Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why there is no effective alternative to Mammography?

134 replies

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 12:47

3 years ago, when I was 48, I was delighted to be asked early for a routine mammogram (I had no pain or lumps). I have dense breasts, and the pain during compression was excruciating. I don't even know if the radiographer managed to complete it, because I went faint. I've had pain in my right breast ever since, which I took to be bruising/strain, but when it didn't go I was referred for investigation at the hospital breast unit June 2021. They did ultrasound which was clear as far 'as they could see' but 'mammogram is the gold standard and only that will tell us for certain'. I had to be content with the ultrasound as my fear of the mammogram pain got the better of me. Fast forward to last Sept, I went on combined HRT and have what I took to be hormonal pain in both breasts which masked the targeted pain in my right. However it's coming through more than ever now and I've been referred back to the hospital for the same process as 18 months ago. Part of me is so angry at myself of being fearful of something that could save my life, and the other part is worried sick about how I will cope even with painkillers if I can get over the fear, and wondering why this is the only scan that still compresses tissue; why in over 100 years there is no effective 3D alternative.

OP posts:
JustDanceAddict · 13/01/2023 14:35

It’s a good question. I had my first routine mammogram last year and I was recalled to the breast clinic and had more, plus ultrasound & biopsy. Luckily all was well but I found the mammogram excruciating- when I walked out of the first one I thought thank fuck that’s over for 3 years
I am literally gritting my teeth and can only bear the pain just for the short amount of time it takes. Next time I’ll take painkillers beforehand.

Whataretheodds · 13/01/2023 14:33

ancientgran · 13/01/2023 14:29

Gosh yes, they get the opportunity to let the cancer advance and maybe too late to treat. Lucky devils. Coming from a family with the BRCA gene and having seen numerous female relative die I've always been very grateful for the screening.

That's not the point at all.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:33

@Hongkongsuey Thank you. I see now it was an American site that said only 1 compression - thank you for correcting that. I took pain relief before the routine mammogram 3 years ago and I felt afterwards like the excruciating pain was my body's way of telling me damage is being done. I've felt discomfort during cervical screening, but I go back year after year without fail or delay, I had both laparoscopy and hysterogram for fertility screening which was a bit painful but this felt completely different. That's the reason I don't want to go back.

However, asking them to stop if it's too much is an option. The radiographer was dismissive and just wanted to keep going even though I was in tears. I know I need to get over that experience and try again.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 13/01/2023 14:29

MrsBrandonspiano · 13/01/2023 14:27

I honestly think that if a man needed to have his cock and balls squashed in a device for preventative screening, a better less invasive test would have been discovered years ago.

Gosh yes, they get the opportunity to let the cancer advance and maybe too late to treat. Lucky devils. Coming from a family with the BRCA gene and having seen numerous female relative die I've always been very grateful for the screening.

ancientgran · 13/01/2023 14:27

Hongkongsuey · 13/01/2023 14:21

Nothing is 100% but mammograms are highly sensitive and have good specificity. For very high risk women, there is MRI but it’s a time consuming exam involving lying face down in an enclosed tunnel for 20 minutes and can involve an injection of contrast. Ultrasound isn’t really effective as a screening tool. Tomosynthesis is very promising for screening of denser breasts but still involves compression-whoever told you it only involves one compression is mistaken. It also takes longer than a standard mammogram due to the number of images taken.
Have you tried taking pain relief half an hour before your mammogram? It can also depend on the skill of the Mammographer. Especially with the sideways picture, compression in the right place is important for reducing discomfort. Unfortunately, not adequately compressing can result in unclear images. I would tell the Mammographer you’re worried-and you can stop the exam if it’s too much. For most women, mammograms are uncomfortable rather than painful but there is a small number of women who do feel pain. Good luck.

I agree about the skill of the mammographer. I had to delay my last mammogram as I'd broken ribs coughing when I had covid. They made me another appointment and said the mammographer was good with "difficult" cases. So I went along, still in pain but nowhere near as bad as when I cancelled the first appointment. The mammographer was great, I was so nervous but she was patient and it was the least uncomfortable mammogram I've ever had.

MrsBrandonspiano · 13/01/2023 14:27

I honestly think that if a man needed to have his cock and balls squashed in a device for preventative screening, a better less invasive test would have been discovered years ago.

novacancy3 · 13/01/2023 14:24

My first mammogram was very painful. My second one was a breeze. I think the operator / technician plays a part in how uncomfortable it is.

I've had to have another medical procedure twice in the last few years. In this case the first was no trouble, but the second was so traumatic it has put me off ever having one again. So, yes, the person carrying out the procedure must have some bearing on the experience.

ancientgran · 13/01/2023 14:24

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:13

@StopGo It's interesting to note that your father wasn't subject compression - I do hope your father is well now and wish him all the best.

