Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 14/01/2023 00:33

I'm an atheist. I believe that religion can be a tool to oppress people, I also see how some people get great comfort from it.
I get how a company should not discriminate on religious grounds but jutst wondering if I wanted to employ someone to work as a nanny, would I be 'allowed' to discriminate, as I wouldn't want them to be imparting their beliefs to my children? Or would I have to say they were unsuitable for some other reason.
This is hypothetical, it could also be an opportunity to show my children that other people believe different things. But as so many religions discriminate against women, I actually don't know how comfortable I would be with someone very religious in my home with my children. I don't care if they're my accountant or dentist or whatever.

Elmo22 · 14/01/2023 00:20

I genuinely don’t understand the ridicule/hate for religion. My husband is an atheist and fits very well into my religious family. I hate the constant defence of my religion because people like to tell me it is bizarre, absurd, a load of nonsense etc or that I am stupid for having a certain belief. I’d never judge someone - particularly publicly - for having no belief or a different belief. We would all benefit from being more tolerant of one another.

Anyway, I am glad that religion is protected in the way that it is. Let us hope that it continues.

tappinginto2023 · 13/01/2023 23:29

@Elmo22 I am GC though!

I do believe that vulnerable groups (and I feel women and girls are the most vulnerable from attack in our society, especially if they have an extra characteristic like race or disability) need protection.
If their rights to safe spaces and opportunities was respected then the world would be a better place (my opinion).

FlamingoCroquet · 13/01/2023 23:16

Throughout history across the world, people of one religion have persecuted people of another. The legislation isn't anything to do with theology / atheism, it's protecting people from being denied a job or a rented house, or bullied out of university or refused service in a restaurant due to their religion.

Though I'm not sure how Lewes bonfire societies are still allowed to burn an effigy of the Pope!

Elmo22 · 13/01/2023 22:47

tappinginto2023 · 13/01/2023 17:45

You can be an atheist and not a dick.

I'm happy with people having rights and respect even if I don't think the same way they do. I don't find it threatening at all.

Thank you for saying this 🙂

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 22:36

Ah, so are you saying that you neither believe there is life after death nor that there isn't life after death?

And that's not how Occam's Razor works. The Razor tells us to prefer (in a sense) explanations for phenomena which don't 'multiply entities unnecessarily'. It doesn't mean 'assume things don't exist until proven otherwise'.

WhereYouLeftIt · 13/01/2023 22:28

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:18

And this was my point. As an atheist, by saying I believe religion is a nonsense, which I'm allowed to do, in directly insulting someone else on the basis of their protected characteristic. It's a bit odd that two protected characteristics are the opposite of each other. But then again for say landlords or employers to discriminate purely based on a religious belief would of course be wrong so, who knows.

"It's a bit odd that two protected characteristics are the opposite of each other."

Not really. Isn't that part of the purpose of the Act, to balance competing rights? Because there will always be situations where that happens - the bakery who wouldn't write a pro-homosexuality message on a cake on religious grounds springs to mind.

Besides, whatever your personal beliefs, would you discriminate on that basis? Would you treat someone less favourably because they were religious? Refuse to serve them in a shop, refuse to employ them, pay them less, fire them? That's what the protection is about, not about hearing someone say they think their beliefs are tosh. As long as your actions did not constitute harrassment etc.

Personally, coming from the west coast of Scotland and growing up in the sectarian society it was then (Catholic and Protestant) I absolutely believe religion should be a protected characteristic.

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 22:13

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:20

No, that's not how Occam's Razor works. You're just believing what you feel comfortable with. That's fine, but don't think your beliefs are on any stronger grounds than people who do believe in 'life after death'.

I'm not believing in what I'm comfortable with - I'd much rather live forever! The very point is that I'm not believing in anything. My disbelief is not on strong ground - it is on no ground It's an absence of belief. The list of things that I don't believe in is infinite - I can't speak for you.

(And it is exactly how Occam's Razor works, so ya boo sucks to you Grin.)

TedMullins · 13/01/2023 22:12

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:53

People are born gay or straight? Their experiences have no effect on their sexuality?

Yes of course they are

MumUndone · 13/01/2023 22:01

Erm, ever heard of the holocaust? Or the ongoing persecution of Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar? Religion absolutely must be a protected characteristic as it has been a primary reason for inequality, hate, and genocide for hundreds of years.

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:53

Sartre · 13/01/2023 21:48

I agree because it’s a choice. You’re born a certain race or sexuality and you can’t change disabilities but religion is a choice.

People are born gay or straight? Their experiences have no effect on their sexuality?

JudgeRudy · 13/01/2023 21:52

LynneBenfield · 13/01/2023 14:37

I’m an atheist too but it’s pretty clear that the law in terms of religion as a protected characteristic is to protect against religious persecution, not from Dave at work saying saying moderately controversial.

I don't think anyone has an issue in any of those things where someone is actively discriminated against simple because they follow a specific religion. I think the problems arise when someone's 'rights' to follow their religious practices clash with say employers needs. Recently there was a thread where the work 'rules' were broken so one additional employee could have Eid? off. Normally only X amount of employees could be off atvanyonevtime but they made an exception as they had a high proportion of Muslim employees.....but when several people all want BH Monday off that's not allowed. That's what I have an issue with. It's saying that believe in some imaginary diety is more important than my family time....no, it's not, and it's unfair.

