Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
Plbrookes · 17/01/2023 22:22

Conkersinautumn · 17/01/2023 22:00

Religion is a choice, the choice to believe in something, despite having no evidence, literally that's faith. Sex, sexuality, race are not a choice. Do to me, yes, religion is a poor 'protected' characteristic as the 'protection' needs to be reserved for the victims of religious coercion, which is swept under the carpet, yet it happens.

Belief is not just a matter of choice though. However much I want to believe I will live for ever, I don't believe it.

MyCreation · 17/01/2023 22:05

Arguing that this should not apply because people choose their religion is a bit misguided (it's not the same sort of choice as choosing to drive a blue car or a red one but rather for many people one which is intimately connected with their cultural and ethnic heritage) and a violation of the principle of religious freedom (which includes your own freedom not to believe).

I am an atheist as are by DBs and as were my late DPs. We are however Orthodox Jews by heritage. I had a DNA kit bought as a present a few years ago and the result came back as 100% European Jewish. If Jewishness is something that is detectable on a DNA test then that suggests it is a racial characteristic and therefore also a protected characteristic ? My DGPs and DGGPs on both sides were all Orthodox Jews from Lithuania. I wasn’t expecting Jewishness to be in my DNA and was very surprised at the result and the implication that some religions encompass more than belief systems.

Conkersinautumn · 17/01/2023 22:00

Religion is a choice, the choice to believe in something, despite having no evidence, literally that's faith. Sex, sexuality, race are not a choice. Do to me, yes, religion is a poor 'protected' characteristic as the 'protection' needs to be reserved for the victims of religious coercion, which is swept under the carpet, yet it happens.

pikiwop54 · 17/01/2023 21:53

first I would not employ a nanny as it is the parents job to bring up kids not farm them out.

Congratulations on not having to work to pay your bills. No need to be so smug about it.

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 21:30

one would certainly not expect a nanny to go against the wishes of parents

There we go. That was like getting blood from a stone.

No, I'm not interested in your proselytising.

Crabo · 17/01/2023 21:05

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 17:11

It's interesting to read what you think you know about me, Crabo, but probably more telling than you think.

That shifting, dodging argument style won't work here, so back to the topic: the sub-discussion we were having was about whether, in the context of anti-discrimination legislation, it would be okay for people to decline to employ a nanny who intended to actively instruct a child in a religion different to that of the child's parents, including teaching them the Christian practice of routinely praying to give thanks to the Christian god before meals. I've known many Christians, of various denominations and varying levels of strictness, and if any of them said grace at meals I shared with them, it must've been quietly in their own heads, which is presumably sufficient. So if the nanny is saying grace out loud with the children, she's not simply following her own religion, she's teaching it to the children. Which is obviously fine if the parents want that, but many wouldn't.

I suspect you'd like to be able to choose whether or not to employ a nanny who intended to teach your child to follow a different religion.

first I would not employ a nanny as it is the parents job to bring up kids not farm them out. However, one does expect professionalism in the workplace and one would certainly not expect a nanny to go against the wishes of parents. Incidentally you might be interested that Anthony Ashley Cooper, Earl of Shaftesbury had a brutal and uncaring father but a loving nanny who prayed with him and taught him the basics of the Christian faith. Later in life it was the Christian faith that drove Shaftesbury to become a major force in factory reform for children and women, as well as freeing then from the mines and chimneys. So some good can come of teaching a kid to pray!

DonnaBanana · 17/01/2023 17:15

Very few people “choose” a religion unless it’s some hippy phase or a cult. It’s a process of how you’re brought up, the culture you’re raised in, etc. You can theoretically change your personality as well but people generally don’t.

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 17:11

It's interesting to read what you think you know about me, Crabo, but probably more telling than you think.

That shifting, dodging argument style won't work here, so back to the topic: the sub-discussion we were having was about whether, in the context of anti-discrimination legislation, it would be okay for people to decline to employ a nanny who intended to actively instruct a child in a religion different to that of the child's parents, including teaching them the Christian practice of routinely praying to give thanks to the Christian god before meals. I've known many Christians, of various denominations and varying levels of strictness, and if any of them said grace at meals I shared with them, it must've been quietly in their own heads, which is presumably sufficient. So if the nanny is saying grace out loud with the children, she's not simply following her own religion, she's teaching it to the children. Which is obviously fine if the parents want that, but many wouldn't.

