Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people who phone for an ambulance could make their own way to hospital?

359 replies

fillmeup · 12/01/2023 22:13

Either by getting family or friends to drive them there or getting a taxi. Obviously if you’re on the floor with a broken hip etc and can’t be moved or had a severe stroke an ambulance is required but most people I’ve heard on the news recently talking about how long they have waited, I’ve seriously wondered why they waited 20 hours (or thereabouts) and didn’t just get a lift.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allergictoironing · 07/02/2023 20:12

Sometimes the problem is that the patient, or person with them, genuinely don't know whether it's an emergency/life threatening.

I had severe pain in my back and upper stomach/lower chest area so bad I was panting, sobbing & sweating with the pain. I couldn't sit down, I couldn't stand up, only position that was bearable at all was standing leaning across the back f the sofa. Never experienced anything like it. I live at home, it was about 3am, there's no way I could have driven myself without crashing. Though I have a reasonable understanding of illness & injury I had no idea what was wrong, so I called 111. After 25 mins on hold, I started to go through the 111 on line diagnostic thingy which said call 999 immediately.

The paramedics asked if I'd taken any pain relief - 2 30/500 co-codamol and a naproxen I'd taken hadn't touched the pain so they gave me gas & air plus morphine which just about took the edge off.

Turn out it was gall stones, but I didn't know that and I doubt there's any way I could have known. This isn't a life threatening condition but the pain was such that I needed much more than my normal prescription painkillers plus IV buscopan. Now I can recognise the signs if an attack starts and know to take the Buscopan & painkillers early, but at the time I genuinely thought whatever was wrong was going to kill me.

Kendodd · 07/02/2023 18:06

Thank you. I was just curious how they'd categorise it. He was fine, but it could have turned bad very quickly.

SleepyRich · 07/02/2023 01:50

Kendodd · 06/02/2023 21:51

@SleepyRich
Can I ask a question?
I posted earlier about my son when he was about six, about ten years ago. He got his leg trapped in a peice of equipment at the playground. He was fine, well, crying and a bit bruised but not bleeding or injured. He was trapped about five feet in the air and myself and some other woman were holding him up so no weight was on his leg and he wasn't hanging upside down from it. It was really hard to hold him though and taking all our strength, we couldn't have held him for long although I'm sure other members of the public would have taken over from us.
Anyway, ambulance arrived in about 90 seconds (thank God!) and fire engine was on it's way. Reading this thread though, I do wonder how they would have categorised this? My son would have been in serious trouble if he'd had to wait like that for ten hours for an emergency response although fire fighters could have freed him so I suppose he didn't need an ambulance at all.

So that's an unusual call, I suspect the call taker would have flagged for a clinician to listen in/take over the call - with the concern that tailored advice might be needed to be provided - whilst fine now you know good outcome, and maybe you could see he was ok whilst being supported, but on the other end of the line hearing a child is suspended in the air from a frame would be concerning. I wouldn't be surprised if it ended up being a cat 1, or 2 at least but its not the type of job attended very often so I'm not quite sure.

I've never answered the 999 calls but I've sat in for a few to listen in. All calls start off as cat1, but as you answer more questions you either downgrade yourself, or stay as a cat1. Occasionally you can say something that puts you back up again also but this isn't as common. So the first 2 questions "are they breathing, are they conscious? If yes to both of these then you drop to cat 2, then you're asked what the nature of the call is - this then gives the call taker a page to use for the questions to start from - essentially tick here for trauma, maternity, breathing problem, chest pain,... the system then gives a series of questions to get to an outcome where it guesses a diagnosis - i.e. pt has a heart problem, patient having a stroke... Depending on what it is the system will either give closing instructions to end the call - please call back if anything gets worse I need to hang up now and take another call... or they'll need to stay on the line with you - generally cat 1 which in theory would think the patient is either in cardiac arrest or is about to be in cardiac arrest - so they stay on the line in case they need to give cpr instructions.

Rainbowqueeen · 07/02/2023 00:07

This has been really interesting to read.

I would never drive myself if I had chest pains because the risk to other road users is too high. Would get someone else to drive me if available though rather than call an ambulance.

Have driven DC to hospital with broken wrist, broken elbow and dislocated knee (3 separate occasions). Had to park in a 5 minute zone one time and DH moved my car when he arrived.

I would never drive an elderly person with suspected broken bones other than a broken wrist.

