Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
TheHateIsNotGood · 15/01/2023 19:51

Agnostic here - I find that many people find solace in their religious beliefs which is great. I also find that many people cast off their personal choices and responsibilities in the name of whatever organized religion they believe in or subscibe to which is not so great.

All religions have extremes that a few subscribe to and sometimes their religious beliefs enter into other non-religious aspects of their lives and expect others to pay credence to them too.

It's a very difficult realm to negotiate, you can't do right without doing wrong if you are a non-believer in their particular religion, even sent to hell (or similar) if you believe in a different religion.

I just nod politely and agree with the good points of their religion if it's up for discussion but do draw the line when it's stated that those that don't similarly believe go to hell, are lesser people, etc.

LangClegsInSpace · 15/01/2023 19:38

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 15/01/2023 14:17

That's not what it means though.
To be reprimanded because you have said something to someone re their religion, that would be due to your company's bullying and harassment policy and that would extend to far more than religion and philosophy.
As a protected characteristic, it means you can't discriminate ie a person of faith can't refuse to hire you due to your atheism, or you can't refuse to hire a Catholic because of their faith, and you must consider reasonable adjustments like holidays, feast days etc.

Harassment related to a protected characteristic is unlawful conduct in the equality act.

Harassment is unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic that has the purpose or effect of violating your dignity, or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for you.

Whether the unwanted conduct amounts to harassment doesn't just depend on your perceptions but also on the surrounding circumstances and whether it is reasonable for the conduct to have that effect.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/26

Burgoo · 15/01/2023 19:33

@Crabo "You say you find religion ‘all bizarre and absurd’. That to me is a pretty aggressive statement to begin a post with. If I had begun a post by saying ‘I find atheism bizarre and absurd’ you would no doubt have thought me aggressive."

Aggressive? Come on. This isn't a playground. If you don't like what someone says that is perfectly okay. Words aren't violence.

LangClegsInSpace · 15/01/2023 19:32

There's no requirement to accept or respect other people's beliefs. The requirement is to accept and respect other people's right to hold those beliefs and not discriminate against people because of their beliefs.

Burgoo · 15/01/2023 19:32

Given the persecution of religious folk in history I can kind of see why it is. I am an atheist. But the law prevents people with a religious belief from being fired because of that belief (or needing a certain day off for practicing their belief).

You can say what you like about your own views on religion - it is a myth that you can't. As long as you are being respectful and considerate. It is so that employers can't stop you getting a job cos you believe in a god. I think thats fair.

LangClegsInSpace · 15/01/2023 19:30

Crabo · 15/01/2023 15:13

You say you find religion ‘all bizarre and absurd’. That to me is a pretty aggressive statement to begin a post with. If I had begun a post by saying ‘I find atheism bizarre and absurd’ you would no doubt have thought me aggressive.

I'm an atheist, I wouldn't find that aggressive.

Crabo · 15/01/2023 15:13

You say you find religion ‘all bizarre and absurd’. That to me is a pretty aggressive statement to begin a post with. If I had begun a post by saying ‘I find atheism bizarre and absurd’ you would no doubt have thought me aggressive.

LakieLady · 15/01/2023 14:49

Extreme Christian’s aren’t the only religion who see women and gay people as second class citizens. Do you openly ridicule Muslims then? The extreme side of their faith also has discriminatory principles.

I find that quite challenging, and get myself into a sort internal "ideological top trumps".

Despite being an atheist, who privately feels that all religions involve belief in "sky fairies" of one sort or another, if that's someone's belief, I think it should be respected. But an awful lot of bigotry against women, gay and bi people, and other faiths has its roots in one religion or another.

I really struggle to accept such beliefs.

PlumbleCrumble · 15/01/2023 14:20

of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion

This is why.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 15/01/2023 14:17

That's not what it means though.
To be reprimanded because you have said something to someone re their religion, that would be due to your company's bullying and harassment policy and that would extend to far more than religion and philosophy.
As a protected characteristic, it means you can't discriminate ie a person of faith can't refuse to hire you due to your atheism, or you can't refuse to hire a Catholic because of their faith, and you must consider reasonable adjustments like holidays, feast days etc.

x2boys · 15/01/2023 10:16

x2boys · 15/01/2023 10:14

People in professional roles don't generally go.round talking about their beliefs it would be a bit odd,and inappropriate surely ?

Sorry i.meant to.quite @CosmicVaginaBiscuit

x2boys · 15/01/2023 10:14

GrownPersonHere · 14/01/2023 01:36

The protection should be for ones to be able to freely practice their faith without opposition and or persecution, but not from opposing opinions.
But there is a time and place. First of all, the workplace isn't a place for religious debates between people who hold very sensitive and divisive views.

Why would an atheist want to debate with - or even ridicule a religious person anyway? Why do they care what one believes in? Does it personally affect your life if someone else believes in God and has a faith and you don't? There isn't gonna be any changing of minds or beliefs between them, especially if they have to resort to insults and ridicule, what would be the point?

I really don't think there should be ANY need for protection for ANY group if people learn to respect each other regardless of their beliefs - or just agree to disagree. But it seems too much to ask for these days, maybe I'm just too naive to expect it. People are so triggered by what other people are saying or doing with their lives. Unless it directly impacts one's life, family, job, mental health etc, one should just mind one's own own business.

People in professional roles don't generally go.round talking about their beliefs it would be a bit odd,and inappropriate surely ?

