Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why so many people choose to have such a short age gap between their children?

616 replies

Lightningfast · 12/01/2023 20:28

I hear of so many people with two children two years apart and can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want

a. To be pregnant with a child of around only a year old
b. To have a newborn baby when the older one is still a toddler and therefore still needs support in so many really basic ways. Sure, they don’t need the same level of support as a new baby but still...

I’ve heard the ‘they will be close enough to be friends’ theory but in practice I have seen at least as many if not rather more siblings who are close in age but are not especially close emotionally and it feels a rather weak reason.
I see this happening so often, even with mothers who have really struggled with getting their first baby to feed, sleep etc. and yet seem hellbent on having another only a matter of months later. Just...why?

If this is you I’m not judging, just genuinely interested in what you are getting out of it.

OP posts:
IAmMam · 14/01/2023 11:52

I’ve two close (16 months gap) and then a 5 year gap between the youngest two. The older two were easier when I look back as you never get out of the feeding/nappies etc, they played lovely together growing up and yes, always had a friend. Maybe it was the difference in my age with my third but I was a lot more tired, maybe it was because I was no longer used to lack of sleep. Sometimes I feel like he is more like an only child because he doesn’t have someone to always play with or when we do days out for him. They all fight and bicker but they also all can get along, sometimes in twos which varies. Ideally I would have loved to have another close to my youngest too but financially and for our health we couldn’t.

MrsAlexKarev · 14/01/2023 11:50

It’s bloody hard, however I’ve seen the implications first hand of having children with a big age gap and I didn’t want that for my kids. Also I can do days out that are fun for us all rather than only a couple. It also got the nappy stage over and done with quickly rather than getting one out of nappies then going back over it again. There’s definitely pros and cons to both ways!

PumpkinSly · 14/01/2023 11:46

There is only 2 years and a few weeks between my children and I love it. It's hard when the second one comes along but you get on with it. Its great for my children now because they are playmates. They aren't so far apart in age that they have very different interests. I think they will stay close as they grow, and hope they will be there to support eachother as adults. It may not be for everyone to take on the challenge of having a second baby when your first is only just two, but I feel that it's worth it. It was especially great during the pandemic because they had eachother.

hot2trotter · 14/01/2023 11:43

Personal preference and, really, it's nobody else's business.
2 years 4 months between my first two. 1 year 10 months between second and third. 1 year 5 months between third and fourth.
I would say the 2 years 4 months gap was perfect for me. The 1 year 5 month gap was really hard (and unplanned, might I add). Four kids aged 5 and under was a challenge! Especially with no family support. But we manage and my kids are happy and loved.
I don't judge anyone on the age gaps of their children.

Dammitthisisshit · 14/01/2023 11:34

Because no 1 took 6 years and fertility treatment to conceive and my periods hadn’t returned (breastfeeding) and we had sex once. Turns out we were no longer infertile.

Quinniebellie · 14/01/2023 11:30

I had 4 really close together - they’re now 1, 2, 4 and 5 and I wouldn’t change a thing

for me, the idea of having them spaced out scares me - having an older child and getting my life back a bit, returning to work etc then starting from scratch again didn’t appeal to me.

the way we saw it, we’ll have been in the baby/toddler stage for 4 years but then it’s done and we don’t need to do it again. That sounds bad, I love that stage but you know what I mean!

Plus it is so lovely them being interested in the same/similar things, going through milestones at similar times etc

its chaotic but I love it!

Brunelofbrio · 14/01/2023 11:29

I had 2, 2 years apart and there are loads of advantages . I took a few years out when they were small and went back to work when they were 3/5. I was able to stay at home and save on massive nursery costs at the same time as enjoying their early years. I was glad to get the nappy/ no sleep period over while I wasn’t trying to juggle work and kids. Now I can focus on my career without maternity leave interrupting.
They are both at the same school/nursery so only 1 place to do drop offs and pick ups - same wraparound and same holiday arrangements.
They are also at a simmilar stage for toys and activities. They like a lots of the same TV shows for example and we have been able to move on our baby stuff quickly as they grow out of it.
They are also friends (most of the time) DC1 will admit that DC2 is ‘quite interesting’ and they will play happily together. Being at roughly the same stage makes lots of things easier.
I have friends who have 3 DD 12 years apart and they where happy with that until they found themselves parenting teens for 15 years!

Sunshine275 · 14/01/2023 11:22

I have 2 years 9 months between my two. I was 30 which my first but separated from my abusive ex. I met my now husband and knew I wanted another child, I felt age wise I didn’t want to be much older so had my second at 33. My decision was down my age and relationship circumstances. Theyre now much older and the age difference is great, financially it worked well too.

