Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
Mary46 · 13/01/2023 18:06

We all cope differently. I wanted a gap. Had one in school baby at home. Two toddlers is hard work!!!

LMB0716 · 13/01/2023 18:00

BabyFour2023 · 13/01/2023 16:24

Are they? Do they do anything together or have anything in common?

@doingitalllagain my DD and DS1 have 3.5 years. Get along very well!

It sort of works that the oldest one passes on what he’s outgrown to his younger brother, board games, computer stuff, cuddly toys etc and little brother thinks he’s amazing for being so kind. Then big brother helps him to play with them, therefore reliving his childhood while pretending he’s too cool for Ben 10 and Moshi Monsters! 😂

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/01/2023 17:54

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 17:43

how can you love the experience but find the prospect of repeating so aversive??

thats the bit I don’t get!

Because you can love the smell of your babies head, the tiny cuddleyness, there little smiles, seeing them watch and absorb the world around them, feel joy as the get excited and kick their arms and legs, see them starting crawl, take their first steps, learn the do little things, their laughter, learning to talk. there is so much joy in watching your babies grow.

At the same time you can not love or enjoy, the sleep deprivation, the crying, the colic, the relentless feeding and nappy changing, the puking, the military operation just to leave the house for a pint of milk, the lack of money, the boringness of samey days, the having to be alert 100% 24/7

@ThatOneChinHair

thank you!

I can see why the first list you gave is lovely whether it’s enough to outweigh the second list you cite…probs not, but I appreciate everyone is different!

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 17:47

cross post with ClubhouseGift as I took so long to type, but she manged to say it in in fewer words 😊

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 17:43

how can you love the experience but find the prospect of repeating so aversive??

thats the bit I don’t get!

Because you can love the smell of your babies head, the tiny cuddleyness, there little smiles, seeing them watch and absorb the world around them, feel joy as the get excited and kick their arms and legs, see them starting crawl, take their first steps, learn the do little things, their laughter, learning to talk. there is so much joy in watching your babies grow.

At the same time you can not love or enjoy, the sleep deprivation, the crying, the colic, the relentless feeding and nappy changing, the puking, the military operation just to leave the house for a pint of milk, the lack of money, the boringness of samey days, the having to be alert 100% 24/7

BiasedBinding · 13/01/2023 17:37

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:52

Ok then, keep struggling.

Oh you wee numpty.

BiasedBinding · 13/01/2023 17:34

allfurcoatnoknickers · 13/01/2023 14:46

@WaddleAway I'm saying I'm the weirdo because we don't do "days out"! Seems like they're a massive part of life that just passed me by? I mentioned the city bit because we've got world class museums a 20 minute walk away, so we don't have to commit to a whole day.

@BiasedBinding That's interesting. I'd class a day trip as something where you leave the house in the morning and you're gone all day until bedtime or similar. I'd just class a trip to the park as a totally normal day-to-day activity.

So would I class those as normal day-to-day activities. As apparently you do a trip to a museum (and me, I’m lucky enough to have them in easy distance). Those day-to-day activities may also be easier with children of similar ages for some people, that’s what I’m saying. And people may be lumping that all in, especially when faced with fake-no-judgement posts.

as my post said, we’re all different.

ClubhouseGift · 13/01/2023 17:31

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/01/2023 17:13

@ClubhouseGift

how can you love the experience but find the prospect of repeating so aversive??

thats the bit I don’t get!

again not being goady, just genuinely curious!

if I didn’t like something and I had a choice in whether or not to do it again I definitely wouldn’t! Especially when I think about how many siblings don’t get on as adults.

Because I love the joy and laughter, I love watching them reach each milestone and learn to walk, talk, and become their own people with little personalities and likes and dislikes.