I suspect you'd like to be able to choose whether or not to employ a nanny who intended to teach your child to follow a different religion.

ScrollingLeaves · 17/01/2023 17:10

I think it is a lot safer to say someone has a soul than to say they have an inner gender identity and have been in the wrong body.

AnorLondo · 17/01/2023 16:59

Crabo · 17/01/2023 16:46

Most teaching in schools is de facto atheistic. Or at least Epicurean / deistic. I can assure you in our society that one religion doesn’t dominate.
Secularism is king! You have nothing to fear from society. But as CS Lewis said the young atheist cannot be too careful as God sets traps everywhere! He knew from experience, of course!

Schools in England and Wales have to have collective worship by law. I've never heard of a school in the UK teaching pupils that god does not exist.

Melroses · 17/01/2023 16:55

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

It protects belief but also lack of belief in a religion.

So it protects atheists too.

No one can force you to believe.

Crabo · 17/01/2023 16:46

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 16:12

@Crabo CosmicVaginaBiscuit said I wouldn't want my nanny teaching DC about god(s) or saying grace before meals or telling them that God is everywhere or whatever. That was the only reference to saying grace. I assumed when you responded to her comment about saying grace in that context, calling the poster jumpy and talking about hackles rising, you were responding to what was actually written. If you had switched subject and were referring to saying grace at a mums and tots group, then you should have said so. It's an entirely different context. As is school, though I think that's closer to the nanny situation if trusted adults are teaching children to follow religious practices in loco parentis. This is why people sometimes prefer to send their kids to faith schools that match their own religious beliefs.

By the way, I think you need to go and find out what "secular" means (outside the clerical meaning, obviously). It doesn't mean atheistic or irreligious. It just means not connected with religion, or in a more specifically political sense, it refers to a view that religion should be separate to the state and public institutions, so that things which are for all of us like, say, the courts, or roads, or GP surgeries, should leave out religious aspects or at least not allow one religion to dominate, so that everyone can participate equally. But I've a feeling when you said "secular views" you meant something quite different.

Most teaching in schools is de facto atheistic. Or at least Epicurean / deistic. I can assure you in our society that one religion doesn’t dominate.
Secularism is king! You have nothing to fear from society. But as CS Lewis said the young atheist cannot be too careful as God sets traps everywhere! He knew from experience, of course!

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 16:12

@Crabo CosmicVaginaBiscuit said I wouldn't want my nanny teaching DC about god(s) or saying grace before meals or telling them that God is everywhere or whatever. That was the only reference to saying grace. I assumed when you responded to her comment about saying grace in that context, calling the poster jumpy and talking about hackles rising, you were responding to what was actually written. If you had switched subject and were referring to saying grace at a mums and tots group, then you should have said so. It's an entirely different context. As is school, though I think that's closer to the nanny situation if trusted adults are teaching children to follow religious practices in loco parentis. This is why people sometimes prefer to send their kids to faith schools that match their own religious beliefs.

By the way, I think you need to go and find out what "secular" means (outside the clerical meaning, obviously). It doesn't mean atheistic or irreligious. It just means not connected with religion, or in a more specifically political sense, it refers to a view that religion should be separate to the state and public institutions, so that things which are for all of us like, say, the courts, or roads, or GP surgeries, should leave out religious aspects or at least not allow one religion to dominate, so that everyone can participate equally. But I've a feeling when you said "secular views" you meant something quite different.

Crabo · 17/01/2023 15:46

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 15:24

Come on, a nanny is an important person in a child's life, spends a lot of time with the child, and is in a position to have a lot of influence on a child's developing worldview and value system. By hiring a particular person as a nanny, you implicitly communicate to the child(ren) that this is a person to be trusted and obeyed.

It's not "jumpy and threatened" to say that you would not want to hire a nanny who would actively teach your children a worldview that's completely different to your own — not just teaching them about different religions, but teaching them to practice that religion.

If you aren't religious, or you believe in a different god or gods, or have another religious worldview that doesn't involve any gods, then why would you want your nanny to communicate the importance of praying to show gratitude towards the nanny's god at every meal your children take with them? I think you'd struggle to find many people, religious or not, who'd want a major, trusted figure in their young child's life to be actively teaching the child to follow religious practices different from the family's own beliefs

But I wasn’t talking about hiring a nanny I was talking about saying grace at a mums and tots group. I hardly think that is ‘teaching the child religious practices.’ Besides if your own views are so correct and right what is the problem of exposing your child to different views? My children were brought up Christians but we’re of necessity exposed to secular views all the time at school. Just that I believe the arguments for faith are rational and historical and can take being exposed to different views. See Professor John Lennox on that
So I assume you would also make sure your nanny had all the correct political opinions and talked the correct PC speak?

