Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Passed up on promotion

114 replies

ellie09 · 13/01/2023 12:17

So, in my work we get EOY apprisals where there is a certain amount of automatic promotions allocated.

I've been with the company 4 years. I've worked my backside off the last year covering illness and as the more experienced team member, I've had to help out the others in the team quite often.

I was disappointed in my appraisal I must say. I got given a pay rise, and a bonus similar to last year. The feedback given to me was that the team would be lost without me, I'm so experienced and great with helping out with others and next chance I get I should apply for promotion. Despite this, I was given the same rating as last year (where admittedly I didn't work as hard)

There are two others in my team. They've been there for around one year and are very friendly with the manager. They know about 30% of the processes I do, and I regularly help them with their work etc. They work hard and are nice people but I don't feel as though they are on the same level as me.

Anyhow, the two of them got automatic promotions.

We are told to keep hush hush about any news we are told but I overheard conversations as they sit behind me.

I am obviously very upset. I've always been considered the more tenured team member, the one people apparently "need" and I have been passed up over them.

As its not common knowledge, I'm sitting here today keeping my mouth shut, really trying to hold back tears of frustration and anger. I'm thinking about taking some time off.

AIBU?

What would you guys do in my situation?

OP posts:
Crimeismymiddlename · 19/01/2023 08:06

It’s time to look for a new job-for whatever reason the manager has favoured these other two women. You may, or may not get a promotion next year so you might as well go elsewhere.
I went through a similar thing last year-not for a promotion but severe staffing issues meant I worked sick, through a/l and rest days not happy about it but all the shops in the area had had the same issue and it was strongly hinted no cover available. I found out there was-and it was given to shops who have more staff and make less. It’s made me re-think how I have been putting the job before my well being and not making a noise so now I protect my time off. It has also made me see how I am seen by my manager-not worth supporting as I just get on with it. I will be looking for a new job soon.

Jimboscott0115 · 19/01/2023 07:14

There's several potential reasons OP and it's impossible to say as an outsider:

  • It may be that you're indespensible in your current role/level (common)

  • It may be that there are responsibilities or expectations of the senior role that your bosses don't think you are capable of (also common)

  • Perhaps elements of your performance weren't as good as you believed? Maybe on the behavioural side? Was there some not so glowing feedback somewhere?

The only advice here is ultimately to ask why you haven't had a promotion and what you need to do to get it next time. A good manager will be quite open and honest about it and work on a plan with you. However, I'll also give advice not to use tenure as an argument for promotion because it means nothing and waters down your argument significantly.

Take the outcome of this conversation as a decision point on whether it's worth staying or not.

Ladybug14 · 19/01/2023 07:05

2 women have been promoted above you with no explanation as to why?

That is not good practice - you deserve to have the why explained to you so at least you understand

And if the why is your minor mistakes then you need to point out that the 2 who have been promoted also made minor mistakes

I would email manager who made the promotion decisions. See what is said

If the answer is shit, email managers manager cc-ing manager and explain how you feel

In the meantime work your hours only , no overtime

Once you have an answer review the situation. If you're still not happy get signed off 2 weeks sick with stress and find a new job

HandsOffMyCarrierBags · 19/01/2023 06:29

Personally I think you need to go up the chain and talk to those above the manager

HandsOffMyCarrierBags · 19/01/2023 06:28

email your manager and your managers manager and tell them how devalued you feel despite supporting others and undertaking critical tasks, you feel devalued after inexperienced workers x and x have promotions, that you have worked your socks off even while ill and your outcome is still the same as last year. This has made you feel very low and anxious about work. Be honest. Take a week off and look for jobs. Start applying.

InsomniacVampire · 19/01/2023 06:07

@JustinOtherdad But OP has already been doing all those things, and if you read her update, it is clear her manager fas been displaying a lot of favouritism towards the two other candidates, so it seems it's more personal and the lower grade is just an excuse for not giving promotion rather than OP not deserving it.

JustinOtherdad · 18/01/2023 20:15

You need to ask your manager, assuming you all have the same manager, why you were not promoted and the others were. If, as you say, you're working at a higher level and already do more and to a high level then there must be other factors at play that should be explained to you. Or (and I'm not being mean when I say this) you're not quite achieving the standard of work you think you are, and maybe your manager has bottled giving you an honest appraisal.

I was frustrated with missing promotion for a few years, a victim of conflicting line management and unclear visibility I thought. I queried what I needed to do to be moved up a level and there were some specific behaviours I needed to work on that I thought were only minor but had been blocking my progress. I worked on them over the next year and then was promoted in the next cycle.

If you don't ask you'll just be left guessing or frustrated. Ask calmly and if there are issues ask for pointers on ways you can overcome them.

InsomniacVampire · 18/01/2023 19:35

Well done OP, take time off and let them stew in it.
I was once in a similar position and ended up leaving, and it was really worth it. If you don't stad up for yourself, no one else will.

