Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
Bluelightbaby · 12/01/2023 23:24

fakenamefornow · 12/01/2023 23:22

I remember my son got his leg trapped in a climbing frame in a playground about nine years ago. He was trapped about 5ft up. Somebody else called 999 and didn't know whether to ask for an ambulance or fire brigade. Anyway, ambulance arrived in about 3 minutes and managed to free him before the fire brigade got there.

I do wonder how the 999 call handler categoried the call. Im guessing even though my son (age about 6) was fine it must have been cat 1. He was fine because me and some other women was holding his weight so he wasn't hanging from his leg.

Medical requirements will always come before any other service. It would definitely not have been a cat 1. That is for things like cardiac arrests and severe life threatening emergencies. It was just luck that one came so quickly tbh

Bluelightbaby · 12/01/2023 23:22

Snowpatrolling · 12/01/2023 23:20

I once rung 111 for an emergency out of hours appointment on a Saturday, I was having chest pains but it felt like really bad indigestion. They sent an ambulance which I said no to, I just wanted an emergency appointment as was painful! Paramedics turned up and said I needed to go to hospital, no problem i said, I’ll drive! Nope they wouldn’t let me! Got to the hospital and was rushed through. It was ok in the end and was just an infection in my lung lining but I really could have driven myself. They didn’t let me refuse.

In fairness it was right you had an ambulance. Chest pains could be anything from cardiac issues to pulmonary embolism. Our protocol is all chest pains attend hospital

fakenamefornow · 12/01/2023 23:22

I remember my son got his leg trapped in a climbing frame in a playground about nine years ago. He was trapped about 5ft up. Somebody else called 999 and didn't know whether to ask for an ambulance or fire brigade. Anyway, ambulance arrived in about 3 minutes and managed to free him before the fire brigade got there.

I do wonder how the 999 call handler categoried the call. Im guessing even though my son (age about 6) was fine it must have been cat 1. He was fine because me and some other women was holding his weight so he wasn't hanging from his leg.

Snowpatrolling · 12/01/2023 23:20

thaegumathteth · 12/01/2023 23:16

@Gilmorehill I'm glad you admit you didn't need the ambulance.

People who say they were forced to accept an ambulance - how? Twice it's been suggested I get one, once for me and one for Dd but we had a car and could go right away so I said no and that was it. I honestly don't understand how you can try and refuse and be made to have an ambulance.

I once rung 111 for an emergency out of hours appointment on a Saturday, I was having chest pains but it felt like really bad indigestion. They sent an ambulance which I said no to, I just wanted an emergency appointment as was painful! Paramedics turned up and said I needed to go to hospital, no problem i said, I’ll drive! Nope they wouldn’t let me! Got to the hospital and was rushed through. It was ok in the end and was just an infection in my lung lining but I really could have driven myself. They didn’t let me refuse.

ItsTheEndOfTheWorld · 12/01/2023 23:18

I've called for an ambulance a couple of times in the last year or so.

First was actually DH calling for me as I was suffering anaphylaxis and we were over 3 hours from the nearest hospital. A first responder arrived with a defib and the ambulance was about 30 minutes after and saved my life.

More recently I dislocated my knee and was told by 999 there was an 8 hour plus wait for an ambulance. I gritted my teeth and managed to pop my knee back in (not easily!) and was driven to A&e but had to wait alone due to covid restrictions. I was in a wheelchair in the waiting room for 9 hours during which time I passed out several times from the pain and had to rely on other patients to put me back in the wheelchair. One of the most harrowing experiences of my life. What is the nhs coming to.

SecondhandTable · 12/01/2023 23:18

I work in general practice, not a clinical role, but I read a lot of clinical post. This includes reports from the ambulance service. You would not believe some of the reasons people give the call handlers for why they've called. I wish I could say more on this but don't feel I can/should for obvious reasons of confidentiality. It's frequent too, I work for a large group of practices and every day there are probably about a handful of ridiculous ones. Just at our own practice group. Multiply that across the population and it's utterly ridiculous.

Thesonglastslonger · 12/01/2023 23:18

A problem is that when you’re on the phone to 999 they strongly recommend you wait for the ambulance and do not attempt to travel. They repeat it over and over. Their advice was written back when an ambulance would be there within minutes.

Ugh system so broken 😭

thaegumathteth · 12/01/2023 23:16

@Gilmorehill I'm glad you admit you didn't need the ambulance.

People who say they were forced to accept an ambulance - how? Twice it's been suggested I get one, once for me and one for Dd but we had a car and could go right away so I said no and that was it. I honestly don't understand how you can try and refuse and be made to have an ambulance.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 12/01/2023 23:16

999 isn't just to call an ambulance though is it?