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 15:24

Crabo · 17/01/2023 14:53

You seem very jumpy and threatened about someone saying grace. I wouldn’t think that someone saying grace is exactly ‘indoctrination’. Amazing how much indoctrination takes place and you don’t turn the hair over the media and whatever yet somebody’s saying grace causes your hackles to rise.

Come on, a nanny is an important person in a child's life, spends a lot of time with the child, and is in a position to have a lot of influence on a child's developing worldview and value system. By hiring a particular person as a nanny, you implicitly communicate to the child(ren) that this is a person to be trusted and obeyed.

It's not "jumpy and threatened" to say that you would not want to hire a nanny who would actively teach your children a worldview that's completely different to your own — not just teaching them about different religions, but teaching them to practice that religion.

If you aren't religious, or you believe in a different god or gods, or have another religious worldview that doesn't involve any gods, then why would you want your nanny to communicate the importance of praying to show gratitude towards the nanny's god at every meal your children take with them? I think you'd struggle to find many people, religious or not, who'd want a major, trusted figure in their young child's life to be actively teaching the child to follow religious practices different from the family's own beliefs

Crabo · 17/01/2023 14:53

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 17/01/2023 14:09

I'm not talking about sharing Christmas hampers, I also donate to a food bank. You don't have to be religious to think of others. While many religions have an ethos of helping others I personally feel it is overshadowed by their treatment of women or teachings on sex or homosexuality.
I went to a playgroup in a local CoE church, I didn't like it because the songs were singing thank you God for this that and the other. I wouldn't want my nanny teaching DC about god(s) or saying grace before meals or telling them that God is everywhere or whatever. I'm happy for them to learn about religions but not to be indoctrinated. This is only a tiny and quite specific detour from the original question about discrimination, and religion as a protected characteristic.
Thinking it over I think it is good that it's protected, but where there is a conflict religion should not trump innate characteristics like sex or sexual orientation.

You seem very jumpy and threatened about someone saying grace. I wouldn’t think that someone saying grace is exactly ‘indoctrination’. Amazing how much indoctrination takes place and you don’t turn the hair over the media and whatever yet somebody’s saying grace causes your hackles to rise.

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 17/01/2023 14:09

I'm not talking about sharing Christmas hampers, I also donate to a food bank. You don't have to be religious to think of others. While many religions have an ethos of helping others I personally feel it is overshadowed by their treatment of women or teachings on sex or homosexuality.
I went to a playgroup in a local CoE church, I didn't like it because the songs were singing thank you God for this that and the other. I wouldn't want my nanny teaching DC about god(s) or saying grace before meals or telling them that God is everywhere or whatever. I'm happy for them to learn about religions but not to be indoctrinated. This is only a tiny and quite specific detour from the original question about discrimination, and religion as a protected characteristic.
Thinking it over I think it is good that it's protected, but where there is a conflict religion should not trump innate characteristics like sex or sexual orientation.

Crabo · 17/01/2023 07:14

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 16/01/2023 22:11

@Crabo I'm not making assumptions, I'm wondering what would be the position if I were to employ someone to look after my child, and they went on to share their religious views with my child or let their views influence their treatment of our child.
I went to a convent school, I know that Catholicism has many mysoginistic practices and homophobia, we learned about other religions and many of them did not seem any better.
I have a Muslim fríend who drinks alcohol and smokes and parties (but will absolutely not eat pork). At his wedding there was a separate room for alcohol to be served in, because some of his family didn't want to be around it. I know not every member of every religion subscribes to all the beliefs (like many Catholics ignore the teachings on contraception or sex before marriage).
So many religions have an awful lot to say about sex, usually with a heap of judgement on women.
I believe companies should not be able to discriminate due to religion, I already said that upthread.

Just to say that if you wanted to book your children into our playgroup at our church it is oversubscribed. The atmosphere is so friendly that ladies (and some men) of all persuasions seem to be drawn to it with their kids. We did take some Christmas hampers out to those in need at Christmas to give them a good Christmas. If that is what you were talking about in ‘sharing religious views’ that is what we do.

