Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to take DD out driving?

85 replies

Jknow · 13/01/2023 01:58

DD is 18 and learning to drive. She’s been having lessons since July. She has her own car which has been fitted with a dual brake, she has her lessons in her own car.

I first went in the passenger seat with her a few months ago and no word of a lie, it was fucking terrifying, her driving was awful (basic stuff like driving directly at a row of parked cars). I decided I’d let her have a good few more lessons before I went out practicing with her again.

I tried it again today, and she is a bit better now,
I only had to brake for her twice, grab the wheel to stop her from clipping a house once, and she hit the curb once. But it was still pretty scary, she’s very erratic and despite trying my best to stay and sound calm my heart was going like the clappers.

i know she needs more hours on the road practicing, that’s the only thing that’s going to get her ready to pass. And I’m a single parent so it’s all on me, there’s no one else who can take her out. And I know I’m being unreasonable in not wanting to take her, but I guess it’s a self preservation thing, it honestly feels like anything could happen.

How can I make this more bearable? Also, driving instructors, I salute you, I’m definitely crossing that off the list of jobs that I could do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hawkins001 · 13/01/2023 23:55

I would like to drive but it's the $$. All the best op

UnhappyAcademic · 13/01/2023 13:19

And I think manual cars are a dying breed so what’s the point in struggling with them.

UnhappyAcademic · 13/01/2023 13:18

Dd was like this and was so bad her instructor actually dumped her and said she was too dangerous. We swapped her to automatic lessons. She is dyspraxic and really struggled with manual. Took to automatic like a duck to water and passed first time, she could concentrate on steering if she wasn’t thinking about gears.

CKL987 · 13/01/2023 12:59

My mum used to take me to a business park at 8am on a Sunday as there wouldn't be much traffic and the car parks would be empty. Maybe you could do something like that.

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 11:57

It doesn't sound like driving comes naturally to her. Poor you. My DS is 17 next week and has his first driving lesson booked. I'll be going out with him in his own car, but won't be going on the actual roads where there's other cars until I'm confident he has mastered the basics.

Large empty car parks is where we will be.

Roselilly36 · 13/01/2023 11:56

Aww yes, I remember it well, with DS1 at 17, in the end it was too stressful for me, gave DH the job of going out with him.

Oinkypig · 13/01/2023 11:51

That sounds hard, my nephew is learning and the only one who can bear to take him out is my mum. His mum and dad caught with him and I was terrified. But he is nearly there now.

I know you are saying you don’t want to think because she is autistic she can’t drive but I also think you need to consider she might not be able to drive because she just can’t not related to her autism if that makes sense? I know some people who are just not made to drive and have spent huge amounts of time and money they could used for taxis instead before accepting they were one of life’s pedestrians. Whatever happens she will find a way to get where she needs to be!

mistlethrush · 13/01/2023 11:44

DS is only 17 and having driving lessons.. I drive a large estate car - and that's the one that he's insured to drive at the moment. The first time I took him out in it I did quite a bit of screaming... and we agreed that the narrow roads of Dorset weren't ideal... a few more lessons and I started taking him out near where we live - it has been a lot better - and it's clear that he does gain considerable benefits from driving more regularly than just his weekly lessons. The only thing I can suggest is to try to go to somewhere that's quiet and relatively low traffic - and ideally low traffic speeds, and drive around that quite a bit rather than busier locations until things improve.

Tohaveandtohold · 13/01/2023 11:42

Maybe you should take her to big car parks when it’s late and quite and practice parking, manoeuvres and also drive home when it’s quite. Let her learn mainly with the instructor but after 36 lessons and still driving like that, maybe you need to change instructors.

Littlewhitecat · 13/01/2023 11:39

Does her driving instructor think she is safe enough to go out with you? My DD had 5 lessons before her instructor said give it a go with a parent. She passed first time after 20 lessons and me taking her out as well. Okie nearest roundabout is 9 miles away so that's mainly what I took her out to practice on. You sound like you are quite nervous as well so maybe you just aren't suited to teaching her. I also think the fact your own car has dual controls is part of the problem. I couldn't brake when I was taking my DD out so it meant she was responsible for all the decisions. If you genuinely believe your DD is not safe without your braking for her you should not be on the road with her.

GasPanic · 13/01/2023 11:33

Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:24

@HesDeadBenYouCanStopNow she wouldn’t cope with an intensive course, she gets burnt out and tired very easily (there’s been times when she’s not been able to manage the whole two hour lesson because she’s so tired and the instructor has had to drive them back).

Well no-one knows her like you do, but it does sound like she might be hyper focussed and over stressed. No one is going to learn well in that condition.

Again you might try looking for a specialist instructor that can de stress the experience for her and get her into a more relaxed state so she can learn.

PollyPut · 13/01/2023 11:29

It could undermine your relationship. I would be very wary.

But if you go ahead, find somewhere with no traffic (e.g. an estate) and no potholes. Start there

Tiani4 · 13/01/2023 11:28

I wouldn't take her out

She's 18
She's had 36 hours of lessons already
I was a nervous driver who barely got out of 1st and second gear the first 5 lessons. I passed easily with less than 30 hours driving instructor and no additional

Sounds to me that she lacks awareness of road rules - you could drive her round roundabouts and explain how they work.
Sit here in passenger seat and do a running commentary of what you're doing and why

I think it's the road awareness she needs improving on

She can practise manoeuvre skills in a big open car park, late at night or early morning with you

Then she can then practice put them all together in her driving lessons

Some people aren't really meant to drive

My adult DD (adhd) is adamant she won't & I'd be scared if my youngest did as both are very distractible

Neither can focus on the road and I often have to pull over and move them to back seat from passenger as they won't stop distracting me and blocking my view as they can't keep still

GasPanic · 13/01/2023 11:27

OK so you've already made it as easy as possible by going for the automatic.

YANBU to fear going out with her if she still struggles. Remember that with an instructor she is a lot safer because they have dual controls, plus they are a lot more experienced at knowing when and how to intervene.

What I would do is focus on the stuff you can do with her that is low risk. Parking manoevers, theory test etc. Make sure you let the instructor know that they should focus on the "riskier stuff", basic driving skills and not waste expensive time on things you can teach her (or at least wait until she gets better).

Also think about whether this is the right time of year to learn. You can take her out early on a Sunday morning in the summer when it is light with little risk from other cars. Harder to do in the dark and in winter.

It's clear she is not a natural. Yes I'm sure there are people who take a lot longer to pass with even more instruction than this. But I would say that learning for 30 hours plus and still being at the "scary" stage shows she is struggling a lot. You need to be prepared that this is going to be a long haul, not a sprint and that its going to cost and be comfortable with that, otherwise you're both going to get angry and stressed with her lack of progress.

Finally I would look to see whether there is a specialist driving course available for her. I know there are these available for people with SEN/learning difficulties. They may be expensive, but you might save money in the long run as the instructors will be more used to dealing with customers who find driving more challenging and will have developed strategies to help develop good driving skills that normal instructors will have not. Also they should be able to give you an honest opinion on whether or not a pass will be possible.

Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:24

@HesDeadBenYouCanStopNow she wouldn’t cope with an intensive course, she gets burnt out and tired very easily (there’s been times when she’s not been able to manage the whole two hour lesson because she’s so tired and the instructor has had to drive them back).

OP posts:
GreetingsToTheNewBrunette · 13/01/2023 11:24

Honestly, I think going out with a parent can make driving more stressful! My driving instructor told me to stop going out with mine because is made me really stressed!

Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:22

@MeridianB honestly the way she is now it’s difficult to see how she will ever pass. But her instructor thinks she will be ready by April 🤷‍♀️. Personally I think it’s likely she’s going to need a few tests before passing.

OP posts:
Thistooshallpsss · 13/01/2023 11:21

I helped all mine but I learnt to find a quiet office park place on the edge of town that was deserted on a Sunday. We only drove round there doing roundabouts manoeuvre ing etc until I felt they really had proper control of the car. Before that I chose a local park but that was much too busy with pedestrians etc. later on we practiced test routes and the tricky bits in them. After they passed I paid for our lovely instructor to do pass plus and get them more used to motorway driving and rush hour driving. It was very expensive having them insured on our modest car but I felt it was a life skill they all needed.

xogossipgirlxo · 13/01/2023 11:18

Is the instructor right fit for her? Sometimes someone's teaching doesn't sit right with student. My husband changed his instructor and new one was way much better. I like all those youtube videos that explain roundabouts etc. in very simple terms. Good luck OP, I always feel sorry for parents teaching kids how to drive, rolling 15mph 😂

HesDeadBenYouCanStopNow · 13/01/2023 11:17

Have you considered an intensive course? Sometimes the issue with lessons is that you do 1 or 2 hours a week, half of each lesson just ends up recapping and relearning what you forgot from last week

My DS had just done a 35 hours intensive course over 7 days with test on the last day and passed. Day 1 and 2 were really hard but by day 3 he was so much more confident and by the weekend he started to feel ready for his test. It was a big chunk of money and still worked out at about £40 per hour but really helped him. He has ADHD and felt the big chunks of practice was the key, with no time to forget things.

GerbilsForever24 · 13/01/2023 11:10

Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:03

Sorry if it’s seen as a drip feed - I didn’t actually think it was that relevant as autistic or not, she still needs to practice. Also although I am not diagnosed, I have 2 dc (different fathers) who are both diagnosed, I’m the common denominator and knowing what I know now about autism (and myself), I would eat my hat if I am not autistic. And I learnt to drive fairly easily (passed less than 3 months after turning 17). Although in hindsight the instructor did offer my dad his money back and said I was the first person who had made her consider giving up driving tuition 🤣. But my point is, it’s not like autistic = unable to learn to drive so I didn’t see that it was that relevant. DD is bright and capable in lots of ways.

Well, no, of course autistic does not equal can't drive.

But in your update you specify that she has issues with not being observant or recognising things around her. You also provide this as info on why YOU are so nervous regarding her driving. The autism itself is not the issue, but how it presents in this case and how that impacts both her and you absolutely is and would certainly have changed my initial feedback.

MeridianB · 13/01/2023 11:08

Presumably her instructor won't put her in for a test if he thinks she won't pass. But is there any question in your mind that she will pass a test at some point, OP?

Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:08

@sanityisamyth her instructor said there is an app for practicing roundabouts, although he doesn’t know what it’s called. I think she’s over complicated them in her head and completely bamboozled herself. I was talking through them with her the other day and she was like “oh! That’s it? Instructor makes them sound so much more complicated than that”. We are yet to put them to the test in practice though.

OP posts:
Jknow · 13/01/2023 11:03

Sorry if it’s seen as a drip feed - I didn’t actually think it was that relevant as autistic or not, she still needs to practice. Also although I am not diagnosed, I have 2 dc (different fathers) who are both diagnosed, I’m the common denominator and knowing what I know now about autism (and myself), I would eat my hat if I am not autistic. And I learnt to drive fairly easily (passed less than 3 months after turning 17). Although in hindsight the instructor did offer my dad his money back and said I was the first person who had made her consider giving up driving tuition 🤣. But my point is, it’s not like autistic = unable to learn to drive so I didn’t see that it was that relevant. DD is bright and capable in lots of ways.

OP posts:
sanityisamyth · 13/01/2023 10:58

@Jknow that information would have been VERY useful in the original post ...

Would modelling roundabouts at home be useful? An old child's play at and some Lego cars? Or draw a roundabout on paper and some cotton reels for cars? Anything so you can run through different scenarios with her?