It somebody was having a baby, even if I knew we were trapped in thick snow and an ambulance was unlikely to get there in time, I'd still call 999 because I'd hope they'd be able to talk me through what to do.

Ditto if somebody has fallen or is unconscious — it wouldn't just be the ambulance I wanted, it would be advice on how to safely help in the meantime.

I didn't think you're supposed to ring 111 in time-sensitive emergencies?

Battybaa · 12/01/2023 23:16

Calling for an ambulance isn't just about conveyance to a & e. Paramedics medically assess you to see if you need immediate treatment. It seems you are at fault whichever decision you make. Dragging someone to wait hours in a waiting room or wait at home. People panic and rely on the safety net of 999 in times of need. Ambulances are more than taxi's you rely on the arrival and medical care of the paramedic.

Badgirlriri · 12/01/2023 23:16

Hohohoholidays · 12/01/2023 23:06

you see it would never have dawned on me to call an ambulance in this situation. I am sure you and your husband could have given him a piggy back or a passerby could have helped do that or as like you said, your husband managed to drive there anyway. No wonder there is a shortage of ambulances!

I agree. I wouldn’t have called an ambulance for that either.

IWineAndDontDine · 12/01/2023 23:15

My housemate at uni phoned an ambulance because she hurt her ankle the night before at a club... was fine the day after

Badgirlriri · 12/01/2023 23:14

YANBU. The amount of people who come in by ambulance for a non life threatening reason and then then the family follow in the car behind 🤷🏼‍♀️

Bluelightbaby · 12/01/2023 23:14

Hohohoholidays · 12/01/2023 23:06

you see it would never have dawned on me to call an ambulance in this situation. I am sure you and your husband could have given him a piggy back or a passerby could have helped do that or as like you said, your husband managed to drive there anyway. No wonder there is a shortage of ambulances!

This !! This is part of the reason we’re screwed. This is NOT a reason to call an ambulance!! And the reason it was cancelled. We would have driven at normal road speed, it would be a very low priority call so you would have waited hours. We dont carry off roading equipment so all we would have done would be help you assist him to walk to your own car…..

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 12/01/2023 23:13

I got told off (politely, but clearly the Dr thought I was an idiot) when I drove myself to A&E in the midst of a gallbladder attack, it was a 5 minute drive, I had to pull over twice to vomit but it was 3am Sunday morning, there were no taxis available, my husband doesn't drive, I have no family or friends I could have called for a lift (literally none, my parents are both dead, most of my friends don't drive, the ones that do are out of town and in my in laws were away).

I probably should have called an ambulance but I just don't think I could call one unless I was actually completely immobile or dying. Turns out I just had a severely infected gallbladder requiring urgent surgery, 5 days of IV antibiotics and lots of morphine, so perfectly fine 😂

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 12/01/2023 23:11

If you have ever watched any of the ‘emergency’ type programs, you will have seen how frequently ambulances are sent to people who have collapsed on the street due to alcohol or drug abuse.
People need to take more responsibility for their health, as this situation will only get worse.

GoingtotheWinchester · 12/01/2023 23:10

@justasking that was poor triaging - there’s no priority for ambulance admissions I assure you.

Toddlerteaplease · 12/01/2023 23:09

Totally agree. Particularly some of the calls you see on programs like Ambulance. But we've had some really tragic cases in my hospital recently, where the parents have driven their child to hospital when they were choking, or in peri arrest.

justasking111 · 12/01/2023 23:07

I remember flying down the dual carriageway to get my husband back to the hospital, post surgery complication. On arrival we had to wait because he hadn't come by ambulance. A guy arrived in an ambulance complaining he was missing Corrie. Kicked up a fuss. Diagnosis sprained thumb.

All this whilst my OH was rolling on a gurney in agony.

With my children I've seen drunks, addicts causing problems. Police escorting prisoners. A huge guy threatened a tiny nurse.

OH said that they should have shipping container in the car park with slatted seating for the drunks. Let them sleep it off throw them out then pressure wash it down with a strong disinfectant solution

Hohohoholidays · 12/01/2023 23:06

Gilmorehill · 12/01/2023 22:43

We called for an ambulance and they said it was on its way, then we got a call cancelling it. My ds (14) had sliced his foot open on a rock in a river . The car park was over a mile away and we had no idea how to carry him there. There was a small crowd gathered round helping us and everyone was appalled at them cancelling the ambulance. My dh ended up having to ignore all the road signs and drive onto the riverbank. I suppose the fact we found a way suggests we didn’t need an ambulance but it was pretty brutal to do it. I don’t know how some people can convince the call handlers they need one.

you see it would never have dawned on me to call an ambulance in this situation. I am sure you and your husband could have given him a piggy back or a passerby could have helped do that or as like you said, your husband managed to drive there anyway. No wonder there is a shortage of ambulances!