MysteryBelle · 14/01/2023 11:21

One reason is so the siblings will be close, and that is easier if they’re closer in age. My sister is nine years older than me. She went off to college when I was nine, and before that she was busy in high school. And not much in common with such a big age gap. It’s just so different. Two years apart is perfect in that context. Of course I agree with you that it is very hard to have two or several young children at the same time, it feels like you’re not giving the older child the attention he or she needs, and other factors. But I do believe a shorter age gap helps foster closeness. Yes I’m sure there are many examples of the opposite. I have a good relationship with my sister, but it’s a different kind to that of closer in age siblings.

Waspsnbees · 14/01/2023 11:21

i have 4 kids with 2y between each. i couldn't have gone back to nappies after being nappy-free. it wasn't really that hard.
i imagine for a lot of people it's an age thing. if you have your first in your 30s you have to have them close together if you want more than 2.
but close gaps are also good for having things in common while they're small. my 1st kid is 6y older than my 4th so they have little in common. they get on well, but on holidays etc they just want to do different things.

zingally · 14/01/2023 11:18

All sorts of reasons. In the case of my parents, they wanted to get the baby years out of the way reasonably quickly, and wanted us kids to be at similar life-stages going forwards.

Friends of my parents didn't get together until they were both 40. They had 2 kids one after the other, because they were aware their time was nearly up for successfully producing kids without help.

As for me, I ended up with twins, and no plans to have any more. DH is a twin, so it wasn't a massive surprise.

Goinglocodowninsainsburyslocal · 14/01/2023 11:14

Money for me, managed to go back full time when dd was 10mo then only had to work a few months before next mat leave. I had annual leave to use to bring it down to pt hours.

I couldn't have afforded sibling if my second mat leave was based on a pt wage so I was lucky that I managed to get pregnant when we wanted. Dh thought I was mental but it's worked out great in the long run.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/01/2023 11:11

Madaboutthecat · 14/01/2023 11:08

On the other hand, I wonder why leave a big gap between children. Just when you start (sort of) getting your life back, BOOM … right back to sleepless nights, puke and nappies. No thanks. Get it out of the way. But, each to their own.

Or only have one! Thats my thinking.

why put yourself through something you know you won’t enjoy?? It’s not compulsory to have more than one!

and it’s not like you’re putting yourself through something that only lasts a couple of weeks which you won’t enjoy - the baby stage is months and months! Years really! Life is too short to be wishing that amount of your life away surely?!

CatA27 · 14/01/2023 11:09

I had 4 children with gaps of 3 years, just under 2 years and 4.5 years and there were pros and cons to each. I would say the best for me as a mum was 3 years but those 2 weren't particularly close growing up, too big an age gap for them to be interested in the same things whereas the 2 who were less than 2 years apart played together all through growing up but yes, baby and a toddler was hard work, huge celebrations when i got them to nap both at the same time though! The hardest was the 4.5 gap as I had forgotten so much of the pain of nappies, feeds, sleepless nights and it came as quite a shock. So I dont think there's any perfect gap and of course it depends on the personalities of the children too.

Madaboutthecat · 14/01/2023 11:08

On the other hand, I wonder why leave a big gap between children. Just when you start (sort of) getting your life back, BOOM … right back to sleepless nights, puke and nappies. No thanks. Get it out of the way. But, each to their own.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/01/2023 11:08

@XanaduKira

whats a “proper family activity”?

MadMumOfTwoHorrors · 14/01/2023 11:07

My two are 14 months apart and it was totally planned. I had my first when I was 30 and when he was 4 months old I wanted to give him a sibling. There are 16 months between me and my sister and we grew up as best friends and I wanted the same for my children.
I loved having two babies at the same time and once the first year was over, their needs have been pretty much the same. When my second son was born, I had a year off as mat leave, then only went back to work for a few months before deciding to take 3 years off to be a SAHM with them, which was amazing, and something that would have been much harder with a bigger age gap. They have always played together, of course they fight at times, but what siblings don’t? When we go out or on holiday, having two similar aged kids means everything is age-appropriate for both of them and we’re not trying to find suitable things to do for different aged children. They are only one school year apart so their needs have been very similar there too.
They are now 15 and 16 and still the best of friends. One did his GCSEs last year and the other is doing them this year, so they are helping each other with revision, and they will do the same with A levels.
Everyone does what works for them, but for me, this is perfect.

