Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else think that religion is a bit of an odd protected characteristic?

263 replies

ADHDPI · 13/01/2023 14:13

I may be way off the mark here as it is only a thought that has popped into my head just now.

As an atheist, I have quite strong feelings about religion and find it all quite bizarre and absurd. However, if I said that to someone religious in my office I could potentially be sacked due to criticism of their protected characteristic.

I just don't feel it is the same as saying a similar comment about disability, ethnicity, sex etc. Of course I don't think anyone should be actively discriminated against because of their religion, but no more so than because of the colour of someone's eyes. It doesn't effect anyone else. It's more the fact that I as an atheist cannot voice my opinion about religion without insulting a protected characteristic and vice versa.... Yet its generally OK to believe that God doesn't exist. Odd!

Thoughts? Have I missed something? Am I being far too black and white here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 15:38

Crabo · 18/01/2023 15:23

Just to counter your point that the Christian faith is not the negative force sone people were making it out to be. I can give you dozens of examples if you like but I might be accused of proselytising. Just trying to balance the books a bit

I've said absolutely nothing about whether Christianity is a negative force.

It's interesting that you perceive a defence of parents' right to raise their child according to their own beliefs, and their right not to employ someone who actively teaches their child practices from other religions, as anti-Christian.

I wonder why, in the UK, you would think that a stance against parents being required to allow others to impose different religious teachings on their children is an attack on Christianity specifically.

AltheaVestr1t · 18/01/2023 15:25

89redballoons · 13/01/2023 14:37

As a very lapsed Catholic, I'm not sure I agree that religion is something you choose freely.

In lots of societies, religion is deeply intertwined with ethnicity, nationality, culture, class - things you can't change and some of which are protected characteristics.

Human rights law, which underpins the Eqaulity Act, developed as a response to WW2 and the Nazi atrocities against Jewish people. The Nazis weren't really interested in how faithful or devout the Jews they persecuted were. Nazi thought was much more based on race/culture than on religious belief.

Also, thinking practically about current UK law, if (eg) religion wasn't a protected characteristic but nationality was, then if (eg) you wanted to not employ many Polish or Irish people you could just say no Catholics. So it would create a loophole.

Yep. OP, you are massively missing the point. Belief in religion may be 'bizarre' when taken out of context, but religion is deeply rooted in sociology, culture, history, ethnicity and many other aspects of life. In addition to which, freedom of belief is a basic human right. How about if I was sacked for distributing Christmas cards? Are people still allowed to wear crosses? Should Muslims be forced to eat pork? What if they are vegetarian? Your argument breaks down almost immediately. So yes, as a fellow atheist, YABU. Don't be ridiculous.

Crabo · 18/01/2023 15:23

JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 14:58

Mmhmm, and what was the point of view? What was the point that you were using the example to illustrate?

Just to counter your point that the Christian faith is not the negative force sone people were making it out to be. I can give you dozens of examples if you like but I might be accused of proselytising. Just trying to balance the books a bit

JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 14:58

Mmhmm, and what was the point of view? What was the point that you were using the example to illustrate?

Crabo · 18/01/2023 14:55

It was just giving a point of view - like you were just giving a point of view! I don’t see why you must be so jumpy that everyone who gives a different point of view over the Internet must be accused of proselytising

ErrolTheDragon · 18/01/2023 14:08

Your motive in posting a carefully-selected lovely positive story about a person who credited their philanthropy to a nanny who taught them to be a Christian was… what?

That sometimes farming out kids can work out well?Grin

JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 12:42

Crabo · 18/01/2023 12:35

As you indeed have a motive for writing what are you did of course!

Obviously. My motive is that I think it's okay for people to decide not to employ a person as a nanny to help raise their children, if that person intends to train the children in a religion the parents don't share (and I'm backed up by the law in that), and that I wanted to draw out from you what you thought about that.

Your motive in posting a carefully-selected lovely positive story about a person who credited their philanthropy to a nanny who taught them to be a Christian was… what?

Crabo · 18/01/2023 12:35

JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 10:05

Nobody's trying to "cancel" anyone from history. What point were you trying to make about parents' right to choose a nanny who won't actively teach a religion the parents don't follow, with the particular fact you selected? The proselytising angle is that you selected this historical story to tell, in this particular context, and you had a motive for doing so.