LuluBlakey1 · 12/01/2023 23:05

I've been watching programmes about ambulance calls and police calls and A and E departments, late at night because I am not sleeping well and there are lots of them on TV.

I'm amazed at how many people call 999 totally unnecessarily. Last night there was a young woman called an ambulance saying she'd collapsed in the street and couldn't breathe. She clearly could breathe when they arrived, all her checks were normal and it turned out she had a cut on her head, had been drinking and had walked out if A and E half an hour earlier having already called an ambulance. They took her back again to get checked and found she had called an ambulance more than 400 times in the last year. She actually died a few days later at home (unrelated).

Another man rang 999 said he was suicidal, had tried to commit suicide and had a bomb. Refused to speak on the phone- was using a text type system made for deaf people. A whole emergency response was put in place- police, fire, ambulance, bomb squad. Looked like they would have to evacuate a hospital next door to his home. It turned out to not be true. He was a resident in an adult supported living facility- which the 999 emergency call manager noticed. They rang the place and the carer on duty checked him- no bomb, no suicide attempt.

A youngish woman (students) rang to say her boyfriend was very drunk and had vomited blood.Ambulance sent- not very drunk (4 drinks) said he had been sick but no blood. All checks normal. Refused to go to hospital.

Man about mid 30s, mental health problems. 31st call from him in 3 weeks. Had fallen at home. Uninjured but clearly drunk and upset. Refused to go to hospital after chat with staff from ambulance.

Woman with asthma - numerous calls every week. Staff gave her a nebuliser and she was fine. Didn't need to go to hospital.

There are many who do need the ambulance- chest pains, serious falls and clearly injured, often frail and elderly and alone or with partner also frail and elderly, very sick people with known, serious conditions, children with worrying symptoms, RTAs.

Then there are many who turn up at A and E and have trivial injuries- cuts that don't even require stitching, or twisted ankle 3 days ago and it's still sore, sore throats, lost tampons, their bad back medication isn't working or are just absolutely drunk or on drugs and aggressive.

I think every A and E should have a minor injuries unit and people should be diverted to it by nurse as they arrive at A and E. There should be a £50 charge for the clinic. The people do not need to be at a hospital and should not have gone- so if they stay for treatment they should pay.

I also think we need to be stricter about sending out ambulances. They are for potentially life-threatening injuries/illnesses or conditions or times when moving someone could be dangerous.

I also wondered about on duty nurse teams locally who go out to some of the elderly callers. Often they need assessment/ reassurance/ nebulisers/ pain medication and don't actually need/want to go to hospital. They ring 999 because they are scared.

Drunks should not be allowed into A and E or collected by ambulances.

Non-necessary calls should not be taken to hospital.

Mental health issues seem to result in massive use of police and ambulance staff. In the last two series of the police teams who deal with missing people- at least 50% of cases are mental health cases, people who regularly go off threatening to commit suicide, or upset, or drunk and depressed, or are vulnerable and the use of police and ambulance resources is huge with rarely an outcome that is not simply repeated again within days or weeks. The other two big user groups of police missing persons teams are dementia sufferers who get lost.

Police or ambulance and A and E are rarely the solution even that night. There is no access to appropriate resources so they become the service called-out. Again, it would seem better services for the elderly with dementia and for those with mental health would actually improve things.

thaegumathteth · 12/01/2023 23:05

Yanbu. I've been sent an ambulance once because I had what they thought was a dislocated hip and couldn't move.

111 offered to send an ambulance for dd when she was a baby when they heard her croup breathing but I just drove her in instead because it was quicker tbh. Obviously if I couldn't drive I'd have accepted their offer.

However I know a lot of people who have called them for broken bones such as arms (not talking open fracture etc) or for vomiting etc.

Of course not all people and all injuries / illnesses can be dealt with without an ambulance but it's definitely a misused service.

RiktheButler · 12/01/2023 23:05

Got chatting to a paramedic from West Midlands AS when they were called to a wedding I was working. When I suggested that 50% of their blue light calls weren't emergencies (based on the documentary series) she informed me that it is closer to 90%

90% of "emergency calls" do NOT require an emergency ambulance.

I see this figure is the same as quoted higher up....

Oh, and this call out was drink related...

GoingtotheWinchester · 12/01/2023 23:01

@FriedasCarLoad most A&Es have a drop off right by the door and then u go and park. Obviously not ideal with a child but dh and I have both done it.

Bluelightbaby · 12/01/2023 23:01

In addition I find it soul destroying at the number of threads on here about the ambulance service and derogatory comments, we work so so hard and it’s not us on the frontlines fault it’s broken :(:(

Swipe left for the next trending thread