Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why there is no effective alternative to Mammography?

134 replies

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 12:47

3 years ago, when I was 48, I was delighted to be asked early for a routine mammogram (I had no pain or lumps). I have dense breasts, and the pain during compression was excruciating. I don't even know if the radiographer managed to complete it, because I went faint. I've had pain in my right breast ever since, which I took to be bruising/strain, but when it didn't go I was referred for investigation at the hospital breast unit June 2021. They did ultrasound which was clear as far 'as they could see' but 'mammogram is the gold standard and only that will tell us for certain'. I had to be content with the ultrasound as my fear of the mammogram pain got the better of me. Fast forward to last Sept, I went on combined HRT and have what I took to be hormonal pain in both breasts which masked the targeted pain in my right. However it's coming through more than ever now and I've been referred back to the hospital for the same process as 18 months ago. Part of me is so angry at myself of being fearful of something that could save my life, and the other part is worried sick about how I will cope even with painkillers if I can get over the fear, and wondering why this is the only scan that still compresses tissue; why in over 100 years there is no effective 3D alternative.

OP posts:
jetadore · 13/01/2023 17:21

Probably because it only affects women so it’s not important enough to find a better solution or fund more expensive alternatives. If men had to have their knob squished every few years to check for cancer you can guarantee there’d have been a painless way of checking invented decades ago.

FictionalCharacter · 13/01/2023 17:15

“I doubt men would agree to have their testicles crushed every couple of years.”

Too right @milkyaqua . If this had ever been proposed as a screen for testicular health issues, it would have been rejected as being too painful for a diagnostic procedure.

PregnantandPissedoff · 13/01/2023 16:52

Mammograms pick up small microcalcifications which can be associated with DCIS (early non invasive cancer) which ultrasound can't.
Ultrasound can pick up small masses in dense breasts that mammogram can't.
In symptomatic clinic both are used, for screening mammogram is most effective.
It's rubbish you had so much pain in your last mammogram!

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 13/01/2023 16:51

Because of the patriarchy.

RatherBeRiding · 13/01/2023 16:45

I've had a few mammograms now, and none of them were remotely painful - slightly uncomfortable at worst. Maybe I'm just lucky, or had sympathetic and skilled staff but although I really wasn't looking forward to the first one, I found it extremely quick and honestly not painful at all. It's not what I would call a pleasant experience, having boobs squished between metal plates, but on a scale of 1-10 I'd rate it a 1.5.

GlassBunion · 13/01/2023 16:45

I've always dreaded mammograms as I've always found them painful and thought that my breasts would burst.
Went for a routine mammogram last autumn . Was dreading it but immediately noticed the machine was much smaller than previously.
I slapped me bap out onto the plate and waited for the crushing pain. None whatsoever.

I mentioned how different and more comfortable it was and the nurse said that they'd got a new machine that also offer better imaging. She said that this new machine was becoming the preferred one for screening purposes.
Maybe these are more widespread now.

mathanxiety · 13/01/2023 16:44

@Aphrathestorm

The detection of very small, stage 1 cancers is far better accomplished by routine mammograms, especially 3D mammograms, in women with average risk (a 12% lifetime risk).

Very early detection gives a better chance of cure.

In women with a first degree relative who has had breast cancer or if there's a known or suspected genetic risk, routine breast self exam is recommended, and not considered optional, by the American Cancer Society.

Funding of research into breast cancer in the US far outstrips research in other cancers.

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 16:40

Aphrathestorm · 13/01/2023 16:17

I don't go for smears and I won't go for mammograms.

They should invite all 50+ women to classes to teach self breast exam. That's how most breast cancers are detected.

Self exam used to be promoted and there were leaflets teaching you how to do it. It is no longer recommended as the negatives i.e. unnecessary treatment and side effects from that, outweigh the positives. Instead we are supposed to be breast aware. So not a formal examination, just be aware what your breasts normally look like and feel like.

LadyVictoriaSponge · 13/01/2023 16:37

Yes, the painful one was very painful, and my breasts ached for a long time afterwards, with transient pain for months

This does not sound good at all, no one should suffer breast injury from screening, it’s barbaric.

Trauma to the breast can cause injury to the breast tissue and bleeding, which can form into a palpable mass. Bleeding can result in a hematoma, a collection of blood in the breast from the disruption of a blood vessel. On a mammogram, this area of injury will eventually be represented by calcifications. Hematomas eventually get reabsorbed by your lymphatic system.

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 16:37

I am so sorry you had a bad time.
I have had one mammogram and it was absolutely fine. It might be okay with someone more gentle? The nurse I had was very gentle. You could ring up to talk to them about it beforehand.

As someone else has already explained mammograms are currently the best detection method. And MRIs can be pretty awful for some people.

malificent7 · 13/01/2023 16:31

There are 2 reasons why they have to compress the breast. The 1st is to reduce radiationdose, the second is to improve tissue contrast. I did an essay on this at uni and Ultrasound shows great promise but not quite as sensitive.