I would always drive someone with a deep cut that needed stitches unless it was a head injury. I’d probably drive someone with breathing issues unless I knew an ambulance would get there faster.
My neighbour has driven her DC and the ambulance arranged to meet them at a particular spot as it was quicker.

GrandTheftWalrus · 06/02/2023 23:28

I had to get an ambulance when in labour with my 2nd as about 5 mins after losing my bloody show I lost my waters and contractions were coming too quick for me to even breathe. I had barely any sign of labour before then, infact I was in the middle of getting dressed to go to hospital after phoning maternity triage. We had planned on phoning a taxi but our hospital is 30 mins away by car. If I'd been in taxi when that all happened she'd have been born on the road.

Turned out the cord was round her neck twice and she went into severe distress so was trying to get out quickly.

They got there in 10 mins.

I also had to call when dh was in severe dka. Again there in minutes.

Chupney · 06/02/2023 21:54

I was haemorrhaging post partum and I got DH to drive me to the hospital with basically my tracksuit bottoms full of muslins. Afterwards people asked me why I didn't call an ambulance but he could drive me there as quickly (albeit with some danger of damaging the passenger seat) and it made me realise why there's such a demand for ambulances.

Kendodd · 06/02/2023 21:51

@SleepyRich
Can I ask a question?
I posted earlier about my son when he was about six, about ten years ago. He got his leg trapped in a peice of equipment at the playground. He was fine, well, crying and a bit bruised but not bleeding or injured. He was trapped about five feet in the air and myself and some other woman were holding him up so no weight was on his leg and he wasn't hanging upside down from it. It was really hard to hold him though and taking all our strength, we couldn't have held him for long although I'm sure other members of the public would have taken over from us.
Anyway, ambulance arrived in about 90 seconds (thank God!) and fire engine was on it's way. Reading this thread though, I do wonder how they would have categorised this? My son would have been in serious trouble if he'd had to wait like that for ten hours for an emergency response although fire fighters could have freed him so I suppose he didn't need an ambulance at all.

Aldith · 06/02/2023 20:14

I have been taken to hospital by ambulance twice and as I have dyspraxia and this means I am clumsier than most. I have fallen onto a brick wall and down a flight of stone stairs landing on my back on tiled floor. Both times by some miracle I avoided striking my head on the ground but both times I split my leg open down to the muscle. The first time I did it I ended up getting two layers of stitches and the scar is around 10cm long and V shaped and the second time one layer of stitches and then staples and it was the length of a 10 year child’s hands diagonally from pinkie tip to thumb tip. They could apparently have healed without medical intervention but with it I have a leg that whilst the scars mean it doesn’t look pretty I can still run on it. Should I not have gone in an ambulance?

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 20:02

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:52

@SleepyRich Thank you, that's very interesting! I always thought I'd hate to be a call handler for the very reason of being put in a position to make a judgement call so I'm glad to hear they're not implicated in the decision-making.

No worries.

Their role is still extremely challenging for a variety of reasons and not one I think I could stick at very long!!

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 20:00

SchoolQuestionnaire · 06/02/2023 19:11

And when you think that 40% of the people who get a c1 or c2 response (ie high priority calls) don't go to hospital at all it seems reasonable to deduce that quite a few of those didn’t need an ambulance response in the first place.

How many of those didn’t survive to make the trip?

Very very few people that call 'need' an ambulance, its vanishingly rare actually. Its really common for patients coding cat1 or 2 to actually turn out to be a minor ailment that's been occurring for months or years, already diagnosed and they just need to self care. You can easily work a week of shifts without ever seeing a single patient that needed any treatment beyond telling them to take paracetamol. It's not uncommon for people to need to be seen in a&e to work out what's going on, but in terms of it being an instance when hours matter or the injury/illness has caused them to be physically incapable of making own way just make such a tiny fraction of the work we do - so much that some students are now coming through their training without ever attending a cardiac arrest, stroke, major trauma, child birth - so the first time they do attend one of these events, possibly as the only qualified member of staff, will be the time they're responsible to manage it and make the decisions. Having only ever role played it in the classroom! It's a real baptism of fire!! Can anyone imagine the same for a newly qualified doctor to be let loose in the first week to see and treat a trauma job with no oversight?!?

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:52

@SleepyRich Thank you, that's very interesting! I always thought I'd hate to be a call handler for the very reason of being put in a position to make a judgement call so I'm glad to hear they're not implicated in the decision-making.

