paradise! And I'm afraid that quite understandably that comfort blanket, and a fear of mortality, is undoubtedly at the root of humanity's long-standing belief in countless deities and various forms of immortal existence. One of the tragedies of our species is that we've evolved far enough to understand the oblivion that we're heading towards.

I reluctantly believe in mortality because there is no evidence whatsoever for the alternative, and the arguments in its favour (which I've explored over decades) are vacuous even when dressed up in intellectual puff!

MichaelFabricantWig · 13/01/2023 20:53

ApiratesaysYarrr · 13/01/2023 20:24

By that logic, pregnancy should not be a protected characteristic, and women (mostly) choose to be pregnant).

Pregnancy is unique though as it has its roots in sex discrimination and is therefore intrinsically connected with the protected characteristic of sex.

Crabo · 13/01/2023 20:48

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 20:03

But there is a huge difference.

Religions are ideologies some of which have in the past, and do now, prescribe death for certain people as the will of their deity. In other words religion can lead directly to murder, over and above any natural human instinct towards violence. Many millions have died over the centuries because religious people believed that their religion required and justified the deaths.

Atheism is nothing more than an absence of ideology. It contains no moral values and does not require anyone to do anything. No one ever killed anyone because atheism required it. Some murderers may not have believed in any god. But the fact that they did not believe in god did not lead to them killing anyone, any more than the fact that they did not believe in a heliocentric solar system or the Loch Ness monster.

Exactly. Atheism has no morality. That’s why atheistic regimes have justified themselves in behaving in an amoral and subhuman way as there is no objective morality. The fruits of it were over 100 million murders

ApiratesaysYarrr · 13/01/2023 20:24

MichaelFabricantWig · 13/01/2023 14:15

I can see your point. Ultimately religion is something that people choose so expecting legal protection due to lifestyle choices is a bit odd. But then so is gender reassignment and it’s protected. However the religion and belief characteristic includes a lack of belief so as an atheist you are also protected.

By that logic, pregnancy should not be a protected characteristic, and women (mostly) choose to be pregnant).

Forestfire12345 · 13/01/2023 20:19

It's about discrimination. Stop being obtuse.

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 20:12

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 19:48

I mean nobody definitely knows what's going to happen tomorrow. But if someone tells you that all birds will transform into guided missiles, that you will grow three more arms and that it will become a capital offence to speak English would you build those possibilities into your plan?

How many times have you died to inform your estimate of the probability of there being 'something' after your next death? Or are you just believing what you're comfortable with?

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 20:09

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 20:03

But there is a huge difference.

Religions are ideologies some of which have in the past, and do now, prescribe death for certain people as the will of their deity. In other words religion can lead directly to murder, over and above any natural human instinct towards violence. Many millions have died over the centuries because religious people believed that their religion required and justified the deaths.

Atheism is nothing more than an absence of ideology. It contains no moral values and does not require anyone to do anything. No one ever killed anyone because atheism required it. Some murderers may not have believed in any god. But the fact that they did not believe in god did not lead to them killing anyone, any more than the fact that they did not believe in a heliocentric solar system or the Loch Ness monster.

You need to look up what happened in the Soviet Union.

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 20:03

Crabo · 13/01/2023 19:51

Hatred also comes from atheism. Atheistic systems killed 100 million people last century. It’s actually calked human nature.

But there is a huge difference.

Religions are ideologies some of which have in the past, and do now, prescribe death for certain people as the will of their deity. In other words religion can lead directly to murder, over and above any natural human instinct towards violence. Many millions have died over the centuries because religious people believed that their religion required and justified the deaths.

Atheism is nothing more than an absence of ideology. It contains no moral values and does not require anyone to do anything. No one ever killed anyone because atheism required it. Some murderers may not have believed in any god. But the fact that they did not believe in god did not lead to them killing anyone, any more than the fact that they did not believe in a heliocentric solar system or the Loch Ness monster.

Crabo · 13/01/2023 19:51

catgirl1976 · 13/01/2023 18:41

Well your lack of belief is also a protected characteristic so YABU I think

plus look how much discrimination and hatred comes from religion. Of course people need protection from that

Hatred also comes from atheism. Atheistic systems killed 100 million people last century. It’s actually calked human nature.

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 19:48

mbosnz · 13/01/2023 19:40

I figure that none of us genuinely know what happens after death. Those that believe could be the ones ultimately laughing. I guess that makes me agnostic. But if anyone can stand up and say with absolute certainty what happens in the hereafter, I'll defer to their knowledge. Until then, I'm going to suffer the barbed wire up my arse, and respect all viewpoints.

I mean nobody definitely knows what's going to happen tomorrow. But if someone tells you that all birds will transform into guided missiles, that you will grow three more arms and that it will become a capital offence to speak English would you build those possibilities into your plan?

mbosnz · 13/01/2023 19:40

I figure that none of us genuinely know what happens after death. Those that believe could be the ones ultimately laughing. I guess that makes me agnostic. But if anyone can stand up and say with absolute certainty what happens in the hereafter, I'll defer to their knowledge. Until then, I'm going to suffer the barbed wire up my arse, and respect all viewpoints.

Fivebyfive2 · 13/01/2023 19:36

It's fine to not be religious and to think those that are are wrong. It's not fine to up to someone and say you think they're absurd or ridiculous. That's just being a dick.

oohokay · 13/01/2023 19:32

Fellow ADHD PI here, just wanted to say I like your username (and your respectful curiosity)!

