Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 13/01/2023 14:38

Can you not envisage circumstances where you are discriminated against because of your religion, op? Maybe you need to read up on Northern Ireland or sectarianism in Scotland.

89redballoons · 13/01/2023 14:37

As a very lapsed Catholic, I'm not sure I agree that religion is something you choose freely.

In lots of societies, religion is deeply intertwined with ethnicity, nationality, culture, class - things you can't change and some of which are protected characteristics.

Human rights law, which underpins the Eqaulity Act, developed as a response to WW2 and the Nazi atrocities against Jewish people. The Nazis weren't really interested in how faithful or devout the Jews they persecuted were. Nazi thought was much more based on race/culture than on religious belief.

Also, thinking practically about current UK law, if (eg) religion wasn't a protected characteristic but nationality was, then if (eg) you wanted to not employ many Polish or Irish people you could just say no Catholics. So it would create a loophole.

HermioneWeasley · 13/01/2023 14:37

@babyjellyfish thanks to Maya Forstarter, being gender critical is a protected belief

OP, I understand where you’re coming from - being religious is a choice in a way that your sex or disability is not, but is it also a major axis of discrimination. I don’t think anyone would be comfortable with businesses announcing they’re not serving Jews for example.

it leads to a delicate balancing of rights - it is perfectly acceptable for someone to be an open practising Christian, to talk about their faith and (subject to dress codes) to wear a crucifix. It is not acceptable for them to kneel at my desk praying for my salvation because I’m gay and atheist. I am perfectly free to say I don’t believe in god, it is not acceptable in the workplace for me to call someone an idiot who has an imaginary friend.

LynneBenfield · 13/01/2023 14:37

I’m an atheist too but it’s pretty clear that the law in terms of religion as a protected characteristic is to protect against religious persecution, not from Dave at work saying saying moderately controversial.

Xenopus · 13/01/2023 14:34

Think you’re misinterpreting why it’s a protected characteristic. It’s so you can’t be discriminated against (getting a job, house etc.) because you are X religion (or not as the case may be).

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:32

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 14:30

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

That's the daft argument. There's no history of people being discriminated against nor privileged for the colour of their t-shirts. The protected characteristics are those which need protection. Homophobia, sexism, ableism, discriminating against pregnant women, racism, transphobia, religious intolerance ... all known, real issues. The latter is probably the one which has historically caused most bloodshed.

Yep that's a very good point!

OP posts:
PoIIyPandemonium · 13/01/2023 14:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 14:30

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

That's the daft argument. There's no history of people being discriminated against nor privileged for the colour of their t-shirts. The protected characteristics are those which need protection. Homophobia, sexism, ableism, discriminating against pregnant women, racism, transphobia, religious intolerance ... all known, real issues. The latter is probably the one which has historically caused most bloodshed.

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:30

PinkFrogss · 13/01/2023 14:28

I don’t think you understand protected characteristics and the equality act OP

I probably don't to be fair! And I'm genuinely not trying to be goady. It was just a random thought that came to me and I have learnt a fair bit already through people's responses. Just thought it would be an interesting conversation.

OP posts:
ClaudiaWankleman · 13/01/2023 14:30

Presumably you wouldn't want to be discriminated against for being an atheist? To make it workable you have to protect religious believers and atheists.

Hiphopskotch · 13/01/2023 14:30

Atheism falls under the same "religion or belief" protected characteristic, so your views are also protected. You are entitled to express them but not in a way that undermines the protected characteristic of another.

DinnerThyme · 13/01/2023 14:29

If your job said there was now mandatory prayer and that you would be fired if you didn’t pray at work then I’m sure you’d suddenly decide that protecting your freedom of belief mattered.

PinkFrogss · 13/01/2023 14:28

I don’t think you understand protected characteristics and the equality act OP

BelperLawnmower · 13/01/2023 14:28

The Equality Act doesn't prevent you from insulting people. You're quite free to call any religious belief ridiculous and religious people are quite entitled to tell you that you're going to burn in hell for all eternity. But you can't discriminate against each other in employment or the provision of services.

UsuallySuze · 13/01/2023 14:28

Why do you think you're not allowed to say you think religion is nonsense and don't believe in God?

Religion as a protected characteristic isn't about stopping people expressing their religious views but about preventing discrimination on the grounds of religion. So you're not allowed to deny someone a service or a job on the ground that they are Jewish, say. Arguing that this should not apply because people choose their religion is a bit misguided (it's not the same sort of choice as choosing to drive a blue car or a red one but rather for many people one which is intimately connected with their cultural and ethnic heritage) and a violation of the principle of religious freedom (which includes your own freedom not to believe).

kitsuneghost · 13/01/2023 14:27

I get where you are coming from but yes I do think you are looking at it a bit too black and white.