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 16/01/2023 22:11

@Crabo I'm not making assumptions, I'm wondering what would be the position if I were to employ someone to look after my child, and they went on to share their religious views with my child or let their views influence their treatment of our child.
I went to a convent school, I know that Catholicism has many mysoginistic practices and homophobia, we learned about other religions and many of them did not seem any better.
I have a Muslim fríend who drinks alcohol and smokes and parties (but will absolutely not eat pork). At his wedding there was a separate room for alcohol to be served in, because some of his family didn't want to be around it. I know not every member of every religion subscribes to all the beliefs (like many Catholics ignore the teachings on contraception or sex before marriage).
So many religions have an awful lot to say about sex, usually with a heap of judgement on women.
I believe companies should not be able to discriminate due to religion, I already said that upthread.

BelperLawnmower · 16/01/2023 13:44

Crabo · 16/01/2023 08:56

I think you would do well to educate yourself on faith rather than starting with assumptions.

Catholicism, Islam, the Christian American right - that covers a large swathe of faith-based nonsense. It's all irredeemably misogynistic and homophobic (unless you indulge in the type of logical gymnastics that religion often delights in: that keeping women in the home is showing them respect, and that god made people gay to teach them the virtues of self denial).

Crabo · 16/01/2023 08:56

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 15/01/2023 21:36

@x2boys I was thinking more of childcare, possibly too specific on my part but as you say you wouldn't expect people to go on about religion in a professional environment. I was wondering if I employed e.g. a Christian / Muslim / Jewish nanny would they be praying or teaching my child about Jesus or not feeding them ham sandwiches or something, because of their religious beliefs.
As a PP says I find it difficult to respect many religions because of their basic starting point with women as second class citizens, and homophobic views. Not for me.

I think you would do well to educate yourself on faith rather than starting with assumptions.

x2boys · 15/01/2023 21:56

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 15/01/2023 21:36

@x2boys I was thinking more of childcare, possibly too specific on my part but as you say you wouldn't expect people to go on about religion in a professional environment. I was wondering if I employed e.g. a Christian / Muslim / Jewish nanny would they be praying or teaching my child about Jesus or not feeding them ham sandwiches or something, because of their religious beliefs.
As a PP says I find it difficult to respect many religions because of their basic starting point with women as second class citizens, and homophobic views. Not for me.

Well I would hope a professional Nanny would keep.their personal beliefs to themselves as it really wouldn't be appropriate to bring their.beliefs into.the work place and if they couldn't than I wouldn't blame you for not employing them

CosmicVaginaBiscuit · 15/01/2023 21:36

@x2boys I was thinking more of childcare, possibly too specific on my part but as you say you wouldn't expect people to go on about religion in a professional environment. I was wondering if I employed e.g. a Christian / Muslim / Jewish nanny would they be praying or teaching my child about Jesus or not feeding them ham sandwiches or something, because of their religious beliefs.
As a PP says I find it difficult to respect many religions because of their basic starting point with women as second class citizens, and homophobic views. Not for me.

Crabo · 15/01/2023 20:36

Burgoo · 15/01/2023 19:33

@Crabo "You say you find religion ‘all bizarre and absurd’. That to me is a pretty aggressive statement to begin a post with. If I had begun a post by saying ‘I find atheism bizarre and absurd’ you would no doubt have thought me aggressive."

Aggressive? Come on. This isn't a playground. If you don't like what someone says that is perfectly okay. Words aren't violence.

I have no problem with it but the OP was complaining about religious people being aggressive. With respect I have noticed that atheists tend to have a different set of rules for themselves than other people. I can debate as robustly as you like as I believe atheism is an unprovable fantasy (even Dawkins says he’s only 70% sure God doesn’t exist!) and am sure of my faith, but we are not debating here the validity of faith but the right of people to religious view - ie the right to religious freedom - which includes, btw the right to disbelieve. A right God gives us all.

ADHDPI · 15/01/2023 20:21

Crabo · 15/01/2023 15:13

You say you find religion ‘all bizarre and absurd’. That to me is a pretty aggressive statement to begin a post with. If I had begun a post by saying ‘I find atheism bizarre and absurd’ you would no doubt have thought me aggressive.

I don't think that's aggressive at all. It's my genuine opinion, a lot of people disagree and think atheism is bizarre and absurd. Fair enough, if that's what you believe.

I think I've made a fair effort to actually take in what people have said on this thread and I've learnt a lot. I agree that religion should be a protected characteristic, I wasn't sure when I initially posted.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread