Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to take DD out driving?

85 replies

Jknow · 13/01/2023 01:58

DD is 18 and learning to drive. She’s been having lessons since July. She has her own car which has been fitted with a dual brake, she has her lessons in her own car.

I first went in the passenger seat with her a few months ago and no word of a lie, it was fucking terrifying, her driving was awful (basic stuff like driving directly at a row of parked cars). I decided I’d let her have a good few more lessons before I went out practicing with her again.

I tried it again today, and she is a bit better now,
I only had to brake for her twice, grab the wheel to stop her from clipping a house once, and she hit the curb once. But it was still pretty scary, she’s very erratic and despite trying my best to stay and sound calm my heart was going like the clappers.

i know she needs more hours on the road practicing, that’s the only thing that’s going to get her ready to pass. And I’m a single parent so it’s all on me, there’s no one else who can take her out. And I know I’m being unreasonable in not wanting to take her, but I guess it’s a self preservation thing, it honestly feels like anything could happen.

How can I make this more bearable? Also, driving instructors, I salute you, I’m definitely crossing that off the list of jobs that I could do.

OP posts:
naemates · 13/01/2023 10:51

DH is autistic and really struggled to learn to drive. He couldn't make the rules of the road 'fit' with what he thought the rules of the road should be, and also struggled with the fact that other road users would not stick to either his rules or the actual rules.

He got there eventually - we had a sort of debrief after his lessons to talk round why things were as they were or why they had happened - I think NT people would have just known or accepted these things. I went out with him a few times to practice (8 months pregnant at the time 😱) and realised he wasn't thinking how I was thinking, so had to try different ways of explaining. There were still many fights and threats of divorce!

And his poor driving instructor! She was still in training when they started, I'm sure he was great practice for her Smile

Triffid1 · 13/01/2023 10:38

That's one hell of a drip feed.

  1. You expect her to be bad so are reinforcing that so even more, someone else must teach her.
  1. You should be looking for strategies specifically to support someone with her challenges. What works for the vast bulk of the NT population clearly is not working for her.
Jknow · 13/01/2023 10:12

To answer some questions - DD is autistic and I’m not sure it’s so much spatial awareness that is the problem as just not being observant. For example, I’ve had my car over 3.5 years and if I go to pick her up from somewhere she doesn’t recognise my car, I have to beep to get her attention. I think that’s the scariest thing, I know she’s not at all aware of things around her and may not notice potential hazards, I know that’s how she’s wired.

Her car is an automatic. I knew she was going to find driving tricky so I thought I’d make it as easy as I could for her.

We live rurally and public transport is rubbish around here, I really want her to be able to drive as it will be difficult for her to ever be independent without driving. But it’s definitely not coming naturally to her.

I have been speaking to her driving instructor regularly. He thinks she should be ready to take her test by around April. She was booked in for a test in February but I changed it yesterday as there was no way she’d be ready, and the earliest one I could get after that is June. So we have a while but it’s clear that she needs a lot of practice around her lessons. Her instructor said her worst thing is roundabouts - she just doesn’t understand how they work and he’s tried every trick in the book. I haven’t done roundabouts with her yet, you have to drive quite far to get to one, but I’m dreading that.

No lessons aren’t cheaper for her using her own car, even though it’s our car and fuel she’s using. I struggled to find an automatic instructor so that’s why I had to get the dual brake fitted so she could learn in her own car, with a regular instructor. I don’t think the instructor is the problem, he’s very experienced.

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 13/01/2023 10:02

If my child was driving that dangerously that I wouldn't want to be in the car with them they shouldn't be driving in the first place

It is dangerous

JustFrustrated · 13/01/2023 09:59

She needs a new instructor. Obviously this one isn't helping her.

It may just be his style doesn't suit her.

I had three instructors, and the first was awful and terrified me, the second was too slow and patient and the third.... He got me...he undid all the damage the first did and I passed after 10 lessons with him.

In fact, 7 years after passing, I've only just told my family and DH some of things my first instructor did and said and they're all appalled (think making me pay, on the spot, for a tyre after I clipped a kerb, taking me on the busiest and most notorious round about in the town, on my second lesson, shouting at me for stalling).

PartySock · 13/01/2023 09:59

36 hours is nothing, really. It's 3 days in real terms.

OfCourseChangs · 13/01/2023 09:49

I also refused to take DS out on lessons mainly because my insurance was going to be sky high. I am also not a driving instructor . But he passed after 16 lessons. Even with more lessons it would have still been cheaper than adding him as a learner driver. I was not used to cars as my family didn’t have one so had about 40 lessons which meant that was my total practice time when I passed. I also changed instructor because the first 10 lessons were actually terrible. I had unfortunately block booked.

It’s the instructor or she is just terrible or a bit of both but I think you need to stop teaching her. How much extra was your insurance?

sanityisamyth · 13/01/2023 09:25

MintyPrincess · 13/01/2023 09:21

@asanityisamyth lol not enough coffee *brakes

🤣

MeridianB · 13/01/2023 09:24

Oblomov22 · 13/01/2023 05:08

I also agree re pp, why is she so poor after 7 months and 36 hours of lessons? I'd have a polite but stern conversation with driving instructor re what the main areas to focus on, and what the objectives and timeframe is for getting her passed.

This. It sounds very unusual. To be so poor on spatial awareness and control after this time. Can you change teacher or did you pay for a course? Is it much cheaper because she is using her own car?

