Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have woken him up?

136 replies

StAlphonzospancakebreakfast · 13/01/2023 07:42

My partner and I have 3 children, the youngest is 4 and gets up every night (often several times) and comes into our room to ask for water or various things. She always wakes me up and not her dad. He never gets up with her in the night. Last night I had just managed to fall asleep and I felt her tapping me. I asked her to go and wake her dad up instead and she wouldn’t (she never will) so I woke him and asked him to deal with her. He jumped up and said that was the most selfish and privileged behaviour he had ever seen and that if I am awake anyway I should just continue to get up with her every night.
for context we both work part time and I also get up in the mornings 90% of the time and take the kids to school.
was I unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UnshakenNeedsStirring · 14/01/2023 12:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sirzy · 14/01/2023 09:28

KettrickenSmiled · 14/01/2023 08:51

Hmm. Now you're sounding a bit martyrish. If you know you could have 'trained' (horrible word) your child to sleep better, and you've chosen not to, then I am absolutely with your DH and would be cross about being woken up.

@BIWI Why does DH get a free pass for being cross about being woken for his non-'sleep trained' child when HE is also responsible for her lack of sleep training?

Perhaps when he is woken he takes a firmer “back to bed appraoch” hence the daughter now going where she will get attention.

thecatsmum12346 · 14/01/2023 08:56

Lazy man. Selfish man. Kids must be scared of him so he’s probably not a nice man either. Show him this if you want. Wake him up.

KettrickenSmiled · 14/01/2023 08:51

Hmm. Now you're sounding a bit martyrish. If you know you could have 'trained' (horrible word) your child to sleep better, and you've chosen not to, then I am absolutely with your DH and would be cross about being woken up.

@BIWI Why does DH get a free pass for being cross about being woken for his non-'sleep trained' child when HE is also responsible for her lack of sleep training?

Hesma · 14/01/2023 07:37

Forget the husband, it the kids that needs sorting out!

Logicpuzzle · 14/01/2023 05:20

2bazookas · 13/01/2023 11:43

Your DH is an entitled git and his daughter has learned from him, to treat you the same way. Because you always cave in.

Tell her she mustn't come and wake you up in the night because it makes Daddy VERY ANGRY. Next time she appears just play dead while secretly poking DH in the ribs.

Uncalled for to criticise OP in this exaggerated way then say she should play games with her kid to get her husband back. She is just trying to be a good mum whilst getting enough sleep. Really, why be mean about it.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 13/01/2023 16:21

MrsTag · 13/01/2023 09:25

as a man? 🙄

Yes, as a man. Guess what? OP's husband will also be a man. He's shown that he thinks looking after the baby is a woman's job, and if all he sees is women backing up the OP, he will turn around and say that all the women are ganging up on the man so it's unfair, it's not representative, he's still perfectly correct, it's a men vs women thing etc. He'll still feel he's in the right even if the OP shows him the opinion of a billion women. He'll just see himself as a martyr to the cause.

If you want to change someone's opinion, you need to understand their psychology. In this case, you need to understand how the OP's husband is going to react. My comment "as a man" is directed to him, not to the women on this forum, and certainly not to the OP herself. It's for his consumption and viewing.

Before making sarcastic comments, please try to think beyond what you see.

toocold54 · 13/01/2023 13:21

It’s ok, one of us will carry on getting up for her if she needs it.

Why would she need it unless it’s an emergency?

You need to have a chat with all 3 of you tonight about her waking up and that she’s a big girl now and that she shouldn’t be getting up so much in the nighttime but if she needs something she can ask both of you.

It’s ok for her to wake you up but you can find out what she wants and then send her back to bed without needing to get up with her.

Logicpuzzle · 13/01/2023 13:01

Andypandy799 · 13/01/2023 11:29

Tell him to get a full time job ffs 😳

Really!?! 'Tell him to', is he a child? You don't know why he has a part-time job and the OP isn't asking how to get her OH to work more so probably best to keep an open mind 🙂

Spyral · 13/01/2023 12:31

If it were my DH, I would give him the choice of doing his share of getting up to put DD back to bed when she wakes in the night or, for the foreseeable, him sleeping in her room/bed while DD sleeps with me in our bed.

ivykaty44 · 13/01/2023 12:14

in the middle of the night isn't the time to be deciding who does what

sort this out before the 4 year old goes to bed. take them everything they need before bed, water, a night light etc etc

then decide who in an emergency is going to be woken and tell the dc who to wake - if she wakes the wrong person then explain they will go back to sleep as adults need to sleep for various reasons but majorly for safety and secondary as they will be grumpy as hell

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 13/01/2023 12:12

StAlphonzospancakebreakfast · 13/01/2023 10:36

Update is I didn’t show him the thread, as I reflected that this wasn’t a very grown up way to deal with a relationship issue. We haven’t seen each other this morning. He has messaged to apologise and has said I can wake him up and he will talk to her about waking him up instead. I have said that he needs to think about why she doesn’t want to go to him in the night and why he views his needs as more important than mine (or hers) and we will discuss later. Obviously I don’t see this as a happy ending, it’s just an update.