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 19:40

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:01

I haven't read the whole thread but can anyone in the know tell me if someone calls for an ambulance and its the broken nail variety of reasons can the handler under absolutely no circumstances refuse to send an ambulance? I suppose they can say there'll be a veerrrry long wait but they can't just say "nope, you don't need one"?

Strictly speaking is the triage tool computer that would tell the call taker to inform them that no Ambulance will be sent, call takers aren't allowed to make decisions its to input what the caller says as accurately as possible to the questions the computer tells them to say. It's fairly common for people to be told that their complaint does not warrent an ambulance to be sent.

The triage tool is adjusted throughout the day depending on demand/resources availiable - so very quiet itll have a low threshold to send an ambulance, but at the opposite end of the scale and we stop sending for all but the most immediately life threatening calls.

In terms of the calling for a broken nail, if the caller sensibly answered all the questions sensibly - my breathing is fine, not any serious bleeding, just a little bit sore, I'm calling because I'm sad about my nail - then the triage tool would always say no Ambulance and it wouldn't mater a jot if the caller demanded one/threatened to sue, it would nt be sent.

The trouble is the kind of person who makes such a silly call on hearing they won't be getting their ambulance then often says "oh well actually I've got chest pain too" and the call taker has to start the triage tool again for chest pain which will probably lead to Ambulance being sent. The call taker will know the patient is lieing, be sure that the only outcome if the crew arrives will be a lecture on not wasting emergency service time, but they still have to follow the script.

Another thing that happens is that whilst calls are on the stack waiting for an ambulance clinical staff will be looking through them, might see one that they suspect could be managed over the phone and call them back to see if they can deal with it or book a taxi/tell them to make own way. They don't have to stick to a script as they're clinically qualified.

Lucyccfc68 · 06/02/2023 19:36

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 19:22

It'll be what's known as a specialist Paramedic in urgent care. There are similar schemes now to progress paramedics which additional training and they work along side GPs and nurses in primary care. Very much like the nurse practitioner/ACP role.

Broadly speaking these roles come about since the demand for GPs vastly outstrips supply. Paramedics are cheaper to employ and train. Downside is not as skilled as GPs/possible more likely to miss a subtle or more unusual diagnosis but it helps meet demand.

Sounds like a good outcome to review your son.

Thank you. That all makes sense.

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:28

If there are people who are ringing 999 and getting sent an ambulance, and taken to hospital for a stubbed toe or broken fingernail... I wonder what work of fiction that is actually happening in.

Precisely! What discussion like this does do is actually instil a fear in people to not call for fear of 'wasting' resources. Those who call over a broken nail I presume will continue to call but there's a huge grey area, I'd even say most people who call fall in the grey area.

RiktheButler · 06/02/2023 19:26

XenoBitch · 06/02/2023 19:16

My very "extensive research Grin" into this is what I have seen on the various emergency service programs on the BBC etc. A lot of callers were told they did not actually need an ambulance at that time. And sometimes, when an ambulance does attend, they treat on site and either the issue is dealt with, or the patient is told to make their own way to hospital.

If there are people who are ringing 999 and getting sent an ambulance, and taken to hospital for a stubbed toe or broken fingernail... I wonder what work of fiction that is actually happening in.

They are not taken to hospital, but they have taken an emergency ambulance crew off the road for a period of time. Paramedics will tell you that up to 90% of emergency calls do not require any emergency response

SleepyRich · 06/02/2023 19:22

Lucyccfc68 · 06/02/2023 18:49

I can’t get my head round my son getting an appointment with a paramedic tomorrow for a cough he has had for over 5 weeks. I can only get an on-the-day appointment with the Doctors. I have to phone when he has already left for college and then you get what you are given regardless of my working day or his college class times.

so, we have been given a choice of appointment time tomorrow to see a paramedic instead. I can’t get my head round it - surely they are needed to be out in an ambulance dealing with people who need or (idiots who have requested, but don’t need an ambulance)

It'll be what's known as a specialist Paramedic in urgent care. There are similar schemes now to progress paramedics which additional training and they work along side GPs and nurses in primary care. Very much like the nurse practitioner/ACP role.

Broadly speaking these roles come about since the demand for GPs vastly outstrips supply. Paramedics are cheaper to employ and train. Downside is not as skilled as GPs/possible more likely to miss a subtle or more unusual diagnosis but it helps meet demand.

Sounds like a good outcome to review your son.

