Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
SugarQills · 13/01/2023 04:02

BabyOnBoard90 · 12/01/2023 22:17

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking?

Not knowing where to park is not a good enough to call and ambulance ffs!

Jesusmaryjosephandtheweedon · 13/01/2023 03:28

I've called an ambulance 3 times this year. Each time for my daughter(s) having seizures. 1st time was our 5 year old, I didnt know what was going on and panicked so called them and she needed treatment in the ambulance before we could transport her. Next time was the baby having a seizure and I knew what to do to try prevent it but it still happened and she was limp. Thought on the last one we would be able to bring her in the car for a check over but then her airway became compromised and we needed immediate attention. Could not have strapped her in a car seat and brought her by myself while DH stayed at home with younger kids.

So I guess it depends on the accident/emergency. Breathing issues, heart attack, stroke, open wounds with broken bones all ambulance jobs. Bad flu, dislocations etc get a lift.

springerspanielpuppy · 13/01/2023 03:03

Kendodd · 12/01/2023 23:57

Even if I had chest pain, I would get my husband to drive me to hospital or even try to drive myself if I possibly could. If one of my children started having a fit (for example) absolutely no way would I wait around for an ambulance. This isn't because I'm the ambulance police (like some on the thread) and think some people, even with poor, frightened judgement, don't deserve an ambulance. Its because the NHS has been so run into the ground by the government I wouldn't trust a ambulance to come quickly.

Totally agree.
What is wrong with this country that we blame people, some who are desperately ill or dying, for the ambulance crisis rather than government ideology?

And yes there will always be some who call an ambulance for a broken toe and others who will drive themselves with a broken leg. It's still government policy that has fucked the NHS.

lljkk · 13/01/2023 02:58

Yeah that's fair enough. The ambulance transports I've been involved with (for me or DH), we all could have driven by someone. All of those situations, someone else called an ambulance for us. One of them, I started to drive DH but he made me turn around & go back when he saw the ambulance approaching: he was desperate for pain relief. That ambulance stopped en route to put him on morphine, & I got to hospital maybe 20 minutes before him (driving separately). So he would have arrived a lot faster to hospital if I had driven him, too.

Probably experienced more agony, though. Sometimes it's not just about "life threatening" concerns. Ambulances provide treatment not just conveyance.

SomethingOriginal2 · 13/01/2023 02:38

BabyOnBoard90 · 12/01/2023 22:17

Where will you park? What if you're not able to drive? What if the people that can drive you aren't in close proximity? What if you can't afford parking?

The ambulance service is not a free taxi service. This is the problem.

People just can't look after themselves.

DHs cousin once got an ambulance to hospital for a RASH he egged it on as meningitis, he was perfectly well. It was eczema.

The only times I've called an ambulance was when my mum fell down the stairs and couldn't move her legs and when a woman had a seizure with her kid outside my front door.

namechange4774 · 13/01/2023 02:18

I have thought this recently OP but I'm on the fence. Obviously there are many situations where this won't be possible. But I have seen quite afew cases recently where they have waited hours and I have sort of thought your DP etc could have brought you. I do wonder if people think they get seen quicker possibly?
My DF lives 5 minutes away from the hospital and he walked with serve chest pains. Not the best idea you could say as he was having a heart attack. However he was instantly queue jumped and seen.
Why I'm on the fence is that it's just wrong that wait times for ambulances are so long. I feel like it's these sort of times we turn on each other/hospital staff when it's the government who need to fully take the blame and sort it.

Menora · 13/01/2023 01:39

I also work in primary care and we get to see what people called an ambulance for and some of it is just embarrassing tbh. But people panic and call, I get it

GP’s are in many A&E’s often to deal with walking, talking, no breathing problems ‘chest pain’ which is reflux/GERD from over eating

Bagpuss2022 · 13/01/2023 01:16

CMHT have called ambulances for me a few times totally ridiculous your told to ring the crisis team as part of your safety/crisis plan and they phone for an ambulance as they haven’t got the staff /resources to help people in a MH crisis. I don’t bother calling them anymore as what a PP said.

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 00:37

@Nowdontmakeamess You say people insist on staying in two storey houses so you mean they should move to a bungalow? A bungalow costs more than my house, it is not an option.