ADHDPI · 15/01/2023 10:12

Crabo · 15/01/2023 09:49

The point is the OPE appears to be a quite aggressive and evangelical atheist in their opinion. Interesting than atheists appear to desire freedom to spread their point of view while wanting to deny the same freedom to other points of view

I don't think I've been aggressive, at, have I?

OP posts:
ADHDPI · 15/01/2023 10:10

Crabo · 15/01/2023 09:49

The point is the OPE appears to be a quite aggressive and evangelical atheist in their opinion. Interesting than atheists appear to desire freedom to spread their point of view while wanting to deny the same freedom to other points of view

Evangelical atheist 🤔

OP posts:
Crabo · 15/01/2023 09:49

Ereshkigalangcleg · 14/01/2023 08:47

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

It's not a daft argument, the reason you can't be sacked just for being an atheist if someone doesn't like atheism is the same reason you can't just be sacked for being a Jew/Christian/Muslim etc.

The point is the OPE appears to be a quite aggressive and evangelical atheist in their opinion. Interesting than atheists appear to desire freedom to spread their point of view while wanting to deny the same freedom to other points of view

SirMingeALot · 14/01/2023 08:52

Ereshkigalangcleg · 14/01/2023 08:47

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

It's not a daft argument, the reason you can't be sacked just for being an atheist if someone doesn't like atheism is the same reason you can't just be sacked for being a Jew/Christian/Muslim etc.

Absolutely, which is just as it should be.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 14/01/2023 08:47

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

It's not a daft argument, the reason you can't be sacked just for being an atheist if someone doesn't like atheism is the same reason you can't just be sacked for being a Jew/Christian/Muslim etc.

SirMingeALot · 14/01/2023 08:33

Sartre · 13/01/2023 21:48

I agree because it’s a choice. You’re born a certain race or sexuality and you can’t change disabilities but religion is a choice.

This is just not how religious discrimination has worked in the UK. People absolutely can be identified as having been born into and brought up in a particular religion and then discriminated against on that basis regardless of whether they continue to practice it or not. Talk to some people who've been victims of sectarianism, for example. This sort of sweeping statement shows that you don't actually understand how religious discrimination operates.

We also clearly don't require a protected characteristic to be something an individual can do nothing about, and nor should we. There would go all our maternity protections, for example.

ShodanLives · 14/01/2023 08:24

Plbrookes · 13/01/2023 21:53

People are born gay or straight? Their experiences have no effect on their sexuality?

Most likely yes.

Bubblebubblebah · 14/01/2023 08:04

Sartre · 13/01/2023 21:48

I agree because it’s a choice. You’re born a certain race or sexuality and you can’t change disabilities but religion is a choice.

You could claim similar abput nationality, pregnancy, marriage, and gender reassignment.

Bubblebubblebah · 14/01/2023 07:53

LangClegsInSpace · 13/01/2023 18:28

It's not even a very nice colander tbf.

😂

Shame though

Crabo · 14/01/2023 06:54

Sartre · 13/01/2023 21:48

I agree because it’s a choice. You’re born a certain race or sexuality and you can’t change disabilities but religion is a choice.

And I would’ve thought you need to have your rights to religion protected just as your rights to politics protected. Always amazes me that certain atheists think that you can have your rights to politics protected but not your rights to what you believe religiously

GrownPersonHere · 14/01/2023 01:47

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 14/01/2023 00:33

I'm an atheist. I believe that religion can be a tool to oppress people, I also see how some people get great comfort from it.
I get how a company should not discriminate on religious grounds but jutst wondering if I wanted to employ someone to work as a nanny, would I be 'allowed' to discriminate, as I wouldn't want them to be imparting their beliefs to my children? Or would I have to say they were unsuitable for some other reason.
This is hypothetical, it could also be an opportunity to show my children that other people believe different things. But as so many religions discriminate against women, I actually don't know how comfortable I would be with someone very religious in my home with my children. I don't care if they're my accountant or dentist or whatever.

Interesting. If you wanted to employ a nanny, how would their faith come up in the interview? Would you ask them if they have a religious belief, or do you think they'd bring it up? Like if they said they'd like time off for some religious holiday, would you think twice about employing them because of that? And should you even need to ask them not to talk to your children about their beliefs? Unless they're really fanatical, they probably wouldn't, they just want a job. I'd think the same principle would apply if you didn't want a gay person looking after your kids in case they start talking about their same-sex relationship to them, or if a black person started going on about Black Lives Matter to them lol

GrownPersonHere · 14/01/2023 01:36

The protection should be for ones to be able to freely practice their faith without opposition and or persecution, but not from opposing opinions.
But there is a time and place. First of all, the workplace isn't a place for religious debates between people who hold very sensitive and divisive views.

Why would an atheist want to debate with - or even ridicule a religious person anyway? Why do they care what one believes in? Does it personally affect your life if someone else believes in God and has a faith and you don't? There isn't gonna be any changing of minds or beliefs between them, especially if they have to resort to insults and ridicule, what would be the point?

I really don't think there should be ANY need for protection for ANY group if people learn to respect each other regardless of their beliefs - or just agree to disagree. But it seems too much to ask for these days, maybe I'm just too naive to expect it. People are so triggered by what other people are saying or doing with their lives. Unless it directly impacts one's life, family, job, mental health etc, one should just mind one's own own business.

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/01/2023 00:37

I'm from NI, enough said.😒

Swipe left for the next trending thread