Dilbertian · 13/01/2023 16:25

I have had 5 mammograms, which includes an extra one as I had a 2 week referral for a concerning symptom. I have also been told that I have dense breast tissue. Only one of the 5 mammograms was very painful. All the others ranged from mildly uncomfortable to entirely painless.

Yes, the painful one was very painful, and my breasts ached for a long time afterwards, with transient pain for months, but it was just one. The memory of pain does make you flinch and hesitate to expose yourself to pain. It's certainly very real. But it doesn't predict that it will happen the same again.

mathanxiety · 13/01/2023 16:24

I've had 3D mammograms in the US, as well as follow up ultrasounds, and a MRI.

The mammograms were a tight squeeze, no doubt about it, especially with dense breast tissue. But it wasn't so bad that I made a note to self to take something ahead of time for pain next time round.

It sounds as if you had a poorly trained technician and could have suffered an injury to a muscle. Have you considered getting a physiotherapist to take a look?

Blossomtoes · 13/01/2023 16:23

thewinterwitch · 13/01/2023 14:13

Some operators are better than others, also. Some are really vicious.

This. I’ve had mammograms that were a bit uncomfortable and some that hurt. My last one was absolutely fine.

SonnySideDown · 13/01/2023 16:21

Ultrasound or even MRI isn't any BETTER than a mammogram, it just uses different technology as a way to look at your breasts. It's not used as a screening tool as it is only as good as the operator using the machine, is difficult to replicate images and can miss very small lesions as breast tissue isn't easy to look at.

Ultrasound cannot detect early signs of cancer (DCIS) but a mammogram can, hence why it is gold standard. Its true there are mammographically occult lesions but I'll be honest, these are on the rare side. Also it is quick to do, quick to report and is cheap. All good reasons it is good for screening.

JoyPeaceHealth · 13/01/2023 16:19

I relate so much. I had a very painful one at 47, I'd had a cyst. There's no way I could go through that again. I do do self examinations. I bring myself to do smears. I feel like just staying healthy and warding off early warning signs is so unendurable.

Aphrathestorm · 13/01/2023 16:17

I don't go for smears and I won't go for mammograms.

They should invite all 50+ women to classes to teach self breast exam. That's how most breast cancers are detected.

Thighlengthboots · 13/01/2023 16:07

A combo of Thermography and ultrasound is a good alternative although you would have to pay privately for that (ive had several on harley street and also involves no radiation). Thermography can pick up potential risks years before a mammogram. However, if there was any concern they'd then ask you to have a mammo as it wont give a full picture of any concerns.

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 16:04

@SheWoreYellow Thank you. All these suggestions are so helpful and very gratefully received.

OP posts:
SheWoreYellow · 13/01/2023 16:02

Apparently the position of the machine can make a difference - if it is really painful it might be worth asking them to consider whether the machine is too high (or low? I think it is high but am not sure).

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/01/2023 15:58

LoobyDop · 13/01/2023 13:17

YANBU. I’ve only had one, it was absolutely agonising, and I’m dreading having to do it again. I had no idea beforehand how unpleasant it is, I thought it was just the embarrassment that people disliked.

Me too, fortunately it eased off after a week but was so sore!

DonttouchthatLarry · 13/01/2023 15:56

I've only had 2 mammograms - the first one was completely pain free and comfortable and I'll admit to wondering why other women complained about them 😳. However, the 2nd time the height or angle or something wasn't quite right and it was very painful - I felt like I was suspended by my breast! I do think it's maybe a matter of technique and positioning, and some are better at it than others in the same way some people are much better at injections/taking blood.

Chocchops72 · 13/01/2023 15:56

Thesonglastslonger · 13/01/2023 15:46

Yep.

Absolutely.

Same with iron supplements. If men frequently ended up needing to take iron supplements, an alternative to the tablets (which cause such severe constipation, stomach cramps, upset stomach etc that many women simply give up on them) would have been developed.

Thesonglastslonger · 13/01/2023 15:46

MrsBrandonspiano · 13/01/2023 14:27

I honestly think that if a man needed to have his cock and balls squashed in a device for preventative screening, a better less invasive test would have been discovered years ago.

Yep.

KnittedCardi · 13/01/2023 15:28

I had a referral from my last standard mammogram, and then went for a 3D one at the breast clinic. It was so much better. Then they did an ultrasound. They found nothing and suspected a "crease" in the original mammogram. Now this could have been the operator, but I had also had an expert for troublesome boobs at the initial mammogram, as the one a few years earlier had ripped the skin under one of my boobs and made it bleed!

I think some women, like me, with large dense boobs, really can suffer 😥

Swipe left for the next trending thread