Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 08:06

@Outfor150

We aren't really talking about people that have called 111 first though. It's people who call 999 for an ambulance when they are capable of getting themselves to hospital.

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 08:05

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

That's still not a reason to call an ambulance. Are you serious?

Maybe you should put some money aside incase you need to park at hospital again.

Stunningscreamer · 13/01/2023 08:04

gingerhamster · 13/01/2023 07:49

I don't know about your hospital but at ours there is a drop off place in the car park where you can stop for half an hour which would be long enough to get someone into A&E.

Yes we have a drop off place but it's at the main entrance not close to a&e, which is poor planning.

Btw I didn't really word my post well - I know DF clearly needed an ambulance this time but there's been incidents previously when we've taken him by car and struggled with him on arrival if there was only one of us. This might be why some people call ambulances rather than try and drive. I'm not saying it's fine to call them at the drop of a hat.

The thing is, it's not whether it's difficult to get people to A&E by car, it's whether it's possible and safe to do so. Every ambulance that's used for this purpose could also be needed in an emergency (they can't just shunt them into the street if a life threatening emergency comes in).

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/01/2023 08:02

BabyFour2023 · 12/01/2023 22:31

Not being able to afford parking isn’t a reason to call 999.

Obviously not but what about people who drive themselves there and genuinely don't have the money for the rip off parking fees. I went to minor injuries in August and was there for less than an hour and it cost £4. They sent me to A&E and I was there for 4 hours and it was another £7. £11 to park for less than 5 hours is extortionate!

Metabigot · 13/01/2023 08:00

CheesyCrumpet · 13/01/2023 04:32

A few years ago I got billed £25 for calling an ambulance out.
I witnessed a road accident where a cyclist flew out of a side road straight into the path of a car.
Clearly he had sustained some pretty serious injuries so I called an ambulance.
A few days later, I got a bill for the ambulance.
This is normal according to the ambulance service, even if you're just a witness to the event calling one.
I'll never call an ambulance to an rta again unless it's one of my nearest and dearest needing one.

I've never heard of this in the UK.

Calling BS

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 07:56

I watch quite a lot of ambulance programmes on tv, and honestly I've seen so many where someone has fallen or collapsed at home, but they are awake and ok.

The ambulance arrives and asks the person if they can move. They can. They then ask them to get up off the floor and go and sit on the bed or chair. They do this no problem.

I'm sure some people think if they faint at home but then come round, they need to stay in exactly the same position they were when they fainted, and wait for an ambulance.

Complete waste of time and makes person look like a prize tit.

Outfor150 · 13/01/2023 07:54

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 07:50

That's the whole point though, if they can get themselves there, then they don't need to phone an ambulance! They won't be seen any quicker at hospital unless they get taken straight to resus.

An ambulance was sent to me by 111. I didn’t call an ambulance. I told 111 I could get to hospital by myself on public transport. But they said my symptoms demanded they sent an ambulance.

bloodyplanes · 13/01/2023 07:53

BabyOnBoard90 · 12/01/2023 22:17

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking?

Its not a taxi to hospital ffs

bloodyplanes · 13/01/2023 07:53

Op I completely agree! Having worked for the ambulance service i can say you are 100% right!

Simplelobsterhat · 13/01/2023 07:52

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 07:50

That's the whole point though, if they can get themselves there, then they don't need to phone an ambulance! They won't be seen any quicker at hospital unless they get taken straight to resus.

But they will have been seen by a paramedic!

MarshaBradyo · 13/01/2023 07:50

There probably are some who could but discharging medically fit seems key to getting system moving again

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 07:50

Simplelobsterhat · 13/01/2023 07:48

I know the OP didn't mean life threatening emergencies, but it can be hard for an unqualified person to be sure when something is life threatening and when not, or when it is safe to move someone and when not. And some of the examples people are giving of times when they / their relatives have got there themselves rather than phoning an ambulance do sound like ambulance worthy emergencies, so that's muddying the waters and making it sound like some people think you should deal with most things yourself.

That's the whole point though, if they can get themselves there, then they don't need to phone an ambulance! They won't be seen any quicker at hospital unless they get taken straight to resus.

gingerhamster · 13/01/2023 07:49

I don't know about your hospital but at ours there is a drop off place in the car park where you can stop for half an hour which would be long enough to get someone into A&E.

Yes we have a drop off place but it's at the main entrance not close to a&e, which is poor planning.

Btw I didn't really word my post well - I know DF clearly needed an ambulance this time but there's been incidents previously when we've taken him by car and struggled with him on arrival if there was only one of us. This might be why some people call ambulances rather than try and drive. I'm not saying it's fine to call them at the drop of a hat.

Simplelobsterhat · 13/01/2023 07:48

I know the OP didn't mean life threatening emergencies, but it can be hard for an unqualified person to be sure when something is life threatening and when not, or when it is safe to move someone and when not. And some of the examples people are giving of times when they / their relatives have got there themselves rather than phoning an ambulance do sound like ambulance worthy emergencies, so that's muddying the waters and making it sound like some people think you should deal with most things yourself.

Mardyface · 13/01/2023 07:44

I think whether or not most people who call an ambulance should have got themselves to hospital is not really a matter that you can have an opinion on unless you have access to the data about who has called one, why, where they were when they called, and what professional opinion is about the condition they called for.

These endless debates are pointless. It's not for untrained people to bang on about how they drove themselves to hospital with their eyeballs hanging out. It's something a professional body should look at and in a functioning country if it turns out to be the case that people are calling an ambulance when they shouldn't the root cause of that should be established and tackled (e.g. being able to get a gp appointment, having public transport nearby, training more communities in first aid etc).

I get that's not how the UK in 2023 works but we Brits do love this constant 'individuals except me are idiots ' approach don't we.

WishIwasElsa · 13/01/2023 07:44

I would like to say when my son was v young he has pneumonia. But prior to being aware I called an ambulance for him and to be honest it was because I was in a sheer panic about how unwell he was. Luckily it came very quick. I remember them saying to me it was fine to call and they would rather come especially for a young child. He was taken to hospital and spent a week in. So it maybe the stress of the situation rather than anything else.

Foxywood · 13/01/2023 07:41

BabyOnBoard90 · 12/01/2023 22:17

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking?

Phone a taxi

Ginmonkeyagain · 13/01/2023 07:40

Last week I tripped on a broken paveing stone and fell. I stayed there for a bit while I rotated my ankle and moved my toes to check nothing was broken. A woman rushed over and said she would call an ambulance. I managed to convince her not to but she was very insistent. I am a healthy and in my early forties, I had just twisted my ankle!

I could be wrong but in France don't you get billed for an ambulance ride if the receiving hospital refuse to sign it off as necessary? I have memories of helping translate for a British man with an eye injury. The staff at the walk in clinic at the small seaside town we were in decided he would be better off going to hospital in the nearby city. I am sure they warned he might be charged if they called an ambulance to take him. (He would have been charged any way as the idiot did not have insurance or even an EHIC).

TheHauntedPencilCase · 13/01/2023 07:40

TheUsualChaos · 12/01/2023 22:20

Oh come on. The OP is clearly worded to mean that if it's serious/life threatening then of course an ambulance is justified.

Chronic abuse of the service which is already struggling due of years and years of under funding is a real issue.

Perfectly put. I've always been or taken people myself except when DH collapsed. Thankfully they arrived within minutes and were able to support him with heart issues but I literally couldn't get him off the floor and he would have died but the threshold seems much lower for other people I know.

RambamThankyouMam · 13/01/2023 07:38

PinkPlantCase · 12/01/2023 22:16

The times I have needed an ambulance I couldn’t breathe. Should I have got a lift instead?

This clearly doesn't refer to you. Why have you made it about yourself? Think a little more broadly. OP doesn't mean people who can't breathe.

Stunningscreamer · 13/01/2023 07:38

gingerhamster · 13/01/2023 07:26

It's not that simple. At our a&e there's no space for cars to pull up outside, so if someone is really poorly how are they meant to get from the car park?

Incidentally my DF needed an ambulance last week (suspected sepsis following a chest infection, could barely walk, so necessary) and it came within an hour. They had him on oxygen and fluids before he even got in the ambulance. I was so relieved.

Why do people keep giving examples of situations where an ambulance was obviously needed? This thread is not about that, it's about people who aren't really poorly. No-one is saying don't call for an ambulance. It's saying don't call for an ambulance unless you need one, if you could just as easily get there under your own steam. The people who actually work for the service, say it is abused, which means people like your DF might have to wait longer.

For instance, I've been pretty poorly, in a lot of pain and very unwell and ended up admitted for several days. However, I was able to get in a car and get to hospital. Someone drove me so I had someone with me at A&E but I could have got a taxi if there hadn't been anyone. I certainly wouldn't have needed an ambulance.

I don't know about your hospital but at ours there is a drop off place in the car park where you can stop for half an hour which would be long enough to get someone into A&E.

MilkyYay · 13/01/2023 07:36

The times ive used an ambulance were:

Bleeding copiously. I was blue lit straight to hospital

Baby DD working very hard to breathe. She ended up on a ventilator. I was terrified to drive her in a rear facing car seat where i couldn't see her, especially because car seats are not a good position to be in breathing wise for a prem baby. She was in hospital for 2 weeks that time.

Sindonym · 13/01/2023 07:31

TheUsualChaos · 12/01/2023 22:20

Oh come on. The OP is clearly worded to mean that if it's serious/life threatening then of course an ambulance is justified.

Chronic abuse of the service which is already struggling due of years and years of under funding is a real issue.

A bigger issue is lack of proper funding of social care - leading to lack of staff = full hospitals.

in the last few months I have spoken to people who called ambulances for a broken back, being unable to breathe & a stroke - all waited hours and hours. We are in one if the worst affected areas but this issue here is not misuse of ambulances.

When my son was unconscious post- seizure we couldn’t move him & he couldn’t sit up. No way could we have got him down the stairs & into the car, or transported him in a car. Thankfully that was when we had a functioning service.

gingerhamster · 13/01/2023 07:26

It's not that simple. At our a&e there's no space for cars to pull up outside, so if someone is really poorly how are they meant to get from the car park?

Incidentally my DF needed an ambulance last week (suspected sepsis following a chest infection, could barely walk, so necessary) and it came within an hour. They had him on oxygen and fluids before he even got in the ambulance. I was so relieved.

Stunningscreamer · 13/01/2023 07:24

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 00:34

London used to have a mental health A and E staffed by psychiatric nurses. It should never have been closed down.

But this is the trouble with public services. Some consultant is brought in to give advice on saving money. They don't really have expertise in their area concerned, they're some bright spark from university. They just suggest closing down services or support staff. This looks like it's cutting down on waste but it always costs more money further down the line.

For instance there used to be a network of counselling services for young people called Connextions (sp?). It dealt with drop in mental health services and went into schools. Someone had the idea to close it down, presumably to save money. But the need for those services doesn't go away, so those young people end up desperately trying to be seen at the stupidly overworked Cahms services, at the GP's, or in A&E in crisis. All of these services cost more money than a trained counsellor but no-one considers the impact. I am imagining similar happens with care services, social workers etc. What could have been a managed support service, then becomes shunted onto the emergency services, which quite understandably can't cope.

When I used to work in a branch of the NHS we had a couple of restructurings in seven years, all designed to save money and none of which made the service more effective. What it did do was cost a fortune of management time, reorganising the service, often moving staff around, re-interviewing people for the jobs they were already doing, getting rid of buildings that were perfectly functional and having to re-equip new buildings. I imagine they got rid of some staff, which they then had to re-employ several years down the line.

Rather than getting rid of these services that support people I'd rather put more money into improving them and providing better training. But because everyone is short termist, that will never happen.