Lucyccfc68 · 06/02/2023 19:19

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 06/02/2023 19:16

The paramedic will work at the GP surgery, not on an ambulance. Not all nurses work in hospitals; not all paramedics work on ambulances any more.

Thank you. I wasn’t aware of that. 👍

XenoBitch · 06/02/2023 19:16

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:01

I haven't read the whole thread but can anyone in the know tell me if someone calls for an ambulance and its the broken nail variety of reasons can the handler under absolutely no circumstances refuse to send an ambulance? I suppose they can say there'll be a veerrrry long wait but they can't just say "nope, you don't need one"?

My very "extensive research Grin" into this is what I have seen on the various emergency service programs on the BBC etc. A lot of callers were told they did not actually need an ambulance at that time. And sometimes, when an ambulance does attend, they treat on site and either the issue is dealt with, or the patient is told to make their own way to hospital.

If there are people who are ringing 999 and getting sent an ambulance, and taken to hospital for a stubbed toe or broken fingernail... I wonder what work of fiction that is actually happening in.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 06/02/2023 19:16

Lucyccfc68 · 06/02/2023 18:49

I can’t get my head round my son getting an appointment with a paramedic tomorrow for a cough he has had for over 5 weeks. I can only get an on-the-day appointment with the Doctors. I have to phone when he has already left for college and then you get what you are given regardless of my working day or his college class times.

so, we have been given a choice of appointment time tomorrow to see a paramedic instead. I can’t get my head round it - surely they are needed to be out in an ambulance dealing with people who need or (idiots who have requested, but don’t need an ambulance)

The paramedic will work at the GP surgery, not on an ambulance. Not all nurses work in hospitals; not all paramedics work on ambulances any more.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 06/02/2023 19:11

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 12/01/2023 22:26

I wouldn't say “most” but I would certainly say quite a few. And when you think that 40% of the people who get a c1 or c2 response (ie high priority calls) don't go to hospital at all it seems reasonable to deduce that quite a few of those didn’t need an ambulance response in the first place.

I don’t think this is all the fault of individuals though - the emergency services are extremely risk averse, people don’t know what’s happening to them, and sometimes it’s easier for the crew to just take the patient to hospital.

A paramedic friend badly-described her job as “i drive on blue lights to someone who couldn’t get a GP appointment, and call their GP and make an appointment for them”.

And when you think that 40% of the people who get a c1 or c2 response (ie high priority calls) don't go to hospital at all it seems reasonable to deduce that quite a few of those didn’t need an ambulance response in the first place.

How many of those didn’t survive to make the trip?

VladmirsPoutine · 06/02/2023 19:01

I haven't read the whole thread but can anyone in the know tell me if someone calls for an ambulance and its the broken nail variety of reasons can the handler under absolutely no circumstances refuse to send an ambulance? I suppose they can say there'll be a veerrrry long wait but they can't just say "nope, you don't need one"?

Lucyccfc68 · 06/02/2023 18:49

I can’t get my head round my son getting an appointment with a paramedic tomorrow for a cough he has had for over 5 weeks. I can only get an on-the-day appointment with the Doctors. I have to phone when he has already left for college and then you get what you are given regardless of my working day or his college class times.

so, we have been given a choice of appointment time tomorrow to see a paramedic instead. I can’t get my head round it - surely they are needed to be out in an ambulance dealing with people who need or (idiots who have requested, but don’t need an ambulance)

SouthCountryGirl · 06/02/2023 18:37

Kinneddar · 06/02/2023 18:35

A taxi, a neighbour, a friend, local FB group. Theres plenty options available. I dont know many of my neighbours but I wouldn't hesitate to run them to hospital if needed. I'm sure most people would be the same.

If I needed A and E there's no way I'd post online and wait for someone to reply.

Kinneddar · 06/02/2023 18:35

MereDintofPandiculation · 06/02/2023 17:44

So what is the solution if you have someone who needs A&E but you don’t have the means to to get them there?

A taxi, a neighbour, a friend, local FB group. Theres plenty options available. I dont know many of my neighbours but I wouldn't hesitate to run them to hospital if needed. I'm sure most people would be the same.

I8toys · 06/02/2023 18:20

My inlaws called an ambulance because MIL had a nosebleed that wouldn't stop. They have a car and can drive. They then didn't even bother going to the hospital because of the wait in A&E. Absolute madness.

Swipe left for the next trending thread