Lunde · 13/01/2023 00:35

I live in Sweden and there are several things that I think the NHS could adopt (if they could find the staff)

There are several different A&Es so people are steered to the right help and see specialists - in my rural area we have

  • normal A&E for trauma, accidents and severe illnesses etc
  • paediatric A&E - for childhood illnesses, fevers, asthma attacks minor injuries staffed by paediatric specialist drs and nurses
  • MH A&E - for MH crises staffed by psychiatrists, psychologists and MH nurses and they also have a short stay ward where patients can be assessed
  • Addiction services A&E dealing with drug and alcohol issues and patients needing urgent detox etc
  • In the North of the county there is also "Ski A&E" open for 4 months per year to deal with standard ski accidents - sprains, uncomplicated fractures rtc and staffed by locus orthopeds, radiographers and nurses etc to avoid pressure on the larger A&E

Gp clinic within A&E - staffed by GPs to treat non-emmergencies

Patient transport that isn't an ambulance - control can despatch taxis or minibusses to people that don't need dull ambulance care

babsanderson · 13/01/2023 00:34

London used to have a mental health A and E staffed by psychiatric nurses. It should never have been closed down.

XenoBitch · 13/01/2023 00:23

MoscowMules · 13/01/2023 00:15

Re Mental Health I think CMHT needs more funding. They should be able to take over crisis calls of this nature.

Little car with a green Dr light on it and they could drive round in them, they can then immediately triage and decide on next course, that could be support voluntary admission, or start the wheels in motion for a section.

Presentation of self harm would be convey to minors under supervision.

All that happens in a MH crisis is an ambulance crew/police ends up sat with them for ages trying to convince them to go to a and e. Then they sit in A and E for hours waiting in the MH team to triage, and in most cases they are discharged with a referral to the crisis CMHT team. It's pitiful. And round and round we go.

I think a dedicated MH bay in A&E would help too.
I was told one was going to happen in my local hospital. It never did. I have been sat in a general assessment unit with someone who was experiencing mania and psychosis.. the lady in the bed opposite had kidney stones. We all just got dumped together in the no man land that is between A&E and a ward. It was distressing for everyone.

Where I live, at night, there are just two staff members of the crisis team available. They have to take calls on the phone from people at home, and assess people in A&E. Is ridiculous.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/01/2023 00:23

Gilmorehill · 12/01/2023 22:43

We called for an ambulance and they said it was on its way, then we got a call cancelling it. My ds (14) had sliced his foot open on a rock in a river . The car park was over a mile away and we had no idea how to carry him there. There was a small crowd gathered round helping us and everyone was appalled at them cancelling the ambulance. My dh ended up having to ignore all the road signs and drive onto the riverbank. I suppose the fact we found a way suggests we didn’t need an ambulance but it was pretty brutal to do it. I don’t know how some people can convince the call handlers they need one.

If it really had been somewhere you couldn't have got him out of, it would have been a job for highland or lowland rescue I'd have thought, not a regular ambulance.

RobertJohnsonsShoes · 13/01/2023 00:20

111 have sent an ambulance the past 4 times for things I didn't think were serious (and turned out not to be)

MoscowMules · 13/01/2023 00:15

Re Mental Health I think CMHT needs more funding. They should be able to take over crisis calls of this nature.

Little car with a green Dr light on it and they could drive round in them, they can then immediately triage and decide on next course, that could be support voluntary admission, or start the wheels in motion for a section.

Presentation of self harm would be convey to minors under supervision.

All that happens in a MH crisis is an ambulance crew/police ends up sat with them for ages trying to convince them to go to a and e. Then they sit in A and E for hours waiting in the MH team to triage, and in most cases they are discharged with a referral to the crisis CMHT team. It's pitiful. And round and round we go.

User837463839 · 13/01/2023 00:12

Drunks should not be allowed into A and E or collected by ambulances.

This is a ridiculous statement. Drunk people can have accidents that are serious and need treating. They can have heart attacks and any number of other medical emergencies, just the same as sober people can.
I drove my cousin to A&E when he was drunk because he had severe stomach pain. He was rolling around in agony. Turned out to be kidney stones but I didn’t know that obviously. I was worried it might be appendicitis and he’d need surgery. He was admitted for days anyway so obviously did need to be seen in A&E.

alexdgr8 · 13/01/2023 00:10

Georgeskitchen · 12/01/2023 23:27

If only GPS still did home visits, especially for very elderly people who might just need antibiotics, pretty sure ambulance callous would drop like a stone.

but this is what the out of hours service is for.
you ring 111 and eventually a doctor comes and gives antibiotics.
done it several times for a bed-bound neighbour.
last time xmas eve, rang at 7.40pm, two call backs, doc arrived 4.50am xmas day.
maybe it is not avail in some areas ?

