Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 13/01/2023 07:24

There is undoubtedly too many people who confuse ambulances and taxis. That doesn’t take away from the fact that their are massive issues with the system but it is part of the issue.

the fact the number of 999 calls for ambulance drops so much on strike days shows that many people use it when they don’t need it

Simplelobsterhat · 13/01/2023 07:21

Of course people shouldn't phone an ambulance if they don't need one, and I luckily haven't had to, but a lot of posters saying that you don't get seen any quicker seem to be missing the point that paramedics are healthcare professionals, so even if you still have to wait a long time once in a&e, you will already have been seen by a healthcare professional, and in many cases they will have been able to provide some treatment, or at least assess the urgency (which most of us aren't actually trained to do for ourselves, so understandably sometimes we panic). Ok at the moment it still might be quicker driving there if the ambulance is going to be hours and hours, but you don't know how long it's going to be until you phone (do they even tell you then?). Also I'm unlikely to be sure, in case of a fall or bad injury, if it is safe to move them myself (or likely to be strong enough if it's an adult / teen!)

If phoning 111 doesn't result in good advice on if an ambulance is needed or time to get yourself to a&e, or phone GP, then how are ordinary untrained people expected to always make the right call on that themselves?

Also, whilst again, I of course agree parking difficulties shouldn't in theory mean you call an ambulance, if you desperately worried about a loved one, who is either too young, old immobile or unwell to be 'dropped off' alone, then you do need to factor in if you can get them from the parking to the door of the hospital yourself, and if you are not someone who needs to use the hospital often you may well be unsure of that. I haven't been to a&e for years but as far as I can remember if I had to abandon my car outside the door of a&e, I'd be blocking an ambulance bay or the one drop off point for other patients. And I have no idea if there are wheelchairs I could use from the car park, or any staff around to help.

Even if I did feel I could cope with the parking situation, if I was worried about the person I don't think I'd be driving that's safely if I also had to keep an eye on them. So if I was in my own with someone I was very worried about, I may well decide I had better call an ambulance as not sure if I can safely get them there themselves. Yes you are right that a taxi could be an option, and that's probably what I would do, but again, not all areas get them quickly, some situations, eg blood and vomit I'd assume they would refuse, and they are very expensive and probably don't offer freebies in an emergency!

I'm also pretty horrified by suggestions and stories of people driving themselves with chest pains, head injuries, injuries that affect their movement etc - I'm not sure someone passing out at the wheel or being less able to operate a car normally is something to encourage to reduce pressure on emergency services!

So on the whole, of course people should think about if they really need an ambulance or not, but I have empathy for people who make the wrong call, and think the government shouldn't be blaming ordinary people for their shortfalls!

abmac95 · 13/01/2023 07:21

Sturmundcalm · 13/01/2023 07:04

why would a taxi agree to take someone who is bleeding/vomiting/in the process of having a heart attack???

and some people are so dismissive of other people's reality - if you don't have money or a car or friends who have a car then what are you supposed to do when an urgent medical situation arises? i worked for a taxi company years ago and the vast majority of users of taxis were people who were in that kind of situation - couldn't afford to run a car, didn't know anyone who could afford to run a car, lived in an area with a crappy bus service.

This 👏

Also my friend called a taxi when she was in labour as her partner can't drive and she wasn't in a state to drive. Taxi turned up saw friend in very obvious labour and told them to call an ambulance/said he couldn't take them.

Sturmundcalm · 13/01/2023 07:04

why would a taxi agree to take someone who is bleeding/vomiting/in the process of having a heart attack???

and some people are so dismissive of other people's reality - if you don't have money or a car or friends who have a car then what are you supposed to do when an urgent medical situation arises? i worked for a taxi company years ago and the vast majority of users of taxis were people who were in that kind of situation - couldn't afford to run a car, didn't know anyone who could afford to run a car, lived in an area with a crappy bus service.

notallcupsinthecupboard · 13/01/2023 06:49

Here in Germany when you’ve had a trip in an ambulance you get sent the paperwork a week or so later - in our case a bill for 450€, with a note saying that the Krankenkasse was paying 440€ of it and we had to pay 10€. This and the fact that at the time of calling it I was only allowed to take the ill child with me, had to leave my second child and arrange for them to be picked up from the place we were at the time by a neighbour while I was on my way in ambulance means that I would really only call an ambulance if it was absolutely necessary. Not to say I would have behaved differently before but these are quite low level and easy to implement incentives to discourage inappropriate ambulance calling.

GreenDanglyearrings · 13/01/2023 06:26

BabyOnBoard90 · 12/01/2023 22:17

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking?

You think it's OK to call an ambulance as you cannot afford the parking? Is this a joke? This comment unfortunately demonstrates the entitlement of some people.

PurBal · 13/01/2023 06:20

I’ve never called an ambulance because I or someone else has needed to go to hospital. I’ve called because someone’s life is in danger and they need immediate medical care. I thought that was the only reason you dial 999. Otherwise yes, drive in or get a lift.

Mexicola · 13/01/2023 06:17

Completely agree. I know loads of situations where people I know have called ambulances.

Best example is my MIL and FIL. FIL had minor surgery and afterwards was coincidentally doing some (physical) repair work at MIL workplace. He developed moderate pain in the area where the surgery was done and she called an ambulance despite having a car there. The. She was complaining afterwards it took over 40 minutes to come (circa 2018).

I just softly said I don’t know why you called an ambulance though, couldn’t you have just driven him in your car, it wasn’t life threatening? And she was genuinely perplexed it just didn’t seem to have occurred to her.

Leeanne922 · 13/01/2023 06:16

I feel this blame the patients is a distraction tactic to shift the blame away from the goverment failures- NHS has more funds than ever, but half the amount of beds that it had in the 80s with the population growth of 20 million and adding to it daily (thanks to RNLI).

I cant speak for every area but in my area near a large always busy hospital they have built no new hospitals, they have closed and limited urgent care centres down?

what happened with the Nightingale hospitals that were built during covid,stood empty and were put never to use and half a year later dismantled- what a waste of taxpayers money and why were they not put to use?

And of course, Brexit and the current state of the UK is putting people off moving here, I have a few friends who have a medical degree who are not even entertaining the idea of moving to the UK but have gone to Finland, Sweden etc instead.

camelfinger · 13/01/2023 06:15

The current pressures are more to do with handover delays though, rather than people calling ambulances for the wrong reason (which is obviously unacceptable, but has long been the case). If 20% of people in hospital wards are fit to leave but can’t, this means there aren’t enough beds for people in A&E who need them. So the paramedics can’t hand over patients as A&E is over full. We all need to pay more for health and social care, and things would improve.

abmac95 · 13/01/2023 06:08

Fam23 · 13/01/2023 05:57

Exactly this, where I work someone calls the parking team to explain the situation, they give the registration number and then when the patient is well enough to leave or someone can come and pick up the car they open the barriers for them and the person doesn’t get charged.
absolutely not a reason to call an ambulance,, which costs a hell of a lot more than parking 🤦🏼‍♀️

But do people know that you can do that? I certainly didnt.

I am luckily not in the situation that being ill would cause me financial stress but many many people are.

Some people don't have/can't afford cars. Some people have no petrol and no way to get petrol. You can't phone a taxi and say 'i'll pay you back next week'. Or sit and wait on a bus in the freezing cold if you are so ill that you need to go to hospital.

For some people calling an ambulance is their only option.

Remaker · 13/01/2023 06:07

I’ve called an ambulance 4 times. Twice we called the health info line and they deemed it serious enough for an ambulance and put us straight through.

And twice my mum has been on the floor with a broken hip/vertebrae unable to get up. Ambulance was definitely needed!

I think there are definitely those who abuse it. Thankfully I live outside the UK and near a major hospital so our ambulance waits are 10-20 minutes, not hours.

Fam23 · 13/01/2023 05:57

SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:48

@abmac95 is that a genuine question? If you're really concerned about the cost of parking to the point you'd call an ambulance out unnecessarily.. I'd suggest you ask a friend to take you, or I'd speak to the parking team at the hospital and explain. Most have a discretionary policy where I
They'll waive the parking fee or ticket if you get one.

Or speak to the nurse in the department you're in for a form to waive the fee.

Either way, it's not a good enough reason to use the ambulance service as a taxi

Exactly this, where I work someone calls the parking team to explain the situation, they give the registration number and then when the patient is well enough to leave or someone can come and pick up the car they open the barriers for them and the person doesn’t get charged.
absolutely not a reason to call an ambulance,, which costs a hell of a lot more than parking 🤦🏼‍♀️

Fam23 · 13/01/2023 05:53

I agree with you OP. I think, unfortunately, many people feel entitled to be taken to the hospital via ambulance, or be seen by a paramedic at the very least.
Of course if someone is seriously ill then paramedics will be able to provide care at the point of arrival but the majority could have made their own way there.
As brilliant as it is, 111 seem to have taken people’s ability to risk assess their own health away from them. It’s all broken and I think, after the past few years with covid, people have become scared for their health/ lives and maybe the panic of the unknown potential severity of their health makes them reach for the phone to call 999 🤷🏼‍♀️.
Of course a good start to fixing all of this mess would be education to the community on what warrants a trip to the pharmacy/ GP/ minor injuries/ ED but it doesn’t seem to be that easy as people don’t understand or don’t want to be told these things so it’ll continue to be a struggle!

Leeanne922 · 13/01/2023 05:39

With chest pain you never know, my husband drove himself to hospital- consultant told him to never drive again with chest pains as he had had an heart attack.

Many taxi drivers dont take unwell people on for obvious reasons.

I was told off by a paramedic for calling an ambulance, even I had been vomiting, fever,dizzy etc and strong stomach ache- she said I can walk so why didnt I take the taxi since they are not a taxi service? I felt so embarassed, I got to the hospital turned out my appendix was about to burst.

MavisMcMinty · 13/01/2023 04:55

The compensation also repaid all my sick pay - a whole year’s worth!

MavisMcMinty · 13/01/2023 04:54

I was charged £25 for the ambulance that attended my RTA 30 years ago, it’s not a new thing, and it came out of the compensation I received 6 years later. I’m lucky they only charged me once, as another crew had crashed on their way to me, writing off their ambulance! (It was a terrible night, weather-wise.)

Funkyblues101 · 13/01/2023 04:51

PinkPlantCase · 12/01/2023 22:16

The times I have needed an ambulance I couldn’t breathe. Should I have got a lift instead?

Rather than wait for an ambulance, absolutely yes!

CheesyCrumpet · 13/01/2023 04:49

SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:45

Is that in the uk? I've never heard of that

Yes, in the UK.

CheesyCrumpet · 13/01/2023 04:49

SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:45

Is that in the uk? I've never heard of that

Yes, in the UK.

SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:48

@abmac95 is that a genuine question? If you're really concerned about the cost of parking to the point you'd call an ambulance out unnecessarily.. I'd suggest you ask a friend to take you, or I'd speak to the parking team at the hospital and explain. Most have a discretionary policy where I
They'll waive the parking fee or ticket if you get one.

Or speak to the nurse in the department you're in for a form to waive the fee.

Either way, it's not a good enough reason to use the ambulance service as a taxi

SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:45

CheesyCrumpet · 13/01/2023 04:32

A few years ago I got billed £25 for calling an ambulance out.
I witnessed a road accident where a cyclist flew out of a side road straight into the path of a car.
Clearly he had sustained some pretty serious injuries so I called an ambulance.
A few days later, I got a bill for the ambulance.
This is normal according to the ambulance service, even if you're just a witness to the event calling one.
I'll never call an ambulance to an rta again unless it's one of my nearest and dearest needing one.

Is that in the uk? I've never heard of that

abmac95 · 13/01/2023 04:34

Princesspollyyy · 12/01/2023 22:45

Ambulances aren't there for people who can't afford parking, or don't know where they will park 🙈

So what do u do if you have to drive but can't afford to park? Its actually a problem for some people but obviously not priveleged people like you...

CheesyCrumpet · 13/01/2023 04:32

A few years ago I got billed £25 for calling an ambulance out.
I witnessed a road accident where a cyclist flew out of a side road straight into the path of a car.
Clearly he had sustained some pretty serious injuries so I called an ambulance.
A few days later, I got a bill for the ambulance.
This is normal according to the ambulance service, even if you're just a witness to the event calling one.
I'll never call an ambulance to an rta again unless it's one of my nearest and dearest needing one.

MavisMcMinty · 13/01/2023 04:13

Many years ago I knew a paramedic who kept her horses at the same yard as me, and she was on duty one Christmas Day when they got a call-out. Turned up at the address, door opened by a man dressed in a suit, suitcase in hand, noises coming from the house of guests enjoying Christmas dinner, expecting to be taken to A&E because he’d had swollen testicles for several days.