Good update op.
Sounds like he was having an unreasonable moment (and was overly harsh for which he's apologised) and your later conversation was much more collaborative (and hopefully a better reflection on your relationship).
You sound like a lovely family.

StAlphonzospancakebreakfast · 13/01/2023 11:59

BIWI · 13/01/2023 11:40

Hmm. Now you're sounding a bit martyrish. If you know you could have 'trained' (horrible word) your child to sleep better, and you've chosen not to, then I am absolutely with your DH and would be cross about being woken up.

Does he agree with it being OK for your DD to come in and wake you regularly?

You say one of us will carry on getting up for her if she needs it but from your OP it's only you who is doing this. Does he think she should be asleep?

The fact that he works part-time is neither here nor there. You still seem to think it's OK to wake him up. I'd be livid if my partner woke me up for something only they think is important!

Didn’t mean to sound martyrish, was trying to sound non judgemental. I probably have Martyrish tendencies sometimes to be fair, I don’t think in this instance though. The ‘one of us’ was based on my previous update that he had said he would do his share. Trained is a word several previous posters used.
Neither of us mind in theory her coming in for reassurance at night (he might change his mind once he is waking more often though!), she settles immediately. She also has phases of this and phases of sleeping through the night. He doesn’t think I’m soft for waking to her, we have chosen the way we parent. He just doesn’t wake up and last night I was really tired and suddenly furious at the unfairness of it. I felt hard done by and reacted. he said I was unreasonable, I wanted to show him I wasn’t, he reached that conclusion by himself this morning.

OP posts:
NotTerfNorCis · 13/01/2023 11:55

Tontostitis · 13/01/2023 07:46

I can't vote on this as the obvious solution is to say no, go back to bed to the child not to wake another adult up.

Agreed. The child needs to break the habit.

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 13/01/2023 11:49

A bloke's perspective here. He's a selfish twat.

Coffeeandchocs · 13/01/2023 11:46

redskydelight · 13/01/2023 11:01

Nobody is saying the child should be staying in their bedroom if they are frightened or unhappy.

From what OP says, her DC has got into the habit of waking up and coming in to ask for a drink or similar. However there are very few things a 4 year old actually needs in the middle of the night. This isn't a healthy habit (the 4 year old needs her sleep as well as OP) and it would be best to discourage it.

If she felt ill or she'd had a bad dream or she'd lost her comfort toy (that would constitute an emergency in our house) then of course it's fine to go and see her parents. But from what OP says, that doesn't to be the reason that she's coming in.

Why? Why isn’t it healthy to want to be near someone you love at night? I often wake in the night and snuggle in closer to my husband for comfort. Why is it considered unhealthy for a child to want someone they love for comfort? It’s because as a society we have put expectations on children, that they should be independent of us, especially at night. If you actually ask yourself why, do you have any actual reasons for why a child should only come to you in the night for reasons you consider to be an emergency?

If the reason is because you’re too tired, you have work the next day, you have another child to care for etc. then I totally understand! Put boundaries in place if you feel you need to, to get a good night’s sleep. But to suggest it isn’t healthy for a child to want a parent in the night, isn’t true.

Logicpuzzle · 13/01/2023 11:44

BIWI · 13/01/2023 11:40

Hmm. Now you're sounding a bit martyrish. If you know you could have 'trained' (horrible word) your child to sleep better, and you've chosen not to, then I am absolutely with your DH and would be cross about being woken up.

Does he agree with it being OK for your DD to come in and wake you regularly?

You say one of us will carry on getting up for her if she needs it but from your OP it's only you who is doing this. Does he think she should be asleep?

The fact that he works part-time is neither here nor there. You still seem to think it's OK to wake him up. I'd be livid if my partner woke me up for something only they think is important!