ColadhSamh · 18/01/2023 16:03

Well done @ellie09 Put you first for a change. Your mental health and wellbeing is more important. If some see that as petty then it says a lot about their character.

ellie09 · 17/01/2023 10:36

Puffin87 · 17/01/2023 08:29

To be honest, the people linking the lack of promotion to having children (discrimination) are clutching at straws and you don't appear to have any evidence of it being due to that.

From what you've said, the others are recent graduates and that's probably why the manager has given them more support. They'll be on some sort of training pathway - official or not.

When the manager cancelled your one to ones, that was a sign of no investment.

The timing of going off sick - especially after discussing the lack of promotion with other people at work - is going to look petty, so you need to be prepared for that.

I don't think there is any discrimination going on. Others have been promoted that have children in the past

I am aware it may look petty, but it has done a number on my anxiety when you are sittng listening to people gossiping. My paranoia was going ten fold and I couldn't concentrate. Also, I have to decide if I want to pursue the path of getting another job. Working 45 hours a week as a single mum, I would have no time for applying, interviews etc. Using this time to decide on what I would like to pursue and have time for interviews if opportunity arises. If I'm at work I will become complacent again and so the cycle restarts

At this moment in time, after 4 years of blood sweat and tears, canceling annual leave to help them and coming in sick when they begged me, I couldn't really care if they think I'm petty (which I am sure majority do, I'm not naive)

OP posts:
Puffin87 · 17/01/2023 08:29

ellie09 · 16/01/2023 18:55

No they don't have children, they are much younger women than me in their first jobs

It may be a factor but its not really something I could prove

HR don't decide on promotions, its down to managers and HR just signs it off

To be honest, the people linking the lack of promotion to having children (discrimination) are clutching at straws and you don't appear to have any evidence of it being due to that.

From what you've said, the others are recent graduates and that's probably why the manager has given them more support. They'll be on some sort of training pathway - official or not.

When the manager cancelled your one to ones, that was a sign of no investment.

The timing of going off sick - especially after discussing the lack of promotion with other people at work - is going to look petty, so you need to be prepared for that.

ellie09 · 16/01/2023 18:55

tootiredtobother · 16/01/2023 18:25

just read that you are a single mum, do the other two women have kids. perhaps HR is thinking a promotion would be too much for you, for whatever draft reasoning they have appied to it

No they don't have children, they are much younger women than me in their first jobs

It may be a factor but its not really something I could prove

HR don't decide on promotions, its down to managers and HR just signs it off

OP posts:
tootiredtobother · 16/01/2023 18:25

just read that you are a single mum, do the other two women have kids. perhaps HR is thinking a promotion would be too much for you, for whatever draft reasoning they have appied to it

MichelleScarn · 16/01/2023 18:16

Am so sorry @ellie09 things like this really knock your confidence. Agree with pp to use your energy in looking for a new role.

ellie09 · 16/01/2023 18:00

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 16/01/2023 17:46

How much does the promotion affect what you do in relation to your skill set? I used to work in a niche roll in the company I was with prior to my current job. I was sensational at it and widely recognised/appreciated for it. A chance came up for a middle manager job that encompassed some of my role due to company expansion. I sailed the assessment and interview and proceeded to be absolutely diabolical at the job as I just wasn't suited for it - I couldn't take my eye of my work to manage the team well enough and as such also never grasped the skill of over seeing things that was required for that role. Could that be a factor or is it just a literal step up into more important work in the same bracket?

Its basically the same job role, with slightly more challenging tasks given to you e.g. you may be given certain projects to complete

I don't know. I told my manager around 6 months ago that I would like to go for promotion next time it was there. I got feedback at the time that was taken on board and I felt I was completing

I should note we are supposed to have a one to one session once a month. I schedule these in for us and often, they will get pushed back or canceled by my manager. I've maybe had 2 one to one meetings in the last 6 months. Feedback from these were positive and no negative feedback or improvement areas given so I believed I was on the right track

When you compare that to the two that got promoted. She never canceled their one to one. They were clearly receiving much more frequent guidance than I was. These two will frequently go for lunch with the manager and she will buy them lunch and coffee etc (the rest of us don't get)

Just before news was given on the promotions, she had a chat with me. Reassured me that I was going to be her "project" into the new year and once I took a step back I realized she used the other two as "projects" and I was put on the back burner. I did have a lot of work assigned to me (a lot more than most could cope with) but I was accepting it as I thought after letting her know I was working towards a promotion, that this would help me. It clearly hasn't

I was filled with dread about coming into work. Everyone's gossiping. Everyone couldn't believe I didn't get any kept telling me "I already thought you were in a higher position with everything you do" .. So there you have it

I've decided to take some time off work to decide on how I would like to move forward as I am mentally drained and exhausted. A company I have worked sick for, canceled annual leave to help them out throughout the year etc and the ones that seemingly get promoted are the ones doing as little work as possible and constantly taking months off sick at a time

I've put off going on sick to work hard for this all year. Now I'm just over it to be honest

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 16/01/2023 17:46

ellie09 · 13/01/2023 12:17

So, in my work we get EOY apprisals where there is a certain amount of automatic promotions allocated.