I don’t like the disrupted sleep or food mess or changing nappies, but having actual babies and toddlers is amazing.

mast0650 · 13/01/2023 17:24

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/01/2023 09:03

For those that don’t like the baby/little kid stage and want to have another to get it out the way, get it over with etc - fair play to you!

it’s not like the baby/little kid stage lasts a few days or even a few weeks - it’s months / years!

so as I say hats off to you - I could never voluntarily put myself through something that I didn’t like for that amount of time (especially when I already had a child)

I didn't enjoy the baby/toddler stage much at all. I'd have much rather skipped that and started from about age 3-4! However, that's not an option and I would still choose to have children - I'm expecting to know them (and possibly their families) for around 50 years or so, as well as having the knowledge that they and will go on after me, so perfectly happy to put up with the first 3!

Having said that, I think the first years were much harder for me because they were so close in age (16-17 months). So I don't subscribe particularly to the "get the early years out of the way" model. I think the benefits of having children close in age which I mentioned in an earlier stage kick in from age 3-ish and last right through to teens and the young adult stage.

Twiggywinkle13 · 13/01/2023 17:17

It’s taken me a while to get pregnant with my first baby. In an ideal world, we would love to have 3 or 4 if we are lucky enough. Baby is due April, I intend and very much hope to be pregnant this time next year again!

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/01/2023 17:13

ClubhouseGift · 13/01/2023 16:55

I love having babies and toddlers, but there’s absolutely no way I would want to finish changing nappies, potty training, weaning, dealing with sleep issues… and then have to start it all again a few years later.

@ClubhouseGift

how can you love the experience but find the prospect of repeating so aversive??

thats the bit I don’t get!

again not being goady, just genuinely curious!

if I didn’t like something and I had a choice in whether or not to do it again I definitely wouldn’t! Especially when I think about how many siblings don’t get on as adults.

Orangello · 13/01/2023 17:07

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:52

Ok then, keep struggling.

I'm not struggling, my children are not babies and toddlers any more.

So you are really saying people who don't enjoy every minute shouldn't have kids? Taking into account that one cannot know that before one actually has kids, should we have given them up then? What a bizarre opinion. Does it apply to other areas as well? I don't particularly enjoy certain aspects of my job that I otherwise love, so I shouldn't work?

mast0650 · 13/01/2023 17:04

Mine 16-17 months apart. This wasn't a choice and I wouldn't choose it if I had my time again (20 years ago now...). However, I would probably choose a gap of less than 3 years. Looking at friends and family whose children are more spread out in age, they are dealing with a wide range of different stages, abilities and needs at once. It's harder to find activities, daily schedules, house rules, holidays, etc. that suit everyone. They spend more years having to deal with different childcare providers or schools. And it is, on the whole, less likely that the children will spend lots of time together and that they will happily hang out with each other's friends. And, if I'm honest, I like the fact that the period when you are very tied down by childcare doesn't last as long!

Outfor150 · 13/01/2023 17:04

I actually think two years is quite a long-ish gap. Not very long, but longer than desirable - which to me would be around 18-21 months.

RidingMyBike · 13/01/2023 17:04

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:01

Why do so many people cite getting the baby and toddler stage "out of the way"? Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?
Seems like so many just wish their kids' childhood away.

I'd personally choose 5 year gaps or so if I wanted to have more than one kid and my age allowed it.

Who on earth says you're meant to enjoy every stage?! Not everyone likes or enjoys particular ages, it's just something you have to do if you want children.

I thought the baby year was particularly awful and felt like it lasted forever and toddler years not much better but DD (7) now just gets better and better and is a delight to be with.

Dominoeffecter · 13/01/2023 16:58

I just did, I never thought of 2 years being a shockingly short gap, I was in my 20’s if that means anything and they are brilliant friends now as teens but that’s not why I had them 😄

ClubhouseGift · 13/01/2023 16:55

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:01

Why do so many people cite getting the baby and toddler stage "out of the way"? Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?
Seems like so many just wish their kids' childhood away.

I'd personally choose 5 year gaps or so if I wanted to have more than one kid and my age allowed it.

I love having babies and toddlers, but there’s absolutely no way I would want to finish changing nappies, potty training, weaning, dealing with sleep issues… and then have to start it all again a few years later.