Sartre · 13/01/2023 21:48

I agree because it’s a choice. You’re born a certain race or sexuality and you can’t change disabilities but religion is a choice.

NestingSparrow · 13/01/2023 21:46

Many people are killed in atheist and religious countries for their religious beliefs. That’s why it needs to be a protected characteristic.

WandaWonder · 13/01/2023 21:44

I presume there is law in place, or if not there should be, to be that if you are aware of a crime ie child abuse you are required to report to the police and not use religion as a get out card?

I am not an atheist, I am perfectly happy for religion to exist but not partake myself but I don't think religion should mean people should be able to act in a different way that is against normal society

Metabigot · 13/01/2023 21:43

babyjellyfish · 13/01/2023 14:18

This.

Whereas belief in gender identity is equivalent to a religious belief, but the right not to believe in that isn't protected.

Ever heard of Maya Forstater?

JudgeRudy · 13/01/2023 21:39

I think it's not religion per se but belief system. So eg veganism would be classed as a belief system....as would be, wait for it......views around sex and gender.
Im not quite sure how you can define a belief system.
My gripe is that more unusual belief systems dont seem to be taken as seriously and treated fairly. Why should eg a Catholic requesting Easter BH off have more 'grounds' than say asking for Friday off as 'Mercury is retrograde'? I believe (like most) I am entitled to be physically comfortable at work. My employer has made provision to ensure adequate heating is in place so its not uncomfortably cold. I don't care about being a bit chilly. I do care about being hot though and there's no law to back me up).
What happens when freedom of expression and religion clash? I don't think it's right that when working in operating theatres you are not required to remove a wedding ring but you arecrequired to remove jewelery that your deceased grandma gave you. How is that fair? Well apparently that's because its part of Mrs Christian's belief system but not apparently Ms Atheiests!
If say l believe The Beatles are the greatest band ever can have a moment to reflect in silence on each of the members birthdays?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/01/2023 21:36

I think, though, religion can sort of mean your cultural background which you can’t really change or help. Other people can discriminate against you on the basis of a perception you belong to that religion, even if you no longer believe in it.So I guess it’s a bit of a “catch all” characteristic.

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:32

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 15:05

Ah yes, or maybe we are all just brains in vats! You know what I mean. I accept that God can never be disproven. Technically nothing can. Maybe I should have referred to probability as opposed to proof.

But how can you come up with a rational estimate of the probability of God existing?

SnoozyLucy7 · 13/01/2023 21:25

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 20:09

You need to look up what happened in the Soviet Union.

The religious leaders were replaced by political leaders. It’s all the same - cult of the leader, either way, it’ the same, surely?

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:20

No, that's not how Occam's Razor works. You're just believing what you feel comfortable with. That's fine, but don't think your beliefs are on any stronger grounds than people who do believe in 'life after death'.

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 21:13

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:06

So you've no evidence for 'life after death' and you've no evidence for 'no life after death'. Why do you choose to believe the latter?

Occam's razor.

There's a very very very long list of things which I don't believe in, although there's no evidence against them. I think if you're honest the same is true for you. (If not your life must be quite exhausting Grin)

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 21:09

Crabo · 13/01/2023 20:48

Exactly. Atheism has no morality. That’s why atheistic regimes have justified themselves in behaving in an amoral and subhuman way as there is no objective morality. The fruits of it were over 100 million murders

I strongly disagree.

Humans have evolved the capacity for morality regardless of any particular religion or belief system (or lack of) because we have evolved to survive in groups and that only works if we don't all shit on each other. Morality is part of being human.

The problem, for atheists and religious people alike, is the conviction that you are so right, and everyone else is so wrong, and their beliefs, or lack of belief, are so harmful, that they must be suppressed by force. Neither atheism nor any religion has clean hands.

Out of interest, what is your religion?

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:06

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 20:54

Obviously I'd be very much more comfortable believing in an eternal existence in paradise! And I'm afraid that quite understandably that comfort blanket, and a fear of mortality, is undoubtedly at the root of humanity's long-standing belief in countless deities and various forms of immortal existence. One of the tragedies of our species is that we've evolved far enough to understand the oblivion that we're heading towards.

I reluctantly believe in mortality because there is no evidence whatsoever for the alternative, and the arguments in its favour (which I've explored over decades) are vacuous even when dressed up in intellectual puff!

So you've no evidence for 'life after death' and you've no evidence for 'no life after death'. Why do you choose to believe the latter?

LauraNicolaides · 13/01/2023 21:01

Crabo · 13/01/2023 20:48

Exactly. Atheism has no morality. That’s why atheistic regimes have justified themselves in behaving in an amoral and subhuman way as there is no objective morality. The fruits of it were over 100 million murders

This is ridiculous! It's like saying that baldness has no morality, and therefore bald men are a menace to humanity. Baldness and atheism have no morality in the sense that they are not, and do not claim to be, moral codes. They are both just absences (of hair or a belief in a deity). Religion (in most cases) does involve a moral code (and its moral values are often appalling).

Both atheists and bald men can be deeply moral. Their moral philosophy has nothing to do with atheism. Ideally it is rational.