The law is set to protect people from a higher level discrimination such as getting refused jobs, entry to places, services and sometimes verbally and physically attacked.

Unfortunately some (but definitely not all) people use it as a wall to prevent their religion getting put up for debate.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 13/01/2023 14:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RunnerBum · 13/01/2023 14:26

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:21

This is a daft argument though. I mean, I wouldn't want someone to sack me because I wear a yellow t-shirt, but I don't think the want to wear yellow t-shirts should be a protected characteristic.

You think my argument is “daft” and then produce that in response? Ok then. 😂You’re not posting in good faith, you’re just looking to be told how silly religion is so you can feel justified in insulting it. I’m not religious but I’d much rather spend time talking to someone about their religion than listening to someone jabbing at others’ faith for no reason. You’re just as protected, you’ve invented a reason to be annoyed that doesn’t exist.

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 13/01/2023 14:26

And this was my point. As an atheist, by saying I believe religion is a nonsense, which I'm allowed to do, in directly insulting someone else on the basis of their protected characteristic

Can you not see that saying “I don’t believe in religion” is very different to saying to someone “I believe religion is nonsense”?

I would be very unhappy if any of my employees said they think religion is nonsense in a work environment. That is not a difference of opinion, it’s telling someone with a different view that you think their view is nonsense.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 13/01/2023 14:25

But if your religion said God would judge you for not wearing a yellow t shirt and it was necessary for your faith, you would react very badly to being told not too.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 14:25

Religion - which includes lack thereof - is something which unfortunately in the real world is a pretty common source of discrimination.

I'm not sure there's any grounds for someone getting into trouble for a civil discussion of beliefs (or lack thereof). Its if that turns into harassment or worse - then that not acceptable.

I'm an atheist, I'm glad we have this characteristic, which at least partially protects us too. (Of course schools are allowed to discriminate against our kids Hmm)

PinkFrogss · 13/01/2023 14:24

You probably wouldn’t be sacked for that, and protected characteristics aren’t protected in the sense people aren’t allowed to comment, it’s more that you can’t be sacked or disadvantaged because of them. So you could say you think religion is absurd (but probably get told workplace discussions need to be appropriate) but you couldn’t refuse to give someone a promotion on the basis that they’re Muslim for example

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:23

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 13/01/2023 14:21

I'm an atheist RS teacher. You can say you don't believe it without insulting it and calling it absurd, as I frequently have to explain to the students. It's protected because for most people it's so ingrained in them from birth, upbringing etc that it is a fundamental part of their identity. I do think there are difficulties in areas such as circunmcision, halal or kosher slaughtering techniques, or the clash between a traditional scriptural view of homosexuality and equality law etc where traditional practice is contrary to modern UK views, but in general terms, I think it is right that it is protected, probably increasingly so as it becomes less and less common.

Sure. And I don't have conversations like that at work. But actually I do believe it is absurd, and I think it's bizarre that people believe in something they've never had proof of, and I think it's all a bit daft and cringe worthy. It bothers me that a belief (or non belief) that I have is up there in the list eotj racism and sexism when it comes to protected characteristics. I don't think it's the same. I do see what you mean though, and I am more than willing to have my mind changed!

OP posts:
Sqqueeeeeeee · 13/01/2023 14:23

This thread is so goady. You obviously know the difference between “being an atheist” and “saying that religion is bizarre/absurd/nonsense”. You can be an atheist and not be a dick - 99% of atheists manage it. Regardless, you wouldn’t be fired for your belief. But you could be if it weren’t protected. If a Catholic person said Islam was “nonsense” they’d have the same repercussions as if you said Catholicism is “nonsense”. Your atheism is a protected characteristic just like everyone else’s belief. You’re not complaining about religion being protected, you’re just complaining that people don’t like you be rude under the guise of it being your “belief”.

TirisfalPumpkin · 13/01/2023 14:23

It is religion or belief - it’s the same grounds under which your atheism is protected. Saying religious is nonsense might be a protected manifestation of your non belief, depending on context.

many people find religion ridiculous and irrational, but that doesn’t make it any less sacred/core to who they are for believers. If you are one (whether about a religious or deeply held philosophical belief) - it doesn’t feel like you can change it, any more than you can any other aspect of who you are as a person. It should remain protected on that basis IMO - with protection obviously not extending to believers trying to force their belief on others.