Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
Chittering · 14/01/2023 10:01

I think it works better to have a small age gap. You have all the pram and high chair stuff and toys and baby clothes just there ready. You know them all at nursery and school. The kids are at the same level for days out ie soft play age etc. Mine have 2 years 2 months and were really good friends. I did think about having a third and thought about leaving it till the second one got to school, in terms.of finances being better, but by then I was out of the baby stage and didn't want to do it again.

Benjispruce4 · 14/01/2023 09:49

@lljkk Was she anti contraception too?

lljkk · 14/01/2023 09:07

PPffffft.
I'm still not accepting the choice word. I guess I know a lot of people where 'choice' doesn't belong in the picture.

I know a lady had 3 babies in 25 months, 4 in space of 3.5 years. All singletons.
She was first to tell you they were all unplanned pregnancies.
She had strong anti-abortion views.
She was an ambitious person, well-groomed, very snobby in some respects, antithesis of feckless parent stereotypes.
I dunno about her family planning efforts. We didn't get that far in the conversations.
She fiercely loved her children but there was no 'choice' in close timing of their arrival.

HyacinthBridgerton · 14/01/2023 09:03

I do understand your point and can only answer for me.

I had 4 kids in 7 years and honestly nothing was so hard (for me) as going from no kids to one kid. The total loss of identity, the grief at friendships altered and lost and the sheer grinding weight of responsibility for this whole other human was an absolute fucker.

My periods came back at 15-18 months post partum each time (once we had a good 8 hour break in overnight breastfeeds) and we were very lucky with each subsequent pregnancy happening within 2 or 3 periods, weirdly each time once I got back to my pre-pregnany weight. It seemed to me to feel like that was my body being ready, I guess. I did have very uncomplicated vaginal deliveries though.

Finally, adding another child definitely doesn't double the work - physical work or, interestingly, headspace / mental load. The mental load is already most of the way there iyswim.

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 14/01/2023 08:55

I have three children and there’s 23 months between the oldest and youngest.

There were many reasons why I wanted my children close together, I wanted them to be at similar stages in life so everyone wanted to do similar things, a friend has two children 6 years apart and it’s a constant battle of the older one not wanting to do boring toddler things and the younger one not being old enough to do the things the eldest wants to do - though one plus side to this is they have lots of brilliant one to one time!

I wanted them to be close in age in the hopes they’d be close in general, and so far as they’ve left toddlerhood and gone into childhood it’s worked, they’re incredibly close and most evenings are spent playing together or cuddling with each other on the sofa for movie time, they support each other and care for each other immensely, honestly more than I imagined they would.

I also just couldn’t get past the idea of getting some normality back with regards to sleep and day to day life and then throwing myself back into it, so I decided to just roll from one crazy first year to the next!

Don’t get me wrong I’m not suggesting it’s all sunshine and roses, life is hectic and sometimes downright chaos, there are more toys in my house than I thought possible and if they do fall out it’s WW3, but on the whole it’s brilliant and I wouldn’t change a thing!

I really think it just depends on what works for the parents, some people have 5+ year age gaps and it’s perfect for them for so many reasons, some people have very small age gaps and that’s what’s perfect for them!

C8H10N4O2 · 14/01/2023 08:54

XanaduKira · 13/01/2023 20:55

Completely agree. Plus I think some of us just take to motherhood way easier than others so it's easy to have multiple children with small age gaps.

No judgment on those who struggle and need bigger gaps, but for me it's been fab. Small age gaps, all like the same things / have things in common, so can all do proper family activities that please everyone.

Do tell, what is a "proper" family activity?

I'm worried I may have done it all wrong, being one of those inadequate plebs who found it hard going having four under five.