MasterBeth · 13/01/2023 18:57

LolaSmiles · 13/01/2023 14:19

I doubt you'd be sacked for saying you don't believe in God and find religion absurd.It would be an unusual topic of conversation in the workplace though.

People experience discrimination for their religious belief and discrimination is not the same as someone else expressing a different view.

It would be a perfectly ordinary topic of conversation in my office. Politics, religion, football, we do the lot.

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 18:54

Thanks everyone, this is massively eye opening. I have learnt a lot and amazingly for AIBU people have been pretty polite and have been really willing to help me understand! I hope I haven't offended anyone.

OP posts:
ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 18:53

Mangogogogo · 13/01/2023 18:52

You don’t seem to understand the term ‘discrimination’

Where exactly where I've mentioned discrimination has it not made sense?

OP posts:
Mangogogogo · 13/01/2023 18:52

You don’t seem to understand the term ‘discrimination’

RandomCatGenerator · 13/01/2023 18:51

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 18:06

The free expression of beliefs is not absolute. It can be restricted when it interferes with the rights of others. E.g. you may have a religion based belief that homosexuals are going to hell. You have the right to believe that, you also have the right to say it, e.g. in a discussion about religion you could say, 'I believe homosexuals go to hell when they die', but at a certain point, this would cross over into unlawful harassment, e.g. saying to a gay colleague, 'you're going to hell.'

Similarly, it's fine for a RC to say, 'I believe abortion is a terrible sin' but not to harass a colleague who is seeking or has had an abortion.

As a PP has noted, where exactly the line is keeps employment lawyers busy. This is why it's generally a bad idea to have these kinds of discussions in the workplace.

I don't think single sex swimming sessions are the same kind of thing because it's not a case of imposing those beliefs on others. There may be e.g. women and girls from strict Muslim families who would prefer mixed sex swimming sessions and are prevented from attending by family members, but the EA does not cover what goes on in families anyway. A leisure centre would not be allowed to prevent them from attending a mixed sex session.

Another well said post.

RandomCatGenerator · 13/01/2023 18:49

Notwavingbutsignalling · 13/01/2023 14:52

@RandomCatGenerator

The law protects people from Islamophobia and Anti-semitism both of which are on the rise in the U.K. and across Europe

and anti Christianity- rife in some countries which we don’t always see here.

There are also some faiths you can’t leave - Islam and now Catholicism so you are of that faith often due to where you or your parents were born in the world.

But I think religion has been used as a pretext to discriminate against poor people and immigrants in general.

Absolutely, well said. And there is also the ethnic element - many, although not all, Jews see Judaism as an ethnicity as well as a religion. David Baddiel put it well: his atheist uncle couldn’t opt out of being shot for being Jewish just because he didn’t believe in God. His family, where he lived, where he went to school, where his family came from, what he looked like maybe - that all made him Jewish enough to be killed for it.

catgirl1976 · 13/01/2023 18:41

Well your lack of belief is also a protected characteristic so YABU I think

plus look how much discrimination and hatred comes from religion. Of course people need protection from that

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 18:28

It's not even a very nice colander tbf.

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 18:15

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 17:58

@LangClegsInSpace interesting! How are pastafarians doing?

Not great. They also seem to be failing Grainger (iv) 😞

www.theargus.co.uk/news/12889221.pastafarian-to-protest-as-dvla-still-reject-photo-of-him-wearing-religious-colander/

The DVLA’s operational driver investigation team manager said the body was required to abide by the Equality Act 2010 which defines religion and belief.

The letter said: “In order to be protected by the act, a religion or belief must be recognised as being cogent, serious, cohesive and compatible with human dignity.

“Your religion is not included in this definition and consequently neither is the head wear you have provided in the photograph.”

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?
LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 18:06

TedMullins · 13/01/2023 16:53

Of course people should be protected from discrimination and bigotry because of their religion. They should be free to practice their beliefs without imposing them on others. But I do see your point. The stumbling block I have is protecting misogyny in the name of religion - e.g. accepting that men and women of some religions must be separated to go swimming, or that Catholics can spout anti-abortion rhetoric under the guise of faith. I'm not sure as a secular country we should be enabling the discriminatory practices of religion.

The free expression of beliefs is not absolute. It can be restricted when it interferes with the rights of others. E.g. you may have a religion based belief that homosexuals are going to hell. You have the right to believe that, you also have the right to say it, e.g. in a discussion about religion you could say, 'I believe homosexuals go to hell when they die', but at a certain point, this would cross over into unlawful harassment, e.g. saying to a gay colleague, 'you're going to hell.'

Similarly, it's fine for a RC to say, 'I believe abortion is a terrible sin' but not to harass a colleague who is seeking or has had an abortion.

As a PP has noted, where exactly the line is keeps employment lawyers busy. This is why it's generally a bad idea to have these kinds of discussions in the workplace.

I don't think single sex swimming sessions are the same kind of thing because it's not a case of imposing those beliefs on others. There may be e.g. women and girls from strict Muslim families who would prefer mixed sex swimming sessions and are prevented from attending by family members, but the EA does not cover what goes on in families anyway. A leisure centre would not be allowed to prevent them from attending a mixed sex session.

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 17:58

@LangClegsInSpace interesting! How are pastafarians doing?

Bubblebubblebah · 13/01/2023 17:56

tappinginto2023 · 13/01/2023 17:45

You can be an atheist and not a dick.

I'm happy with people having rights and respect even if I don't think the same way they do. I don't find it threatening at all.

Exactly.

Same like I am happy my belief god doesn't exist is protected and I can't be fired etc (unless the job has x religion as GOR) for not believing. It works both ways.