Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why there is no effective alternative to Mammography?

134 replies

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 12:47

3 years ago, when I was 48, I was delighted to be asked early for a routine mammogram (I had no pain or lumps). I have dense breasts, and the pain during compression was excruciating. I don't even know if the radiographer managed to complete it, because I went faint. I've had pain in my right breast ever since, which I took to be bruising/strain, but when it didn't go I was referred for investigation at the hospital breast unit June 2021. They did ultrasound which was clear as far 'as they could see' but 'mammogram is the gold standard and only that will tell us for certain'. I had to be content with the ultrasound as my fear of the mammogram pain got the better of me. Fast forward to last Sept, I went on combined HRT and have what I took to be hormonal pain in both breasts which masked the targeted pain in my right. However it's coming through more than ever now and I've been referred back to the hospital for the same process as 18 months ago. Part of me is so angry at myself of being fearful of something that could save my life, and the other part is worried sick about how I will cope even with painkillers if I can get over the fear, and wondering why this is the only scan that still compresses tissue; why in over 100 years there is no effective 3D alternative.

OP posts:
Skap · 15/01/2023 10:13

Sorry to hear that @ReindeerBelieve . Very good that's it's been caught early but utterly terrifying nonetheless.
When I had BC I found the long running cancer support thread on MN was a great source of mutual support.

Skap · 15/01/2023 10:10

Aphrathestorm · 15/01/2023 09:16

I didn't actually realise they were painful until this thread.

Sounds barbaric.

I think there needs to be more education on prevention.

I breastfed for 3 1/2 years. Having DC when you are younger also reduces the risk but this isn't well known at all.

A lot of the risk is associated with obesity/ inactivity. But our culture creates these unhealthy behaviours.

The biggest risk factor for breast cancer, apart from being female, by far is age.
It's really not someting you can prevent because you can't avoid getting older.
I breast fed, didn't use HRT or the pill, no family history, not overweight. Still got it.
I would hate for anyone to be put off a mammogram because of this thread. Yes it's unpleasant but it's momentary. For those like me who have had surgery the breast is permanently painful and more sensitive. It's still a life saver.

ReindeerBelieve · 15/01/2023 10:02

I am sorry to hear of negative painful experiences but please please do not put off going when you are called.

I have been having yearly mammograms for a few years now - I was recalled after this years and had to go back for another mammogram , ultrasound and biopsy. I just finished the 2 week wait for my results and found out I have cancer - discovered very very early , for which I'm incredibly thankful - don't get me wrong I'm scared as hell right now but still glad that I go every year .

Notjustanymum · 15/01/2023 09:29

Because women’s health is largely ignored by the medical profession. Can you imagine if testicles needed to be checked in the same way? They’d have spent lots of money developing some other method of testing…
Women put up with far too much medical BS and neglect, IMO.

Aphrathestorm · 15/01/2023 09:16

I didn't actually realise they were painful until this thread.

Sounds barbaric.

I think there needs to be more education on prevention.

I breastfed for 3 1/2 years. Having DC when you are younger also reduces the risk but this isn't well known at all.

A lot of the risk is associated with obesity/ inactivity. But our culture creates these unhealthy behaviours.

Carriemac · 14/01/2023 09:32

Ultrasound is complementary to, not instead of a mammogram. As others said here , early cancers show on mammograms.

Hongkongsuey · 14/01/2023 09:04

SewingBees · 13/01/2023 22:42

My last mammogram, after treatment for breast cancer, was torture. I cried and shouted out it was so painful, and I'm usually very stoic. I decided there and then that if my cancer comes back I'm having a full mastectomy, just so I don't have to have another mammogram.

Once you’ve had surgery, that side can be very painful due to the effects of the treatment. Ask the Mammographer to go slowly with the compression-and ask her to stop when you’ve reached your tolerance level. That’s what I do with my women-and they often can tolerate more than if I’d just squashed them because they know they have an element of control.

lurchermummy · 13/01/2023 23:24

@JenniferBooth J cup here although it seems it can be painful for smaller boobs too

SewingBees · 13/01/2023 22:42

My last mammogram, after treatment for breast cancer, was torture. I cried and shouted out it was so painful, and I'm usually very stoic. I decided there and then that if my cancer comes back I'm having a full mastectomy, just so I don't have to have another mammogram.

JenniferBooth · 13/01/2023 22:37

@lurchermummy Im bigger too. HH cup. Really dismayed to see how painful this procedure is.

EsmeGythaMagrat · 13/01/2023 19:55

All I will say is that I’m grateful that my mammogram picked up my microcalcifications that was actually DCIS when I was 42. I had a mastectomy so next time I’ll just have to have the remaining boob squeezed until I get that one removed as well.