Yes I agree, she should just do everything and get over any frustration, become superhuman and also take full responsibility for training her children. Clearly children waking in the night is very strange, 100 percent the mums fault, that poor father.

Everyone knows suppressed rage and one partner doing more than the other is great for marriage.

(I'm not serious on this)

JustJustWhy · 13/01/2023 11:43

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/01/2023 07:57

He's gaslighting you, and a crap parent. More than happy for you to show him this.

I know MNetters fall over themselves about gaslighting...but this isn't it. Twattish behaviour, maybe. But not gaslighting.

2bazookas · 13/01/2023 11:43

Your DH is an entitled git and his daughter has learned from him, to treat you the same way. Because you always cave in.

Tell her she mustn't come and wake you up in the night because it makes Daddy VERY ANGRY. Next time she appears just play dead while secretly poking DH in the ribs.

Logicpuzzle · 13/01/2023 11:41

BIWI · 13/01/2023 10:52

The thing is though, you've trained your 4yo to come to you, because you get up and deal with her!

I do think your DH was unreasonable in what he said/refusal to help, but tbh if you woke me up for something you were already awake for - and usually dealt with/seemed to encourage - I'd be cross in that moment too!

You really need to sort out why your child is coming in to you every night. By this age they should be sleeping through the night, reliably. (Bad dreams/illness etc to one side)

Four year old getting up in the night is normal. In many cultures 4 year olds still sleep with their parents. It's not your fault they get up. You don't 'really need to sort it' and I like how this post assumes it's just down to you mum.

Though there might be things you can do. Like of they're getting up for the toilet, wake them up for that before you get in bed. Consider if they're too warm, cold etc..

BIWI · 13/01/2023 11:40

StAlphonzospancakebreakfast · 13/01/2023 11:07

It’s ok, one of us will carry on getting up for her if she needs it. I appreciate people have different parenting styles, I don’t mind if people want to sleep train, I’m pleased they are getting a good nights sleep! And I don’t mind if people think I’m pandering her. I do put water by her bed. We are all just doing what we think is best.

Hmm. Now you're sounding a bit martyrish. If you know you could have 'trained' (horrible word) your child to sleep better, and you've chosen not to, then I am absolutely with your DH and would be cross about being woken up.

Does he agree with it being OK for your DD to come in and wake you regularly?

You say one of us will carry on getting up for her if she needs it but from your OP it's only you who is doing this. Does he think she should be asleep?

The fact that he works part-time is neither here nor there. You still seem to think it's OK to wake him up. I'd be livid if my partner woke me up for something only they think is important!

ImBlueDab · 13/01/2023 11:38

Of course tan I. Your dh on the other hand is being unreasonable for two thing, firstly for not doing his fair share of nights and secondly for being an arse for calling you names

Every other night from now onwards wake him of your dc come in. If he moans tell him it's now 50/50 for night wakings

Andypandy799 · 13/01/2023 11:29

StAlphonzospancakebreakfast · 13/01/2023 07:42

My partner and I have 3 children, the youngest is 4 and gets up every night (often several times) and comes into our room to ask for water or various things. She always wakes me up and not her dad. He never gets up with her in the night. Last night I had just managed to fall asleep and I felt her tapping me. I asked her to go and wake her dad up instead and she wouldn’t (she never will) so I woke him and asked him to deal with her. He jumped up and said that was the most selfish and privileged behaviour he had ever seen and that if I am awake anyway I should just continue to get up with her every night.
for context we both work part time and I also get up in the mornings 90% of the time and take the kids to school.
was I unreasonable?

Tell him to get a full time job ffs 😳

Logicpuzzle · 13/01/2023 11:27

Ignore the posts that are like, sorry you're with a horrible guy. I mean is that supposed to help!? I do despair sometimes.

However, he should never call you selfish and entitled. My husband doesn't wake up at night and he's not a b** or whatever. It's our arrangement. If I suddenly asked our kid to wake him up my husband would assume there's an emergency and be grumpy. There are also trade offs like my husband is not woken up at night be he watches our child whilst I have a nap if I need one. It works for us.

Clearly if you're too tired and find your arrangement unfair it doesn't work.

You need a proper conversation where you agree how this will work. So you have 3 kids, could he be up for one of them, or from a certain time it's his turn.

starfishmummy · 13/01/2023 11:16

It's difficult to vote. I have a husband who sleeps through anything while I am a light sleeper. It wouldnt occur to me to wake him up when I am awake anyway. However he does stuff in the mornings especially since working from home.