I've been with the company 4 years. I've worked my backside off the last year covering illness and as the more experienced team member, I've had to help out the others in the team quite often.

I was disappointed in my appraisal I must say. I got given a pay rise, and a bonus similar to last year. The feedback given to me was that the team would be lost without me, I'm so experienced and great with helping out with others and next chance I get I should apply for promotion. Despite this, I was given the same rating as last year (where admittedly I didn't work as hard)

There are two others in my team. They've been there for around one year and are very friendly with the manager. They know about 30% of the processes I do, and I regularly help them with their work etc. They work hard and are nice people but I don't feel as though they are on the same level as me.

Anyhow, the two of them got automatic promotions.

We are told to keep hush hush about any news we are told but I overheard conversations as they sit behind me.

I am obviously very upset. I've always been considered the more tenured team member, the one people apparently "need" and I have been passed up over them.

As its not common knowledge, I'm sitting here today keeping my mouth shut, really trying to hold back tears of frustration and anger. I'm thinking about taking some time off.

AIBU?

What would you guys do in my situation?

How much does the promotion affect what you do in relation to your skill set? I used to work in a niche roll in the company I was with prior to my current job. I was sensational at it and widely recognised/appreciated for it. A chance came up for a middle manager job that encompassed some of my role due to company expansion. I sailed the assessment and interview and proceeded to be absolutely diabolical at the job as I just wasn't suited for it - I couldn't take my eye of my work to manage the team well enough and as such also never grasped the skill of over seeing things that was required for that role. Could that be a factor or is it just a literal step up into more important work in the same bracket?

InsomniacVampire · 15/01/2023 20:52

Concur with people who say you should leave. No point staying in a place that keeps you where you are because you are too good.

RockGirl · 15/01/2023 20:46

**two

RockGirl · 15/01/2023 20:45

This happened to me. I eventually left. They replaced me with someone to rungs up on the management scale.

If you were a man you would have left by now.

gumball37 · 14/01/2023 22:24

Work your level. They obviously have no desire to promote you, so before you leave for a new position, do just what you're paid for and nothing more. Your new "senior" team members can take care of the extra stuff.

JudgeJudee · 14/01/2023 22:01

I’ll keep this brief because it’s Saturday night and I wasn’t planning on thinking about work but my work involves adjudicating employment tribunals, managing things like appraisal or disciplinary appeals, and mediation.

Where I have seen someone unhappy with an appraisal, they often cite other employees being treated different and talk about what happens in those EOY conversations, but the truth is that they really don’t know what went on.

I often see people who are great workers but spend so much of their time doing the day to day, they never end up doing tasks that lead to them going above and beyond in another other than a transactional or operational capacity. Often, it can be a case that someone prides themselves on being the go-to for a particular activity and believe they’re the only one who can do it well so end up spending a large amount of time on one existing process while other people move on to more complicated and value-add things, safe in the knowledge that someone is taking the slack on the business-as-usual activity.

Another thing that can come up is behaviours. What you do is one thing, but how you do it is also hugely important. Do you get on with your manager and support them? You’re being a bit snide here about your colleagues- does that tone come when you’re in work?

gigithecat · 14/01/2023 21:23

This sucks OP. This happened to me and that soured me relationship with my LM and with company in general. I decided to leave as I lost all my trust in them. Your place clearly doesn’t value you enough to promote you but they don’t have any issues with you working overtime and taking on extra responsibility. Leave if you can, and go somewhere you’ll be appreciated.

Pottyaboutplants · 14/01/2023 21:21

I'm sorry this has happened to you.
I think they don't like you as much. It an be as simple as that although that is very hard to hear. Sometimes imo if they keep you where you are, they are hoping you will move. They may think you are a steady worker but don't bring enough ideas to the table. I was that person and changed departments. In hindsight I shouldn't have changed because the original dept and role suited me very well. I left because I was hurt and where I moved to was worse!

Eleganz · 14/01/2023 21:13

Time to move on OP, that is what that situation always signifies.

Sorefootouch · 14/01/2023 21:09

I was in a similar situation. In my case it was an internal role that a peer and I both applied for. He was told he would get the role even before the interviews took place, and the only thing he was better at than me was being male. The boss was a total misogynist and would never have given the role to a woman in a thousand years.

it gave me the push I needed to go and get another job and the career progression I have made in the four years since leaving had been phenomenal. I have doubled my salary and am working in a role that appreciates my skills. I love it! So don’t look back OP. Leave these losers behind and get out there!