Everyone must make their own decisions on this, just please ensure it’s an informed one. I wouldn’t wish the last six months I’ve just had on anyone!

PaperMonster · 13/01/2023 19:33

Charliesunnysky10 · 13/01/2023 14:05

@PaperMonster I'm so sorry to hear that. The first thing I did when I left the clinic was Google when I'd next be called back. I was shaking, sore and tearful. My boss thought I'd been attacked. I hope that you're feeling better and I'm glad for you too, that there seem to be other options, albeit with caveats.

Thank you. It’s not 100% better after two years. I think I’ll be due another mammogram at the end of this year, which is a worry.

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 13/01/2023 18:36

When my mammograms showed things theyvwanted to check, they then did an ultrasound.

Maybe ask for an US instead?

Carriemac · 13/01/2023 18:31

My last mamo was quite painless , but as a radiographer I think the more compression the better the image .

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 13/01/2023 18:28

JenniferBooth · 13/01/2023 14:42

Oh goody Another painful procedure to look forward to. I turn 50 this year.

I've had two and neither hurt. Uncomfortable yes, but not painful.

Lolreally · 13/01/2023 18:16

I have had two the first very painful, second barely any pain so it is possible.

Skap · 13/01/2023 17:56

caramac04 · 13/01/2023 17:37

I’ve had one mammogram and found it very painful, pain and tenderness for over a week afterwards too.
That was years ago. I’ll never have another. Hoping my years of breast feeding and clear family history protect me.

Yes I hoped that. Fully BF'd two children. Never took HRT in case of risk of breast cancer. Still got me.
The biggest single risk factor for BC is age, something no-one can avoid. All the other risk factors are insignificantly small in comparison.

Skap · 13/01/2023 17:54

I was diagnosed with breast cancer 3 years ago (first symptom was breast pain) so have had more than my fair share of mammograms. Part of the planning treatment was a breast MRI which was hideous.
I now have annual mammograms. My take on this is that technicians vary a lot. Some grumpy ones who are a bit rough and others who are lovely and kind.

I have a lot of BC friends and all of us plan to pay privately for annual checks once the five years is up. Sometimes ultrasound picks up something a mammogram misses. The radiologists know exactly what they are looking for though.

lurchermummy · 13/01/2023 17:51

YANBU I'm afraid this is why at 55 I have never had one - I have very large dense breasts and I just can't face it even though I gave a high pain threshold. There is also a school if thought that the compression causes trauma to the breast which is in itself harmful, plus there's a high rate of false positives. I'm thinking of going private and requesting only ultrasound and just taking the risk - possibly better than nothing at all??

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 17:39

GlassBunion · 13/01/2023 16:45

I've always dreaded mammograms as I've always found them painful and thought that my breasts would burst.
Went for a routine mammogram last autumn . Was dreading it but immediately noticed the machine was much smaller than previously.
I slapped me bap out onto the plate and waited for the crushing pain. None whatsoever.

I mentioned how different and more comfortable it was and the nurse said that they'd got a new machine that also offer better imaging. She said that this new machine was becoming the preferred one for screening purposes.
Maybe these are more widespread now.

Maybe that is why I had no pain at all? It was honestly no big deal at all.

PregnantandPissedoff · 13/01/2023 17:39

MissyB1 · 13/01/2023 17:34

Yes both tests have purpose, that’s maybe why both should be offered? As I said I pay for ultrasound and am happy to do so, not everyone might be able to do that.

The point of screening is to pick up early cancers, most of which are occult on ultrasound and picked up by microcalcifications on mammogram.

caramac04 · 13/01/2023 17:37

I’ve had one mammogram and found it very painful, pain and tenderness for over a week afterwards too.
That was years ago. I’ll never have another. Hoping my years of breast feeding and clear family history protect me.

MissyB1 · 13/01/2023 17:34

PregnantandPissedoff · 13/01/2023 16:52

Mammograms pick up small microcalcifications which can be associated with DCIS (early non invasive cancer) which ultrasound can't.
Ultrasound can pick up small masses in dense breasts that mammogram can't.
In symptomatic clinic both are used, for screening mammogram is most effective.
It's rubbish you had so much pain in your last mammogram!

Yes both tests have purpose, that’s maybe why both should be offered? As I said I pay for ultrasound and am happy to do so, not everyone might be able to do that.

LadyEloise1 · 13/01/2023 17:26

As @StopGo states"..... Crushing delicate breast tissue seems draconian."

It certainly is.Sad

Oblomov22 · 13/01/2023 17:25

Interesting. I find a few of the procedures they do to women poor, and can't understand why there isn't better alternatives.