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:52

Orangello · 13/01/2023 16:19

Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?

No, I checked and there is no law that you must enjoy every minute to be allowed to have kids.

Ok then, keep struggling.

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:48

I guess we're just all not as virtuous as you.

I bet you're not, rude person.

Bunnycat101 · 13/01/2023 16:27

Ours is closer to 3 but think life would have been easier now with a 2 year gap as the logistics of having one in school and one in nursery is a bit of a pain especially doing holidays. One youngest starts school having them in the same location will be much easier. I’ve got quite a few fiends with 18 month gaps and just one school year. Their life was hard during baby and toddler years but feels easier at primary age.

SleepingStandingUp · 13/01/2023 16:26

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:01

Why do so many people cite getting the baby and toddler stage "out of the way"? Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?
Seems like so many just wish their kids' childhood away.

I'd personally choose 5 year gaps or so if I wanted to have more than one kid and my age allowed it.

I guess we're just all not as virtuous as you.

It isn't about wishing their lives away, it's about excepting that there's a particular type of grind to an endless stream of nappy changes, food in one end and put of of two others, being communicated with in a weird language you can't interpret, your bodily and hormonal changes, career breaks, social isolation etc and it's perhaps preferable to have one long period of this rather than two separate ones over several years.

The 5 yo gap you'll have between yours if you get any actual say over it is also subject to criticism

BabyFour2023 · 13/01/2023 16:24

LMB0716 · 13/01/2023 16:21

22 months between me and my sister too and we’ve never got on. I hated her as a child, she was a sly, manipulative, little tattle tell, who liked nothing better than getting me into trouble. (I’m sure she would remember differently). As adults we’re on speaking terms and sit together with my mam at family parties, but we’re not close and I definitely don’t feel like she’s enriched my life any.

I have a 9 year gap between my boys, and they’re best friends. The older I’ve is so protective and helps his little brother to do things. He lets him play in his room and shows him how to work the characters in computer games. The younger one idolises his big brother, and follows him like a shadow.

I think it’s definitely more to do with personalities that age. X

Are they? Do they do anything together or have anything in common?

@doingitalllagain my DD and DS1 have 3.5 years. Get along very well!

LMB0716 · 13/01/2023 16:21

xogossipgirlxo · 13/01/2023 09:26

Same age difference between me and my sister. We never got on well and we don't as adults unfortunately. You never know, no age gap will guarantee you that they will like each other.

22 months between me and my sister too and we’ve never got on. I hated her as a child, she was a sly, manipulative, little tattle tell, who liked nothing better than getting me into trouble. (I’m sure she would remember differently). As adults we’re on speaking terms and sit together with my mam at family parties, but we’re not close and I definitely don’t feel like she’s enriched my life any.

I have a 9 year gap between my boys, and they’re best friends. The older I’ve is so protective and helps his little brother to do things. He lets him play in his room and shows him how to work the characters in computer games. The younger one idolises his big brother, and follows him like a shadow.

I think it’s definitely more to do with personalities that age. X

Orangello · 13/01/2023 16:19

Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?

No, I checked and there is no law that you must enjoy every minute to be allowed to have kids.

Ineedaholidaysoon · 13/01/2023 16:16

I guess everyone's circumstances/reasons are different. For us we took many years to have a successful pregnancy. We definitely wanted a second child so decided to try sooner rather than later (we were early 30s at this point) and it happened a lot quicker than we expected. We have 16 months between ours. I went back to work from MAT leave pregnant. Luckily i did not suffer with morning sickness as i think that would have been really difficult. It was good to get certain stages 'out the way' in one go. Easier for practical reasons like school drop offs etc both being in the same school/nursery usually or being the same ages for fun activities, so both a similar height to be able ride the same theme park rides for example. Although very expensive when they were under 3 and both in nursery! I was hoping they would be 'best friends' and they are sometimes but not usually!

Swipe left for the next trending thread