Ladylalaboo1 · 14/01/2023 08:46

I guess it's just personal preference and then also just how it happens? My eldest is 8, and I was 24 when I had her, then we decided fairly soon that we wanted another and to start trying when she was around 8 months old. We wanted to have them close as I struggled with pregnancy (hypremesis) and I thought it would be easier to do them close together now when I know what to expect, have a baby still so already sleepless nights, still buying nappies etc. my 2nd was born when my youngest was 19 months, and the age gap between them is wonderful, they are one school year apart so play in school alot together and it was a really smooth transition for us having my second so soon after my first, I already was basically doing the whole new baby thing so she just got in seamlessly. We then had our third child in 2020 and at this point my two children were 6 and 4 and without a doubt that was 100 times more difficult. My two children were now sleeping through the night and enjoying older activities such as painting and playing out in the garden without me having to sit with them etc, and then suddenly having another baby it was exhausting- but I knew it would be, and the age gap between them is fine now, they love their little sister and often play with her and love mothering her! I don't think age gap will effect their relationship I think they will all be close no matter what I think the only thing for us was the fact we were so used to being parents to children at the point my 3rd was born and not babies so it took us right back and was much more difficult- like having a newborn for the first time again. But it's completely personal preference isn't it just because I think the first twos age gap worked better doesn't mean I regret having my 3rd 4 years later or that I think it was wrong? It just worked for us, and actually even though it was hard again getting used to the newborn, being abit older myself I felt alot more confident and enjoyed the first year alot more. So pros and cons to both, just do what you feel is right 😌

BabyFour2023 · 14/01/2023 08:36

XanaduKira · 13/01/2023 20:55

Completely agree. Plus I think some of us just take to motherhood way easier than others so it's easy to have multiple children with small age gaps.

No judgment on those who struggle and need bigger gaps, but for me it's been fab. Small age gaps, all like the same things / have things in common, so can all do proper family activities that please everyone.

“Proper” family activities as opposed to what exactly?

saraclara · 14/01/2023 08:30

Completely agree. Plus I think some of us just take to motherhood way easier than others so it's easy to have multiple children with small age gaps.

I had a small gap between my two, but I still think that the above is one of the most smug things I've read on mumsnet.
🙄

XanaduKira · 13/01/2023 20:55

Mrsuntidy · 13/01/2023 19:56

18 month gap. I did it all in one go to get through stages at once. My boys are so close and I'm so glad I did it. They're into the same things at the same time..they share toys, like the same films and enjoy the same activities. I never had the jealousy from the eldest as he was only 18 months when the second was born. Maternity leave also meant more time with both.

Completely agree. Plus I think some of us just take to motherhood way easier than others so it's easy to have multiple children with small age gaps.

No judgment on those who struggle and need bigger gaps, but for me it's been fab. Small age gaps, all like the same things / have things in common, so can all do proper family activities that please everyone.

LMB0716 · 13/01/2023 20:41

BabyFour2023 · 13/01/2023 20:08

That is so lovely! There is going to be 9 years between my eldest and youngest when this baby is born so it’s nice to hear! There is a similar gap between my eldest and youngest sibling but my youngest brother is disabled so changed the dynamic somewhat.

They are 17 and 8 now, and they also now have a 1 year old sister! Infertility sucks but it is what it is, I’d rather the big gaps than not have them at all so we make it work. It does have its challenges, but at least they were old enough to understand and not be jealous when the next was born. And they also help me out passing things etc. And the oldest now watches the 1 year old while I collect middle from school if he’s not at college. It has its plus points too! Good luck with yours, I’m sure they will be great together! X

Mammyloveswine · 13/01/2023 20:15

Because sometimes it's a surprise...,

What a horrible judgey thread! Less than 2 years between my two and it's so easy now they are 7 and 5!

BabyFour2023 · 13/01/2023 20:08

LMB0716 · 13/01/2023 18:00

It sort of works that the oldest one passes on what he’s outgrown to his younger brother, board games, computer stuff, cuddly toys etc and little brother thinks he’s amazing for being so kind. Then big brother helps him to play with them, therefore reliving his childhood while pretending he’s too cool for Ben 10 and Moshi Monsters! 😂

That is so lovely! There is going to be 9 years between my eldest and youngest when this baby is born so it’s nice to hear! There is a similar gap between my eldest and youngest sibling but my youngest brother is disabled so changed the dynamic somewhat.

Mrsuntidy · 13/01/2023 19:56

18 month gap. I did it all in one go to get through stages at once. My boys are so close and I'm so glad I did it. They're into the same things at the same time..they share toys, like the same films and enjoy the same activities. I never had the jealousy from the eldest as he was only 18 months when the second was born. Maternity leave also meant more time with both.

louise5754 · 13/01/2023 19:34

HelloJan · 13/01/2023 16:01

Why do so many people cite getting the baby and toddler stage "out of the way"? Isn't the point of having kids to enjoy them during every stage?
Seems like so many just wish their kids' childhood away.

I'd personally choose 5 year gaps or so if I wanted to have more than one kid and my age allowed it.

I used those words. I didn't want to start the baby stage again and re buy everything.

mrsnjw · 13/01/2023 19:23

There are twenty five months between my two. I was thirty four when I had my son so time wasn't on my side. I also stopped work for seven years and got the whole early years/pre school done without a huge gap.

Diorama1 · 13/01/2023 19:22

I had 3 in 3 years because I wanted 3 and also wanted to return to college and get another qualification. It was very tough, in hindsight it was too much for me, I didnt cope very well. It didnt help that my middle child was a very challenging child and really affected my mental health. Those years were a blur, I didnt really get a chance to enjoy them as I was just too busy.

It is great now as they are 12-15 years old, love each other, get on fantastically well, enjoy the same activities and are so close (the two boys 12 and 13 are like twins). There are pros and cons to short age gaps.

Wombatbum · 13/01/2023 19:00

Just adding, all with same father as people seem to think my third must be someone else’s due to the gap 😂

EmmaDilemma5 · 13/01/2023 19:00

I'd it because I didn't want my career to be regularly impacted. I wanted to get the baby stages over with quickly (it's my least favourite stage).

I can't understand why people would want to wait 6/7 years then go right back to the sleepless night stage again!

Each to their own, there isn't a better way, just different.

Wombatbum · 13/01/2023 18:59

There are 17 months between my eldest two. For some reason we thought it might take months to conceive despite our first being a surprise! I was 19 when I had my first then 21 for second. I think for me because I was an only child and found it very lonely I wanted to make sure my daughter had a sibling sooner rather than later…..then number 3 there’s nearly 9 years between him and number 2 😂😂😂

ricketybeauty · 13/01/2023 18:57

Not got two yet, but thinking of a shorter age gap due to Age of me and additionally toddler has gone into her own bed AND started doing really cute things like telling me she loves me, so idea of another is quite appealing at the moment!

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 13/01/2023 18:50

I have 4 between the ages of 9 and 3. The baby stage is over all at once. I'm not returning to it every 5 years. We knew we wanted 4 so I wouldn't want a new baby every 5 years and start again for the next 30 odd years! When I can have them close together. The hard parts done almost all together. Still time with my dh when they are a bit older and they get on well and I hope it continues, so they have similarities and hopefully stay close to each other.

ThatOneChinHair · 13/01/2023 18:41

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/01/2023 17:54

@ThatOneChinHair

thank you!

I can see why the first list you gave is lovely whether it’s enough to outweigh the second list you cite…probs not, but I appreciate everyone is different!

That's the whole point you are going through it anyway, so might as well have two, keeping the shitty bits to a shorter length of time, whilst having double the lovely bits.

that's why people have said "might as well get that stage out the way" we are not wishing part of their childhood away, we still get to enjoy it, we are just getting the shitty bit out the way in one go.

Howabsolutelyfanfuckingtastic · 13/01/2023 18:25

My first 4 were close, I had a 4 year old, 3 year old, 18 month old and a newborn baby. I just loved caring for all my babies/children and it came so naturally to me even at such a young age (I was just turned 23 when I had my fourth). I now have another 3 children but the age gaps are a little bigger. Life is fun and busy just how i like it and there's never a dull moment! I wouldn't change a thing, my children all get a long and i love seeing them happily playing and chatting together. It brings me so much joy. They're not little for long, my oldest 4 are all teenagers now. If I could go back, I would do it all again in a heartbeat.

ThreeRingCircus · 13/01/2023 18:15

For us the good bits outweighed the bad, plus that nappies/sleep deprivation stage is so short really in the grand scheme of things. Hence the "getting it out the way" mentality. We've now moved on to the primary school years and DDs are a delight, lovely to spend time with and so much easier.

During the teenage years however I may feel differently 🤣