mezlou84 · 14/01/2023 11:01

My hubby and I have done both. We have a 14yr old, 2yr old and 9mth old. I say the big age gap is the worst thing ever. Its much better to have them closer in age. The 12yr 2mth age gap wasn't anything to do with not wanting more we just couldn't fall pregnant again and the now 2yr old was a welcome shock. We wanted another and because we are now late 30s we didn't want to wait too long for a 3rd admittedly we didn't expect it so soon as we obviously had trouble conceiving 2nd. With a closer age gap you get to do everything as a family. No one is too old for something or too young for something. So we go on a family day out, little ones want to see animals or go to soft play etc. Oldest obviously doesn't want to and prefers waterboarding at the beach, adventure golf, bowling etc which the little ones really don't and can't do. You get them into schools close together so you don't have one finishing school and others starting it. You get yourself together faster as it's the same routine eg. Eldest has after school activities and it's difficult having to wake little ones up from naps to take them to an under 15s football match where its almost 2hrs out plus travel time. The little ones are bored and can't let them play just in case a rogue ball knocks them out plus it's blooming cold poor mites lol. It's helps them learn compassion and role play so much easier and better for their social skills. My eldest was in private nursery from being a baby as well as lots of baby groups but it's not the same. It is so much easier with a shorter age gap x

Gin1982 · 14/01/2023 10:58

UK based so we tried (as best we could) to make it work for us financially to tie in with my maternity leave. I returned to work expecting our second but work had someone in post to do my job during my leave, & she happily agreed to return a few months later when I commenced my second maternity leave. I’m not going to lie, it was chaos at home…which only became more chaotic when number three came into the mix two years later - a bit of a surprise & proof that even when older, you should be very careful! We’d three under school age at home so some days just getting all of us dressed was an achievement! We didn’t have childcare or help from others. I’m not going to lie, I lost a bit of myself along the way. I was never a priority for myself & self care etc was nonexistent. My hubby is an only child & he always said he didn’t want that for our firstborn. Our three are so close, our middle & youngest especially so. I’ve also found a better balance now that all three are at school. Age was against us (hubby a lot older than me) so obviously that was a contributing factor too.

MamaBear4ever · 14/01/2023 10:57

To get the baby/ toddler stage over and done with. As they grow they have similar age related interests, in school at same time. I don't know why you would want big gaps to be honest

Yb23487643 · 14/01/2023 10:56

I think there’s a logic that you’ll be over the nappy phase sooner and back to being able to sleep through sooner etc.
But I agree, most kids I know who are that close have big sibling rivalries and home life is a lot more fractious than when kids are a good 3y apart. Huge over generalisation and there’ll be lots of exceptions to that I’m sure. Each to their own.
I’m very glad to have had a 3y gap and able to have lots of 1:1 on mat leave with both (during 15-30h free childcare hours) and they’re really close.

Outfor150 · 14/01/2023 10:46

The majority of my friends had their second baby at around 21 months. We had our first babies in the same week or so -met at a baby group - and had a second baby at 21 months apart -almost to the day. We all had them within the same two-week period. The longest gap was my sister, who had her second 25 months after her first.

MarvellousMonsters · 14/01/2023 10:37

A two year age gap is ok, but my mind is blown by the people who go for less, 12-18 months between babies. It's madness. Your body needs time to heal, and not just the 6 weeks it takes to stop bleeding! Pregnancy is a huge physical event, to do it several times close together is not healthy. Just because you 'were ok' doesn't mean it's a good idea. Nature spaces children out at roughly 3 year intervals, (breastfeeding reduces fertility, even though it's not a 100% contraception, lots of breastfeeding mothers find their period doesn't return for 12-18 months) and we really should be listening to that. I see so many 'cute' reels etc about 'Irish twins' and honestly I think it's madness.

thisisme2468 · 14/01/2023 10:31

I had just over 2 years between mine who are now 12 and 10. Both born before I was 30. Number 1 was an easy child though he didn’t sleep massively well he was a joy as a toddler (and still is!) so never felt difficult. First 6 months of having a toddler and baby was hard (and she was born in December so could just be the winter blues!!) but after that it’s been great fun. They have similar interests and have been at similar stages the whole time. I wanted to finish having babies by 30 because I have MS and it will progress as I age so wanted to be able to run around after them while I could!

Benjispruce4 · 14/01/2023 10:15

I had a 3 yr 5 nth gap. Eldest had nursery most mornings so I had time to focus on my second child for a few hours each day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread