Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
Minfilia · 06/02/2023 18:00

I agree with you, but low priority calls are just that - low priority. They will have to wait for hours, if they get an ambulance at all.

My SM called an ambulance for my dad when he fell down the stairs and broke his collarbone and injured his back - he was told 4-8 hour wait so I went over, and between us we managed to pick him up and get him to the car. He was in a lot of pain but we made it in the end.

When my DS had sepsis, DH drove him the ten minutes to A&E. It would have taken longer to wait for an ambulance and he was grey with blue lips at this point.

And when I took my brother to A&E, he had to be transferred to a specialist neuro unit at a different hospital - but the staff wouldn’t let me take him. He had to wait for an ambulance transfer. It took ten hours, he was left on a bench with no food or water. I had to leave after four hours to pick up DC and he is autistic so not great at advocating for himself. If I’d driven him it would have taken 20 minutes.

We are lucky to live near a hospital though. If I lived 45 mins away then I’d 100% have called an ambulance for DS.

XenoBitch · 06/02/2023 17:46

MereDintofPandiculation · 06/02/2023 17:44

So what is the solution if you have someone who needs A&E but you don’t have the means to to get them there?

I would post on social media. Hopefully a friend would offer a lift there.

MereDintofPandiculation · 06/02/2023 17:44

Kinneddar · 12/01/2023 22:23

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking

Ffs not knowing where to park or not having money for the car park are NOT reasons to call an ambulance. No wonder the system is so broken if that's how people think

So what is the solution if you have someone who needs A&E but you don’t have the means to to get them there?

XenoBitch · 06/02/2023 17:38

@Pushkinia you did the right thing. You had an accident, and the paramedics administered treatment whilst they were there with you.
You are right though, on MN you would have been told to hop all the way to the hospital.

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 13:58

MacarenaMacarena · 06/02/2023 09:52

I suspect in the case of a broken nail that every ambulance sent would be diverted to an emergency while en route - unlikely that patient would be a high priority, unless the phone triage thought bleeding or nerve damage might be a thing.
A good triage system on the phone could direct people to get to hospital by other means, it's just hard for some patients who might be terrified in that moment to not think the worst and feel an ambulance is the only way.

Often not actually. It's like you say they tend to code for something else that isn't really an actual risk for something that could happen. People call for stupid stuff tend to code the highest and you can be diverted from a stroke etc to attend to them.

The kind of person whom calls 999 for a broken nail, or simple nose bleed doesn't describe it as a simple broken nail, they say "the pain is agonising, there's blood pouring out, if someone doesn't help me I'm going to have to kill myself to stop the pain. .. ". The call taker isn't allowed to question the integrity of what the caller says so quite often these jobs code cat1 for something like catastrophic bleeding and bump to the top of the list over any heart attack, broken hip, stroke.

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 13:52

alexdgr8 · 06/02/2023 01:11

i had to call out of hours doc on 111 recently for someone who has complex medical problems, very vulnerable, bedbound.
she had clear signs of 2 infections, both of which have previously become near fatal.
we requested antibiotics.
usually a doc comes, examines, and give antibiotics.
this time, middle of night, an ambulance came, wanted to take her to hosp. she said no.
she needs at least 4 people to move her, so they would have to have waited for another crew.
the paramedic said he thought she had an infection and needed antibiotics.
yes we said. that's why we rang 111.
the ambulance remained outside her home for 4 hours, while he said he was trying to speak to a doctor to prescribe antibiotics.
i suggested his control could do that, but he said no.
we were quite shocked. this was during period when news reported severe strain on ambulance service.

I work for Ambulance service and have seen this situation played out many times.

Very few paramedics have minor illness training, even fewer have a qualification that would give them credibility in diagnosing it. I'm 7 years in and only just done a minor illness course! Hence the need to speak to a doctor. Dealing with minor illness properly is actually far more complex then dealing with something like chest pain/heart attack - in terms of diagnosing and providing the correct treatment.

In a lot of instances paramedics would not be able to leave scene until spoken with a doctor. This is a medicolegal thing - if I see your child or elderly relative for example and say "well doesn't look that unwell, maybe you're right just needs some antibiotics, speak to a doctor when you can" , and leave - then the callback doesn't happen or takes too long, or something is missed and that patient dies x days or weeks later that's going to be on my head and also negative for the service.

Obviously this ties up crews for hours and reduces capacity to respond. However not having resources to respond to people is technically fine legally. Complaints come in all the time for "no one responded to my partner having a heart attack for 18hours then he died in surgery" - no one is even in a little bit of trouble for that as the delay was due to demand and nobody to send. Its just normal now. Last I heard 500 people a week were dieing in the UK due to delays in response and for treatment. This is why we are striking to get services changed and better supported so it stops overwhelming our ability to do provide any kind of proper emergency service.

We've got more ambulances and staff than at any point in history, but staff that become well qualified and experienced able to manage details effectively in a time efficient manner, having the knowledge to be able to confidently with standing tell the patient/family they can wait and try again with the gp or just don't actually need any treatment it's something that will get better itself - they get poached by private/other services who pay much better!

Whilst the rest of the staff are all being tied up dealing with minor illness, waiting to handover people who could have made own way, waiting for gp callbacks. I worked a night-shift last night on front line Ambulance responding to 999 calls. The only medication I used was patients own paracetamol they had in house but hadn't taken, not one person required any support to walk about the house, could have easily driven themselves to hospital or taken the bus actually if they actually felt they needed to go. But were calling 999 effictively because they wanted a checkup and it's more convienent to just call 999 knowing we eventually come and it avoids the difficulty of actually trying to see their gp. But we are not GPs, we don't not have anywhere close to their level of knowledge and experience in dealing with a minor illness presentation and differentiating it from something major, could very easily miss a diagnosis of cancer that would have been obvious to a GP. So 111 or similar keep sending us to check it out, but we are checking out things that we actually have no training in at all!

TizerorFizz · 06/02/2023 10:46

@Pushkinia
But what you describe is what an ambulance is for! Accident - yes. Emergency - yes. What most people find difficult is using A&E for something that will clear up on its own. Hospital is not needed for antibiotics. This needs to be changed so a pharmacist can do it as doctors are not available. Even a community nurse should be able to do this. We don’t seem capable of saving our own services.

MacarenaMacarena · 06/02/2023 09:52

I suspect in the case of a broken nail that every ambulance sent would be diverted to an emergency while en route - unlikely that patient would be a high priority, unless the phone triage thought bleeding or nerve damage might be a thing.
A good triage system on the phone could direct people to get to hospital by other means, it's just hard for some patients who might be terrified in that moment to not think the worst and feel an ambulance is the only way.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/02/2023 09:10

Freudpenis · 13/01/2023 21:07

Oh ffs. As if anyone thinks a gravely ill person should get themselves to hospital. This thread is about people who can. I've relatives who used to work for NHS24 and people really do ask for ambulances because they don't drive or apparently have no money.

Some people genuinely have no money. We had a lovely person volunteering with us in work, but he was literally so skint we needed to give him bus fare in advance as he didn't have the money to pay for it upfront. He walked everywhere he could.

Pushkinia · 06/02/2023 07:39

I’ve only had an ambulance once and, judging by what I read here, I shouldn’t have and should just have made my own way to hospital.

I fell down the stairs at home and was lying half in, half out of the bedroom door. I knew I’d done something to my foot and ankle by the excruciating pain and I couldn’t move. The front door is at the top of the stairs and my 80 year old father couldn’t carry me up them (he would have needed the ambulance) so he called an ambulance for me.

I had broken my heel bone and torn ligaments in my foot and both sides of my ankle - not life threatening but I didn’t know if it was dislocated (the paramedics thought it might be). It took a lot of gas and air to get a splint on my leg.

It’s not always easy to judge. By injury, I didn’t need an ambulance, but could I have moved without it? No.

Desertbarncat · 06/02/2023 02:05

Money can be a huge barrier. I’ve been in a position with no car and literally zero cash for a taxi or bus. So I wouldn’t have a way to get there.

alexdgr8 · 06/02/2023 01:11

i had to call out of hours doc on 111 recently for someone who has complex medical problems, very vulnerable, bedbound.
she had clear signs of 2 infections, both of which have previously become near fatal.
we requested antibiotics.
usually a doc comes, examines, and give antibiotics.
this time, middle of night, an ambulance came, wanted to take her to hosp. she said no.
she needs at least 4 people to move her, so they would have to have waited for another crew.
the paramedic said he thought she had an infection and needed antibiotics.
yes we said. that's why we rang 111.
the ambulance remained outside her home for 4 hours, while he said he was trying to speak to a doctor to prescribe antibiotics.
i suggested his control could do that, but he said no.
we were quite shocked. this was during period when news reported severe strain on ambulance service.

JenniferBooth · 13/01/2023 21:36

@fillmeup A taxi? Would these taxis be driven by the taxi drivers who quit because of the lockdowns. One company here had fifty drivers pre lockdown. Post lockdown......19
Did you support the lockdowns OP?

Stunningscreamer · 13/01/2023 21:14

Outwiththenorm · 13/01/2023 20:44

Wow the Tories have really done a number on so many of you. Lost count of the threads blaming sick people for the state of the nhs. Blame the underfunding government! Not some poor soul who calls an ambulance. Stop believing this guff. Other European countries ARE NOT IN THIS STATE (written as a resident of another European country with an excellent well-funded health service).

Don't be ridiculous. You can blame the Tories for underfunding the NHS and still think people should get a taxi when their condition isn't serious rather than call an ambulance.

Freudpenis · 13/01/2023 21:07

Outwiththenorm · 13/01/2023 20:44

Wow the Tories have really done a number on so many of you. Lost count of the threads blaming sick people for the state of the nhs. Blame the underfunding government! Not some poor soul who calls an ambulance. Stop believing this guff. Other European countries ARE NOT IN THIS STATE (written as a resident of another European country with an excellent well-funded health service).

Oh ffs. As if anyone thinks a gravely ill person should get themselves to hospital. This thread is about people who can. I've relatives who used to work for NHS24 and people really do ask for ambulances because they don't drive or apparently have no money.

coffeepleeease · 13/01/2023 20:54

I guess it depends on who you have to rely on for a lift. When I was unwell a few years ago I saw a nurse at my surgery who said to make my way to hospital and not to drive myself, call and ambulance if needed. Luckily my sister could give me a lift over

Outwiththenorm · 13/01/2023 20:44

Wow the Tories have really done a number on so many of you. Lost count of the threads blaming sick people for the state of the nhs. Blame the underfunding government! Not some poor soul who calls an ambulance. Stop believing this guff. Other European countries ARE NOT IN THIS STATE (written as a resident of another European country with an excellent well-funded health service).

NeelyOHara1 · 13/01/2023 20:08

I would guess that many people are scared that if they didn't call an ambulance for someone but got them there by other means and something terrible happened, they would be blamed and feel guilty for the rest of their lives..

Aldith · 13/01/2023 19:48

I don’t know about post covid but pre covid our local hospital had a minor injuries clinic. You could book an appointment or walk in on the understanding that if you walked in you could be waiting a while but if you booked an appointment they would see you as close to the appointment time as possible. You could book appointments that day and they never released all the slots in the morning. It was open 24 hours and staffed by nurses and doctors and they would have some dealing with appointments and some with walk ins.

It took the pressure off of A & E but as it was part of the hospital it meant that you could quickly get transferred to a different department if needed.

Fam23 · 13/01/2023 19:20

Sturmundcalm · 13/01/2023 17:01

Really? You think most of the people on here think that vomiting or having a cut arm is an acceptable reason to phone an ambulance??? Cause that's not how I'd read the responses...

No I was referring to having a heart attack.
sorry I didn’t make that clear as I was doing something else at the time of replying.

if you read my other post on here you’ll see how I feel about it all.

Kendodd · 13/01/2023 18:33

One terrible thing my A&E has done now is moved upstairs. It used to be right there as soon as you came. It's now down a corridor, up the stairs/lift then down another corridor. Madness!

CannibalQueen · 13/01/2023 18:19

Callimanco · 13/01/2023 17:26

I agree with others. In a genuine emergency you can drop. In A and E recently with my DD, a man came running in screaming, a bunch of nurses ran out and within a minute an unconscious young girl was being run through the corridor in a wheelchair, a nurse supporting her head, and into recuss.
As it happens we were on our way to lunch (we were awaiting NG tube fitting...yes we had to present to A and E, seems silly to me too) and his car was just left on double yellow lines right outside the department. He moved it once his daughter had been stabilised.

I parked in a disabled spot late a night in an unfamiliar town with my DS - it was right outside the children's A and E. He was covered in petechiae and bleeding from nose and mouth. Again we were seeing a consultant within 3 mins and I moved the car several hours later, when he was stabler. Turned out to be a rare blood condition, btw.

Yes, have done this too when husband took a bad fall outside and tore his quadriceps tendon in half. I pulled up at the double yellows, went in and asked for help, two nurses came out with a wheelchair and while he was in I moved the car to the parking area.

CannibalQueen · 13/01/2023 18:16

I agree completely. I saw one TV show where someone rang for an ambulance because a condom had burst. People really need to be told that limited resources mean that not everything is an emergency and to use a bit of common sense instead.

LuluBlakey1 · 13/01/2023 18:13

firstaidforlife.org.uk/999when-to-call-for-an-ambulance-and-when-not-to/

Interestingly their costs are wrong.(according to gov.uk)

It is now _
Each 999 call for an ambulance coasts NHS £8
If an ambulance is dispatched it costs £227
If the patient is taking to A and E it costs £395
If they spend a night in hospital it costs another £400 per night.

There are families who made 10,000 999 calls last year for an ambulance (according to The Times) . Just those phone calls cost the NHS £80,000.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 13/01/2023 17:52

AnotherVice · 13/01/2023 15:00

@Kendodd
**Then there are many who turn up at A and E and have trivial injuries- cuts that don't even require stitching, or twisted ankle 3 days ago and it's still sore, sore throats, lost tampons, their bad back medication isn't working or are just absolutely drunk or on drugs and aggressive

Isn't a lost tampon something that needs urgent (and easily with the right tool) removal?**

The thing with a lost tampon though, is that whilst yes it needs removing as they would be at risk of toxic shock, that person may have been walking round with it for days. Not life threatening at that point. As/if toxic shock sets in they may experience a whole host of symptoms such as confusion, feeling faint, weak pulse, reduced urine output....certainly needs prompt attention. If it gets to the point they go into proper distributive shock where their organs start to shut down and they go into peri-arrest/cardiac arrest there may not be an ambulance available because they're sat across town with someone who has just realised they've left a tampon in but is completely asymptomatic at present. One is a life-threatening emergency, the other is not.

Probably best not to let it turn into a life threatening emergency though. A lot cheaper and quicker as well to remove it before it becomes a problem.