MintyPrincess · 13/01/2023 09:21

@asanityisamyth lol not enough coffee *brakes

DailyCake · 13/01/2023 09:08

Don't want to scare you OP but some people never become good drivers. My sil had 100+ lessons and two failed tests before finally passing. During one test she almost mounted the pavement where a pedestrian was waiting to cross the road. She said that she was concentrating on the pedestrian and the car just went where she was looking! She persisted because she had two small dc and dh worked away, so she needed to be able to drive. Sil only drives locally and will take a longer route in order not have to make a right turn.
I'm sure that your dd won't be this bad/nervous a driver!

Triffid1 · 13/01/2023 08:58

I have complained about this before, but the way teenagers are taught to drive in this country just seems crazy. Instructors do all the heavy lifting, they get nowhere near enough practice between lessons and they're not even allowed to drive on certain roads until after they get their license. It's bizarre.

I'm also shocked at how often I see learner drivers on the road being allowed to travel at extraordinarily low speeds, causing chaos all over the place and, I imagine, massively stressing the poor student out.

Learn basic car skills in a car park or whatever.
Begin getting out on quiet roads, probably at awkward times to reduce traffic issues.
Then drive as often as you can. Nervous parents need to get over themselves and stop interfering. I can't believe you felt the need to grab the wheel. If she's really that bad, she shouldn't be on the road. If you're really that paranoid, you shouldn't be helping her learn.

Having said that, it is true that my dad did quite a lot of practice with a few of our friends as their respective parents were like you - excessively nervous and panicky. So maybe you need to see if you have a friend who can do some practicing with her?

Theeaglesoared · 13/01/2023 08:56

It's ok to say to your daughter that it's not for you. Not everyone likes being scared!

My daughter scared me to death when she was learning so for the sake of our future relationship I refused to teach her any more. She passed first time. As did I - and I too was a terrifying learner driver.

OoooohMatron · 13/01/2023 08:53

They sat you shouldn't teach someone you're close to. I remember going out with my mum and a man beeped me. My mum went ballistic on him! Like other PPs though maybe look to change instructor as she shouldn't be that bad after all those lessons.

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 13/01/2023 08:49

Take her to a empty car park and do it there. A lot less scary for all involved. Grin

Aprilx · 13/01/2023 08:48

I don’t think you should go out with her, at least not until she has got better with her instructor. You don’t have to at all of course, I never got any practice between lessons and many other people don’t either.

GerbilsForever24 · 13/01/2023 08:47

Yes, as PP have said - if she is this bad after 30 odd hours with an instructor, then either she has a problem with driving or her instructor is terrible. Or both.

Altnernatively, she's not nearly as bad as you think she is and if she was posting on here it would read, "AIBU to refuse to let my mother teach me to drive? She is absolutely terrified. I was driving perfectly normally and she was so scared I was going to clip some parked cars she grabbed the steering wheel from me. It was so dangerous and terrifying. She also has a habit of using the learners break to just stop me when I'm trying to drive."

Personally, I'm a bit gobsmacked that you've had a second break fitted in her car.

You need to figure out which is the problem - her or you - and then come up with a solution because she needs to learn to drive.

Newusernameaug · 13/01/2023 08:47

Either your daughter is shockingly bad and I wonder if they should really be on the road or you’re very nervous and over panic?

I taught my ds to drive, he had 2 lessons as this was during lockdown so couldn’t get instructors, it was fine and this was in a normal car, no duel breaks.
it should t be a big deal, so trying to understand why it’s so bad for you.

OnaBegonia · 13/01/2023 08:44

grab the wheel to stop her from clipping a house once, and she hit the curb once.
after 36 hours and she doesn't have basic skills?? maybe time for a new instructor.

sanityisamyth · 13/01/2023 08:44

MintyPrincess · 13/01/2023 08:03

You're not a qualified driving instructor.I get that she's got dual breaks but the way you've described her driving she could cause an accident.

Sounds painful!

WrigglyDonCat · 13/01/2023 08:42

daisyjgrey · 13/01/2023 08:26

Sorry, she's had thirty six hours of lessons and is still nearly driving into houses, needing someone to brake and clipping curbs?

Either the driving instructor is shit, or your driving is not your daughter's calling.

Drive a mile in my shoes, hell, half a mile with some pupils, and you will soon learn that this is very far from uncommon. I would guess that easily 1 in 5 learners would still require significant levels of intervention at around the 30-40 hour mark.

Perhaps not always physical action - ADIs get very good at verbal intervention before a situation really develops. It might just be a subtle prompt about lane choice when we can sense what a learner is going to do for example - long before the learner has got themselves into a bad position.

As I said above, I wouldn't rule out a poor instructor - there are plenty out there - but 36 hours and still needing lots of intervention is far from unusual.

Would you expect say a novice to knock out a bit of Mozart or something to a moderately competent standard after 30-40 hours tuition? Driving a manual car is heading towards that level in terms of motor skills, but with the added fun of hundreds of other pianists you have to interact with at the same time.

Xrays · 13/01/2023 08:29

KimberleyClark · 13/01/2023 07:51

Driving doesn’t come naturally to lots of people. Including me. Doesn’t mean they’ll never pass their test. They’ll just take longer.

Exactly.

These types of threads always attract people who passed first time with zero minors etc after 20 minutes of sitting behind a steering wheel (😆) and can’t understand that some people will just take longer to learn. It doesn’t mean someone is destined to be a dangerous or shit driver because they take longer.

daisyjgrey · 13/01/2023 08:26

Sorry, she's had thirty six hours of lessons and is still nearly driving into houses, needing someone to brake and clipping curbs?

Either the driving instructor is shit, or your driving is not your daughter's calling.

MintyPrincess · 13/01/2023 08:03

You're not a qualified driving instructor.I get that she's got dual breaks but the way you've described her driving she could cause an accident.

Chickenvoicesinmyhead · 13/01/2023 07:51

Have you spoken to the instructor to gauge what's going on?