Nowdontmakeamess · 13/01/2023 00:04

Antigonads · 12/01/2023 22:17

I’ve driven myself with a dislocated shoulder, got a taxi with a broken arm and DH and friends have taken me on several occasions.

Ambulance twice, called by school and after an RTA on horseback.

YANBU

Driving with a dislocated shoulder is incredibly dangerous, you could have ended up killing someone.

There definitely needs to be more done to stop people misusing the ambulance service but not to the extent where people who need one refuse and end up in a worse situation.

Call handlers could advise alternatives eg minor injuries unit, take a taxi etc.

When I dislocated my knee I was initially told by 111 to make my own way to hospital. There was no way I could get downstairs and in a car so they sent a first responder. Gas & air, popped it back in and I was able to make my own way to a&e to have it xrayed.

The system needs more contingencies built in, and there needs to be massive investment in mental health and care services.

A lot of the problems at the moment are being caused by people ready to be discharged but with no care/suitable accommodation in place.

People need to face the realities of getting older and put plans in place a lot sooner. I know so many people who insist on staying in their 2 storey homes, refuse any care then end up calling several ambulances a year when they have a fall etc.

crimsonpeak · 13/01/2023 00:03

Worth saying that I do think a lot of people think that because they have come in by ambulance that they will be seen quicker. Not the case. You’re triaged and put into the queue, that’s it. I’ve spent a lot of time in A&E over the last few years and I’m sure some people are there just because they’re lonely, bored or any other number of reasons. Bank holidays and Christmas are like a ghost town. I was at A&E on Christmas Eve and was seen and back home within 4 hours.

Aldith · 13/01/2023 00:03

DH has been taken in by ambulance once and that was after we phoned 111 and they sent one. The ambulance was here in under an hour in March last year. He was taken in on the Tuesday, had surgery on the Wednesday and was kicked out on Thursday. He had Cauda Equina which they class as urgent but non life threatening.

If 111 send an ambulance there is often not a lot you can do as they don’t tell you what they think it might be or ask if you can make your own way there.

Lunde · 13/01/2023 00:01

I think that the underfunding and staffing issues in many NHS services is resulting in the ambulance service being used in place of urgent (but non-emergency) GP and MH appointments. There was an article about a month ago (Guardian I think) that stated that only 50% of patients for ambulances that are sent out even require a trip to hospital and of those that are taken in many are not emergencies. It is clear that if people could see a GP within a couple of days many would not call an ambulance

I think that Britain also needs to find a better solution for non-life threatening MH patients. Having recently watched several ambulance docu-series they seem to be a large proportion of workload yet many do not require a fully equipped ambulance, nor I would think, do many people in MH crisis benefit from being taken to wait in a chaotic A&E for hours and hours

crimsonpeak · 13/01/2023 00:00

Totally depends on the situation. My DF had a heart attack, DM recognised his symptoms, got him in the car and drove the 10 miles to hospital. If they had lived closer they perhaps would have called an ambulance, but driving was the best option. Another family member was also driven by car to hospital with a pulmonary embolism. The situation just meant they would have been better off driving there than waiting for an ambulance at home. Both very stressful situations for the drivers though!

Kendodd · 12/01/2023 23:57

Even if I had chest pain, I would get my husband to drive me to hospital or even try to drive myself if I possibly could. If one of my children started having a fit (for example) absolutely no way would I wait around for an ambulance. This isn't because I'm the ambulance police (like some on the thread) and think some people, even with poor, frightened judgement, don't deserve an ambulance. Its because the NHS has been so run into the ground by the government I wouldn't trust a ambulance to come quickly.

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2023 23:56

Lots of people don’t need Accident and Emergency either. They are neither. If you drive in, no one sees you anyway!

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 12/01/2023 23:56

Actually not being able to park is an issue. I drove my 3 year to A and E from the GPs surgery during an asthma attack. GP had suggested an ambulance but since I had my car I thought driving him would be quicker. Problem is the hospital is an a main road with nowhere you can stop the car and the car park was completely full. I was literally freaking out, considering dumping my car and just grabbing him and running in for help but what then? I'd have blocked the way for somwone else in an emergency or for an ambulance. It was fucking terrifying I drove round the whole carpark before finding a space and just running in without paying. I genuinely found the parking almost as stressful as him being so ill. Not leaving the car could have meant he didn't get help.in time but dumping could have meant someone else not getting help.

Swipe left for the next trending thread