As you indeed have a motive for writing what are you did of course!

ArtixLynx · 18/01/2023 10:33

i think it depends.. i'm Pagan, and a practising Witch, i'm always happy to discuss religion/faith/belief if people have questions.

However, i DO have a right to be protected at work from Christians who want to call me a Satanist, or leave evil eyes/crosses on my desk, or tell me they'll pray for me to save me from the Devil, or refusing to include me in things, or refuse promotions or opportunities because of my faith.. all which are things which HAVE happened in the past.

ShodanLives · 18/01/2023 10:28

Crabo · 17/01/2023 21:05

first I would not employ a nanny as it is the parents job to bring up kids not farm them out. However, one does expect professionalism in the workplace and one would certainly not expect a nanny to go against the wishes of parents. Incidentally you might be interested that Anthony Ashley Cooper, Earl of Shaftesbury had a brutal and uncaring father but a loving nanny who prayed with him and taught him the basics of the Christian faith. Later in life it was the Christian faith that drove Shaftesbury to become a major force in factory reform for children and women, as well as freeing then from the mines and chimneys. So some good can come of teaching a kid to pray!

Using childcare is not farming out kids ffs.

JarByTheDoor · 18/01/2023 10:05

Crabo · 18/01/2023 07:04

There you go. I was right. You are is jumpy is anything. Simple history lesson of fact is taken as proselytising. So Anthony Ashley Cooper should be cancelled from history because his Christianity does not agree with your views?

Nobody's trying to "cancel" anyone from history. What point were you trying to make about parents' right to choose a nanny who won't actively teach a religion the parents don't follow, with the particular fact you selected? The proselytising angle is that you selected this historical story to tell, in this particular context, and you had a motive for doing so.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/01/2023 09:45

There is a state religion.
But no one should now be privileged by belonging to it or discriminated against for not belonging, that's the point.

Of course, there's still some shameful exceptions around schools admissions (I live in an area with a ludicrous excess of faith schools), but we have the freedom to campaign about our children being discriminated against at least.

Marths · 18/01/2023 09:28

Crabo · 18/01/2023 08:24

I would have thought that in our secular society one thing that is protected is the right not to believe!

There is a state religion.

littleburn · 18/01/2023 08:57

HaroldeVwilliam · 18/01/2023 07:41

Only read the op but I agree,the right not to believe should also be protected

It is. The right not to have a religious belief and the right to have 'comparable' beliefs such as atheism, humanism etc has always been included under this protected characteristic. More recently case law has established that being 'gender critical' - not believing in gender or that people can literally change sex - is a 'comparable' protected belief. The overall point of the legislation is that you shouldn't be treated less favourably in the workplace or in the provision of good or services because of your religion or belief.

Crabo · 18/01/2023 08:24

HaroldeVwilliam · 18/01/2023 07:41

Only read the op but I agree,the right not to believe should also be protected

I would have thought that in our secular society one thing that is protected is the right not to believe!

Plbrookes · 18/01/2023 08:10

Which it is and which no-one is disputing.

HaroldeVwilliam · 18/01/2023 07:41

Only read the op but I agree,the right not to believe should also be protected

littleburn · 18/01/2023 07:38

My professional background means I work a lot with employment law. My understanding is that the EA2010 and the protected characteristic of Religion or Belief is primarily about protecting individuals from discrimination and harassment on the basis of being a member of a religious group. For example, you cannot refuse services, or refuse to employ, or sack someone because they are Muslim or Jewish etc. It's not about protecting the expression of religious belief per se, and the guidance from ACAS is that prosletysing in the workplace can in itself be a form of harassment (e.g. telling work colleagues that gay marriage is 'wrong'). I think most of us would agree that refusing to employ someone because they are, say, a Muslim woman is wrong and harassing that woman for wearing a headscarf is wrong and that 'well you don't have to be Muslim' isn't a good response to addressing that discrimination.

Similarly, an employer couldn't refuse to employ the OP because they are an atheist. However, if the OP were to go around their workplace telling people their religion is ridiculous, those employees may well have a case for saying they are being harassed in the workplace on the basis of their religion. If an evangelical Christian colleague kept trying to convert the OP, they would have a similar case. If an employer refused a Muslim employee a 5 minute break to say their prayers, but allows other employee cigarette breaks, they would have a case etc etc.