Presumably he wasn't screened, men aren't are they, so the cancer would have been found later. I'm not sure that is a good thing.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:23

@Seaweedandsalt Thank you for this!

OP posts:
Hongkongsuey · 13/01/2023 14:21

Nothing is 100% but mammograms are highly sensitive and have good specificity. For very high risk women, there is MRI but it’s a time consuming exam involving lying face down in an enclosed tunnel for 20 minutes and can involve an injection of contrast. Ultrasound isn’t really effective as a screening tool. Tomosynthesis is very promising for screening of denser breasts but still involves compression-whoever told you it only involves one compression is mistaken. It also takes longer than a standard mammogram due to the number of images taken.
Have you tried taking pain relief half an hour before your mammogram? It can also depend on the skill of the Mammographer. Especially with the sideways picture, compression in the right place is important for reducing discomfort. Unfortunately, not adequately compressing can result in unclear images. I would tell the Mammographer you’re worried-and you can stop the exam if it’s too much. For most women, mammograms are uncomfortable rather than painful but there is a small number of women who do feel pain. Good luck.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:20

@MissyB1 I suspect that's the case. The NHS will have invested billions into this equipment, it won't be in there interests to deviate, I guess.

OP posts:
Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:19

@Redblanky I thought the same. Believe it or not, I read up on the day before so I was fully prepped - or so I thought. It was still nothing like I imagined!

OP posts:
Eatentoomanyroses · 13/01/2023 14:17

Does it hurt more if you have implants does anyone know?

MissyB1 · 13/01/2023 14:16

I suspect mammogram is the most cost effective tool for a mass public screening programme.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:16

@Flowersinthebasement I'm glad all turned out well for you. And yes, everything you wrote resonated with me. I'm glad you've found an alternative too.

OP posts:
Seaweedandsalt · 13/01/2023 14:14

LoobyDop · 13/01/2023 13:17

YANBU. I’ve only had one, it was absolutely agonising, and I’m dreading having to do it again. I had no idea beforehand how unpleasant it is, I thought it was just the embarrassment that people disliked.

This was my experience too. It helps if you have a hot bath before hand apparently. Or so I read.

thewinterwitch · 13/01/2023 14:13

Some operators are better than others, also. Some are really vicious.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:13

@StopGo It's interesting to note that your father wasn't subject compression - I do hope your father is well now and wish him all the best.

OP posts:
Redblanky · 13/01/2023 14:12

It was a real shock to me. I imagined you just stood in front of a screen like having an xray.

Flowersinthebasement · 13/01/2023 14:11

I'm in my 60s and the boobies have gone South. I find it both embarrassing and very uncomfortable/painful.

Anyway, I had a mammo a couple of years ago and something needed further investigation (all good thankfully), and I was referred for an ultrasound.

When with the sonographer, I asked why the ultrasound is not the first thing to do and he really couldn't answer that to my satisfaction, other than to say they direct the u/s at the area pinpointed by the mammo. The other thing is the mammo is radiation, and the ultrasound is not.

I now pay for a private 3D ultrasound every two years or so with the breast clinic at a private hospital. They haven't pushed me towards mammo first YET, but they did strongly suggest it.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:10

@MissyB1 I'm so glad your cancer was detected and I hope you made/make a full recovery. I obviously felt reassured enough 18 months ago to leave hospital with only ultrasound results, but they really did (albeit kindly) hammer it home that only compression mammography held the key. Your experience makes me wonder if they are just upholding a general rule about ultrasound v mammography.

OP posts:
Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:05

@PaperMonster I'm so sorry to hear that. The first thing I did when I left the clinic was Google when I'd next be called back. I was shaking, sore and tearful. My boss thought I'd been attacked. I hope that you're feeling better and I'm glad for you too, that there seem to be other options, albeit with caveats.

OP posts:
Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 13:59

@milkyaqua No indeed. There are many uncomfortable female procedures I feel would be revised and modernised, even on the NHS, if men had to be subjected to them. Ultrasound & thermography are apparently not as effective with smaller irregularities, though I do wonder if we are sold this as a convenience, because to make exceptions isn't cost effective. I will look into Tomosynthesis a bit further - the research I'd done suggested it was indeed more thorough, but involved the same compression rate - but that only one compression per breast is required.

OP posts:
xogossipgirlxo · 13/01/2023 13:59

I will never go to mammography, I know this for sure. It sounds like torture and it's not even that effective or healthy smashing your breasts. My mum's friend had cancer that wasn't detected by mammogram. You can book private scan or 3d mammogram if you want to have it done anyway.

StopGo · 13/01/2023 13:53

My father was treated for breast cancer he was never subjected to a mammogram. Crushing delicate breast tissue seems draconian.