Crabo · 18/01/2023 07:04

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 21:30

one would certainly not expect a nanny to go against the wishes of parents

There we go. That was like getting blood from a stone.

No, I'm not interested in your proselytising.

There you go. I was right. You are is jumpy is anything. Simple history lesson of fact is taken as proselytising. So Anthony Ashley Cooper should be cancelled from history because his Christianity does not agree with your views?

Rickandmortified100 · 18/01/2023 05:39

This is so ignorant, narrow minded and just lacking in a basic understanding of religion and faith and how it affects a persons identity. Only an atheist could say that someone can just ‘change’ their religion. Actually, no, they can’t. It’s not a hobby. It’s not a fad. People who are truly religious KNOW their God with as much certainty as you know, say, your next door neighbour. Sure, some people might, at a later time lose their faith for whatever reason, but for a huge number of people, their faith is an essential part of their identity for their whole lives. It is who they are. Of COURSE you shouldn’t be able to discriminate against people based on nothing other than their religion? What happened to freedom of religious belief? I don’t care if you’re an atheist, but if you, say, refuse to allow my child to study at your school because of their religion, or refuse to hire me into a position I’m well qualified for purely because of my religion then yes, that is wrong. I couldn’t change my religion any more than I could my ethnicity, nor would I want to. My religious beliefs aren’t harming you so why should you be legally allowed to discriminate against me for them?

ErrolTheDragon · 18/01/2023 00:26

I know I wouldn't be able to change what I believe to be true and real through a simple act of choice.

Not a simple one. I went from being a Christian to being an atheist, the "choice" I suppose was to examine the basis of my belief. I didn't choose where evidence and logic would lead. Once I'd stopped believing there was a god, I couldn't just choose to believe again, and certainly couldn't continue participating in a religion I now believed to be untrue, even though I missed the church (though not god).

Shelefttheweb · 18/01/2023 00:14

Religion isn’t something you choose of can’t just change. It isn’t a lifestyle (though I get for some it is more of a culture). If you believe in a religion then that can be a total conviction. Just as much as an atheist can be sure there is no god, a religious person can be certain there is. Do you think it is ok to sack people because they are atheist not Muslim? Or Christian not humanist? Or pay someone less because they are Jewish?

ScrollingLeaves · 18/01/2023 00:01

MichaelFabricantWig · Today 22:59
+I agree. People can wake up tomorrow and make a choice not to follow the religion they are. It may have cultural implications but it is still possible. People can’t choose not to be gay, disabled, black, etc*

People who are religious are following a belief in something greater than themselves, beyond the material world, on a spiritual plane. It is like an inner search and need pursued through a religion to give it structure, form and ritual. For some humans it is a primary need. It is an orientation.

It is just as important not to be discriminated against at work simply for having a religion, as it is to be discriminated against for any of the other characteristics like sexual orientation.

JarByTheDoor · 17/01/2023 23:14

MichaelFabricantWig · 17/01/2023 22:59

I agree. People can wake up tomorrow and make a choice not to follow the religion they are. It may have cultural implications but it is still possible. People can’t choose not to be gay, disabled, black, etc

Are you sure? I dare you to try it tomorrow. For a whole day, genuinely believe something entirely different about the way the world works. Whatever religious status you know the most about, outside your own beliefs — so if, for example, you're a non-religious person with a culturally Christian heritage, that might involve spending a day believing that Jesus existed died for your sins and was resurrected, and that you can talk inside your head to an all-powerful god who is listening and may well respond in some way. I bet you can't choose to actually, genuinely believe those things are literally true for a day. I know I wouldn't be able to change what I believe to be true and real through a simple act of choice.

MichaelFabricantWig · 17/01/2023 22:59

Conkersinautumn · 17/01/2023 22:00

Religion is a choice, the choice to believe in something, despite having no evidence, literally that's faith. Sex, sexuality, race are not a choice. Do to me, yes, religion is a poor 'protected' characteristic as the 'protection' needs to be reserved for the victims of religious coercion, which is swept under the carpet, yet it happens.

I agree. People can wake up tomorrow and make a choice not to follow the religion they are. It may have cultural implications but it is still possible. People can’t choose not to be gay, disabled, black, etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread